GOVERNING · Part II · The Captured Lottery
The numbers and sources
Chapter 10: The Case Against
The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 69 open
- 18 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- About a third: the share of Americans who cannot name the party that controls the House of Representatives, with no improvement over decades of rising schooling (Somin 2013 and 2016, SY-01). Row C10-07. Shared number owned here.
- About nine in ten: the share of citizens invited to an assembly drawn by lot who decline (OECD 2020 and 2023, SY-02, which gives 90% to 97% and elsewhere 90% to 95%). Row C10-19. Shared number owned here.
- Doubled: witch killings in years of extreme rainfall across 67 villages of Meatu district, Tanzania, 1992 to 2002, while other homicides did not move (Miguel 2005, Review of Economic Studies, SY-03). Row C10-29. Shared number owned here.
- Between one in eight and one in seven, against more than four in five: deaths in war in pooled small-scale samples (Bowles 2009, 13% to 15%) against the share of killings among mobile foragers that were between individuals (Fry and Söderberg 2013, 85%), both SY-04. Rows C10-37 and C10-38. Shared numbers owned here.
- Two to three centuries and four generations: the length of Turchin's secular cycle and of Ibn Khaldun's dynastic cycle (HI-14). Rows C10-51 and C10-49. Shared numbers owned here.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Source | Document | Row | Kind | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | publication of Against Democracy | Brennan 2016, Princeton University Press | SY-01 | C10-03 | record | robust |
| Most voters hobbits, most of the rest hooligans | Brennan's typology of the electorate | Brennan 2016 | SY-01 | C10-04 | inferred | contested |
| About a third | Americans unable to name the House majority party | Somin 2013, Democracy and Political Ignorance, and 2016 | SY-01 | C10-07 | record | robust |
| Errors that lean the same way | systematic voter bias, four kinds | Caplan 2007, The Myth of the Rational Voter, SAEE survey of the public and economists | SY-01 | C10-08 | inferred | contested |
| 1916 | the New Jersey shark attacks and Wilson's vote | Achen and Bartels 2016, Democracy for Realists | SY-01 | C10-10 | inferred | fallen |
| The last few months of income | the window that drives incumbent votes, 2 to 3 quarters | Achen and Bartels 2016 | SY-01 | C10-11 | inferred | contested |
| 1872 to 2012 | the elections in the shark replication | Fowler and Hall 2018, Journal of Politics | SY-01 | C10-12 | inferred | robust |
| 1890 and 1965 | Mississippi's literacy test and the federal law that ended exclusion | no source named | SY-01 | C10-14 | record | open |
| 2020 | publication of Democracy without Shortcuts | Lafont 2020, Oxford University Press | SY-02 | C10-16 | record | robust |
| About nine in ten | invited citizens who decline an allotted assembly | OECD 2020 and 2023, 289 or more cases | SY-02 | C10-19 | record | robust |
| A series of weekends, a long list | the French convention's sittings and recommendations, seven and 149 | Giraudet et al. and narrative | SY-02 | C10-21 | record | robust |
| Several struck out | measures the president vetoed, three "jokers" | narrative | SY-02 | C10-22 | record | robust |
| A fraction | measures enacted intact by the 2021 law, "fewer than 10% to 20%" | no source named | SY-02 | C10-23 | record | open |
| Failed it | members' mark for the government, 2.5 out of 10, February 2021 | narrative, single source | SY-02 | C10-24 | record | open |
| 4 November 1948 | Ambedkar's speech in the Constituent Assembly | Constituent Assembly Debates | SY-03 | C10-26 | record | robust |
| Again and again | capture of devolved village funds | Mansuri and Rao 2013, Localizing Development, World Bank, about 490 evaluations | SY-03 | C10-27 | inferred | robust |
