THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 11: The Hearth and the Tithing

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 85 open
  • 26 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 85 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. About 150: the size near which a Hutterite colony splits and Dunbar's predicted human group (PS-02, Dunbar 1993, predicted 147.8, contested by Lindenfors, Wartel and Lind 2021, Biology Letters. ME-11, Evans and Peller 2016, 130 to 150). Rows C11-41 and C11-46. The Preface's P-20 and chapter 3's C03-53 cite these rows.
  2. Ten households, or ten men under a chief pledge: the English tithing (DT-10 against DT-11, Morris 1910). Row C11-10. Chapter 4's C04-46 cites it.
  3. 25 to 40 families: the Old Order Amish church district, 150 to 300 people (ME-11, via Encyclopedia.com, tertiary). Row C11-52.
  4. About six, about 150, about 1,500: Johnson's thresholds of scalar stress, for a deciding body, a splitting settlement and permanent hierarchy (SY-08, Johnson 1982, Organizational Structure and Scalar Stress, theory). Row C11-44.
  5. Over twelve: the age from which every free man had to be in a tithing (DT-10, DT-11, SY-10 citing Morris 1910). Row C11-03.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
Twice a yearThe view of frankpledgeThe sheriff's tourn, Norman EnglandDT-11, DT-10C11-02recordrobust
Over twelveAge of enrolment in a tithingMorris 1910, The Frankpledge SystemDT-10, DT-11, SY-10C11-03recordrobust
Ten households or ten menSize of a tithingMorris 1910, Wormald 1999DT-10, DT-11C11-10recordcontested
Twelve and four sworn men (not in the prose)Presenting juries per district and per villageAssize of Clarendon, 1166PS-08C11-13recordrobust
NineThe other members of a tithingFollows from tenDT-11C11-15inferredrobust
About 150Dunbar's predicted human groupDunbar 1992, 1993, neocortex ratio about 4.1, prediction 147.8PS-02C11-41inferredcontested
69.2 to 108.6, interval 3.8 to 520 (not in the prose)Reanalysed group sizeLindenfors, Wartel and Lind 2021, Biology LettersPS-02C11-43inferredcontested
About sixJohnson's strain point for a deciding bodyJohnson 1982SY-08C11-44inferredopen
About 150Johnson's split or hierarchy pointJohnson 1982SY-08C11-44inferredopen
About 1,500Johnson's permanent hierarchy (1,500 to 2,500)Johnson 1982SY-08C11-44inferredopen
1528Hutterite community of goods beginsJakob Hutter, Tyrol and MoraviaPS-02C11-45recordrobust
About 150Hutterite colony splitEvans and Peller 2016 (130 to 150), Hostetler 1974 and Peter 1987 (breakdown 130 to 160), MO-08 (120 to 150), CA-11 (150 to 230 adults)ME-11, PS-02, MO-08, CA-11C11-46recordcontested
25 to 40 familiesAmish church districtEncyclopedia.com entryME-11C11-52recordcontested
Three centuriesAmish stability despite a middling capture score (59.1 per cent)Synthesis scoringSY-09C11-58inferredopen
About a thirdShare of firelight criticism driven by envyWiessner 2014, 44 years among the Ju/'hoansiPS-04C11-72saidrobust
Two per taskCross-training in the householdSynthesis designSY-10C11-40designopen
About 1,000Household numeracySynthesis designSY-10C11-75designopen
Under half an hour a day, two hours a weekHousehold timeSynthesis design (20 to 30 minutes daily, 2 hours weekly)SY-10C11-75designopen
Six to eight householdsHamlet compositionSynthesis designSY-10C11-78designopen
Two turnsBar on the keeper serving againSynthesis designSY-10C11-78designopen
An hour a week, two days a yearHamlet timeSynthesis designSY-10C11-81designopen
Three daysRebuilding a burnt house (72 hours)Synthesis designSY-10C11-83designopen

