GOVERNING · Part I · The Levelling Floor
The numbers and sources
Chapter 4: Cities Without Kings
The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 82 open
- 27 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- 5,000 to 8,000 people lived at Çatalhöyük on the Konya plain, from about 7100 BCE to about 5950 BCE, with no palace and no central building (Hodder, as DT-08 gives him). Chapter text: "several thousand people". Rows C04-07 and C04-09.
- 13 per cent of the assessed dead at Çatalhöyük carried recurrent healed head injuries, and of the 12 in 93 "injury recidivists" most were adult women (Larsen and colleagues 2019, PNAS, 470 complete and 272 partial individuals, DT-08). Chapter text: "about one skull in eight". Row C04-12.
- 10,000 to 15,000 people at the Trypillia mega-sites of Nebelivka and Maidanetske, 4100 BCE to 3600 BCE, with a Gini coefficient of house sizes of 0.2295 across 7,000 houses at 38 sites (Müller, Hofmann and Müller-Scheeßel 2024, Antiquity 98(398), DT-08). Rows C04-13 and C04-16.
- 30 pre-modern polities scored for collective action, with internal revenue going with bargaining and public goods and external revenue with autocracy (Blanton and Fargher 2008, Collective Action in the Formation of Pre-Modern States, DT-08). Row C04-38.
- Egypt came apart three times between its kingdoms: the First Intermediate Period lasted about 126 years, the Second about 100 and the Third about 405 (DT-09). Chapter text: "three times, each time for a century or more". Row C04-39.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Source (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date) | Document | Row | Kind | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Konya plain, central Turkey | setting of the opening | Çatalhöyük, Anatolia, as DT-08 places it. "Konya plain" and "central Turkey" are general knowledge | DT-08 | C04-01 | record | open |
| Nine thousand years ago | age of the town in the opening | 7100 BCE to 5950 BCE. Preface row P-39 says "nine thousand years ago" and leaves the row to this chapter | DT-08 | C04-02 | record | robust |
| Roofs as streets, entry through the roof, no streets or plazas | the town's layout | Hodder, as DT-08 cites him | DT-08 | C04-03 | record | robust |
| Dead under the floors, houses rebuilt on the same footprint | continuity of houses | Hodder 2014 | DT-08 | C04-04 | record | robust |
| Grain kept in the house, where it could be seen | storage domestic and visible | DT-08's reading. "Beside the room where she sleeps" is scene setting | DT-08 | C04-05 | inferred | open |
| No palace, no central building | absence of a ruler's architecture | Hodder 2014 | DT-08 | C04-06 | record | contested |
| Several thousand people | population of Çatalhöyük | Hodder: 5,000 to 8,000 on 13.5 ha | DT-08 | C04-07 | inferred | contested |
| Ian Hodder, the archaeologist most bound up with the mound | named person | DT-08 cites Hodder 2014 and his edited volume. His role at the site is general knowledge | DT-08 | C04-08 | record | open |
| About 7100 BCE to about 5950 BCE | span of occupation | DT-08 | DT-08 | C04-09 | record | robust |
| Houses of roughly one size, shrines inside houses | equality of houses | Hodder 2014 | DT-08 | C04-10 | record | robust |
| History houses gathering burials and ritual, a tension between an egalitarian ethos and hierarchy | the first claim to rank | Hodder 2014, history houses chapter in Hodder (ed.), Religion in the Emergence of Civilization | DT-08 | C04-11 | inferred | contested |
| Infectious disease, stunting, heavy wear, about one skull in eight with recurrent healed injuries, mostly adult women | health and violence at Çatalhöyük | Larsen and colleagues 2019, PNAS, 470 complete and 272 partial individuals, 13 per cent recurrent injuries, 12 of 93 injury recidivists | DT-08 | C04-12 | record | robust |
| 10,000 to 15,000 people, 4100 BCE to 3600 BCE, several centuries, Ukraine | Trypillia mega-site population and span | DT-08 (Nebelivka 235 ha, Maidanetske 200 ha) | DT-08 | C04-13 | inferred | contested |
| Concentric rings round an empty plaza, no royal tombs, central stores or citadel | Trypillia layout | DT-08 | DT-08 | C04-14 | record | robust |
| Peas manured by hand | intensive garden plots | δ15N 4.2 to 7.0 per mil against a baseline of 2.5, Maidanetske | DT-08 | C04-15 | record | robust |
