THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 12: Three Hundred and a Chest

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 97 open
  • 27 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 97 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Two locks, then three: Cromwell's injunction of 5 September 1538 asked for "one sure coffer with two locks and keys", and Canon 70 of 1603 made it three, one key for the minister and two for the churchwardens. ME-14, citing the injunction and the canon. SY-10 puts three keys in 1538. This chapter owns the chest and the Three Keys. C12-08, C12-10, P-24.
  2. A fifth come, fewer women speak: average attendance at Vermont town meetings of about a fifth of registered voters, with women 46 per cent of those present and 36 per cent of speakers. Bryan 2004, Real Democracy, 1,435 meetings in 210 towns, 1970 to 1998. HI-12. Chapter 8 owns the 20.5 per cent (C08-64). C12-54, C12-56.
  3. One in five, then under one in a hundred: attendance at the Tswana kgotla at village level against district level in Ngamiland, Botswana. IN-03, from a single study. C12-41.
  4. A quarter missing, a third saved: in 608 Indonesian villages about 24 per cent of road money was missing, and raising the audit probability from 4 to 100 per cent cut the loss by about a third, while village monitoring meetings did nothing to it. Olken 2007. MO-09, ME-06, SY-03. This chapter owns the rows. C12-74, C12-76.
  5. 35 to 70, three years out, banned for life: the age range, cooling-off bar and penalty for unrendered accounts in the Uttaramerur inscription of 921 CE. IN-10, on weak sources. C12-32, C12-33.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
1603, three locks, two keys to the wardenscustody of the parish registerCanon 70 of 1603ME-14C12-01, C12-10recordcontested
Within a month of Easterthe yearly copy to the bishopCanon 70, the Bishop's TranscriptsME-14C12-05recordrobust
5 September 1538, two locksCromwell's injunctionRoyal Injunction of 1538ME-14C12-07, C12-08recordcontested
1597registers copied onto parchmentConvocation of Canterbury 1597ME-14C12-09recordrobust
150 to 500the village rungthe book's ladderSY-10, SY-08C12-13designrobust
A few hundred peopleTörbel's populationNetting 1981 (400 to 600, 200 to 600 burghers, up to 700)GL-03, GL-06, SY-06C12-15recordcontested
1981Netting's study publishedNetting 1981, Balancing on an AlpGL-03, GL-06, SY-10C12-16recordrobust
Around 1500the wintering rule written down1 February 1483 against 1517GL-06, SY-10, GL-03C12-17recordcontested
A share of each finereward for the catcherhalf to the warden against split with the informantGL-06, GL-03C12-21recordcontested
1990, eight design principlesOstrom's long-enduring commonsOstrom 1990, Governing the CommonsGL-06, SY-10C12-26inferredrobust
Many commonsthe later test of the principlesCox, Arnold and Villamayor-Tomas 2010, 91 or over 100 or 112 casesGL-06, ME-09, ME-11, GL-08C12-28inferredcontested
919 and 921 CEthe Uttaramerur inscriptionsVaikunda Perumal temple, reign of Parantaka IIN-10C12-30recordopen
Wards, 35 to 70, a minimum of landeligibility for the pot921 CE inscription (30 wards, a quarter veli)IN-10C12-32recordopen
Three years, for lifethe bar after office, the ban for unrendered accounts921 CE inscriptionIN-10C12-33recordopen
30 to 60, then 35 to 70the tightening between inscriptions919 and 921 CEIN-10C12-35recordopen
One in five, under one in a hundred, almost nobodykgotla attendance at village, district, MaunNgamiland study, 19.8 per cent, under 1 per cent, 0.1 per centIN-03C12-41recordopen
10 June 1931Sebele II deposedResident Commissioner Charles ReyIN-03C12-44recordopen
1956the osu caste abolished in lawEastern Nigerian Osu System Abolition LawIN-02C12-50recordrobust
1630stown meetings beginthe recordHI-12C12-52recordrobust
More than a thousand meetings, 1970 to 1998Bryan's sampleBryan 2004, 1,435 meetings, 210 townsHI-12, PS-02, PS-07C12-53recordrobust
About a fifthmean attendanceBryan 2004, 20.5 per centHI-12, PS-07C12-54, C08-64recordrobust
Most of the difference, almost nonevariance explained by size and by educationBryan 2004, 58 and 1 per centHI-12, PS-07C12-55inferredopen
46 and 36 per centwomen among attenders and speakersBryan 2004HI-12C12-56recordcontested
A few hundred, the 1970sSelby's size and dateMansbridge 1983, Beyond Adversary Democracy (about 350, or about 500)HI-12, PS-02C12-58recordcontested
1889Land Captains over the skhodthe recordHI-12C12-62recordrobust
1906, millions of householdsStolypin's exitUkase of 9 November 1906HI-12C12-63recordrobust
Since the seventeenth centuryage of the Quaker methodover 370 years against over 350ME-03, ME-04C12-64recordcontested
1827, 1955the Philadelphia schism and reunionthe recordME-03C12-65recordrobust
Over 85 billion dollarsaid spent on community-driven developmentMansuri and Rao 2013 as MO-09 gives itMO-09C12-72recordrobust
Changed nothingGoBifo's effect on village institutionsCasey, Glennerster and Miguel 2012, 236 villages, 63 measures. Follow-up 2021MO-09C12-73recordrobust
About a quartermissing road moneyOlken 2007, 608 villages, 24 per centMO-09, ME-06, SY-03C12-74recordrobust
Almost nothing to certain, about a thirdaudit probability and the cut in lossesOlken 2007, 4 to 100 per cent, minus 8 points or 30 per cent, or 24 to 9 per centMO-09, ME-06, SY-03C12-76recordcontested
A large shareKerala's devolved plan budget35 to 40 per cent, 1,214 bodies, 1996MO-02, PS-07, IN-10C12-79recordrobust
One year, then three outsyndics' term and barSY-10's design against SY-09's six months twiceSY-10, SY-09C12-84designcontested
Half a day and a day a month, a few days a yearassembly, common work, the boundsSY-10's time budgetSY-10C12-80, C12-93designopen
Within days, a large majoritythe constable's clockSY-10, 72 hours, three-fourthsSY-10C12-92designopen
Two readers, or a small sharethe literacy floorSY-10, two individuals against 3 to 5 per centSY-10C12-95designcontested

