THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 16: The Clock on the Emergency

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 94 open
  • 33 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 94 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Six months against no date at all: the Roman dictator's longest term (row C06-42, owned by chapter 6, cited by the Preface as P-29) against the Reichstag Fire Decree of February 1933, issued under Article 48 with no end date (P-27, owned by the Preface). Rows C16-09 and C16-04.
  2. Three-fifths, then seven in ten, then four in five: Bruce Ackerman's supermajority escalator for renewing an emergency, from Before the Next Attack, 2006 (HI-13). Row C16-31. HI-13's own design of 30 days and 60, 75 and 90 per cent is a different proposal and is not Ackerman's.
  3. Seven: the members of the Swiss Federal Council, elected by the federal parliament since 1848, with a presidency that rotates each year (ME-07, SY-09). Row C16-35. Shared number owned here.
  4. Between a third and a half: the share of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth's diets broken by a single veto, with most of them broken in the century after 1652 (HI-08 citing Konopczyński at second hand, PS-03 citing Davies). Row C16-54. Shared number owned here.
  5. Twelve years: Agamben's count of the time Hitler held the Weimar constitution suspended without abolishing it (HI-13). Row P-28, owned by the Preface, cited as C16-17.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
27 February 1933the night the parliament building burnedgeneral knowledge, not in the documentsnoneC16-01recordopen
1919the Weimar constitution and its Article 48the constitution as quotedHI-13C16-03recordrobust
Three chancellors, 1930 to 1933Brüning, Papen and Schleicher governing by decreeWeimar recordHI-13P-26, C16-05recordrobust
50 to 500 millionthe nation or continent rungthe book's rung definitionsconcept noteC16-08designopen
Six monthsthe Roman dictator's longest termLintott 1999, Rossiter 1948HI-13, HI-02C06-42, P-29, C16-09recordrobust
1922, 1931Schmitt's Political Theology and his Guardian of the Constitution, Kelsen's replySchmitt 1922, 1931, Kelsen 1931HI-13C16-14, C16-15saidopen
Twelve yearsthe suspension of the Weimar constitutionAgamben 2005, State of ExceptionHI-13P-28, C16-17inferredopen
1933the Enabling ActWeimar recordHI-13C16-18recordrobust
1948Rossiter's Constitutional DictatorshipRossiter 1948HI-13C16-22inferredrobust
April 1861, 4 July 1861, 1863, 1864Lincoln's suspension, his message, the ratifying act, the wartime electionthe record of the Civil WarHI-13C16-23 to C16-25recordrobust
April 1793, July 1794the Committee of Public Safety and its fallGreer 1935, Quinet 1865HI-13C16-27recordrobust
June 1975, 1977India's emergency and the election that ended itthe recordHI-13C16-28recordrobust
2006, three-fifths, seven in ten, four in fiveAckerman's escalatorAckerman 2006, Before the Next AttackHI-13C16-31designopen
The first year of the pandemicV-Dem's tracking of 144 countries, Q2 to Q4 2020Edgell et al., V-Dem PanDemHI-13C16-32recordopen
Seven, 1848the Swiss Federal Counciluncited in ME-07, Vatter 2018 in SY-09ME-07, SY-09C16-35recordopen
1959the magic formulauncitedME-07, SY-09C16-37recordopen
2003, 2007Blocher's seat and his removal at the scheduled electionVatter 2018, Linder 1994SY-09C16-39recordrobust
1971federal vote for Swiss womenthe recordSY-09C16-40recordrobust
Two consulsRome's collegial executiveLintott 1999HI-02, ME-07C06-36, C16-41recordrobust
1243, two, six monthsSan Marino's Captains Regenttourism and atlas sites, an old State Department pageME-07C16-42recordopen
January 2026the offensive and ceasefire in north-east Syrianews sourcesMO-05C16-44recordopen
1952, 1967, 1973Uruguay's council, its abolition, the coupthe recordME-07C16-45recordrobust
2019the standing citizens' council in German-speaking Belgiumthe recordME-08C16-50recordrobust
1652Siciński's first vetoa Polish blog, Davies 1981HI-08, PS-03C16-52recordopen
Between a third and a halfdiets broken by one vetoKonopczyński 1918 at second hand, Davies 1981HI-08, PS-03C16-54recordcontested
1788 to 1792, 3 May 1791the Great Diet and the constitution that abolished the vetothe recordHI-08, PS-03C16-56recordrobust
1792, 1793, 1795, 1918Targowica, the partitions, the returnthe record, 123 years in HI-08HI-08C16-57recordrobust
1579the Union of Utrechtthe recordHI-08, GL-05C16-59recordrobust
1672the Disaster Year and the killing of the de Witt brothersWikipedia pagesME-07C16-61recordopen
1781Rhode Island's refusal of the impostone blogHI-08, GL-05C16-62recordopen
1414 to 1418the Council of Constancethe recordGL-04C16-64recordrobust
1987, early 2000sChina's village elections and their recentralisationMartinez-Bravo et al. 2022, American Economic ReviewMO-11C16-67recordrobust
2011, 2016Wukan's election and its head's arreststate mediaMO-11C16-68recordopen
2015Indonesia's Village FundLaw 6/2014MO-11C16-69recordrobust
March 2014, 2015, 2016, 2022, May 2024the Sunflower occupation, vTaiwan and Pol.is, Tang's officesthe recordMO-04, ME-13C16-72 to C16-77recordrobust

