THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 15: The Valley of Death

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 93 open
  • 35 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 93 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Half a million to five million people: the region rung, which this book calls the Valley of Death, where face to face has failed and the state is not yet built (SY-08, a synthesis). Row C15-22. House term defined here.
  2. In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed, and most who crossed the region did so by becoming a state (SY-08 reading NO-07, HI-05, MO-05). Row C15-23. Shared number owned here (P-23).
  3. Between a tenth and a third: the share of citizens who attend a Landsgemeinde, by most counts. The documents range from 10 to 15% (SY-08, Rochat and Kübler 2021) to 30 to 40% (HI-05, Schaub 2012). Row C15-28. Shared number owned here.
  4. Twenty monks at Cîteaux in 1098, about seven hundred Cistercian houses by 1300, bound by a yearly General Chapter and yearly visitation (HI-09, weak source for the counts). Row C15-47. Owned here.
  5. Between a tenth and a third of households at Rojava's commune meetings, and over four-fifths of its territory lost in January 2026 (MO-05). Rows C15-62 and C15-68. Owned here.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
930founding of the Althing and the Lawspeaker's recitationthe record, chapter 5's row C05-47NO-07, HI-07C15-01recordrobust
1220start of the Age of the Sturlungsthe record, chapter 5's row C05-62NO-07C15-03recordrobust
1262the Old Covenant sworn at the AlthingByock, The Age of the Sturlungs, as GL-06 cites it, and Sigurðsson 1999GL-06, NO-07, NA-01, SY-09C15-07recordcontested
1264the last districts swearSkemman thesis as NA-01 cites itNA-01, GL-08, HI-07C15-08recordopen
1241killing at Reykholtthe record, chapter 5's row C05-64NO-07C15-16recordrobust
1253burning at Flugumýrithe record, chapter 5's row C05-63NO-07, PS-01C15-17recordrobust
1281Jónsbókthe record as NO-07 gives itNO-07C15-18recordopen
About as many people as a market townIceland's population (40,000 to 80,000 across documents)Byock (HI-07), Wikipedia (NA-02), a tourism Facebook post (NO-07)GL-06, NA-02, NO-07, HI-07C15-20recordcontested
Half a million to five millionthe region rungSY-08's ladder, a synthesisSY-08C15-22designopen
In the millionsthe rung where face to face failedSY-08's reading of the domain documentsSY-08, NO-07, HI-05, MO-05C15-23inferredopen
A minority, a tenth to a thirdLandsgemeinde attendanceRochat and Kübler 2021 (Glarus, N 2042), Schaub and Rochat 2025, Schaub 2012SY-08, ME-03, ME-14, HI-05, MO-01C15-28recordcontested
1990Appenzell Innerrhoden's last vote against women's suffrage and the court rulingBGE 116 Ia 359, 27 November 1990HI-05, ME-09, MO-01C15-31recordrobust
1798French invasion, end of the old confederationthe recordGL-05, HI-05C15-36recordrobust
1291, 1891date on the charter, year it became the founding textSablonier 2008 (about 1309)HI-05, PS-08C15-37recordcontested
1603Althusius, Politica methodice digestathe recordME-09C15-38recordrobust
About 1119Carta CaritatisWikipedia as HI-09 cites itHI-09C15-44recordopen
Twenty monks, 1098founding community at Cîteauxcathar.infoHI-09C15-47recordopen
Some seven hundred houses by 1300Cistercian growthcathar.infoHI-09C15-47recordopen
1414 to 1418Council of ConstanceSchaff and standard secondary worksHI-09C15-49recordrobust
February 1999Öcalan's capturethe record as MO-05 gives itMO-05C15-54recordrobust
1978founding of the PKKthe record as MO-05 gives itMO-05C15-55recordrobust
2012start of the administration in north-east Syriathe recordMO-05, ME-09, GL-05C15-57recordrobust
Several millionpopulation at its height (2 to 5 million across documents)Wikipedia (MO-10) and estimates without primary sourceMO-05, SY-05, SY-09, ME-07, MO-10, GL-05C15-60recordcontested
A tenth to a third of householdscommune attendanceAllsopp and van Wilgenburg 2019, Schmidinger 2018MO-05C15-62recordopen
Most of the budget (80 to 92%)oil's share of revenueJusoor for Studies, local finance commissionMO-05C15-64recordopen
June 2013Amuda shootingthe record as MO-05 gives itMO-05C15-65recordopen
January 2026, over four-fifthsterritory lost after the offensiveOSW 2026MO-05C15-68recordopen
Six timesthe Guurti's self-extensionschapter 5's row C05-26NO-03C15-70recordopen
Eight yearsa Gada class in powerchapter 5's row C05-32NO-04C15-71recordrobust
1653Swiss peasant warBritannica, a BYU paperGL-05, HI-05C15-78recordrobust
Þingvellir, the Law Rockplace of the Althing and of the 1262 scenethe record, chapter 5's rows C05-47 and C05-52NO-07, HI-07, GL-06C15-01recordrobust
Gissur Thorvaldssonchieftain of the Haukdælir, sworn to the King of Norway before 1262Byock as GL-06 cites him, Grokipedia in SY-10GL-06, NO-07, SY-10C15-05recordopen
Reykholt, Flugumýriplaces of the killing of 1241 and the burning of 1253the record, chapter 5's rows C05-63 and C05-64NO-07C15-16, C15-17recordrobust
Glarus, Appenzellthe surviving Landsgemeinde cantonsthe recordMO-01, HI-05, ME-09C15-26, C15-27recordrobust
Johannes Althusius, Emdenthe theory of nested association and the city that lived itPolitica methodice digesta 1603ME-09C15-38, C15-39recordrobust
Stephen Harding, Cîteauxabbot and house of the Carta CaritatisWikipedia as HI-09 cites itHI-09, GL-08C15-44recordopen
Constancethe council of 1414 to 1418 and FrequensSchaffHI-09C15-49recordrobust
Abdullah Öcalan, Nairobi, İmralıfounder of the PKK, place of capture, prison islandthe record as MO-05 gives itMO-05C15-54recordrobust
Amudathe shooting of June 2013the record as MO-05 gives itMO-05C15-65recordopen
Alfred Kieserthe strongest case againstKieser 1989HI-09C15-75inferredcontested
Bernthe patrician city cantonWürgler 2013, Maissen 2010GL-05C15-77recordrobust