| House sizes remarkably even across thousands of houses | Trypillia inequality | Müller, Hofmann and Müller-Scheeßel 2024, Antiquity 98(398) 380 to 400, 7,000 houses, 38 sites, Gini 0.2295 (range 0.13 to 0.31) | DT-08 | C04-16 | record | robust |
| Assembly halls in each quarter and a larger one on the plaza, a council of councils | nested councils | DT-08's reading of the mega-structures | DT-08 | C04-17 | inferred | contested |
| From about 3800 BCE the house size spread widens, the small halls go out of use, central buildings become exclusive | the capture at Trypillia | DT-08 | DT-08 | C04-18 | record | contested |
| Around 3600 BCE the towns burned and were left, people returned to villages, read as a refusal | the end of the mega-sites | DT-08 | DT-08 | C04-19 | inferred | contested |
| Mohenjo-daro: tens of thousands, standard bricks, covered drains, great bath, no palace, no royal grave | Indus city without a ruler's trace | DT-08: 40,000 or more, bricks in a 1 to 2 to 4 ratio, Great Bath 12 by 7 by 2.4 m. Partly Wikipedia and klarifyedu | DT-08 | C04-20 | record | open |
| The Priest-King, a statuette small enough to hold, read as minor | the missing king | Green 2021, Journal of Archaeological Research 29(2), "Killing the Priest-King". 17.5 cm | DT-08 | C04-21 | inferred | contested |
| Teotihuacan, Valley of Mexico, temple face covered around 300 CE, thousands of apartment compounds | the turn away from ruler monuments | Manzanilla 2017. Feathered Serpent temple covered by the Adosada platform, over 2,000 compounds of 60 to 100 people. Partly Facebook and Wikipedia. "Valley of Mexico" is general knowledge | DT-08 | C04-22 | record | open |
| Lower town at Mohenjo-daro ate worse and was hurt more | inequality within the Indus city | DT-08, after Kenoyer | DT-08 | C04-23 | record | open |
| Teotihuacan's houses far less even than Trypillia's | inequality compared | Feinman and Carballo 2022: Gini 0.41, collectivity score 3, against Trypillia 0.23 | DT-08 | C04-24 | record | robust |
| Teotihuacan burned 550 CE to 650 CE | end of the city | DT-08 | DT-08 | C04-25 | record | robust |
| The absence of a palace is not the presence of a democracy, a hidden elite can leave no gold | the chapter's caution | Flannery and Marcus 2012, The Creation of Inequality | DT-08 | C04-26 | inferred | contested |
| Cities did not need kings | key learning | DT-08's synthesis across sites | DT-08 | C04-27 | inferred | contested |
| James C. Scott, a political scientist who wrote on peasants and on Zomia | named person | DT-09 cites Scott 2009 and 2017. The discipline is general knowledge | DT-09 | C04-28 | record | open |
| Grain ripens at once, above ground, can be seen, cut, measured, divided and stored. Tubers resist the assessor | why states grew on cereals | Scott 2017, Against the Grain | DT-09 | C04-29 | inferred | contested |
| Walls kept taxpayers in, captives taken, epidemics, "a late Neolithic multispecies resettlement camp" | the early manpower state | Scott 2017 | DT-09 | C04-30 | inferred | contested |
| Early farmers shorter than the foragers before them | stature with farming | Mummert and colleagues 2011, systematic review | DT-09 | C04-31 | record | robust |
| Wealth stayed fairly even long after the first crops, often for more than a millennium, and pulled apart with layered states | the lag of inequality | Kohler and Smith 2018, Ten Thousand Years of Inequality, 62 cases, over 1,100 sites. DT-09 says both "more than a millennium" and "for millennia" | DT-09 | C04-32 | record | robust |
| States rose in valleys the defeated could not leave | circumscription | Carneiro 1970. Chapter 3's ground | DT-09 | C04-33 | inferred | contested |
| Mancur Olson, an economist, the stationary bandit | named person and theory | Olson 1993, American Political Science Review. Preface row P-10 | CA-06 | C04-34 | inferred | robust |
| The roving bandit takes all and nobody plants, the stationary one takes a share and keeps others off | Olson's mechanism | Olson 1993 | CA-06 | C04-35 | inferred | robust |
| Eastern Congo: armed groups settled to tax bulky, observable coltan at chokepoints, more of them when its price rose, gold did not draw them | resource and the stationary bandit | Sanchez de la Sierra 2020, Journal of Political Economy, 650 villages. Preface rows P-11 and P-12 | CA-06 | C04-36 | record | robust |
| The state is a stationary bandit, and his staying is the oldest bargain | key learning | CA-06 on Olson, with DT-09 | CA-06 | C04-37 | inferred | contested |