| Doubled | witch killings in extreme rainfall years, Meatu | Miguel 2005, Review of Economic Studies 72(4), 67 villages, 65 witch murders | SY-03 | C10-29 | inferred | robust |
| Most often their own households | relation of killers to victims, 87% same household | Miguel 2005 | SY-03 | C10-30 | record | robust |
| About five hundred voters | town meeting size below which it works best | Bryan 2004, Real Democracy, 1,435 meetings in 210 Vermont towns | SY-03 | C10-31 | inferred | open |
| 1609 and 1672 | first uses of "noble savage" | Ellingson 2001, The Myth of the Noble Savage (Lescarbot, Dryden) | SY-04 | C10-34 | record | robust |
| Between one in eight and one in seven | deaths in war in pooled small-scale samples | Bowles 2009, 15 populations, 13% to 15% | SY-04 | C10-37 | inferred | contested |
| More than four in five | killings among mobile foragers that were between individuals | Fry and Söderberg 2013, Science, 21 societies, 85% | SY-04 | C10-38 | inferred | contested |
| 1777 | Brant's breach of the League's unanimity | Richter 1992 | SY-04 | C10-44 | record | robust |
| 1377 | Ibn Khaldun's Muqaddimah | Ibn Khaldun | HI-14 | C10-49 | record | robust |
| Four generations | Khaldunian dynastic cycle, about 120 years | Ibn Khaldun, via dergipark and Wikipedia | HI-14 | C10-49 | said | open |
| Two to three centuries | Turchin's secular cycle | Goldstone 1991, Turchin and Nefedov | HI-14 | C10-51 | inferred | contested |
| 2010 and 2020 | Turchin's forecast and its target year | Turchin 2010, Nature, reached via his site and a video | HI-14 | C10-52 | said | open |
| The income Argentina had in 1975 | wealth above which no democracy fell, $6,055 PPP | Przeworski, Alvarez, Cheibub and Limongi 2000, Democracy and Development, 141 countries | SY-01 | C10-63 | inferred | robust |
Nine figures in the prose are counted against the limit of ten: a third, nine in ten, doubled, five hundred, one in eight to one in seven, four in five, four generations, two to three centuries, and Argentina's 1975 income. Years and dates are not counted.
The capture test
The chapter makes one capture turn, the most patient person in the room in an assembly drawn by lot. SY-02 names four stages at which organisers capture an allotted body: framing the agenda, choosing the evidence and experts, facilitating the talk and drafting the text. Ostbelgien's secretariat filters the topics and draws on a narrow circle of experts. The resisting feature SY-02 accepts is a body drawn by lot that holds only a negative veto (Bagg), so that there is less to steer.
The other captures the chapter touches, as the reports give them:
| Arrangement | Who captures and how | Case | What resisted | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Epistocracy | whoever writes and administers the test | Mississippi 1890 to 1965 | federal law from outside | SY-01 |
| Village development funds | the literate, landed men who chair the committee | Mansuri and Rao's evaluations, the Punjab water boards | outside audit, reserved seats, direct transfers | SY-03 |
| Village justice in a crisis | kin and neighbours with the vigilance committee's cover | Meatu 1992 to 2002 | the distant state police, weakly | SY-03 |
| Indigenous confederacy | a war leader with outside guns bypassing unanimity | Brant 1777 | the clan mothers' power to remove a chief | SY-04 |
| Asabiyyah polity | the ruler who replaces his own people with paid foreign soldiers | Samarra, 836 | religious revival, temporarily | HI-14 |
| Structural-demographic cycle | a frustrated counter-elite mobilising the immiserated | France 1789 | elites yielding, as in Britain's Reform Acts and the repeal of the Corn Laws | HI-14 |
The scale ledger
Labels as the reports give them. W worked, S strained, mixed or marginal, F failed, N never tried, I inapplicable.