The capture test

ArrangementCaptorFirst moveWhat resistedCaseDocument
Icelandic Commonwealththe chieftain with church income and many menbuying chieftaincies, then swearing to a foreign kingthe farmer's right to switch, which emptied as chieftaincies concentratedGissur Thorvaldsson, 1262NO-07, GL-06
Landsgemeindethe employer or patron in the squarewatching the raised hands of dependentsthe secret ballot, by abolishing the assemblySchwyz and Zug 1848, Uri 1928HI-05, SY-08
Old Swiss confederationpatrician family cartelsmonopolising council seats and mercenary pensionsrural assemblies, armed citizens, rotation of bailiwicksBern, seventeenth and eighteenth centuriesGL-05
Cistercian federationkings and commendatory abbotsbarring travel and payments to Cîteaux, granting abbeys to outsidersyearly visitation with power to depose, the General Chapterthe national monarchiesHI-09
Conciliarismthe popenot calling the councilFrequensEugene IV after BaselHI-09
Rojavathe patient cadre in the ministryinformal clearance of fuel, budget and security decisionsco-chairs and the women's councils, which caused friction but did not stop itthe kadro system, Amuda 2013MO-05, ME-09
Gadathe war chief with booty to keepkeeping plunder and a private following, refusing to step downthe fixed calendar, the Gumii Gaayo, povertythe Gibe kingdomsNO-04

In the chapter the test is used once, as a turn, on Rojava's cadres.

