GOVERNING · Part I · The Levelling Floor
The numbers and sources
Chapter 5: Ordered Anarchy
The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 87 open
- 22 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- 332 years, 930 to 1262: the Icelandic Commonwealth kept laws and courts with no king, executive or police (NO-07). Row C05-48. Shared number owned here. The Preface's "three centuries" (P-33) rests on it.
- Eight years: the term of each Gada class in power, after which the whole class steps down (Legesse 1973, NO-04). Row C05-32. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 15.
- A hundred camels for a man and half that for a woman: the Somali blood price (Lewis 1961, NO-02, DT-07). Row C05-18.
- The 37th consecutive Gumii Gaayo, observed in 1996, counted from 1708 (NO-04). Row C05-35.
- Six self-extensions of the Guurti's term, 1995 to 2021 (NO-03). Row C05-26.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Source (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date) | Document | Row | Kind | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A year in the 1930s | date of the opening scene | Evans-Pritchard's fieldwork, general knowledge, not in the documents | none | C05-02 | record | open |
| A life priced in cattle, 40 to 50 head | Nuer compensation for a killing | Evans-Pritchard 1940, The Nuer, Oxford, Clarendon Press | NO-02, DT-07 | C05-05 | record | robust |
| 1940 | publication of The Nuer and the phrase ordered anarchy | Evans-Pritchard 1940 | NO-02 | C05-07 | inferred | robust |
| Dinka captives adopted in great numbers | absorption into Nuer lineages | Johnson 1982 | NO-02 | C05-12 | record | contested |
| 1980s | return of an anthropologist to the Nuer | Hutchinson 1996, Nuer Dilemmas, University of California Press | DT-07 | C05-13 | record | open |
| 1999, hundreds of chiefs, elders and women (over 300) | Wunlit Dinka and Nuer peace conference | the record of the conference as DT-07 gives it | DT-07 | C05-14 | record | open |
| 1950s | fieldwork among the northern Somali | Lewis 1961, A Pastoral Democracy, Oxford University Press | NO-02 | C05-18 | record | open |
| A hundred camels for a man, half for a woman | Somali blood price (diya) | Lewis 1961 | NO-02, DT-07 | C05-18 | record | robust |
| Elders killed by al-Shabaab, in great numbers (NO-03 says over a thousand) | assassination of clan elders | no primary named | NO-03 | C05-22 | record | open |
| January 1991 | collapse of the Somali state | the record, 1991 | NO-03 | C05-23 | record | robust |
| 1993, four months | Borama conference | Bradbury 2008, Becoming Somaliland | NO-03 | C05-24 | record | robust |
| Paid for locally (about $100,000, about 2,000 attendees, 500 delegates, 150 Guurti voting) | funding and size of Borama | somalilandeconomic.com, not a primary source | NO-03 | C05-24 | record | open |
| Six extensions (1995, 2002, 2003, 2006, 2010, 2021) | the Guurti extending its own term | the record of extensions under Article 83(5), count by the chapter | NO-03 | C05-26 | record | open |
| Better off on most measures, 18 indicators, 1985 to 1990 against 2000 to 2005 | Somali welfare before and after the state | Leeson 2007, Journal of Comparative Economics, 18 indicators, 11 tabulated against 14 claimed | NO-03 | C05-27 | inferred | contested |
| 1980s, aid 58 per cent of GNP | aid dependence of the Somali state | no primary named | NO-03 | C05-28 | record | open |
| 1973 | publication of Gada | Legesse 1973, Gada: Three Approaches to the Study of African Society, Free Press | NO-04 | C05-30 | inferred | robust |
| Five classes | generation classes (gogeessa) | Legesse 1973 | NO-04 | C05-31 | record | robust |
| Forty years | interval between a father's and a son's entry | Legesse 1973 | NO-04 | C05-31 | record | robust |
| Eight years | term of the class in power, and the interval between grades | Legesse 1973, 2000 | NO-04 | C05-32 | record | robust |
| 37th assembly, 1996, since 1708 | continuity of the Gumii Gaayo | ethnographic observation 1996 as NO-04 gives it | NO-04 | C05-35 | record | open |
| 2016 | UNESCO inscription of the Gada system | UNESCO list, 2016 | NO-04 | C05-37 | record | robust |
| Sixteenth century (Butta wars 1522 to 1618, twelve wars) | Oromo expansion by grade | a school textbook, weak | NO-04 | C05-39 | record | open |
| Nineteenth century, 1932 | Gibe kingdoms, Jimma until its end | Mohammed Hassen 1983 and the record | NO-04 | C05-41 | record | robust |
| 1260, two rival assemblies | the kurultai splitting | Jackson, Morgan 1986, with weak web sources | NO-01 | C05-43 | record | open |
| 870s | first settlement of Iceland | the record (Landnámabók) as NO-07 gives it | NO-07, NA-01 | C05-46 | record | robust |
