THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 10: The Case Against

69 claims, 18 to check first

C10-07 Check first open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

About a third of Americans cannot name the party controlling the House, and the share has hardly moved as schooling spread

To check against
SY-01 (Somin 2013 and 2016, about 35%, "no improvement" over about 60 years). Survey based, single compiler. Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-12 Check first open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Two younger political scientists re-ran the shark test for every election 1872 to 2012 and found no effect distinguishable from zero

To check against
SY-01 (Fowler and Hall 2018, Journal of Politics). Achen and Bartels have replied. "Younger" is the narrator's word, not the documents'
The verdict
OPEN
C10-14 Check first open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Mississippi wrote a literacy test into its constitution in 1890, administered by officials, and most Black citizens could not vote until federal law intervened in 1965

To check against
SY-01 ("over 90%" excluded, no source named). Check against a history of the 1890 Mississippi constitution and the Voting Rights Act 1965
The verdict
OPEN
C10-19 Check first open §The drawn room and the small place

About nine in ten of those invited to an allotted assembly decline

To check against
SY-02 (OECD 2020 and 2023, refusal 90% to 97%, elsewhere in the same text 90% to 95%). CCC: about 4.5% of those screened seated. Irish assembly 3% to 8% response. Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-23 Check first open §The drawn room and the small place

The law that followed kept a fraction of the rest

To check against
SY-02 (Loi Climat 2021, "fewer than 10% to 20%" intact, over 70% diluted, no source named). Check against an independent count of the Loi Climat et Résilience
The verdict
OPEN
C10-24 Check first open §The drawn room and the small place

Asked to mark the government's response, the members failed it

To check against
SY-02 (2.5 out of 10, February 2021). Single source
The verdict
OPEN
C10-31 Check first open §The drawn room and the small place

The New England town meeting, the small institution its admirers love most, works best below about five hundred voters and thins as towns grow

To check against
SY-03 (Bryan 2004, Real Democracy: high fidelity to about 500 registered voters, attendance 20% to 25% under 500, 3% to 5% over 5,000). SY-03 also gives a breaking point near 1,500. The turnout of about a fifth is owned by chapter 8 (C08-64). The ceiling of about 500 is this chapter's own. The Preface's assembly threshold of a few thousand is P-21
The verdict
OPEN
C10-33 Check first open §The drawn room and the small place

Scale ledger in a sentence: assembly and levelling hold at hamlet and village and fail above, lot has worked only inside a closed citizenry, and where the misfit was rescued at all, the rescue came from the rung above

To check against
SY-01, SY-02, SY-03, SY-04 scale ledgers. SY-02 gives lot at village scale as "chores only" and finds historical lot only inside a closed citizenry (Athens excluding about 85%, Venice, Florence). SY-01, SY-03 and SY-04 design allotted village councils without citing one. HI-14 says Athenian demes drew magistrates by lot, without a source. Rescue from above: SY-03 (Little Rock 1957, Phips at Salem 1692, Shakti Vahini 2018)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-35 Check first open §Old does not mean good

Chapter 1 set the Kalahari homicide rate beside the insulted meat

To check against
Cites C01-43
The verdict
OPEN
C10-37 Check first open §Old does not mean good

An economist pooling samples put deaths in war at between one in eight and one in seven

To check against
SY-04 (Bowles 2009, 15 populations, 13% to 15%). SY-04 elsewhere calls 15% to 25% "intergroup", which its own source does not support. Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-39 Check first open §Old does not mean good

The violence tables were mostly compiled by authors arguing for high violence, and many societies in them lived beside farmers, traders and states

To check against
SY-04's own samples (Keeley 1996, Bowles 2009), compiled by authors arguing for high violence. Ferguson's tribal zone (Ferguson 1995, 2013). Inference
The verdict
OPEN
C10-49 Check first open §The wheel

Ibn Khaldun, North Africa, 1377: asabiyyah, and a dynasty decays within four generations

To check against
HI-14 (Muqaddimah, four generations of about 30 years, about 120 years). HI-14 cites dergipark and Wikipedia. Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-50 Check first open §The wheel

An Abbasid caliph built a new capital at Samarra and filled it with Turkic slave soldiers

To check against
HI-14 (al-Mu'tasim, 836 CE, no source named)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-52 Check first open §The wheel

Turchin built a large database of past societies, and in 2010 predicted unrest in the United States would peak around 2020

To check against
HI-14 (Seshat, 373 societies. Nature 2010 forecast, sourced to peterturchin.com and a video). Check the Nature piece
The verdict
OPEN
C10-54 Check first open §The wheel

A historian of inequality: only war, revolution, state collapse and plague have levelled wealth