| Arrangement | Household | Hamlet | Village | District | Watershed | Region | Nation | Planet | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct assembly | F (dysfunctional) | W | W | S | S (ceiling, quorum 6,000) | F | N | N | SY-01 |
| Epistocracy | F | F | F | S (distorted) | W | W | S (ceiling) | N | SY-01 |
| Polyarchy | F | S | W | W (core strength) | W | W | S (ceiling) | N | SY-01 |
| Sortition | I | I | S (chores only) | S (marginal) | W (with an excluded underclass) | S (consultative only) | S (symbolic) | F (impossible) | SY-02 |
| Madisonian republic | N | F | F | S (vulnerable) | W | W (optimal) | W or S | F | SY-03 |
| Community-driven development | N | S | F (primary failure site) | S (partly worked) | W | F | N | N | SY-03 |
| Town meeting assembly | W | W | W (golden rung) | S (under 10% attend) | F | N | N | N | SY-03 |
| Forager band and levelling | W | W | F | N | N | N | N | N | SY-04 |
| Haudenosaunee League | W | W | W | W | W | F | N | N | SY-04 |
| Mixed constitution | N | N | W | W | S | F (cyclic) | F (cyclic) | N | HI-14 |
| Asabiyyah polity | W | W | W | S | F (cyclic) | F (cyclic) | F (cyclic) | N | HI-14 |
| Venetian lot and supermajority | N | S | W | W | W | W | N | N | HI-14 |
The chapter's sentence: assembly and levelling hold at the hamlet and the village and fail above them, lot has worked only inside a closed citizenry, and where the village's misfit was rescued at all, the rescue came from the rung above. The evidence is thick at village and town and thin at the district. HI-14's Venetian row puts Venice at region where other documents put its Great Council at district, and its village cell rests on Athenian demes without a source. Many "worked" cells, such as the household for the Haudenosaunee, are assertions without a case.
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
The critics win on the voter: ordinary voters know little, vote by team and take their opinions from their party, and their mistakes do not cancel. They win on the romance: old does not mean good, small does not mean fair, indigenous does not mean democratic, and the forager record cannot support "peaceful". Lot and localism fail the same way, to whoever stands closest to the mechanism. The cycle is real, and the scoring of designs misses the four forces that turn it: size, arms, debt and favours, and a host state. What design changes is the length of the cycle, not its existence.
The case against
The chapter's case against is the case for the book, and it is deliberately the weaker section. No substantial famine in a democracy with a free press (Sen). Leaders matter where institutions are weak (Jones and Olken 2005). A body drawn by lot can be limited to a veto (Bagg). The critics defeat designs that never ran a capture test. The chapter itself undercuts this: Przeworski's wealth line lies far above any society the book is written for, the famine line was drawn in countries with newspapers and railways, and the veto-only lottery is untried.
Where the sources disagree
- The sharks. Achen and Bartels's 1916 effect did not replicate across 1872 to 2012 (Fowler and Hall 2018). SY-01 holds that the central finding on identity voting survives. Status: the illustration fallen, the finding contested.
- Refusal. SY-02 gives 90% to 97% in one place and 90% to 95% in another.
- Violence. SY-04 calls 15% to 25% of deaths "intergroup", but its source for war deaths gives 13% to 15% (Bowles 2009), and Fry and Söderberg (2013) find 85% of killings interpersonal. The violence samples were compiled by authors arguing for high violence.
- Town meeting ceiling. SY-03 gives a breaking point of about 1,500 people in one place and a ceiling of about 500 voters in another. Chapter 12 owns the turnout figures.
- Lot in the village. SY-02 holds lot fit for chores only at village scale, while SY-01, SY-03 and SY-04 draw village councils or wardens by lot. No document cites a village governed by an allotted council, though HI-14 asserts Athenian demes drew magistrates by lot.
- Venice. SY-01 calls Venice the most resilient anti-capture design, 1,100 years without a coup. SY-02 calls it lot inside an oligarchy that disenfranchised over 95% (Finlay 1981). HI-14 says the doge procedure ran flawlessly for seven centuries and lists ten steps after promising nine. Chapter 7 owns Venice.
- Growth. SY-01's text gives Przeworski's growth rates in one order and its own summary in the other (4.4% against 4.2%). The chapter does not use them.
- Sortition as proof. HI-14's summary calls lot with supermajority "proven" against capture, while its own capture test gives Florence as a counter-example.
- Turchin. Goldstone faults the later variables, Slingerland the coding of the database, Meadows and Ryall the mechanism itself. Scheidel holds that only violence levels.
- Synthesis scores. SY-09 scores Athens at 14 of 22 (63.6%), Porto Alegre 16 (72.7%), the Amish 13 (59.1%) and Venice 10 (45.5%). Its oddities include full marks to Venice for tenure and rotation though its doge served for life. The scores are synthesis only and appear nowhere in the chapter.
Open questions
- Does voter ignorance matter as much in a village, where the results of a decision are on everyone's plate, as in a nation? No document measures it.
