THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

Chapter 11

The Hearth and the Tithing

Its governing metaphor: the tally stick

3,858 words · 5 movements

The Opening

A man stands in the wet grass of an English churchyard, some spring in the twelfth century, with his neighbours in a line behind him, and waits for the sheriff to call his tithing. He is its chief pledge. The sheriff rides his circuit and holds the view of frankpledge, and at the view every free man must be found in a tithing, and every tithing must account for its men.

He has brought all of them but one. The missing man took what was not his and was gone before morning, and the hue and cry, which every household was bound to raise and follow, was raised too late to catch him. The sheriff does not ask where the man went. He asks why the tithing has not produced him, and when no answer comes, his clerk writes a fine against all of them together.

The men in the line will pay it out of their own stores. Each of them knows to the sack what the others hold, which house can bear its share and which cannot, and not one of them can read what the clerk has written. They do not need to. What they have is older than the roll: a lifetime of watching each other, and, for debts, the notched stick split down its length, one half in each hand, a record two people can keep honest without either being able to read.

The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.

The Story

  1. Every neighbour a constable
  2. The house with the door shut
  3. Split before you stack
  4. The strongest case against
  5. In practice

The numbers and sources

The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.

  1. Numbers to carry
  2. Every figure
  3. The capture test
  4. The scale ledger
  5. The case for and the case against
  6. Where the sources disagree
  7. Open questions
  8. The documents