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Icelandic CommonwealthWWWWF (town never tried in NO-07)F (GL-06 calls the region its ceiling, GL-08 impossible)FNNO-07, GL-06, GL-08, NA-01, NA-02, NA-05
LandsgemeindeWWWWS (Glarus, a tenth to a third attend)F (inferred)NNHI-05, SY-08, MO-01
Old Swiss confederation and TagsatzungWWWWWW (about 1.5 million for 500 years, as a league of oligarchies)F (replaced by the federal state of 1848)NGL-05, HI-05
Althusius's consociatio (Emden)WWWWWNNNME-09
Cistercian federationWWWFWW (reach, not population)W (reach)NHI-09
Conciliarism (Constance)NNNNNWWFHI-09
Rojava's democratic confederalismWWWSSF (a quasi-state, war economy)NNMO-05, ME-09, GL-05
Somaliland's xeer and GuurtiWWWWSF in isolation, S as a hybrid stateFNNO-03
Oromo GadaWWWWWW (on the Borana's account)FNNO-04
HanseNNNNWW (NO-07)F (SY-08)NNO-07, SY-08
HaudenosauneeWWWWWWNNSY-08, GL-05. Chapter 13 owns the rows

W worked, S strained or mixed, F failed, N never tried. The chapter's sentence: in the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed, and most who crossed the region did it by becoming a state. The ledgers that mark the region as worked (Swiss confederation, Cistercians, Gada, Hanse, Haudenosaunee) describe leagues of oligarchies, members spread across a continent, or a people's own account of itself, not a population of millions governing itself face to face.

The thresholds SY-08 draws from Johnson 1982 and Spruyt 1994: about 150 (informal mediation fails), about 1,500 (sequential gives way to standing hierarchy), about 50,000 (direct assembly gives way to representation), about 5 million (leagues give way to territorial states). These are synthesis thresholds (P-21, P-22, P-23) and the chapter uses them only in words.

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

  • The region is the thin rung. In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face failed, and most who crossed did it by becoming a state (SY-08 reading NO-07, HI-05, MO-05. P-23).
  • Iceland had law in plenty and no one to enforce it, and its farmers chose a king for peace in 1262 (NO-07, GL-06 citing Byock, NA-01, C05-81).
  • Nesting works when each layer does only what the one below cannot, and when delegates carry instructions they did not write and can be called home (Althusius 1603 in ME-09, the Tagsatzung in GL-05 and HI-05).
  • The ratio of delegates to people mattered less than the leash: the old confederacy far exceeded every safe ratio and held (GL-05).
  • Officers stay honest when members audit each other in person on a calendar nobody at the top can move (Carta Caritatis, visitation and General Chapter, Frequens, HI-09).
  • The proper work of a region after a collapse may be to remember rather than command (Gunderson and Holling 2002, NA-06).
  • Enforcement is the thing no federation has solved without becoming a state (C05-81, SY-08, HI-09, MO-05).

The case against

  • Monasteries were rent-seekers whose governance needed someone else's monopoly on violence (Kieser 1989, Kieser and Padovano, HI-09).
  • The Swiss confederation was a league of oligarchies: Bern under fewer than 70 families, subject territories, mercenary export, peasants crushed in 1653, survival as a buffer for the great powers (Würgler 2013, Maissen 2010, GL-05, HI-05).
  • The Landsgemeinde excluded women, foreigners and the landless for centuries and hands the square to those with free Sundays (Blickle 1990 in HI-07 as chapter 4 gives it, C04-56. Rochat and Kübler 2021 in SY-08).
  • Rojava held behind an armed party, paid for itself with oil and fell when the oil and outside support went (MO-05. ME-03 calls it a Leninist one-party statelet).
  • Leagues of towns lost to territorial states (Spruyt 1994 in SY-08). The Hanse may have been a cartel (Ogilvie 2011 in NO-07).
  • Iceland was an oligarchy with thralls, and its farmers chose the king with their eyes open (Thorlaksson 2001 in NO-07, C05-79).
  • On this view the region is where states are born, for good reasons.

