THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 4: Cities Without Kings

82 claims, 27 to check first

C04-01 Check first open §Opening

Çatalhöyük lies on the Konya plain in what is now central Turkey

To check against
DT-08 (Çatalhöyük, Anatolia). "Konya plain" and "central Turkey" are general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-05 Check first open §Opening

Grain kept in the house, visible to anyone who came down the ladder

To check against
DT-08 (storage domestic and visible). "Beside the room where she sleeps" is scene setting, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-08 Check first open §Roofs of one height

Ian Hodder, the archaeologist whose name is most bound up with the mound

To check against
DT-08 cites Hodder 2014 and an edited volume. His role at the site is general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-20 Check first open §Roofs of one height

Mohenjo-daro, a city of tens of thousands, bricks of one standard shape, covered drains, a great bath, no palace, no royal grave

To check against
DT-08 (40,000 or more, bricks 1:2:4, Great Bath 12 by 7 by 2.4 m). Partly Wikipedia and klarifyedu
The verdict
OPEN
C04-22 Check first open §Roofs of one height

Teotihuacan, Valley of Mexico, covered over the face of its great temple around 300 CE and housed most people in thousands of walled apartment compounds

To check against
DT-08 (Feathered Serpent temple covered by the Adosada about 300 CE, over 2,000 compounds, Manzanilla 2017). Partly Facebook and Wikipedia. "Valley of Mexico" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C04-23 Check first open §Roofs of one height

At Mohenjo-daro the lower town ate worse and was hurt more often

To check against
DT-08 (Kenoyer. Lower towns show more violence and malnutrition). Weak sourcing for the Indus section
The verdict
OPEN
C04-28 Check first open §The man who stayed to count

James C. Scott, a political scientist who spent his career on peasants and on peoples who kept out of the state's reach

To check against
DT-09 (Scott 2009, Zomia. Scott 2017). Discipline and career are general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-32 Check first open §The man who stayed to count

Wealth stayed fairly even long after the first crops, often for more than a millennium, and pulled apart when layered states appeared, in the Old World and the Americas

To check against
DT-09 (Kohler and Smith 2018, 62 cases, over 1,100 sites). DT-09 says both "more than a millennium" and "for millennia"
The verdict
OPEN
C04-38 Check first open §The man who stayed to count

Richard Blanton, an archaeologist, and a colleague scored thirty pre-modern states: internal taxes, bargaining and public goods, external revenue, no consent

To check against
DT-08 (Blanton and Fargher 2008, Collective Action in the Formation of Pre-Modern States, 30 polities). "Archaeologist" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C04-46 Check first open §When the counter left

Frankpledge tithings nominally of ten households, each answering for the others, producing offenders at the district court

To check against
Chapter 11's row for the ten households (C11-10). DT-10 (ten households, the hundred court) against DT-11 (ten men under a chief pledge)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-50 Check first open §When the counter left

Faded in the fourteenth century after the Black Death, replaced by constables

To check against
DT-10 (after the Black Death, constables) against DT-11 (decayed over the fourteenth century)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-51 Check first open §When the counter left

The Gulating, founded around 930 CE, an assembly every free man had the right and duty to attend, later a gathering of delegates

To check against
HI-07 (citing gulatingstaden.no and kringom.no)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-53 Check first open §When the counter left

The Normans kept the moots of shire and district and sent a sheriff to sit in them, turning them to collection

To check against
HI-07 (Witan and moots section, no numbered citations)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-54 Check first open §When the counter left

Dithmarschen held out from 1227 to 1559, opened its dikes against mercenaries in 1500, was governed in its last century by judges for life, with the richest clan holding several seats

To check against
HI-07 (Urban 1991. 48 judges from 1447, the Wollersen clan with 5 seats, Hemmingstedt and the Black Guard). Partly Wikipedia en and de, Fandom, Reddit
The verdict
OPEN
C04-58 Check first open §When the counter left

Jethro tells Moses to choose trustworthy men as "rulers of thousands, hundreds, fifties and tens"

To check against
DT-11 (Exodus 18:21. Van Seters reads it as later etiology). The quotation is DT-11's compressed form of the verse
The verdict
OPEN
C04-59 Check first open §When the counter left

Genghis Khan in 1206 sorted his army by tens, hundreds, thousands and ten thousands, breaking up rival lineages

To check against
DT-11 (de Rachewiltz 2004, Morgan. Arban, zuun, mingghan, tumen). Collective punishment claims rest on Quora and are not used
The verdict
OPEN
C04-60 Check first open §When the counter left

The Inca counted their taxpayers in tens, fifties, hundreds and on upwards, and kept the count on knotted cords