The capture test

The captor in the chapter is a composite drawn from SY-10's capture vector: a patient man who marries into the largest family, lends seed in a dry year so that debtors fall silent at voice votes, and offers to keep the book. His first move, in SY-10's design, is smaller: his kin vote together to excuse their own sons from the spring ditch-clearing. The record supplies the parts. At Uttaramerur the inscription of 921 CE added a lifetime ban on the relatives of anyone who failed to render accounts, which IN-10 reads as a response to men running their kin as proxies. In the kgotla the recall of borrowed cattle silenced speakers (IN-03), and Sebele II was removed only by a colonial commissioner when the village's own checks of exit and armed assembly were closed. In Selby the debtors and the poor kept quiet before their creditors and landlords (HI-12, SY-03). What stops him in the chapter's design is the chest: three locks no one opens alone, keyholders drawn rather than chosen, debts on split tallies, secret votes about persons. What the record says stops him reliably is an audit from outside the village (MO-09, Olken 2007), which belongs to the district.

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Parish chest and written registersnever tried, needlessnever triedworked, English parishes from 1538design only, district copiesnot in the documentsdiocesan copies as backupnot in the documentsnot in the documentsME-14
SY-10's designed villagenot applicablefailed, too heavyworked as designfailed as designnot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicableSY-10
Törbel alpine commonsworkedworkedworked, optimalworked, valley associationsmoderately workedcantonal federationsubordinatedinapplicableGL-06
Uttaramerur kudavolainot applicableworked, wardsworkedworked, shared tanksworked under the Chola statefailednever triednever triedIN-10
Kgotlanot applicableworkedworked, peakstrainedfailed as deliberativeuntried directlyfailedfailedIN-03
Igbo village assemblyworkedworkedworked, optimalfailednever triednever triednever triednever triedIN-02
New England town meetingnever triedworkedworked, peakfailedfailednever triednever triednever triedHI-12, PS-07
Russian mirworkedworkedworked, peakfailed, capturednever triednever triednever triednever triedHI-12
Kerala People's Plannot applicableworked, neighbourhood groupsworkedworkedworkedworkedfailed to spreadnever triedIN-10, PS-07
Community-driven developmentviablerobustviable but fragilefails without federationnever works by itselfunviableunviableunviableMO-09

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

A village of 150 to 500 can govern itself with a monthly assembly, a chest with three keys and a register read aloud. The parish chest shows custody split by law between a cleric and elected laymen, Törbel shows a commons governed for centuries by one rule and an elected warden, and Uttaramerur shows a lot hedged with term bars and a lifetime penalty for unrendered accounts. Every village assembly in the record excluded someone, and attendance and speech thin as the room grows. Consent scales further than consensus. The first failure is a kin bloc excusing its own from the common work.

The case against

The randomised evidence on community-driven development finds that induced village institutions built things but did not change how villages decide (Casey, Glennerster and Miguel 2012, in MO-09), and that outside audits beat village monitoring (Olken 2007). Mansuri and Rao 2013 argue that local participation works only under a responsive state able to discipline local elites. SY-03 adds that open voting puts tenants and debtors at the mercy of landlords and creditors. Every long-lived village in the chapter had something above it: Törbel a canton, the kgotla a colonial power, Kerala a state government. The chapter concedes most of this and hands the outside audit to the district.