The capture test

The chapter's turn is the Swiss Federal Council. The captor: Christoph Blocher, a billionaire who led the Swiss People's Party, elected to the council in 2003. The first move: breaking the council's custom of collegiality by attacking fellow councillors in public and using his department for party campaigning. What stopped it: the fixed term. At the scheduled election of 2007 the Federal Assembly gave his seat to another member of his party (SY-09, citing Vatter 2018). Nothing in law forbade what he did. The college's own clock removed him.

The other captures in the chapter are told without the turn. Weimar's was a single point of failure, a revocation that needed a fragmented parliament to form a majority (HI-13). The liberum veto's capture vector was to buy the weakest node, one deputy (HI-08). Rojava's is one party filling every co-chair, which its critics allege (ME-03).

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Emergency office with a clock, RomeuntrieduntriedworkedworkedworkedfailedfaileduntriedHI-13, HI-02
Emergency article with a check and no clock, WeimaruntrieduntrieduntrieduntrieduntrieduntriedfaileduntriedHI-13
Emergency by the executive's own restraint, Lincolnuntrieduntrieduntrieduntrieduntrieduntriedworked onceuntriedHI-13
Swiss Federal Counciluntrieduntrieduntrieduntrieduntriedworkedworked, at 8.7 millionuntriedME-07, SY-09
Two consulsuntrieduntrieduntrieduntriedworkedworkedfaileduntriedME-07
San Marino's Captains RegentuntrieduntrieduntriedworkedworkeduntrieduntrieduntriedME-07
Rojava's co-chairsworkedworkedworkedworkedworkedworkeduntrieduntriedME-07, advocacy sources
Uruguay's counciluntrieduntrieduntrieduntrieduntriedfaileduntrieduntriedME-07
Veto playersfailedfailedworked under conditionsworked poorlyworkedworkedworkedfailedME-08
Multi-body sortitionfailedfailedworked under conditionsworkedworkedworkeduntriedfailedME-08
Liberum vetountriedworkedfailedfailedfailedfailedfaileduntriedHI-08
Dutch States Generalworkedworkedworkedworkedworkedworkedfailed in the long rununtriedHI-08
EU unanimityn/an/an/an/an/an/afailed at continentuntriedHI-08, GL-05
Pol.is and vTaiwanfailedfaileduntrieduntriedworkedworkedworked with a host stateuntriedME-13, MO-04

The ledgers in the documents do not use the book's rung sizes consistently. HI-08 calls the Polish Commonwealth and the Dutch Republic nations, ME-07 calls Switzerland's 8.7 million a nation, and both are region size on the book's ladder. The chapter's ledger sentence says only what survives that correction: colleges with short terms have worked from a town to a federation of a few million people and are untried at the size of a large nation, and unanimity held in small leagues and failed at the region and above.

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

An emergency power is safe only when it carries an end date written into the grant and only another body can move it. A check that needs a majority to stop the emergency fails in the divided parliaments where emergencies are declared, while a clock that needs a majority to continue lets division do the guarding. Colleges with a rotating chair and fixed terms are slow and can be overthrown from outside, but in the record read none was turned into one man's rule from its own chair. Unanimity at the size of a region or more becomes a veto that can be bought. The documents behind this: HI-13 on what ended on time, HI-02 on the separation of declaring and naming in Rome, ME-07 on colleges, HI-08 and GL-05 on unanimity.

The case against

Giorgio Agamben (State of Exception, 2005, via HI-13) argues that the exception has become the ordinary technique of modern government, so any clock is written by the order that decides when to ignore it. David Dyzenhaus (via HI-13) adds that emergency rules reshape ordinary law whatever their dates. HI-13's own design names the first failure of an escalating renewal: a faction blocking a renewal the danger still needs. Alexander Hamilton's Federalist 70 (via ME-07) holds that a plural executive conceals faults and destroys responsibility, and ME-07's first failure is the college that hesitates before a raiding army and hands power to a warlord. Henry Hansmann (via ME-07) argues that collective executives work only among people with similar interests.