| Richard Blanton, an archaeologist, and a colleague scored thirty pre-modern states | collective action and revenue | Blanton and Fargher 2008, 30 polities, scores 23.5 to 52, building on Levi's predatory theory. "Archaeologist" is general knowledge | DT-08 | C04-38 | inferred | robust |
| Egypt came apart three times, each time for a century or more | how often the state left | DT-09: First Intermediate about 126 years, Second about 100, Third about 405 | DT-09 | C04-39 | record | robust |
| Gaps called dark ages | historians' term | Yoffee 2005, as DT-09 gives it | DT-09 | C04-40 | inferred | robust |
| The presumptive state, law codes closer to propaganda than statute | Mesopotamian state as claim | Richardson 2012 and 2017, Old Babylonian period | DT-09 | C04-41 | inferred | contested |
| After collapse: household and strong house first, then sideways bodies in village and valley, then rank returns | the post-collapse sequence | DT-10's synthesis across cases | DT-10 | C04-42 | inferred | robust |
| 400 CE to 800 CE, peasants working mostly for themselves | the peasant mode of production | Wickham 2005, Framing the Early Middle Ages | DT-10 | C04-43 | inferred | contested |
| Hesiod, eighth century BCE, "gift-devouring" lords, Perses bribed them for Hesiod's share | small does not mean fair | Hesiod, Works and Days | DT-10 | C04-44 | said | robust |
| Anglo-Saxon codes from the early seventh century to Cnut's in the eleventh | the borh | Æthelberht about 600, Ine 688 to 694, Alfred 890s, Cnut 1016 to 1035 | DT-10 | C04-45 | record | robust |
| Tithings nominally of ten households, mutually liable, producing offenders at the district court | the frankpledge | Chapter 11's row for the ten households. DT-10 says ten households, DT-11 ten men | DT-10, DT-11 | C04-46 | record | contested |
| The king's peace | what participants said it was | DT-10 (mund) | DT-10 | C04-47 | said | robust |
| Court rolls of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries: whole tithings fined for fugitives and unraised hues and cries | what the record shows it did | DT-10, DT-11 (view of frankpledge, amercements) | DT-10, DT-11 | C04-48 | record | robust |
| Statecraft for a king without police, policing paid by the peasants | scholars' reading | Morris 1910, The Frankpledge System, Wormald 1999 | DT-10 | C04-49 | inferred | robust |
| Faded in the fourteenth century, after the Black Death, replaced by constables | the end of frankpledge | DT-10 (after the Black Death), DT-11 (decayed over the fourteenth century) | DT-10, DT-11 | C04-50 | record | contested |
| Gulating, around 930 CE, every free man with the right and duty to attend, then delegates | the Norwegian thing | HI-07, citing gulatingstaden.no and kringom.no | HI-07 | C04-51 | record | open |
| Kings narrowed the choice of delegates to their barons and bailiffs, 1274 Landslov, things made courts of appeal | the capture of the thing | Helle 2001 as HI-07 lists it, kringom.no | HI-07 | C04-52 | record | robust |
| Normans kept the moots and sent a sheriff to sit in them, moots turned to collection | the capture of the moot | HI-07, section without numbered citations | HI-07 | C04-53 | inferred | open |
| Dithmarschen 1227 to 1559, dikes opened in 1500, judges for life, one clan holding several seats | a peasant republic and its oligarchy | Urban 1991. 48 judges from 1447, 12 per quarter, the Wollersen clan with 5 seats, Hemmingstedt against the Black Guard. Partly Wikipedia (en and de), Fandom and Reddit | HI-07 | C04-54 | record | open |
| Free farmers of the north debated while slaves worked | the cost of the thing | Karras 1988, Slavery and Society in Medieval Scandinavia | HI-07 | C04-55 | record | robust |
| Swiss open-air assemblies excluded women, foreigners and the landless | the cost of the Landsgemeinde | HI-07, Blickle 1990, Hinz | HI-07 | C04-56 | record | robust |
| After a collapse, people rebuild the small rung first | key learning | DT-10's sequence | DT-10 | C04-57 | inferred | robust |
| "rulers of thousands, hundreds, fifties and tens" | Jethro's advice | Exodus 18:21 as DT-11 quotes it. Van Seters reads it as later | DT-11 | C04-58 | said | contested |
| Genghis Khan, 1206, army by tens to ten thousands, rival lineages broken up | the Mongol decimal army | de Rachewiltz 2004, Morgan. Partly Quora | DT-11 | C04-59 | record | robust |
| Inca taxpayers counted in tens, fifties, hundreds and on upwards, knotted cords | the Inca decimal grid | D'Altroy 2002, Julien, Urton. Chunka 10 taxpayers to hunu 10,000. Partly YouTube and Scribd | DT-11 | C04-60 | record | open |
