THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 17: The Seventh Generation

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 101 open
  • 16 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 101 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Over 98 per cent: the share of ozone-depleting chemicals phased out under the Montreal Protocol, with every country a party (GL-03, citing Barrett 2003 and the protocol's technology panel). Row C17-13. Shared number owned here.
  2. A hundred, and about a third: the members of the Global Assembly of 2021 drawn by lot to stand for the world, and the share of them not entirely literate (GL-02, 35 per cent). Rows C17-39 and C17-40. Shared numbers owned here.
  3. Nineteen years: the median life of national constitutions written since 1789 (Elkins, Ginsburg and Melton 2009, GL-08). Row C17-53. Shared number owned here.
  4. From about a third to about a half: the share of groups choosing to leave resources for later, without and then with members speaking for imaginary future generations (Kamijo 2017, ME-12, 28 to 33.7 per cent against 44.5 to 60 per cent). Row C17-66. Shared number owned here.
  5. Over 40 per cent and two in three: the rise in emissions since 1990 under the climate patchwork, and the share of Covenant of Mayors cities that filed no progress account (GL-03, Palermo 2021, 67.5 per cent of 5,054). Rows C17-78 and C17-79. Shared numbers owned here.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSourceDocumentRowKindStatus
1977facial pockmark searches in IndiaGL-01, about 17,000 specimens collected that yearGL-01C17-01recordrobust
1980smallpox eradicatedWHO, as GL-01 gives itGL-01C17-06recordrobust
1967the WHO's final campaign from its regular budgetWHO, $2.4 millionGL-01C17-08recordrobust
One vial much furtherdoses per vial with the forked needleRubin's bifurcated needle, up to 100 a vialGL-01C17-09recordrobust
1987Montreal Protocol adoptedtreaty recordGL-01, GL-03C17-12recordrobust
Over 98 per centcontrolled ozone-depleting chemicals phased outTEAP, Barrett 2003GL-03C17-13recordrobust
Every countryparties to the protocol198 parties, universal ratificationGL-03C17-14recordrobust
2003Barrett's coercion reading of MontrealBarrett 2003, Environment and StatecraftGL-03C17-16inferredcontested
2018 and 2019illicit CFC-11 traced to eastern ChinaAGAGE monitoring networkGL-03C17-17recordrobust
1959 and 1991Antarctic Treaty and its mining banWikipedia, as GL-01 gives itGL-01C17-19recordopen
1994Rwanda and the Security CouncilFortna and others, as GL-01 gives themGL-01C17-21recordrobust
1992Clark's line on kings, presidents and votingRFC 7241 mirror at hjp.atMO-12C17-23saidopen
2014the IETF note on what consensus meansRFC 7282, Resnick 2014MO-12C17-25recordrobust
A small core of regularsshare of participants who do most of the workMcQuistin 2021: 2,106,804 emails, 840 lists, a 5 to 10 per cent coreMO-12C17-27recordrobust
2016IANA transition to ICANNMO-12MO-12C17-30recordrobust
2019 and April 2020the .org sale and its halt by the California Attorney GeneralMO-12, Ethos Capital, $1.13 billionMO-12C17-31recordrobust
Eight billionthe planet runggeneral knowledge, every GL ledgerGL-01C17-34recordrobust
1795Kant's warning of a soulless despotismKant, Perpetual PeaceGL-02C17-35saidrobust
More constituents than many countriesa world parliament's arithmeticDahl 1999: 1,000 members, 8 million eachGL-02C17-36inferredrobust
2021the Global Assembly at COP26Dryzek, Bächtiger and Milewicz 2011 for the design, the Assembly's own declarationGL-02C17-38recordrobust
A hundredmembers drawn by stratified lotGlobal Assembly, 68 hours over 11 weeks, over 30 languagesGL-02C17-39recordrobust
About a thirdmembers not entirely literateGlobal Assembly, 35 per cent, most under $10 a dayGL-02C17-40recordrobust
2009 and 2010Ostrom's polycentric papers on climateOstrom 2009, World Bank, Ostrom 2010GL-03C17-44recordrobust
1297 to 1323the Serratachapter 7HI-03 via chapter 7C17-49recordrobust
1916written source of the seventh-generation teachingParker 1916IN-01C17-51recordcontested
A century and a half to two centuriesthe teaching's horizonParker 1916, IN-01 inconsistent (150 to 200, and 150)IN-01C17-51inferredopen
Nineteen yearsmedian life of constitutions since 1789Elkins, Ginsburg and Melton 2009, 929 constitutionsGL-08C17-53recordcontested
Sixth century to 2006Kongō Gumi's lifeblogs and Facebook, founding 578 legendaryGL-08C17-54saidopen
1255, twice a yearRijnland water board and its schouwGL-08GL-08C17-56recordrobust
1264Merton's outside VisitorGL-08GL-08C17-57recordrobust
1274the conclave rulechapter 8CA-04 via chapter 8C17-58recordrobust
Seventh centuryIse rebuilt on a cycle of 20 years since 690 CEGL-08GL-08C17-59recordrobust
About a third to about a halfsustainable choice without and with imaginary future generationsKamijo 2017ME-12C17-66recordcontested
A rise in water ratesYahaba's decisionthe Future Design group only, 6 per cent, about 27,000 peopleME-12C17-67saidopen
2015Wales's Well-being of Future Generations Actlegislation.gov.uk, 48 bodies, about 3.1 million peopleME-12C17-70recordrobust
2025Audit Wales, No Time To LoseAudit Wales 2025ME-12C17-71recordrobust
2017Te Awa Tupua Actthe ActIN-05C17-73recordrobust
Over 40 per centrise in emissions since 1990GL-03GL-03C17-78recordrobust
Two in threeCovenant of Mayors cities that filed no progress accountPalermo 2021, 67.5 per cent of 5,054GL-03C17-79recordrobust
Under half an hour, two hours a weektime the Hearth Council needsSY-10, 20 to 30 minutes at dusk plus 2 hours a weekSY-10C17-91designopen