Where the sources disagree

  1. The first senatus consultum ultimum: 133 BC in HI-13 against 121 BC in HI-02 (C06-46). The chapter dates neither.
  2. HI-13 gives the Roman Senate as 150 to 500 members. This looks wrong and is not used.
  3. Ackerman's escalator: 60, 70 and 80 per cent in HI-13's account of his book, then 30 days and 60, 75 and 90 per cent in HI-13's own design, without saying it changed him.
  4. V-Dem: 144 countries, but the three groups HI-13 gives sum to 135.
  5. The liberum veto's count: about 73 of about 150 and 48 of 55 (HI-08) against 53 of 150 (PS-03). Rounded in the chapter to between a third and a half.
  6. Schmitt reaches HI-13 through Goodreads, Agamben through Wikipedia and Medium, Siciński through a Polish blog, Rhode Island's 1781 refusal through one blog, Holland's 58 per cent through Wikipedia, the de Witt killing through Wikipedia, Wukan through state media, India's village figures in MO-11 through coaching sites, Taiwan's mask apps through taiwan.md.
  7. The Swiss seven, 1848, the 1959 formula and 8.7 million are uncited in ME-07. ME-07's Rome section has no citations at all.
  8. Rojava's co-chair record in ME-07 rests on advocacy sources, while ME-03 cites critics who call it a Leninist one-party statelet.
  9. ME-08's figure that only 4 of 25 stable democracies were presidential has a doubtful attribution.
  10. vTaiwan's "80 per cent of 26 cases" comes from a paper co-written by Tang and is audited and narrowed by MO-04, while ME-13 repeats it.
  11. Join petitions: 13,853 initiated and 7,067 verified (MO-04) against 7,067 initiated (ME-13).
  12. MO-11's "+166 per cent" is +155 per cent by its own numbers.
  13. The concept note's key learnings "every tyranny began with an unexpired emergency" and "a college with a rotating chair has never produced a dictator" are stated by no document. The chapter softens both and says so in its rows C16-20 and C16-46.

Open questions

  1. Is it safer for a constitution to forbid emergency powers and force an executive to act illegally and seek indemnity afterwards, as Lincoln did, or to write them in with a clock and risk them becoming the way in, as at Weimar? HI-13 leaves this open.
  2. Can a clock hold when the danger comes from inside and the government defines it? The cases that ended on time all had a visible danger from outside.
  3. Has any college with a rotating chair been turned into one person's rule by one of its own members? The chapter found none in the documents read, and a wider search might.
  4. Does consensus government make societies gentler, or do gentle societies build consensus government? ME-08 records the dispute over Lijphart's findings.
  5. Can an analog version of bridging, statements on a wall and marks of agreement, work without software, and who keeps the tally?
  6. What remains of Rojava's co-chairs after the January 2026 agreement?

The documents

  1. Clinton Rossiter, Constitutional Dictatorship: Crisis Government in the Modern Democracies, 1948.
  2. Bruce Ackerman, Before the Next Attack: Preserving Civil Liberties in an Age of Terrorism, 2006.
  3. Giorgio Agamben, State of Exception, 2005.
  4. Carl Schmitt, Political Theology, 1922, read as the warning, with Hans Kelsen, Wer soll der Hüter der Verfassung sein?, 1931.
  5. John Ferejohn and Pasquale Pasquino, The Law of the Exception: A Typology of Emergency Powers, 2004.
  6. Amanda Edgell and colleagues, the V-Dem Pandemic Backsliding Project.
  7. Norman Davies, God's Playground, 1981, on the liberum veto.
  8. Arend Lijphart, Patterns of Democracy, 1999 and 2012, and George Tsebelis, Veto Players, 2002.
  9. Terrill Bouricius, Democracy Through Multi-Body Sortition, 2013.
  10. Adrian Vatter, Der Bundesrat, 2018, on the Swiss Federal Council.
  11. Monica Martinez-Bravo, Gerard Padró i Miquel, Nancy Qian and Yang Yao, The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China, American Economic Review, 2022.
  12. Yu-Tang Hsiao, Shu-Yang Lin, Audrey Tang, Darshana Narayanan and Claudina Sarahe, vTaiwan: An Empirical Study of Open Consultation Process in Taiwan, 2018, read with MO-04's audit of it.

Its documents in the Library

274 280 285 309 313 314 319 323 333 334 340 345 346 358