The capture test

The captor is the patient head of a household. He takes charge of the root cellar key, speaks for the house at the tithing so that the neighbours hear only his account, keeps the weapons by his bed, names an outside danger to keep sole command, and takes the protein first (SY-10 capture vector, DT-02 on the cellar lock). Nothing he does breaks a rule, and none of it can be seen from the lane. What stopped such men, where anything did, came from outside the house: Igbo women sitting on a man who wronged his wife (PS-09), and English neighbours liable for any violence that left his walls (DT-10, DT-11). The design counters are dispersed weapons, stores in common sight, a hamlet with a right to inspect, and a refuge house that takes in whoever flees. At the hamlet the matching captor is the lender of salt, iron or grain who turns debts into a voting bloc, the road by which SY-10 says free tithings slid into manorial serfdom after 1066. The counters there are proposals: no compound interest, a jubilee, a keeper chosen by lot. The kinetic parity question, whether a household can still check a tyrant who holds the only firearm, is open (SY-10).

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Frankpledge tithing, mutual suretyshipnever tried (SY-10), worked briefly (DT-11)workedfailed into rival cliques of tithings (SY-10), worked through the view (DT-10)worked as the district court, captured by sheriffsabsorbed by the crownnever triednever triednever triedSY-10, DT-10, DT-11
Levelling coalition inside the householdworked (SY-05, SY-08, PS-04), failed through patriarchal violence (SY-07)workedstrainedfailednever triednever triednever triednever triedSY-05, SY-07, SY-08, PS-04, DT-05, NA-03
Hearth council, steward, visible stores (design)proposedhands upnot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicableSY-10
Halved stores, women's council with a veto (design)proposed, functions natively in dual sex systemsproposedproposednever triednever triednever triednever triednever triedPS-09
Hutterite colony fission by lotnot applicableworked, the pioneer daughter colonyequilibrium 60 to 130, breakdown 130 to 160never tried communally, loose conferencenever triednever triednever triednever triedPS-02, ME-11
Amish district split along a roadworksworksreaches its maximumaffiliations without powernever triednever triednever triednever triedME-11
Split tallyworks (design)works (design)works with a three key chest (design)never tried as a local recordnever triednever triedworked at the English Exchequer until 1826never triedME-14, SY-10

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

The two smallest rungs are governed best by people who can see each other and who pay for each other's failures. Mutual suretyship makes every neighbour a constable. The household is where capture is invisible, so the hamlet must be able to see in, within bounds: stores, weapons, bruises and the right to leave. The first failure in a household is a sick breadwinner, the second the family that will not split. A hamlet should split at the threshold rather than stack officers on top of itself, as the Hutterites and the Amish do, and keep its debts on split tallies whose second half lies with the tithing.

The case against

William Ian Miller's Iceland (Miller 1990, via SY-10, DT-07, NO-07) is the best voice. Small is not gentle and old is not humane (SY-10). The household is the oldest and least accountable government, and the hamlet adds a second circle with reasons to look away. The tithing answered for theft, not for violence at home. Gossip, the hamlet's way of seeing in, is about one third envy (Wiessner 2014, PS-04). The Amish district and the Hutterite colony last by shunning and community of goods that leave a dissenter nowhere to stand (ME-11). Suretyship also makes every neighbour an informer, and English frankpledge chiefly raised money for the crown (DT-10). The chapter answers narrowly: the alternative to a hamlet that sees in is the tyrant's privacy, and the seeing must be bounded and exit real.