The capture test

The chapter applies the test once, to a world assembly drawn by lot. The patient figure does not seek to be drawn. He offers to run the secretariat, which chooses experts, frames questions and drafts summaries. GL-02 names the secretariat as the capture vector, and chapter 10 owns the French case (C10-20, C10-21, C10-25).

The reports' other tests, not told in prose: GL-01's state leader who uses a permanent veto to shield his regime, GL-03's chemical firms that use a ban to enclose a market and the smugglers who mislabel banned chemicals, MO-12's filibuster by exhaustion and ICANN's .org sale, ME-12's Machiavellian actor who takes the role of the future generations and speaks for his own interest, IN-05's faction that seizes a settlement board, and GL-06's single global authority, which is itself the largest capture prize. SY-07 names the Serrata effect in a crisis as the first failure at this rung.

The scale ledger

Labels as the reports give them. W worked, S strained, mixed or marginal, F failed, N never tried, I inapplicable.

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Smallpox eradicationWWWWWWWWGL-01
Montreal modelNNNNNN (through national agencies)WWGL-03
UN Security CouncilNNNNNFFF (veto)GL-01
IETF rough consensusF (over-formal)WWSSFFW (digital only)MO-12
ICANN multistakeholderismFFFnot givennot givennot givennot givenS (captured)MO-12
Citizens' assembly by lotFFWWWWSW (implemented, toothless)GL-02
Polycentric governanceWWWWWWWS (slow on acute threats)GL-02
CosmolocalismWWWSFNFW (digital only)GL-07
Future DesignWWWWWNNNME-12
Statutory guardiansNNNNFS (Wales)F (Israel, Hungary)NME-12
Te Awa TupuaIIIIWSSFIN-05
Seventh-generation principleWWWWWFFFIN-01

The chapter's sentence: smallpox is the only arrangement marked as working at every rung, Montreal works at the nation and the planet and nowhere below, and the IETF works at hamlet and village, strains above, fails at the nation and works at the planet only for code. GL-04 and GL-05 mark nearly every model "never tried" at the planet. SY-07 marks Ostrom's design principles failed at the planet, because boundaries cannot be enforced there without a planetary state.

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

The planet has never been governed. The few things done there were narrow, verifiable and polycentric: smallpox because a scar could be counted, Montreal because a chemical could be measured in the air, the IETF because code either runs or does not. A single world body would be the largest Serrata imaginable, with no outside to audit it or leave it for. The institutions that last bind the future with ritual and the present with audit. Seats for the future survive only as advisers. So the first morning starts at the hearth, not the planet.

The case against

Frank Biermann and the Earth System Governance project: tipping points make trial-and-error polycentricity obsolete, the patchwork has coincided with an emissions rise of over 40 per cent, two in three Covenant cities filed nothing, and Montreal itself was top-down coercion (Barrett). Biermann asks for a World Environment Organization with binding powers, a UN Sustainable Development Council voting by qualified majority, and an Earth Trusteeship Council. Bostrom and Ord add risks where one failure is final. Keohane and Victor's regime complex and Nordhaus's climate clubs sit between the two positions.