To check against
HI-14 (Scheidel 2017, The Great Leveler, the four horsemen). HI-14 used a pirate copy and a summary site
The verdict
OPEN
C10-56 Check first open §The wheel

Scoring the arrangements for capture resistance went wrong both ways: Athens and Porto Alegre scored well and fell, the Amish scored middling (59.1 per cent) and Venice poorly (45.5 per cent) and both lasted. The prose now also carries SY-01's opposite verdict on Venice (chapter 7, C07-61)

To check against
SY-09 (synthesis, shape only, scores on the data page). Athens owned by chapter 6 (C06-33), Venice by chapter 7 (C07-33), Porto Alegre's 2004 by chapter 14 (C14-46)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-57 Check first open §The wheel

The scoring missed four forces: size beyond the village, who holds the weapons, debt and favours, dependence on a host state

To check against
SY-09 (scale above about 500, asymmetry of armed force, informal debt and patronage, host-state dependence). Synthesis only
The verdict
OPEN
C10-63 Check first open §The strongest case against

No democracy has fallen above the income Argentina had in 1975

To check against
SY-01 (Przeworski, Alvarez, Cheibub and Limongi 2000, 141 countries, $6,055 PPP). Figure garbled in the text and checked in the SY-01 PDF
The verdict
OPEN
C10-01 open §Opening

The narrator keeps the critics' books on the lowest shelf of his house and kneels to take them down

To check against
Composed scene, the governing image of the concept note (chapter 10, a shelf of books that say the project is a mistake). Not in the documents. The owner may confirm or replace the domestic detail
The verdict
OPEN
C10-02 open §Opening

The shelf as listed: a philosopher against voting, two political scientists and the 1916 sharks, a philosopher against lot as a shortcut, a speech in New Delhi against the village, anthropology against the peaceful forager, a scientist of history and the wheel

To check against
Foreshadows rows C10-03, C10-10, C10-16, C10-26, C10-34 to C10-44, C10-51
The verdict
OPEN
C10-03 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Jason Brennan, an American philosopher, published Against Democracy in 2016

To check against
SY-01 (Brennan 2016, Against Democracy, Princeton)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-04 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Hobbits know little and care little, hooligans follow politics like football supporters and filter facts for their side, vulcans weigh evidence and are rare. Most voters are hobbits, most others hooligans

To check against
SY-01 (Brennan 2016, the three types and their shares as Brennan describes them)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-05 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

The competence principle: a person bound by a decision is owed one made competently and in good faith, likened to a defendant's right to a fit jury

To check against
SY-01 (Brennan 2016, Competence Principle). The jury comparison is Brennan's, wording to be checked
The verdict
OPEN
C10-06 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Brennan entertains votes weighted by knowledge, a veto held by the informed and a test before the ballot

To check against
SY-01 (restricted suffrage, plural voting after Mill 1861, epistocratic veto, simulated oracle)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-08 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

An economist: voter errors are systematic, not random, so they do not cancel. Four biases: anti-market, anti-foreign, make-work, pessimistic

To check against
SY-01 (Caplan 2007, The Myth of the Rational Voter, SAEE survey)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-09 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Christopher Achen and Larry Bartels, political scientists, asked whether voters can at least judge results

To check against
SY-01 (Achen and Bartels 2016, Democracy for Realists)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-10 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

In summer 1916 sharks killed bathers on the New Jersey shore. In November Wilson did worse in the beach towns

To check against
SY-01 (Achen and Bartels 2016). Detail of "resort towns lost their season" is the authors' mechanism as SY-01 gives it
The verdict
OPEN
C10-11 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Voters punish droughts and floods, reward the last few months of income, take their opinions from their party. The folk theory is false

To check against
SY-01 (blind retrospection, myopia over 2 to 3 quarters, party identity, "the folk theory of democracy is empirically false")
The verdict
OPEN
C10-13 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

The central finding, that voters vote by team identity, survives the failed replication

To check against
SY-01 (its own reading after Fowler and Hall, also Busby and Druckman 2017). Inference
The verdict
OPEN
C10-15 open §Hobbits, hooligans and sharks

Brennan answers the demographic objection to a knowledge test with safeguards

To check against
SY-01 (Estlund 2008 on the demographic objection, Brennan's reply)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-16 open §The drawn room and the small place

Cristina Lafont, Democracy without Shortcuts, 2020: an allotted body is a shortcut that asks the rest to defer blindly to people they never chose and cannot remove

To check against
SY-02 (Lafont 2020, Oxford). Also Lafont and Urbinati 2024
The verdict
OPEN
C10-17 open §The drawn room and the small place

Deliberation changes the members, so they no longer resemble the public and lose their claim to speak for it

To check against
SY-02 (Lafont's "democratic alienation" argument)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-18 open §The drawn room and the small place