Where the sources disagree

  1. The 150. Dunbar's 147.8 (PS-02, contested) against Lindenfors, Wartel and Lind 2021, 69.2 to 108.6 with an interval of 3.8 to 520 (PS-02). PS-04, PS-05 and PS-06 treat the number as a hard limit. HI-10 and HI-14 give about 150 without a source, and SY-04's use of Dunbar cites none. The chapter writes about 150 and treats it as a stress point. Rows C11-41, C11-43.
  2. The Hutterite split. 130 to 150 (ME-11, Evans and Peller 2016) against equilibrium at 60 to 130 and breakdown at 130 to 160 (PS-02, Hostetler 1974, Peter 1987) against 120 to 150 (MO-08, via Wikipedia) against 150 to 230 adults (CA-11). ME-11's own village plan says exactly 300. The cause is cognitive in PS-02's main reading and agrarian in Evans and Kraybill's (PS-02). Row C11-46.
  3. Where assemblies degrade: above 150 (ME-09), 150 to 300 (ME-11), 300 (ME-14). Johnson's six, 150 and 1,500 to 2,500 rest on SY-08 alone. Row C11-44.
  4. The tithing. Ten households (DT-10) against ten men under a chief pledge (DT-11). Over twelve as the age of enrolment (DT-10, DT-11, SY-10) against PS-08's twelve sworn men per district under the Assize of Clarendon, which is another twelve. Anglo-Saxon roots ending after the Black Death (DT-10) against maturing under the Normans and decaying through the fourteenth century (DT-11). DT-11 marks frankpledge as worked briefly at the household, SY-10 as never tried there. Rows C11-03, C11-10, C11-24, C11-67.
  5. The household verdict. Reverse dominance worked at the household (SY-05, SY-08, PS-04) against failed through patriarchal violence (SY-07). Assembly worked, egalitarian (SY-03) against patriarchal domination noted in the SY research summary. Row C11-28.
  6. The household's first failure. A sick primary provider (SY-10) against domestic abuse unchecked (PS-04), coercion (PS-09), tyranny or abandonment (PS-01), a member refusing to take part (PS-08) and abuse by the head (SY-06, SY-09). Row C11-40.
  7. The Amish. Defection about 15 per cent, range 2.6 to 40.4 per cent (ME-11, Kraybill) against doubling about every twenty years and retention of 85 per cent or more (MO-08). The district size rests on a tertiary encyclopaedia (ME-11). A capture score of 59.1 per cent against three centuries of stability (SY-09). Rows C11-52, C11-57, C11-58.
  8. Weak routes. /Twi rests on a magazine (PS-02, Works in Progress), and the !Kung quotes in SY-07 on a newsletter. The Hutterite lot in MO-08 is a Reddit post. Kleinsasser comes via Wikipedia and religiousmovements.org (PS-02). The tally scale and the de Boochose fraud come from a Scribd copy of Flegg (ME-14). Boehm reaches SY-10 through a weak web route, so chapter 1's rows are used instead.

Open questions

  1. Kinetic parity: can a household or hamlet still check a tyrant when one man holds a firearm and the rest do not (SY-10)?
  2. Is the 150 a limit of minds, of land, or of neither (PS-02)?
  3. Can a tithing work without a sheriff, with its fines paid to the wronged household rather than a lord (DT-11 asks whether the borh worked organically before the Normans financialised it)?
  4. Can a hamlet see into a household without becoming its censor, and where exactly does the line between stores and beliefs hold?
  5. Does halving the stores between women and men survive a hungry winter, as PS-09 itself doubts?
  6. What happens to budding when there is no more land to bud into?

The documents

Primary: SY-10 (the operational ladder, household and hamlet rungs), DT-05 (gossip, ridicule and the camp, Wiessner, Briggs, Turnbull, Lee), DT-07 (feud, mediation, wergild and outlawry), DT-10 (the borh, frankpledge, Törbel), DT-11 (decimal ladders, frankpledge and the baojia), PS-02 (Dunbar's layers, Lindenfors, the Hutterite fission), PS-04 (gossip and shame, Wiessner), PS-08 (oaths, the Assize of Clarendon, Iceland), PS-09 (the women's share, the Igbo dual sex system), ME-11 (fission and secession, the Amish district and the Hutterite daughter colony), ME-14 (records, split tallies, beating the bounds). Consulted: SY-08 (scalar stress), SY-05, SY-07, SY-09, DT-01, DT-02, MO-08, CA-11, HI-07.

Key works named in the reports: Morris 1910, The Frankpledge System. Pollock and Maitland 1895. Wormald 1999. Dunbar 1992 and 1993. Hill and Dunbar 2003. Lindenfors, Wartel and Lind 2021, Biology Letters. Johnson 1982, Organizational Structure and Scalar Stress. Hostetler 1974. Peter 1987. Evans and Peller 2016. Kraybill on the Amish. Briggs 1970. Wiessner 2014, PNAS. Miller 1990, Bloodtaking and Peacemaking. Byock 2001, Viking Age Iceland. Olson 1965. Fitznigel, Dialogus de Scaccario, about 1179.

Its documents in the Library

240 241 244 246 249 250 258 279 282 286 289 305 315 317 320 321 322 324 325 326 328 329 337 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359