The Library · Document 357 · GOVERNING · Synthesis, critique and method
The scale ledger (meta-prompt, run with the library attached)
Synthesises the library's evidence into one scale ledger from household to planet, citing mainly outside sources. Builds on Johnson's (1982) scalar stress: flat decision making strains at about six people, needs dispute rules near 150 and permanent hierarchy past 1,500 to 2,500. Reviews pirate crews (Leeson 2009), Ostrom's commons, supported at 3.73 of 5 across 91 studies (Cox et al. 2010), the kibbutzim and Mondragon. Concludes that the region of half a million to five million is a valley of death where nothing has lasted without becoming a state.
Open the PDF 18 pages · 367 KB
- Number
- 357
- Letter code
- SY-08
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Synthesis, critique and method
- File
- 357 SY-08 The scale ledger (meta-prompt, run with the library attached).pdf
- Pages
- 18
- Works cited
- 46
Used in
The rows that check it
- 32 open
- 15 to check first
- P-21 open Check first At a few thousand an open assembly of all adults stops working
- P-22 open Check first At around fifty thousand, the watershed or market town, the arrangements thin out
- P-23 open Check first In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed
- C11-28 open Check first Several syntheses mark levelling as working in the household, another marks it failed through patriarchal violence
- C11-44 open Check first Gregory Johnson, archaeologist, 1982, scalar stress: strain at about six, split or hierarchy near 150, permanent hierarchy around 1,500
- C13-34 open Check first Archaeologists put the founding at about 1450 to 1500, from pottery and palisaded villages
- C14-63 open Check first Size disagrees by a factor of four or more. Shared number owned here
- C14-78 open Check first Cooperatives work up to the size of a town, Mondragon strained at region, its foreign plants ordinary capitalism
- C14-84 open Check first Key learning: no commons in the record has governed more than about 50,000 people on its own. Shared with chapter 15, cited from the Preface
- C15-20 open Check first Iceland had about as many people as a market town. Population disagrees: 40,000 to 70,000 and about 50,000 (GL-06), 50,000 to 80,000 (NA-02, Wikipedia), 40,000 to 80,000 (NO-07, a …
- C15-22 open Check first Definition of the Valley of Death: the region rung, half a million to five million people, where face to face has failed and the state is not yet built. The phrase is SY-08's …
- C15-23 open Check first In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed, and most who crossed did it by becoming a state. Shared number owned here (P-23)
- C15-24 open Check first Breaking points on the ladder: the band that splits (about 150), the village that needs written rules, the district that needs standing offices (about 1,500), the town too large …
- C15-25 open Check first The Hanse: no capital, treasury or army of its own, dominated Baltic trade for centuries, lost to territorial states. Why it lost is SY-08's reading of Spruyt. Ogilvie 2011 reads …
- C15-28 open Check first Only a minority come, by most counts between a tenth and a third. Shared number owned here. Documents disagree: 10 to 15% (SY-08, Rochat and Kübler 2021, Glarus, N 2042), about …
- C01-07 open Mobile foraging bands of 30 to 50 people
- C01-41 open Scale ledger: held in the band, strained in the village of 150 to 500 (clans must agree, feud at the edge), failed beyond (bodyguard, civil war)
- C05-71 open Scale ledger: worked household to district, strained at town and watershed, broke at region. Only the Gada claims to have held at region (NO-04 ledger, on the Borana's account and …
- C05-72 open Key learning: holds at the scale where debts can be counted, roughly the district
- C05-81 open No stateless order solved enforcement
- C11-60 open Key learning: split at the threshold rather than stack
- C12-13 open The village rung is 150 to 500 people, the third rung
- C13-30 open Tradition: blood feud among five nations, the Peacemaker, the feared Onondaga chief (Tadodaho, unnamed in the prose) with crooked body and snake hair
- C13-38 open Titles owned by women's lineages, clan mother selects, men of the clan and Grand Council confirm
- C14-05 open The town or watershed rung: 15,000 to 50,000 people
- C15-29 open Those who come are better schooled and freer on a Sunday
- C15-30 open A show of hands lets an employer see how his workers vote
- C15-32 open The square works for a district, strains at a town, is impossible for a region
- C15-67 open Learning: no federation in the record has solved enforcement without becoming a state
- C15-72 open The Haudenosaunee gave the clan mothers power to remove a chief
- C15-87 open No single resource pays the confederation, members pay in proportion
- C15-91 open Implementability: clerks keeping records in two copies, couriers, summer roads, a meeting place for a few weeks, a rotating secretariat, delegates a few weeks a year, auditors a …
Its works cited 46