Where the sources disagree

  1. The date of Iceland's submission: 1262 (NO-07 principles, SY-06, DT-10), 1262 to 1264 (NO-07, HI-07, GL-08, NA-01, PS-01, SY-09), 1264 (NA-02). The chapter has the farmers swear in 1262 and the last districts follow by 1264.
  2. Gissur's 1262 role: GL-06 (citing Byock) has him sworn to the king before 1262, SY-10 via Grokipedia. NO-07 does not give it.
  3. Iceland's population: 40,000 to 70,000 (GL-06), 50,000 to 80,000 (NA-02), 40,000 to 80,000 (NO-07), 40,000 to 60,000 (HI-07). The chapter says "about as many people as a market town".
  4. Iceland's rung: region ceiling (GL-06), region impossible (GL-08), fails from parish (NA-01), fails at town (NA-02), works to town (NA-05).
  5. Örlygsstaðir 1238: over 2,000 (GL-06, SY-09), over 1,000 (GL-08), about 50 dead (PS-01), under 1,000 (NA-05). Not in the chapter.
  6. Landsgemeinde turnout: 10 to 15% (SY-08), about 20% (ME-03), 20 to 35% (ME-14), 30 to 40% (HI-05). ME-09's 9% applies to municipal assemblies.
  7. The Swiss charter: about 1309 (Sablonier, HI-05), a myth with a real oath (HI-07), "over 600 years" (PS-03), "originating 1294" (PS-06), founding text only from 1891 (PS-08).
  8. Tagsatzung unanimity: caused the paralysis of 1798 (HI-05) or prevented domination (HI-07).
  9. The Rohner ruling: 27 November 1990 (HI-05, NA-01) against 26 November (ME-09).
  10. Subsidiarity's origin: 1931 (ME-09) against 1891 (ME-10).
  11. Bound or free delegates: HI-09 wants full power (plena potestas), HI-10 bound mandates, HI-08 shows bound Dutch delegates made the republic slow. The chapter follows the Swiss record and names the slowness.
  12. Rojava's population: 2 to 3 million (ME-07), 2.5 to 4.5 million (MO-05), 3 to 4 million (SY-09), 4 to 5 million (SY-05), about 4.5 million (GL-05), 4.6 million (MO-10).
  13. Rojava's commune size: 30 to 400 households (MO-05), 30 to 150 (GL-05), 30 to 200 rural and 500 urban (SY-05).
  14. GL-05's delegate envelope of 1:15 to 1:150 is breached by every one of its own cases, and its 1:10 ladder claims nine tiers where eight suffice. The concept note's "small delegate ratios" learning runs against GL-05's own cases, and the chapter replaces it with the leash of instructions.
  15. HI-09's Cistercian ledger: fails at parish but works at nation. The ledger counts members across a continent, as the HI research summary warns.
  16. NA-06's figure of 81% is garbled in the PDF. NA-06 also labels Olson "structural-demographic". Neither is used.

Open questions

  1. Is there any case of a population in the millions that enforced verdicts against its strongest members without a standing force of its own?
  2. Did the old Swiss confederation survive because of its diet's weakness or despite it, and how much did the mercenary trade pay for?
  3. Would yearly mutual audit have survived inside the Cistercian federation if kings had not barred travel, or did it depend on a shared faith that a secular region lacks?
  4. Is the region's proper work after a collapse to remember rather than command, and can an office of memory exist without becoming an office of power?
  5. What share of Rojava's commune life outlasts the loss of its territory and oil in 2026?
  6. Where exactly did Iceland's chieftaincies pass the point at which the feud stopped deterring, and could a cap on holdings have held it?