Where the sources disagree

  1. The chest's locks in 1538: two (ME-14, quoting the injunction) against three (SY-10). The chapter follows ME-14.
  2. Törbel's population: up to 700 (SY-06), 400 to 600 (GL-03), 200 to 600 burghers (GL-06).
  3. The wintering rule's date: 1 February 1483 (GL-06, SY-10) against 1517 (GL-03). NA-06's Törbel "Black Death" in 1532 is wrong and is not used.
  4. The share of Törbel's fines: half to the warden (GL-06) against split between informant and treasury (GL-03).
  5. Cox's review: 91 studies (ME-09, GL-06), over 100 (ME-11), 112 (GL-08).
  6. Selby: about 350 residents and a 1983 book (HI-12) against about 500 and 1980 (PS-02). NA-05 credits Selby's figures to Bryan rather than Mansbridge.
  7. The Igbo assembly: unanimity or exhaustion against binding majority decisions, inside IN-02.
  8. Olken's effect: "30 percent" (MO-09), a third by arithmetic from ME-06's 24 per cent and 8 points, against 24 to 9 per cent (SY-03).
  9. Village terms: one year then three barred (SY-10) against six months twice at most (SY-09).
  10. Lot at the village: PS-07 calls it counterproductive below 1,500, while PS-01, PS-02 and PS-03 fill village councils by lot, and SY-02 finds no village governed by an allotted council. Lot from an open list is therefore the chapter's proposal.
  11. The literacy floor: 3 to 5 per cent against "a minimum of two individuals", inside SY-10. ME-14 asks for three literate people.
  12. The keyholders: head syndic, chief scribe and an elder drawn by lot from the poorest tithing (SY-10) against clerk, reeve and an elder elected yearly (ME-14).
  13. The Quaker method's age: over 370 years (ME-03) against over 350 (ME-04). Sociocracy dated to the 1970s with circles of 5 to 7 (ME-03) against 1981 with 10 to 15 (ME-04).
  14. The Vermont breaking point: about 1,500 (SY-03) against about 500 (a reading of Bryan, logged in chapter 10 as C10-31).

Open questions

  1. What does a published edition of the Uttaramerur inscriptions say? Every detail of the rules in the documents comes through quiz sites, Facebook and Scribd.
  2. Can a village audit itself at all, or must the outside check always come from a rung above? Olken's result says the second, and post-collapse there may be no state to supply it.
  3. Does the lot help or harm at 300 people, where everyone knows everyone? No village governed by an allotted council appears in the documents.
  4. How many readers does a village need? The designs ask for two, three, or a small share of the population.
  5. Can consent survive a determined, articulate objector without a majority override?
  6. Can a village keep its consent and its chest without the exclusions that every recorded village practised?

The documents

Robert McC. Netting 1981, Balancing on an Alp: Ecological Change and Continuity in a Swiss Mountain Community. Elinor Ostrom 1990, Governing the Commons. Michael Cox, Gwen Arnold and Sergio Villamayor-Tomas 2010, a review of the design principles. Frank M. Bryan 2004, Real Democracy: The New England Town Meeting and How It Works. Jane Mansbridge 1983, Beyond Adversary Democracy. Steven Hoch 1986, Serfdom and Social Control in Russia: Petrovskoe, a Village in Tambov. Isaac Schapera 1938, A Handbook of Tswana Law and Custom. John Comaroff 1978, Rules and Rulers. Edwin Wilmsen 1989, Land Filled with Flies. Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James Robinson 2003, An African Success Story: Botswana. A.E. Afigbo 1972, The Warrant Chiefs. Victor Uchendu 1965, The Igbo of Southeast Nigeria. Judith Van Allen 1972, Sitting on a Man. Kamene Okonjo 1976, The Dual-Sex Political System in Operation. A.S. Altekar 1949, State and Government in Ancient India. Patrick Heller 2001, Moving the State. Michael Sheeran 1983, Beyond Majority Rule. Benjamin Olken 2007, on monitoring corruption in Indonesian road projects. Katherine Casey, Rachel Glennerster and Edward Miguel 2012, on GoBifo in Sierra Leone. Ghazala Mansuri and Vijayendra Rao 2013, Localizing Development: Does Participation Work? Thomas Glick 1970, Irrigation and Society in Medieval Valencia. José Rivera 1998, Acequia Culture. The Royal Injunction of 1538 and Canon 70 of 1603, as printed in the histories of English parish registers.

Its documents in the Library

262 263 270 284 291 292 309 310 312 315 317 320 321 322 323 327 331 338 344 347 349 351 352 355 357 358 359