| Shang Yang, fourth century BCE, households in fives and tens | Qin grouping | DT-11 | DT-11 | C04-61 | record | robust |
| Wang Anshi, 1070, ten households a jia, ten jia a bao, mutual liability | the baojia | Hsiao 1960. Partly Wikipedia and Kiddle | DT-11 | C04-62 | record | robust |
| The ten-household unit recurs from the Andes to the Yellow River | the decimal pattern | DT-11's convergence thesis | DT-11 | C04-63 | inferred | contested |
| The baojia was never self-governing | the grid as control | Hsiao 1960, Rural China | DT-11 | C04-64 | inferred | robust |
| A clerk could threaten one household to hold the whole group | capture of the grid | DT-11 | DT-11 | C04-65 | record | open |
| Cities held at the town, tithing at hamlet and village, moot at district, absorbed above | the scale ledger sentence | DT-08, DT-10, HI-07 ledgers | DT-08, DT-10, HI-07 | C04-66 | inferred | contested |
| Bryan Ward-Perkins, 2005, tiled roofs, durable pottery and sanitation gone for centuries, tribute to warlords | the strongest case against | Ward-Perkins 2005, The Fall of Rome and the End of Civilization. "Historian of the late Roman world" is general knowledge | DT-10 | C04-67 | inferred | robust |
| Noble households, fortified manors and feuds as coping, not self-government | the case against extended | DT-10's own extension of Ward-Perkins | DT-10 | C04-68 | inferred | contested |
| Hidden elites, hierarchy to handle information, violent collective towns, sacrifice at Tlaxcallan | the archaeologists' case against | Flannery and Marcus 2012. Tlaxcallan via Fargher, Blanton and Espinoza 2010 and weak web sources | DT-08 | C04-69 | inferred | contested |
| A district of a few thousand people in perhaps ten villages | the rung of In practice | The book's rung definition, 1,500 to 5,000. DT-09, DT-10 and MO-10 all design a district of 3,000 in 10 villages | DT-09, DT-10, MO-10 | C04-70 | design | open |
| The roving bandit first, then the stationary one where there is something to watch | what grows back | Olson 1993, Sanchez de la Sierra 2020. Preface rows P-10 and P-11 | CA-06 | C04-71 | inferred | robust |
| Disaster sociologists found panic rare and mutual aid common | what disaster does to people | Quarantelli, Dynes and Haas, Disaster Research Center, from 1963. The "fewer than 6 per cent" figure is from an activist-hosted PDF and is not used | MO-10 | C04-72 | record | robust |
| Disaster cases ran inside states that came back, evidence on their life contradicts itself | limits of the disaster evidence | MO-10: "three to five years" against about 400 recovered firms still running | MO-10 | C04-73 | inferred | contested |
| The meeting grows too big, delegates replace it, someone else chooses them | the moot's failure | HI-07 on the Gulating | HI-07 | C04-74 | record | robust |
| Delegates chosen and recalled by their villages, carrying the village's decision | delegate rules | MO-10's district design | MO-10 | C04-75 | design | open |
| A granary with several locks and keys in different villages, counted aloud | the split key | The chapter's proposal, assembled from DT-08's visible stores and the parish chest of chapter 12. Nobody has run it | none | C04-76 | design | open |
| The protector who keeps a bodyguard, the security caste that stops taking orders | the militia's failure | DT-09 village design, MO-10 district design | DT-09, MO-10 | C04-77 | design | open |
| Fortified manors after the Han filled with peasants who became serfs | the wubao | Lewis 2009 and a blog, as DT-10 gives them. 100 to 500 people | DT-10 | C04-78 | record | open |
| The hue and cry, every household answering the alarm | the old general alarm | DT-11 (unraised hues and cries fined). Chapter 11's ground | DT-11 | C04-79 | record | robust |
| Swiss and Dithmarschers kept their assemblies with their own weapons, other cases show armed households wrecking republics | the arms question | HI-07 against HI-02 and HI-06 as the HI documents give them | HI-07 | C04-80 | inferred | contested |
| Each village meeting every fortnight, district delegates once a quarter | hours of the practice | MO-10 village design (bi-weekly), DT-10 district design (quarterly) | MO-10, DT-10 | C04-81 | design | open |
| Chapters 11, 12 and 13 for the hearth and tithing, the village, the district | the handoff | Concept note §9 | none | C04-82 | design | robust |