To check against
DT-11 (chunka 10 taxpayers to hunu 10,000, quipus. D'Altroy 2002, Julien, Urton). Partly YouTube and Scribd
The verdict
OPEN
C04-62 Check first open §When the counter left

Wang Anshi's baojia of 1070: ten households a jia, ten jia a bao, each answerable for the others' crimes

To check against
DT-11 (Hsiao 1960). Partly Wikipedia and Kiddle
The verdict
OPEN
C04-63 Check first open §When the counter left

The ten-household unit recurs from the Andes to the Yellow River

To check against
DT-11 (convergence thesis). The DT research summary warns that DT-11's verdicts on decimal grids rest partly on Quora, YouTube and Scribd. The concept note's "four continents" is not carried
The verdict
OPEN
C04-66 Check first open §When the counter left

Scale ledger: cities without kings held at the town, the tithing at hamlet and village, the moot at the district, all absorbed above

To check against
DT-08, DT-10, HI-07 ledgers. DT-08 marks Çatalhöyük failed at village and district, DT-11 marks the tithing failed at village
The verdict
OPEN
C04-67 Check first open §The strongest case against

Bryan Ward-Perkins, a historian of the late Roman world: tiled roofs giving way to wooden huts, durable pottery and sanitation gone for centuries, tribute to warlords

To check against
DT-10 (Ward-Perkins 2005, The Fall of Rome and the End of Civilization). "Historian of the late Roman world" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C04-69 Check first open §The strongest case against

Two archaeologists: an empty plaza can hide an elite, hierarchy is needed to handle information, the collective towns were violent, human sacrifice at Tlaxcallan

To check against
DT-08 (Flannery and Marcus 2012). Tlaxcallan via Fargher, Blanton and Espinoza 2010 and weak web sources
The verdict
OPEN
C04-72 Check first open §In practice

Disaster sociologists found people rarely panic and mostly help one another

To check against
MO-10 (Quarantelli, Dynes and Haas, Disaster Research Center, from 1963). The panic percentage comes from an activist-hosted PDF and is not used
The verdict
OPEN
C04-73 Check first open §In practice

The disaster cases ran inside states that came back, and the evidence on how long such bodies last contradicts itself

To check against
MO-10 (Occupy Sandy, Christchurch, Katrina). Three to five years against about 400 recovered firms still running, as the MO research summary warns
The verdict
OPEN
C04-76 Check first open §In practice

A common granary counted aloud and locked with several locks whose keys sit in different villages. Nobody has yet run one this way after a collapse

To check against
A proposal assembled from DT-08 (visible domestic storage) and the parish chest of chapter 12 (two locks from 1538, three from 1603: C12-01, C12-08). Not in any document as a district design
The verdict
OPEN
C04-78 Check first open §In practice

The fortified manors of China after the Han filled with peasants who had become serfs

To check against
DT-10 (wubao, 100 to 500 people, Lewis 2009 and a blogspot page)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-80 Check first open §In practice

The Swiss and the Dithmarschers kept their assemblies with their own weapons, other cases show armed households tearing republics apart

To check against
HI-07 (armed citizens protect the assembly) against HI-02 and HI-06 as the HI documents give them (private arms destroy)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-02 open §Opening

Nine thousand years ago

To check against
DT-08 (7100 to 5950 BCE). Preface row P-39 ("the cities of nine thousand years ago had no palace"), whose rows this chapter owns
The verdict
OPEN
C04-03 open §Opening

No streets between the houses, no square, entry through the roof, the roofs serving as streets

To check against
DT-08 (Hodder: no streets or plazas, access through roof hatches)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-04 open §Opening

The dead buried under the floor, houses rebuilt on the same footprint

To check against
DT-08 (Hodder 2014. History houses with piled burials, rebuilding on the exact footprint)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-06 open §Opening

No palace, no temple standing over the others, no central building

To check against
DT-08 (Hodder. No palace or central building). Preface row P-39
The verdict
OPEN
C04-07 open §Opening

Several thousand people live on the mound

To check against
DT-08 (Hodder: 5,000 to 8,000 on 13.5 ha)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-10 open §Roofs of one height

Houses of roughly one size, shrines inside the houses, no central building

To check against
DT-08 (standard house sizes, domestic shrines)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-11 open §Roofs of one height

History houses gathered burials and ritual, a tension between an egalitarian ethos and hierarchy, a first claim to rank that did not become a throne

To check against
DT-08 (Hodder 2014. History houses chapter in Hodder ed., Religion in the Emergence of Civilization)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-12 open §Roofs of one height

Infectious disease, stunted growth, heavy wear, about one skull in eight with recurrent healed injuries, most of the repeat cases adult women