- Has a body drawn by lot with only a negative veto ever run anywhere for long? The proposal is a theorist's (Bagg), and no case is given.
- What is the refusal rate when there is no state to pay members, mail invitations or compel attendance?
- How long is a cycle at the district or village scale? Every cycle length in HI-14 is measured on states and empires.
- Who holds the weapons? SY-09 names asymmetry of armed force as a force its scores miss, and chapter 1 leaves open how levelling fares if firearms survive and are unequally held.
- Can the critics' questions be asked routinely without the designated critic becoming one more office to capture? The chapter's proposal is untested.
The documents
- Brennan, Jason. Against Democracy. Princeton University Press, 2016 (SY-01).
- Caplan, Bryan. The Myth of the Rational Voter. Princeton University Press, 2007 (SY-01).
- Somin, Ilya. Democracy and Political Ignorance. Stanford University Press, 2013, second edition 2016 (SY-01).
- Achen, Christopher and Larry Bartels. Democracy for Realists. Princeton University Press, 2016 (SY-01).
- Fowler, Anthony and Andrew Hall. Do shark attacks influence presidential elections? Journal of Politics, 2018 (SY-01).
- Estlund, David. Democratic Authority. Princeton University Press, 2008 (SY-01).
- Sen, Amartya. Development as Freedom. 1999 (SY-01).
- Przeworski, Adam, Michael Alvarez, José Antonio Cheibub and Fernando Limongi. Democracy and Development. Cambridge University Press, 2000 (SY-01).
- Jones, Benjamin and Benjamin Olken. Do leaders matter? Quarterly Journal of Economics 120(3), 2005 (SY-01).
- Lafont, Cristina. Democracy without Shortcuts. Oxford University Press, 2020 (SY-02).
- Lafont, Cristina and Nadia Urbinati. The Lottocratic Mentality. 2024 (SY-02).
- Landa, Dimitri and Ryan Pevnick. American Political Science Review 114(1), 2020, and Journal of Political Philosophy 29(1), 2021 (SY-02).
- OECD. Innovative Citizen Participation and New Democratic Institutions, 2020, and later updates, 2023 (SY-02).
- Bagg, Samuel. The Dispersion of Power, 2024, and American Journal of Political Science (SY-02).
- Mansuri, Ghazala and Vijayendra Rao. Localizing Development: Does Participation Work? World Bank, 2013 (SY-03).
- Jacoby, Hanan, Ghazala Mansuri and Freeha Fatima, 2021, on the capture of decentralised irrigation management in Punjab, Pakistan (SY-03).
- Miguel, Edward. Poverty and witch killing. Review of Economic Studies 72(4), 2005 (SY-03).
- Bryan, Frank. Real Democracy: The New England Town Meeting and How It Works. University of Chicago Press, 2004 (SY-03).
- Ambedkar, B. R. Speech of 4 November 1948. Constituent Assembly Debates, New Delhi (SY-03).
- Staudenmaier, Peter, on the völkisch roots of ecology, and Roberts, Alex and Sam Moore. The Rise of Ecofascism, 2022 (SY-03).
- Ellingson, Ter. The Myth of the Noble Savage. University of California Press, 2001 (SY-04).
- Keeley, Lawrence. War Before Civilization. Oxford University Press, 1996 (SY-04).
- Bowles, Samuel. Science, 2009 (SY-04).
- Fry, Douglas and Patrik Söderberg. Science, 2013 (SY-04).
- Wilmsen, Edwin. Land Filled with Flies. University of Chicago Press, 1989 (SY-04).
- Tooker, Elisabeth. Ethnohistory 35(4), 1988 (SY-04).
- Richter, Daniel. The Ordeal of the Longhouse. 1992 (SY-04).
- Polybius. Histories, Book VI (HI-14).
- Ibn Khaldun. The Muqaddimah, 1377 (HI-14).
- Turchin, Peter and Sergey Nefedov. Secular Cycles. Princeton University Press, 2009, and Turchin, End Times, 2023 (HI-14).
- Goldstone, Jack. Revolution and Rebellion in the Early Modern World. 1991 (HI-14).
- Scheidel, Walter. The Great Leveler. Princeton University Press, 2017 (HI-14).