Weak sourcing the reader should know about:

  1. Gissur's oath to the king before 1262 rests on GL-06's reading of Byock and on Grokipedia (SY-10). C15-05.
  2. Iceland's population rests partly on Wikipedia and a tourism Facebook post (NA-02, NO-07). PS-01's "over six centuries" and its Örlygsstaðir figure rest partly on a Facebook post. C15-19, C15-20.
  3. The Cistercian growth figures come from cathar.info, the Carta Caritatis date from Wikipedia, and the conversi from a Scribd copy of James France (HI-09). C15-44, C15-47, C15-52.
  4. Rojava's population of 4.6 million comes from Wikipedia (MO-10). Rojava's own figures for dispute settlement come partly from its supporters (MO-05). C15-60, C15-61.
  5. The Hanse's last diet with nine cities in 1669 comes from Quora (NO-07). Not used.
  6. The Valley of Death and the thresholds of 150, 1,500, 50,000 and 5 million are synthesis readings (SY-08), not findings of a primary source. C15-22, C15-24.
  7. GL-05's and ME-09's ratio models cite "unknown_url" and assume their parameters. C15-42.

No (to be checked) markers were left in the chapter.

The documents

Research documents, primary ones first:

  1. SY-08 The scale ledger (synthesis).
  2. NO-07 Dispersed polities: the Icelandic Commonwealth and the Hanse.
  3. HI-05 Switzerland: seven centuries of self-government from the Landsgemeinde to the collegial council.
  4. HI-09 Monastic and religious federations: 900 years of elected, audited, rotating government.
  5. NO-03 Somali xeer and Somaliland: law without a state, state from the bottom up.
  6. NO-04 Age-sets and generation grades: the Oromo Gada and its cousins.
  7. MO-05 Rojava's democratic confederalism after a decade.
  8. MO-01 Switzerland's direct democracy in numbers.
  9. ME-09 Subsidiarity, federalism and the arithmetic of nesting.
  10. GL-05 The arithmetic and logistics of nesting from household to planet.
  11. NA-06 Panarchy: adaptive cycles, revolt and remember across scales.
  12. Consulted: GL-06, GL-08, HI-07, HI-08, HI-11, ME-03, ME-07, ME-10, ME-14, MO-10, NA-01, NA-02, NA-05, PS-01, PS-03, PS-06, PS-08, SY-05, SY-06, SY-09, SY-10, DT-07, DT-10.

Primary works the documents name:

  1. Byock, Jesse (2001). Viking Age Iceland. London: Penguin.
  2. Althusius, Johannes (1603). Politica methodice digesta.
  3. Gunderson, Lance H. and Holling, C. S. (2002). Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems. Washington: Island Press.
  4. Allsopp, Harriet and van Wilgenburg, Wladimir (2019). The Kurds of Northern Syria.
  5. Schmidinger, Thomas (2018). Rojava: Revolution, War and the Future of Syria's Kurds.
  6. Spruyt, Hendrik (1994). The Sovereign State and Its Competitors.
  7. Johnson, Gregory A. (1982). Organizational Structure and Scalar Stress.
  8. Rochat, Philippe and Kübler, Daniel (2021). Survey of the Glarus Landsgemeinde, as SY-08 cites it.
  9. Sablonier, Roger (2008). Gründungszeit ohne Eidgenossen.
  10. Kieser, Alfred (1989). On the monastic Rule as a designed organisation, as HI-09 cites it.
  11. France, James (1996). On the Cistercian lay brothers, as HI-09 cites it.
  12. International Crisis Group (2017). The PKK's Fateful Choice in Northern Syria.

Its documents in the Library

246 249 254 255 258 277 279 280 281 282 283 287 288 291 292 309 313 315 316 320 321 323 326 328 330 334 339 346 347 349 354 355 357 358 359