To check against
DT-08 (Larsen et al. 2019, PNAS 116(26), 470 complete and 272 partial individuals, 13 per cent recurrent non-lethal injuries, 12 of 93 injury recidivists, mostly adult women)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-13 open §Roofs of one height

Trypillia, far to the north in what is now Ukraine, about 4100 BCE to 3600 BCE, towns of 10,000 to 15,000 people for several centuries

To check against
DT-08 (Nebelivka 235 ha, Maidanetske 200 ha, 10,000 to 15,000 people)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-14 open §Roofs of one height

Concentric rings round an empty plaza, no royal tombs, no central stores, no citadel

To check against
DT-08
The verdict
OPEN
C04-15 open §Roofs of one height

Peas from gardens manured by hand, small plots worked hard

To check against
DT-08 (Maidanetske peas δ15N 4.2 to 7.0 per mil against 2.5)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-16 open §Roofs of one height

House sizes remarkably even across thousands of houses

To check against
DT-08 (Müller, Hofmann and Müller-Scheeßel 2024, Antiquity 98(398) 380 to 400, 7,000 houses at 38 sites, Gini 0.2295)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-17 open §Roofs of one height

Assembly buildings in each quarter and a larger one on the plaza, read as a council of councils

To check against
DT-08 (nested councils in mega-structures)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-18 open §Roofs of one height

From about 3800 BCE the spread of house sizes widens, the small halls go out of use, meetings move to exclusive central buildings

To check against
DT-08 (Gini rose 3800 to 3600 BCE, neighbourhood assembly houses disappeared)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-19 open §Roofs of one height

Around 3600 BCE the towns were burned and left, people went back to villages, read by the excavators as a refusal

To check against
DT-08 (resistance by burning and abandonment). An inference, contested
The verdict
OPEN
C04-21 open §Roofs of one height

The Priest-King statuette is small enough to hold in one hand and now read as nobody in particular

To check against
DT-08 (17.5 cm. Green 2021, Journal of Archaeological Research 29(2), "Killing the Priest-King")
The verdict
OPEN
C04-24 open §Roofs of one height

Teotihuacan's houses far less even than the Trypillia rings

To check against
DT-08 (Feinman and Carballo 2022, Gini 0.41, against Trypillia 0.2295)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-26 open §Roofs of one height

The absence of a palace is not the presence of a democracy. A hidden elite can leave no gold in the ground

To check against
DT-08 (Flannery and Marcus 2012, The Creation of Inequality, the hidden elite)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-27 open §Roofs of one height

Cities did not need kings (key learning)

To check against
DT-08 (synthesis across Çatalhöyük, Trypillia, the Indus, Teotihuacan)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-29 open §The man who stayed to count

Against the Grain: grain ripens at once, grows above ground, can be seen, cut, measured, carried, divided and stored. Tubers resist the tax collector

To check against
DT-09 (Scott 2017, Against the Grain)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-30 open §The man who stayed to count

Walls kept taxpayers in, captives were taken, crowding bred epidemics. Quotation "a late Neolithic multispecies resettlement camp"

To check against
DT-09 (Scott 2017). Wording to be checked against the book
The verdict
OPEN
C04-31 open §The man who stayed to count

Early farmers' skeletons shorter than the foragers' before them

To check against
DT-09 (Mummert et al. 2011, systematic review)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-33 open §The man who stayed to count

States rose in valleys the defeated could not leave

To check against
DT-09 (Carneiro 1970). Chapter 3's ground (C03-20)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-34 open §The man who stayed to count

Mancur Olson, an economist, named the stationary bandit

To check against
Preface row P-10. CA-06 (Olson 1993, American Political Science Review)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-35 open §The man who stayed to count

The roving bandit takes everything and nobody plants for him, the stationary bandit takes a share and keeps other bandits off

To check against
CA-06 (Olson 1993)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-36 open §The man who stayed to count

Eastern Congo: armed groups settled where coltan, bulky and easy to watch at chokepoints, was mined, more of them when its world price rose, and not where gold was

To check against
Preface row P-11. CA-06 (Sanchez de la Sierra 2020, Journal of Political Economy, 650 villages, coltan against gold)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-37 open §The man who stayed to count

The state is a stationary bandit, and his staying is the oldest bargain (key learning)

To check against
CA-06 (Olson 1993). Preface rows P-10 to P-12
The verdict
OPEN
C04-39 open §The man who stayed to count

Egypt came apart three times between its kingdoms, each time for a century or more

To check against
DT-09 (First Intermediate about 126 years, Second about 100, Third about 405)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-40 open §The man who stayed to count

Historians who count from the palaces call such gaps dark ages

To check against
DT-09 (Yoffee 2005, via a Scribd copy)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-41 open §The man who stayed to count

A historian of Babylon: the presumptive state, monumental law codes closer to propaganda than statute