The capture test
- The cities without kings. At Çatalhöyük the captor was the lineage that piled burials and ritual into its history house, and the first move was to make the house carry the past. What resisted was rebuilding on the old footprint and keeping grain at home in view (DT-08, Hodder 2014). At Trypillia the captor was the household that sat in the central hall, and the first move was to let the neighbourhood assembly halls fall out of use and make the central building exclusive, from about 3800 BCE, as house size inequality rose. Nothing inside the town stopped it. The towns were burned and left around 3600 BCE, and people went back to villages (DT-08, Müller and colleagues 2024). This is the chapter's single capture turn.
- The stationary bandit. The captor is the armed group itself. The first move is to stop raiding and start taxing where the resource is bulky and visible, coltan rather than gold. Nothing resisted in the Congo case. Blanton and Fargher's resistance is internal revenue: a ruler who lives on taxes from local labour has to bargain (CA-06, Sanchez de la Sierra 2020, DT-08, Blanton and Fargher 2008).
- What was built when the state withdrew. Frankpledge: the captor was the crown and the manorial lord. The first move was the twice-yearly view of frankpledge, fining whole tithings for fugitives and unraised hues and cries, and lords turned estates into private tithings. Nothing stopped it until the Black Death loosened the villages (DT-10, DT-11, Morris 1910). The thing: the captor was the king. The first move was to narrow who chose the delegates, then to issue one law for the realm in 1274 (HI-07). The moot: the captor was the Norman sheriff, who sat in it and turned it to collection (HI-07). Dithmarschen: the captor was the richest clan, holding several life seats at once. What resisted a single autocrat was the rival clans uniting against any one family (HI-07, Urban 1991). The decimal grid: the captor was the clerk, whose first move was the threat to report one household and so hold the whole jia. What resisted was opposition at court, not in the village (DT-11, Hsiao 1960).
The scale ledger
Rungs: household 4 to 10, hamlet 30 to 50, village 150 to 500, district 1,500 to 5,000, watershed or town 15,000 to 50,000, region 0.5 to 5 million, nation a few million to 500 million, planet 8 billion. Blank means the reports give no verdict at that rung.
| Arrangement | Household | Hamlet | Village | District | Watershed | Region | Nation | Planet | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Çatalhöyük | domestic storage and burial worked | marked failed by DT-08, despite about a thousand years | marked failed by DT-08 (5,000 to 8,000 people) | DT-08 | |||||
| Trypillia mega-sites | worked | worked for centuries at 10,000 to 15,000 | failed, sites burned and left | DT-08 | |||||
| Mohenjo-daro | worked without a palace, unequal lower town | DT-08 | |||||||
| Teotihuacan | apartment compounds | worked at about 100,000, burned 550 CE to 650 CE | DT-08 | ||||||
| Stationary bandit | fails, no surplus | fails | works, chokepoints | works | works (NDC-R) | CA-06 | |||
| Frankpledge tithing | worked briefly (DT-11) | worked | worked (DT-10), failed (DT-11) | hundred court worked | failed, towns too mobile | DT-10, DT-11 | |||
| Gulating and the things | effective | effective | highly effective | effective | strained, delegates replaced the assembly | failed, absorbed by the crown | never tried | never tried | HI-07 |
| English moots | worked | worked | captured at the shire by the sheriff | HI-07 | |||||
| Dithmarschen | highly effective | highly effective | highly effective | effective | effective at about 40,000 | failed against Denmark and Holstein | never tried | HI-07 | |
| Decimal grids (Mongol, Inca, baojia) | Mongol and Inca worked, baojia failed | Inca fifties worked | baojia failed, Inca resisted | Mongol thousand worked | Mongol ten thousand worked | Mongol worked for a time | Mongol failed | DT-11 | |
| Disaster bodies | worked | worked | fragile | absorbed | MO-10 | ||||
| Split-key granary (proposal) | never tried | none |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- Towns of thousands were built and kept for centuries without any surviving trace of a ruler: Çatalhöyük, the Trypillia mega-sites, Mohenjo-daro, Teotihuacan's compound phase (DT-08, Hodder 2014, Müller and colleagues 2024, Green 2021, Manzanilla 2017).