| 930 | founding of the Althing | the record | NO-07, HI-07 | C05-47 | record | robust |
| 332 years, 930 to 1262 | life of the Commonwealth | computed from the record | NO-07 | C05-48 | record | robust |
| A few dozen chieftaincies (36, 39 or 48) | number of goðorð | Grágás and the documents, inconsistent | NO-07, HI-07, NA-01 | C05-50 | record | open |
| Three years | Lawspeaker's term | Grágás | NO-07 | C05-52 | record | robust |
| About 1005 | founding of the Fifth Court | the record (Njáls saga, Skapti) | NO-07 | C05-53 | record | robust |
| Ounces of silver (wergild commonly 100 ounces) | compensation for a killing | Miller 1990, Bloodtaking and Peacemaking, University of Chicago Press | DT-07 | C05-57 | inferred | robust |
| 1096, four parts, half kept | the tithe and the chieftain's share | the record of the Tithe Law | NO-07 | C05-60 | record | robust |
| A handful of families (3, 5, 5 or 6, or 6) | concentration of chieftaincies | Byock 2001, Thorlaksson 2001, as the documents give them | NO-07, DT-07, HI-07, NA-01 | C05-61 | inferred | open |
| 1220 to 1262 | Age of the Sturlungs | the record (Sturlunga saga) | NO-07 | C05-62 | record | robust |
| 1241 | killing of Snorri Sturluson at Reykholt | Sturlunga saga | NO-07 | C05-64 | said | robust |
| Five years later, 1246 | battle of Haugsnes (about 110 dead of 1,100 or 1,200) | Sturlunga saga as the documents give it | NO-07, DT-07 | C05-65 | said | open |
| 1262 | submission to the King of Norway | the record (the Old Covenant) | NO-07, NA-01 | C05-66 | record | robust |
| Early eighteenth century (1716 to 1726) | Golden Age of piracy | Leeson 2009, The Invisible Hook, Princeton University Press | NO-09 | C05-67 | record | robust |
| Two shares to one | captain's share against a sailor's | pirate articles (Roberts 1721) | NO-09 | C05-68 | record | robust |
| Roughly quadrupled (8,700 to over 35,000 square miles, 1820s to 1890s) | Nuer territorial expansion | Kelly 1985, The Nuer Conquest, University of Michigan Press | NO-02 | C05-76 | inferred | contested |
| A few thousand people | the district the chapter addresses | book convention (district rung) | none | C05-82 | design | open |
| Household groups of a few dozen families | size of a liability group | the chapter's proposal from NO-02 and DT-07 | NO-02, DT-07 | C05-82 | design | open |
| Two copies, two or three mediators, a few hours a week | implementability of the district register | the chapter's proposal | NO-02, DT-07 | C05-86 | design | open |
The capture test
| Arrangement | Captor | First move | What resisted | Case | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Segmentary lineage and xeer | the state that pays elders, then the warlord or insurgent who kills them | stipends to clan heads, elders on the payroll, arms to loyal clans | collective liability, the disowning of chronic offenders, rough parity of arms | British stipends, Siad Barre 1969 to 1991, al-Shabaab | NO-02, NO-03 |
| Somaliland's Guurti | the mediators themselves | extending their own term | nothing so far | six extensions, 1995 to 2021 | NO-03 |
| Gada | the war chief with something to keep | keeping plunder, raising a private following, refusing to step down | the fixed calendar, the Gumii Gaayo, poverty on the dry rangeland | the Gibe kingdoms and Jimma, c. 1830 to 1932 | NO-04 |
| Icelandic Commonwealth | the chieftain who owned a church | keeping half the tithe from 1096 and buying chieftaincies | the farmer's right to switch, which emptied as the chieftaincies concentrated | a handful of families, the Age of the Sturlungs, 1262 | NO-07 |
In the chapter the test is used once, as a turn, on the Icelandic tithe.
The scale ledger
Verdicts as the documents give them. W worked, S strained or mixed, F failed, N never tried.
| Arrangement | Household | Hamlet | Village | District | Watershed | Region | Nation | Planet | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Segmentary lineage (Nuer, Bedouin) | W | W | W | S (with a powerless mediator) | S (town vulnerable to capture) | F | N | N | NO-02 |
| Somali xeer and Somaliland | W | W | W | W | S (town with friction) | F in isolation, S as Somaliland's hybrid state | F | N | NO-03 |
| Oromo Gada | W | W | W | W | W | W | F | N | NO-04 |
| Icelandic Commonwealth | W | W | W | W | F (town never tried) | F | F | N | NO-07, SY-10 |
| Pirate articles | W | W (ship of 80 to 200) | S | F (Nassau) | N | N | N | N | NO-09, SY-08 |
The chapter's sentence: these orders worked from the household to the district, strained at the town and the watershed, and broke at the region, where none is known to have held without becoming a state (SY-08, SY-10). The Gada row is the exception the documents claim, and it rests on the Borana's own account and on Legesse.