To check against
DT-09 (Richardson 2012 and 2017, Old Babylonian period)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-42 open §When the counter left

After collapse: safety retreats to the household and the strong house, then sideways bodies in village and valley, then rank returns

To check against
DT-10 (the sequence across cases)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-43 open §When the counter left

400 CE to 800 CE, peasants working mostly for themselves because nobody could take much

To check against
DT-10 (Wickham 2005, Framing the Early Middle Ages, the peasant mode of production)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-44 open §When the counter left

Hesiod, eighth century BCE, the "gift-devouring" basileis, the local lords who judged disputes, Perses bribed them to take Hesiod's share of the inheritance

To check against
DT-10 (Hesiod, Works and Days)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-45 open §When the counter left

Anglo-Saxon codes from the early seventh century to Cnut's in the eleventh bound men into mutual surety

To check against
DT-10 (Æthelberht about 600, Ine 688 to 694, Alfred 890s, Cnut 1016 to 1035)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-47 open §When the counter left

The people inside it called it the king's peace

To check against
DT-10 (mund)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-48 open §When the counter left

Court rolls of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries: whole tithings fined for a man who had run or a hue and cry not raised

To check against
DT-10 (whole tithings amerced). DT-11 (view of frankpledge, unraised hues and cries, failure to capture fugitives)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-49 open §When the counter left

Statecraft for a king without police, making every neighbour a constable at the neighbours' expense

To check against
DT-10 (Morris 1910, The Frankpledge System. Wormald 1999. "A transitional technology of statecraft")
The verdict
OPEN
C04-52 open §When the counter left

Kings narrowed the choice of delegates to their barons and bailiffs. 1274, Magnus the Lawmender's law for all Norway, things made courts of appeal

To check against
HI-07 (lendmenn and syslemenn. Landslov 1274. Helle 2001 in its reading list)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-55 open §When the counter left

Free farmers of the north debated at their things while slaves worked their fields

To check against
HI-07 (Karras 1988, Slavery and Society in Medieval Scandinavia)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-56 open §When the counter left

Swiss open-air assemblies kept out women, foreigners and the landless for centuries

To check against
HI-07 (Blickle 1990, Hinz. Landsgemeinde section)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-57 open §When the counter left

After a collapse, people rebuild the small rung first (key learning)

To check against
DT-10 (the post-collapse sequence)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-61 open §When the counter left

Shang Yang bound households in fives and tens in the fourth century BCE

To check against
DT-11
The verdict
OPEN
C04-64 open §When the counter left

A historian of imperial control in nineteenth-century rural China concluded that the baojia was never self-governing

To check against
DT-11 (Hsiao Kung-chuan 1960, Rural China: Imperial Control in the Nineteenth Century)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-65 open §When the counter left

A clerk had only to threaten to report one household to hold the whole group

To check against
DT-11 (clerks and collective liability, the jia blackmailed)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-68 open §The strongest case against

Noble households of post-palace Greece, fortified manors of China after the Han and the northern feud read as coping, not self-government

To check against
DT-10 (its own extension of Ward-Perkins)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-70 open §In practice

A district of a few thousand people in perhaps ten villages within a day's walk

To check against
Brief's rung definition (1,500 to 5,000). DT-09, DT-10 and MO-10 each design a district of 3,000 in 10 villages
The verdict
OPEN
C04-71 open §In practice

The roving bandit first, then the stationary one, who settles where there is something to watch

To check against
Preface rows P-10 and P-11. CA-06 (Olson 1993, Sanchez de la Sierra 2020)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-74 open §In practice

The moot's failure: the meeting grows too big, delegates replace it, someone else chooses the delegates

To check against
HI-07 (the Gulating)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-75 open §In practice

One design has the villages choose their delegates, recall them whenever they choose and send them to carry a decision rather than make one

To check against
MO-10 (district design: delegates as messengers, instant recall). A design, not history
The verdict
OPEN
C04-77 open §In practice

The protector who drives off a raid and keeps a bodyguard, the security caste that stops taking orders

To check against
DT-09 (village design, first failure). MO-10 (district design, first failure). Designs, not history
The verdict
OPEN
C04-79 open §In practice

Every household answering the alarm, as the old hue and cry required

To check against
DT-11 (hue and cry within the frankpledge). Chapter 11's ground (C11-12)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-81 open §In practice

One design has each village meet every fortnight and the district's delegates once a quarter

To check against
MO-10 (village assembly bi-weekly). DT-10 (district representatives quarterly). Designs, not history
The verdict
OPEN
C04-82 open §In practice

Part III: the hearth and the tithing in chapter 11, the village and its chest in chapter 12, the district in chapter 13

To check against
Concept note §9
The verdict
OPEN