- The early state was built on grain because grain is visible, divisible and storable, and on people kept in place (DT-09, Scott 2017).
- Inequality lagged farming by more than a millennium and rose with layered states (DT-09, Kohler and Smith 2018).
- A bandit settles where there is something bulky to watch and tax, and the settled bandit is the state's origin (CA-06, Olson 1993, Sanchez de la Sierra 2020).
- Rulers who live on internal taxes bargain and provide public goods (DT-08, Blanton and Fargher 2008).
- States collapse often, and in the gaps people rebuild at the household and village first (DT-09, Yoffee 2005, Richardson, DT-10, Wickham 2005).
- The ten-household unit and the decimal ladder recur widely, and serve whoever holds the list (DT-11, Hsiao 1960).
The case against
- The fall of Rome in the West was a collapse in living standards, with tiled roofs, durable pottery and sanitation gone for centuries and warlords taking tribute (DT-10, Ward-Perkins 2005).
- Without a monopoly of violence, local governance falls to the strongest local man (DT-10's reading).
- No royal tombs does not mean no royalty. Hierarchy is needed to handle information at scale. The collective towns were violent (DT-08, Flannery and Marcus 2012).
- The decimal grids were tools of extraction and surveillance, never self-government (DT-11, Hsiao 1960).
- Medieval assemblies were armed male property cartels that relied on slaves and excluded women, foreigners and the landless (HI-07, Karras 1988, and the institutionalist critique of Acemoglu and Robinson as HI-07 gives it).
- Disaster cooperation is real but brief and depends on the state's return (MO-10).
- Graeber and Wengrow's seasonal and urban egalitarianism is disputed by Knight and Ivakhiv, and Scott's Zomia by Lieberman (DT-09). Not in the chapter, chapter 3's ground.
Where the sources disagree
- Çatalhöyük's scale ledger. DT-08 marks it failed at village and district, yet it lasted about a thousand years. The chapter tells it as a long-lived town with endemic violence.
- Frankpledge as building block or extortion tool. DT-10 tells it as a post-collapse building block that turned into statecraft, DT-11 as an extortion grid from the start. The chapter tells both, the participants' king's peace and the court rolls' fines.
- Frankpledge's tithing as ten households (DT-10) or ten men (DT-11). The chapter says "nominally of ten households", the figure chapter 11 owns.
- The end of frankpledge: after the Black Death (DT-10) or decaying over the fourteenth century (DT-11). The chapter says it faded in the fourteenth century after the Black Death.
- Kohler and Smith's lag: DT-09 says both "more than a millennium" and "for millennia". The chapter says "often for more than a millennium".
- MO-10's three to five year life of disaster bodies against its own figure of about 400 recovered firms still running. The chapter says the evidence contradicts itself and uses MO-10 only for what disaster does to people.
- Armed citizens: HI-07 says they protect the assembly, HI-02 and HI-06 say private arms destroy republics. The chapter leaves the question open.
- DT-11 says decimal grids skip fifty, yet its own Jethro and Inca cases have fifties. The chapter names the fifties.
- Iceland: DT-10 says five families bought the goðorð, the Preface's prose says a handful (row P-33's source column notes NO-07's six families), HI-07 says five or six. Not in this chapter, chapter 5's.
- The Trypillia burning as refusal. DT-08 reads it as resistance. It may have been ritual or something else. The chapter says so.