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
Order without a state is real. It rests on reciprocity and the standing threat of the feud, carried by groups who are collectively liable for their members. A mediator with no force can keep it if he stays without force. It holds where people can still count each other's debts, roughly the district. It fails when force or wealth gathers in private hands, as in Iceland after the tithe and the Gibe after coffee. Offices with a fixed end and societies that know they are temporary resist capture better (the Gada, the pirate articles). Evans-Pritchard 1940, Lewis 1961, Legesse 1973 and 2000, Byock 1982 and 2001, Miller 1990, Leeson 2007 and 2009.
The case against
The tidy picture may be the analyst's (Kuper 1982, Holy 1996, Peters 1960, Johnson 1982). The balance pointed violence outward as conquest (Sahlins 1961, Kelly 1985). The feud was costly and continuous (Boehm 1984, Miller 1990, Byock 2001). Iceland was an oligarchy with thralls, the right to switch a fiction by the twelfth century (Thorlaksson 2001, Jón Viðar Sigurðsson). Women were priced at half, low castes stood outside the blood-money system, and Gada gave women no grade (NO-02, NO-03, NO-04). Gada's own record includes the Butta wars and gabbar serfdom (Mohammed Hassen 1983), and one critic calls the modern celebration an anthropological whitewash (Yonas Biru). Somaliland is a modern state-building case, and its mediators became a house that does not go home (Menkhaus 2007, Hoehne 2015). None of these orders solved enforcement.
Where the sources disagree
- Families who held Iceland's chieftaincies at the end: three (NA-01), five (DT-07), five or six (HI-07), six (NO-07). The chapter says a handful, as the Preface does (P-33).
- Number of goðorð: 39 later 48 (NO-07), 36 later 48 (HI-07), 39 (NA-01). NO-07 is internally inconsistent. The chapter says a few dozen.
- Iceland's population: 40,000 to 80,000 (NO-07, weak sources including a Facebook post), about 50,000 (DT-07), 40,000 to 60,000 (HI-07). Not in the chapter.
- Haugsnes 1246: about 1,100 combatants and about 110 killed (NO-07), 110 dead of 1,200 (DT-07). The chapter gives no figure.
- Date of the written law: codified about 1117 (NO-07), compiled mostly in the 1250s and partly literary (HI-07, McGlynn).
- Size of the Somali blood-money group: a few hundred to a few thousand men (NO-03), a few hundred to several thousand (DT-07), village scale (NO-02).
- Leeson's Somali welfare table claims 14 of 18 indicators improved but tabulates 11. Literacy and enrolment fell. Leeson argues for statelessness.
- Cape Coast Castle trial of Roberts's crew: 1723 in NO-09, 1722 in common knowledge. Not in the chapter.
- Butta wars: twelve wars 1522 to 1618 from a school textbook (NO-04). The chapter keeps only the century.
- NO-02's text is printed twice in the source file. The second copy was not read separately.
Open questions
- Did the Nuer genealogy organise anything, or did it describe after the fact what water and pasture had already decided?
- Is the Guurti's self-extension a phase in a young state or the normal end of a council of mediators?
- Why did Gada survive among the Borana for centuries but not in the Gibe, and how much of the difference is surplus alone?
- Could Iceland's tithe trap have been closed by a cap on holdings, or would wealth have found another door?
- What would a district do, short of becoming a state, when a strong family refuses to pay a settled debt?
- Is the pirate ship's short horizon the reason its articles worked, or did universal arms and a shared enemy matter more?
The documents
- Evans-Pritchard, E. E. (1940). The Nuer. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
- Lewis, I. M. (1961). A Pastoral Democracy. Oxford University Press.
- Legesse, Asmarom (1973). Gada: Three Approaches to the Study of African Society. New York: Free Press.
- Legesse, Asmarom (2000). Oromo Democracy: An Indigenous African Political System. Lawrenceville: Red Sea Press.
- Byock, Jesse (2001). Viking Age Iceland. London: Penguin.
- Miller, William Ian (1990). Bloodtaking and Peacemaking. University of Chicago Press.
- Leeson, Peter T. (2007). Better off stateless. Journal of Comparative Economics.
- Leeson, Peter T. (2009). The Invisible Hook. Princeton University Press.
- Hutchinson, Sharon (1996). Nuer Dilemmas. University of California Press.
- Kelly, Raymond (1985). The Nuer Conquest. University of Michigan Press.
- Bradbury, Mark (2008). Becoming Somaliland. James Currey.
- Menkhaus, Ken (2007). Governance without Government in Somalia. International Security.
- Thorlaksson, Helgi (2001), and Sigurðsson, Jón Viðar, on chieftains and power in the Commonwealth.