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 21 journals, universities and public bodies
- 1 book, archive or patent
- 1 document-sharing site
- 2 encyclopaedias
- 2 blogs
- 2 shops and makers
- 17 other web pages
Show all 46
- T H E U N I V E R S I T Y O F C H I C A G isac-idb-static.uchicago.edu/multimedia/534/oi…
- (PDF) Chapter 1 Early human social organizations and ancient researchgate.net/publication/387183036_Chapter…
- Fissioning, Scalar Stress, and Social Evolution in Early Village researchgate.net/publication/227795396_Fission…
- theme and variations - Brill brill.com/view/journals/bki/162/2/article-p218…
- Opovo Revisited. Reconstructing Settlement Development and austriaca.at/0xc1aa5572%200x0041e8c2.pdf
- The Social Evolution of World Politics pub.uni-bielefeld.de/download/2978927/3004182/…
- Whither dominance? An enduring evolutionary legacy of primate pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10877274/
- The Three Ages of Government - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/20.500.12657/47505…
- Individuality and Entanglement: The Moral and Material Bases of dokumen.pub/individuality-and-entanglement-the…
- Whither dominance? An enduring evolutionary legacy of primate cambridge.org/core/journals/personality-neuros…
- THE INVISIBLE HOOK: THE LAW AND ECONOMICS OF PIRATE peterleeson.com/The_Invisible_Hook.pdf
- The Invisible Hook_ The Hidden Economics o - Peter T. Leeson.pdf syllabus.pirate.care/library/Peter%20T.%20Lees…
- Pirational choice - Peter Leeson peterleeson.com/pirational_choice.pdf
- The Invisible Hook: The Law and Economics of Pirate Tolerance researchgate.net/publication/228193281_The_Inv…
- Native American Influences on American Government resourcesforhistoryteachers.pbworks.com/w/page…
- Lies and Terror under Athens' Thirty Tyrants - Brewminate brewminate.com/thirty-tyrants-athens-lies-dece…
- The Peloponnesian War: How Greece Destroyed Itself - Fexingo fexingo.com/history/the-peloponnesian-war/
- Lessons from Athenian Democracy and Modern U.S. Immigration scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/view…
- part i beckassets.blob.core.windows.net/product/readi…
- Secret Ballots and Women's Political Voice - Project APE ape.socialcatalystlab.org/papers/apep_0438/v1/…
- Die Stimmbeteiligung an der Glarner Landsgemeinde - LeGes leges.weblaw.ch/legesissues/2018/1/die-stimmbe…
- Swiss Peasant War of 1653 - Historedia historedia.com/events/swiss-peasant-war-1653
- Assembly democracy between social selectivity and equality boris-portal.unibe.ch/bitstreams/829e2073-a414…
- Die Beteiligung an der Glarner Landsgemeinde ist tiefer als vermutet defacto.expert/2018/05/24/die-beteiligung-an-d…
- Renewal of the Kibbutz - Rah's Open Lid rahs-open-lid.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/R…
- Making Mondragon - United Diversity Library library.uniteddiversity.coop/Cooperatives/Mond…
- Zionist Settlement Policy and Kibbutz Collective Practices, 1920–2010 scholarworks.gvsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti…
- The kibbutz. Awakening from Utopia - Solidaridad Obrera solidaridadobrera.org/ateneo_nacho/libros/Dani…
- TRANSFORMING KIBBUTZ RESEARCH - ResearchGate researchgate.net/profile/Reuven-Shapira/post/W…
- Case Study: Innovations in Corporate Governance - SciSpace scispace.com/pdf/case-study-innovations-in-cor…
- Co-operative Governance Fit to Build Resilience in the Face of ica.coop/sites/default/files/basic-page-attach…
- Workforce participation : learning from the co-operative sector shura.shu.ac.uk/10104/1/EMES_-_DeNormanville%2…
- Grounding and Applying an Ethical Test to Organisations as Moral d-nb.info/1271853248/34
- 1937 in the Spanish Civil War - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1937_in_the_Spanish_Civi…
- Revolutionary Anarchism in Spain - the CNT 1911-1937 (Winter 1981) marxists.org/history/etol/writers/durgan/1981/…
- Enrique Líster - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enrique_L%C3%ADster
- The Economic Origins of the Territorial State cambridge.org/core/journals/international-orga…
- Assessing the Impact of the World Conservation Strategy After 45 mdpi.com/2673-7159/6/3/101
- Governing Outer Space as a Global Commons: Examining 'Tragedy open.uct.ac.za/bitstreams/b28e4429-6aa4-473c-b…
- Institutional Selection in International Relations: State Anarchy as rochelleterman.com/ir/sites/default/files/Spru…
- 4. What do we mean when we speak about the ... - Semantic Scholar pdfs.semanticscholar.org/0ea3/014fecd17dab31aa…
- The Kibbutz and Israeli Society in - Berghahn Journals berghahnjournals.com/view/journals/israel-stud…
- Moving beyond panaceas: a multi-tiered diagnostic approach for cambridge.org/core/journals/environmental-cons…
- (PDF) Introducing the "The Importance of Context, Scale, and researchgate.net/publication/309540260_Introdu…
- Mean and median ranking of the evaluation of the design principles researchgate.net/figure/Mean-and-median-rankin…
- L7 Ostrom Design Principles - Level 7 level-7.org/Philosophy/Ostrom/