Elections give choice and punishment. A member who cannot be returned has no reason to behave and a reason to think of the job afterwards

To check against
SY-02 (Landa and Pevnick, APSR 2020, J Pol Phil 2021, selection and treatment, post-tenure capture)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-20 open §The drawn room and the small place

France drew a citizens' convention after the yellow-vest protests, and the president promised its proposals would go forward without a filter

To check against
SY-02 (Convention Citoyenne pour le Climat 2019 to 2021, "sans filtre")
The verdict
OPEN
C10-21 open §The drawn room and the small place

They met over a series of weekends, heard experts and wrote a long list of measures

To check against
SY-02 (seven weekends, 149 recommendations, 556 pages)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-22 open §The drawn room and the small place

The president struck several out at once, among them a dividend tax and a lower motorway speed limit

To check against
SY-02 (three "jokers": a 4% dividend tax, 110 km/h, constitutional change)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-25 open §The drawn room and the small place

The capture turn: the organiser frames the question, chooses the experts, facilitates and drafts. The figure of "she" is a composite

To check against
SY-02 (organiser capture at four stages: agenda framing, evidence curation, facilitation, drafting. Ostbelgien's secretariat filters topics and uses a narrow circle of experts). Inference
The verdict
OPEN
C10-26 open §The drawn room and the small place

4 November 1948, Constituent Assembly, New Delhi: Ambedkar, chair of the Drafting Committee, born Dalit, "What is the village but a sink of localism, a den of ignorance, narrow-mindedness and communalism?", glad the chapter chose the individual as its unit

To check against
SY-03 (Constituent Assembly Debates, 4 November 1948). Strong. Wording to be checked against the Debates
The verdict
OPEN
C10-27 open §The drawn room and the small place

When aid was devolved to village committees, the World Bank's review found it captured by the literate, landed, high-status men

To check against
SY-03 (Mansuri and Rao 2013, Localizing Development, about 490 evaluations)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-28 open §The drawn room and the small place

In Pakistan's Punjab, water boards handed to farmer organisations were taken by large landholders who starved downstream plots

To check against
SY-03 (Jacoby, Mansuri and Fatima 2021)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-29 open §The drawn room and the small place

An economist counted witch killings across villages of Meatu district, western Tanzania, 1992 to 2002. They doubled in years of extreme rain. Victims were old women

To check against
SY-03 (Miguel 2005, Review of Economic Studies 72(4) 1153 to 1172: 67 villages, 65 witch murders, 96% of victims female, median age 50 to 60). Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-30 open §The drawn room and the small place

The killers came most often from the victims' own households, and the vigilance committee shielded them from the police

To check against
SY-03 (Miguel 2005: 87% of victims lived in the same household as their killers. Sungusungu shields perpetrators)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-32 open §The drawn room and the small place

The romance of the small, hierarchy as a disease of size, borrowed by the far right from blood-and-soil writers to present eco-fascists

To check against
SY-03 (Kohr 1957, Schumacher 1973, Staudenmaier on völkisch roots, Roberts and Moore 2022, The Rise of Ecofascism)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-34 open §Old does not mean good

The noble savage is usually pinned on Rousseau, who never used the phrase. It goes back to a French lawyer's account of New France in 1609 and an English play of 1672

To check against
SY-04 (Ellingson 2001, The Myth of the Noble Savage: Lescarbot 1609, Dryden 1672)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-36 open §Old does not mean good

An archaeologist assembled a table of violent death in societies before the state

To check against
SY-04 (Keeley 1996, War Before Civilization: Waorani, Jivaro, Aché, Dani)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-38 open §Old does not mean good

Two anthropologists found more than four in five killings among mobile foragers were between individuals

To check against
SY-04 (Fry and Söderberg 2013, 21 societies, 85% interpersonal). Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-40 open §Old does not mean good

A revisionist argued, against Lee, that the San had been tied to herders and trade long before the anthropologists came, a quarrel chapter 1 leaves open

To check against
SY-04 (Wilmsen 1989, Land Filled with Flies). Chapter 1 row C01-19
The verdict
OPEN
C10-41 open §Old does not mean good

Every forager society in the literature lived at the edge of a state, on marginal land

To check against
SY-04 (refugia). The narrator's "every" is strong, read as "the foragers studied in the twentieth century"
The verdict
OPEN
C10-42 open §Old does not mean good

An ethnohistorian looked for documentary proof that the Haudenosaunee shaped the American constitution and did not find it

To check against
SY-04 (Tooker 1988, Ethnohistory 35(4) 305 to 336). Payne and Levy as further critics
The verdict
OPEN
C10-43 open §Old does not mean good