- The concept note says the decimal ladders appear on four continents. DT-11's cases cover the Andes, the steppe and China, Europe and Exodus. The chapter says "from the Andes to the Yellow River" and does not count continents.
Open questions
- C04-01, C04-08, C04-22, C04-28, C04-38, C04-67: settings and credentials that are general knowledge, not in the documents.
- C04-05: grain storage location in the house is scene setting from DT-08's "domestic and visible".
- C04-20 and C04-23: Mohenjo-daro figures partly from Wikipedia and klarifyedu.
- C04-22: Teotihuacan partly from Facebook and Wikipedia.
- C04-51: Gulating's founding and attendance rest on gulatingstaden.no and kringom.no.
- C04-53: HI-07's Witan and moot section has no numbered citations.
- C04-54: Dithmarschen partly from Wikipedia (en and de), Fandom and Reddit, with Urban 1991.
- C04-59 and C04-60: Mongol collective punishment rests on Quora (left out), Inca units on YouTube and Scribd with D'Altroy.
- C04-62: baojia partly from Wikipedia and Kiddle.
- C04-78: wubao rests on Lewis 2009 and a blogspot page.
- C04-72: MO-10's panic figure comes from an activist-hosted PDF.
- DT-09's Taagepera parameter is garbled in extraction and its date range differs from the reading list. Not used. Check the PDF before any later use.
- DT-08 asks whether Tlaxcallan's council was a commons or a nobles' pact against the Aztecs.
- HI-07 asks whether local assembly can be separated from the exclusion and conformity that held such communities together.
- CA-06 asks whether the move from roving to stationary banditry depends only on how visible the resource is.
The documents
Research documents, primary first:
- DT-08 Cities without kings: collective rule in early urban sites.
- DT-09 How the state arrived and how often it left.
- DT-10 Governance after collapse.
- DT-11 The rule of ten: decimal ladders of households.
- HI-07 Things, moots and peasant republics: assemblies of medieval Europe.
- CA-06 Extractive and inclusive institutions, the stationary bandit and the narrow corridor.
- MO-10 Governance born of disaster: assemblies, mutual aid and what absorbs them.
- The Preface's verification rows P-10, P-11, P-12 and P-39.
Primary works the reports name:
- Ian Hodder, 2014, as DT-08 cites him, and the history houses chapter in Hodder (ed.), Religion in the Emergence of Civilization.
- Clark Spencer Larsen and colleagues, 2019, Bioarchaeology of Neolithic Çatalhöyük, PNAS 116(26).
- Johannes Müller, Robert Hofmann and Nils Müller-Scheeßel, 2024, Trypillia mega-sites: a social levelling concept?, Antiquity 98(398).
- Adam Green, 2021, Killing the Priest-King, Journal of Archaeological Research 29(2).
- Linda R. Manzanilla, 2017, Teotihuacan Apartment Compounds, Neighborhood Centers, and Palace Structures.
- Richard Blanton and Lane Fargher, 2008, Collective Action in the Formation of Pre-Modern States.
- Kent Flannery and Joyce Marcus, 2012, The Creation of Inequality.
- James C. Scott, 2017, Against the Grain.
- Timothy Kohler and Michael E. Smith, eds., 2018, Ten Thousand Years of Inequality.
- Norman Yoffee and colleagues, 2005, as DT-09 cites it through a Scribd copy.
- Mancur Olson, 1993, American Political Science Review, the stationary bandit.
- Raúl Sanchez de la Sierra, 2020, On the Origins of the State: Stationary Bandits and Taxation in Eastern Congo, Journal of Political Economy.
- Chris Wickham, 2005, Framing the Early Middle Ages: Europe and the Mediterranean, 400 to 800.
- Bryan Ward-Perkins, 2005, The Fall of Rome and the End of Civilization.
- William Alfred Morris, 1910, The Frankpledge System.
- Hsiao Kung-chuan, 1960, Rural China: Imperial Control in the Nineteenth Century.
- Terence D'Altroy, 2002, The Incas.
- Igor de Rachewiltz, 2004, The Secret History of the Mongols.
- William L. Urban, 1991, Dithmarschen: A Medieval Peasant Republic.
- Ruth Mazo Karras, 1988, Slavery and Society in Medieval Scandinavia.
- Knut Helle, 2001, Gulatinget og Gulatingslova.