Where the sources disagree

  • Montreal's credit: GL-01 gives it to concentrated producers, cheap substitutes and verifiability. GL-03, through Barrett, gives it to coercion through trade restrictions, a fund and patents, and says the treaty rejected voluntary polycentric arrangements. The chapter tells both.
  • The IETF: MO-12 recommends humming while naming bad-faith objection as its first failure, and misdates a 2016 Senate testimony as 06/29/2026.
  • Constitutions: GL-08 counts 929, SY-06 counts 591.
  • Lifespans: GL-08's 1,066 years for Valencia uses the legendary 960, its 884 years for the Haudenosaunee uses 1142 against IN-01's c.1450, and Kongō Gumi's 578 is legendary. Kongō Gumi rests on blogs and Facebook and runs "39 generations" yet fails under a "40th patriarch".
  • The seventh-generation horizon: IN-01 gives 150 to 200 years in one place and 150 in another. Its source is Parker 1916. The IN research summary recommends demoting it as an operative rule.
  • Future Design: ME-12 says the effect "repeatedly" doubles, which its own figures do not show. Yahaba rests only on the Future Design group. The ISDG arithmetic is flawed.
  • The world-federalist figures in GL-02 come from the campaign itself, and GL-02 places 1947 both at Montreux and at Asheville.
  • GL-06's metacrisis and third-attractor material rests wholly on Koe's newsletter, a podcast, the Game B wiki, Medium and thethirdattractor.org, from the Game B milieu, and is advocacy-heavy.
  • Whanganui: IN-05 misuses one government source, and its Hui-ā-Motu figures rest on Facebook. Te Urewera is a different case and is not used.
  • GL-05's planetary council in four tiers and its travel times are its own model.

Open questions

  • Whether any planetary body could stay narrow once it had teeth, or whether teeth always widen the job.
  • Whether the Global Assembly's literacy share and income profile hold up in its own published documentation.
  • Whether Future Design's laboratory shift survives replication outside Japan and outside the founding group.
  • Whether Wales's act changes any spending decision, given the 2025 audit.
  • Whether the survivors in GL-08 lasted because of their rituals and audits, or because the ones without them left no record to compare.
  • Whether the household rung in SY-10 has ever been run in the form proposed. It is a synthesis, not a record.

The documents

  • Barrett, S. (2003). Environment and Statecraft. Oxford University Press. (GL-03)
  • Biermann, F. (2014). Earth System Governance: World Politics in the Anthropocene. MIT Press. (GL-03)
  • Bostrom, N. (2019). The Vulnerable World Hypothesis. Global Policy. (GL-06)
  • Brand, S. (1999). The Clock of the Long Now. (GL-08)
  • Clark, D. (1992), as quoted in RFC 7241. (MO-12)
  • Dahl, R. (1999). Can international organizations be democratic? (GL-02)
  • Deudney, D. (2007). Bounding Power. Princeton University Press. (GL-02)
  • Dryzek, J., Bächtiger, A. and Milewicz, K. (2011). Toward a deliberative global citizens' assembly. Global Policy. (GL-02)
  • Elkins, Z., Ginsburg, T. and Melton, J. (2009). The Endurance of National Constitutions. Cambridge University Press. (GL-08)
  • Kamijo, Y. and others (2017). Negotiating with the future. Sustainability Science. (ME-12)
  • Kant, I. (1795). Perpetual Peace. (GL-02)
  • Keohane, R. and Victor, D. (2011). The regime complex for climate change. Perspectives on Politics. (GL-03)
  • Kostakis, V. and others (2015). Design global, manufacture local. (GL-07)
  • McQuistin, S. and others (2021). Characterising the IETF through the lens of RFC deployment and mailing lists. (MO-12)
  • Olson, M. (1982). The Rise and Decline of Nations. (GL-08)
  • Ord, T. (2020). The Precipice. (GL-06)
  • Ostrom, E. (2009). A Polycentric Approach for Coping with Climate Change. World Bank. (GL-03)
  • Ostrom, E. (2010). Polycentric systems for coping with collective action and global environmental change. Global Environmental Change. (GL-03)
  • Palermo, V. and others (2021), on Covenant of Mayors monitoring. (GL-03)
  • Parker, A. C. (1916). The Constitution of the Five Nations. (IN-01)
  • Resnick, P. (2014). RFC 7282, On Consensus and Humming in the IETF. (MO-12)
  • Saijo, T. (2020 and earlier). Future Design. (ME-12)
  • Audit Wales (2025). No Time To Lose. (ME-12)
  • Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River Claims Settlement) Act 2017. (IN-05)
  • Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015. (ME-12)

Its documents in the Library

261 265 275 298 318 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 355 356 359