The League's chiefly titles were held in particular lineages

To check against
SY-04 (Tooker 1988, 50 sachems, 9, 9, 14, 10, 8). SY-09 scores the titles as hereditary
The verdict
OPEN
C10-44 open §Old does not mean good

In 1777 a Mohawk war leader with British guns went round the councils and the League split

To check against
SY-04 (Joseph Brant, Thayendanegea, citing Richter 1992)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-45 open §Old does not mean good

Three kinds of evidence: what peoples said, what the record shows, what outsiders inferred

To check against
House frame. SY-03 and SY-04 tripartite tables
The verdict
OPEN
C10-46 open §Old does not mean good

The Levelling Floor was real, enforced sometimes by killing, and held only without storage and with exit

To check against
SY-04 (Boehm 1999, Woodburn, immediate-return economies). Preface row P-13 for Boehm's sample, chapter 1 rows C01-10, C01-38
The verdict
OPEN
C10-47 open §The wheel

Polybius described a cycle: kings to tyrants, nobles to oligarchs, people to mob, then a strongman

To check against
HI-14 (Polybius, Histories, anacyclosis)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-48 open §The wheel

Polybius held Rome's mixed constitution had broken the cycle. It only slowed it: the Gracchi in his lifetime, then Marius and Sulla, Caesar and an emperor

To check against
HI-14 (Polybius c. 200 to 118 BCE, Gracchi 133 and 121 BCE, Principate 27 BC). Chapter 6 owns Rome (C06-42, C06-46, C06-47)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-51 open §The wheel

Peter Turchin's structural-demographic cycle: population growth, falling wages, elite overproduction, state debt, counter-elites raise the poor. Two to three centuries

To check against
HI-14 (Goldstone 1991, Turchin and Nefedov, secular cycle of two to three centuries). Shared number owned here
The verdict
OPEN
C10-53 open §The wheel

The man who first built the theory says Turchin bends the variables

To check against
HI-14 (Goldstone's critique of Turchin's later variables)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-55 open §The wheel

Weimar's emergency article was opened again and again, lawfully, and the strongman came in through it

To check against
Cites P-26, P-27 and P-28
The verdict
OPEN
C10-58 open §The wheel

Key learnings: the critics win on the voter and the romance. The cycle is real, and design changes its length

To check against
The narrator's inference from C10-03 to C10-57. The Preface's strongest case against ("not a constant")
The verdict
OPEN
C10-59 open §The strongest case against

Quotation: "no substantial famine has ever occurred in any independent and democratic country with a relatively free press"

To check against
SY-01 (Sen 1999, Development as Freedom). Wording to be checked. Colonial Bengal 1943 is no counter-example
The verdict
OPEN
C10-60 open §The strongest case against

Where institutions are weak a ruler's death shifts growth, where strong it hardly matters

To check against
SY-01 (Jones and Olken 2005, QJE 120(3) 835 to 864, 57 leader deaths 1945 to 2000)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-61 open §The strongest case against

An allotted body that can only say no, to a budget or an emergency past its clock

To check against
SY-02 (Bagg 2022 and 2024, negative veto only). The emergency clock is the book's house term, Preface rows P-26 to P-28
The verdict
OPEN
C10-62 open §The strongest case against

The capture test is what this book adds: the designs the critics defeat never asked who would capture them

To check against
The book's frame (concept note). Inference
The verdict
OPEN
C10-64 open §In practice

Removing rulers by vote is historical practice. Restricting an assembly to it is the narrator's proposal

To check against
SY-01 (Sen, Jones and Olken). Proposal
The verdict
OPEN
C10-65 open §In practice

Every steering office rotating and itself drawn is the narrator's proposal. An allotted assembly with a veto rather than a pen is a theorist's proposal

To check against
SY-02 (Bagg). Proposal
The verdict
OPEN
C10-66 open §In practice

An outside audit did more for village roads than village monitoring

To check against
Cites chapter 12, which owns the Olken audit rows at C12-76 (SY-03, Olken 2007, missing funds 24% to 9%. MO-09 gives "30%")
The verdict
OPEN
C10-67 open §In practice

Red eyes from the cooking fire

To check against
SY-03 (Miguel 2005, red eyes "a biological symptom of cooking over smoky fires")
The verdict
OPEN
C10-68 open §In practice

Athens let any citizen prosecute a man for proposing an illegal decree, and the proposer stood trial

To check against
SY-01 (graphē paranomōn). Chapter 6 owns Athens (C06-21)
The verdict
OPEN
C10-69 open §In practice

What the critic's hour takes: one reader and recorder, one designated opponent, a room, about an hour a week in the season of rule-making. A standing critic per rule is a proposal

To check against
Design, the narrator's proposal. No document tests it
The verdict
OPEN