THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part II · The Captured Lottery

The numbers and sources

Chapter 6: The Machine Against Capture

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 67 open
  • 30 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 67 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Six months: the longest term of the Roman dictator, named for one task by a consul on the Senate's advice, with the tribune's veto and the citizen's appeal suspended (HI-13, HI-02, Lintott 1999). Row C06-42. Shared number owned here. The Preface cites it (P-29) and chapter 16 cites rows C06-42 to C06-49.
  2. Five hundred: the Athenian Council (Boule), drawn by lot for one year in equal shares from the ten tribes, at most twice in a life and never two years running (HI-01, ME-01, Aristotle, Athenaion Politeia). Row C06-06. Shared number owned here. The Preface cites it (P-36) and chapter 7 cites the sortition rows C06-01 to C06-11.
  3. 508 to 322 BC, most of two centuries: the life of the Athenian constitution of lot, rotation and audit, interrupted in 411 and 404 (HI-01, ME-01). It is 186 years by arithmetic. Row C06-33. Shared number owned here, cited by the Preface (P-36).
  4. About 30,000 adult male citizens in an Attica of about 300,000 people in the fourth century BC (Hansen 1991, via HI-01, ME-01, CA-01). Row C06-30. Since the edit pass of 2026-10-23 the chapter carries only the 30,000, Attica's 300,000 is on this page. The figure is disputed, see Contested.
  5. 139, 137 and 131 BC: the three Roman laws bringing in the written secret ballot, for elections (Lex Gabinia), for most trials (Lex Cassia) and for legislation (Lex Papiria) (HI-02). Row C06-38. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 12.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
Fourth century BC, a few hundred men at dawnthe scene of a jury allotmentAristotle, Athenaion Politeia 63 to 69, Agora XXVIIIHI-01, ME-01C06-01recordrobust
Black and white balls from a bronze tubethe kleroterion's selecting deviceAristotle, Athenaion Politeia 63 to 69, Agora finds (one kleroterion, nine bronze balls)HI-01, ME-01C06-02recordopen
508 BCCleisthenes' reorganisation into demes (139 or 140) and ten tribesthe record as the documents give itME-04, PS-03, SY-09, HI-01C06-04recordrobust
Ten tribesunits from which the Council was drawnthe recordHI-01C06-04recordrobust
Five hundred, one year, twice at most, never runningthe BouleAristotle, Athenaion Politeia, Hansen 1991HI-01, ME-01C06-06recordrobust
A single day and night, once in a lifethe epistates and his keys and sealAristotle, Athenaion PoliteiaHI-01C06-07recordrobust
Nearly all offices (about 1,100 of about 1,200)offices filled by lotHansen 1991 via a Wikipedia pageHI-01, CA-11C06-08recordopen
Juries of several hundred, 501 for a serious public case (prose says "a few hundred, more for a serious public case")size of a jury drawn on the morning of the trialAristotle, Athenaion Politeia, Hansen 1991ME-01, HI-01C06-09recordrobust
A quarter to a thirdshare of citizens old enough to serve who sat on the Council at least onceHansen 1991HI-01C06-11inferredopen
Ten generals, elected, re-electablethe strategoithe recordHI-01, SY-02C06-12recordrobust
406 BC, eight generals (prose gives no number)the Arginusae trialXenophon, Hellenica 1.7HI-01, SY-01C06-14recordrobust
Within a month (prose says "soon after")time to hand in accounts after officeAristotle, Athenaion PoliteiaHI-01, ME-06C06-17recordrobust
Three days (prose says "a few days")the euthynoi sitting in the agora for chargesAristotle, Athenaion Politeia, EfstathiouHI-01, ME-06C06-18recordrobust
Down to the smallest coinaccounts in marble on the AcropolisCarusi 2024HI-01C06-19recordopen
Many generals condemned (at least 65 adverse votes)generals' accountabilityHansen as HI-01 gives itHI-01C06-20recordopen
Fourth century, routine (about once a month)frequency of the graphe paranomonHansen 1991HI-01C06-21inferredopen
Six thousand (prose says "enough sherds")quorum of potsherds for an ostracismthe record as PS-04 gives itPS-04, CA-01, HI-01C06-22recordrobust
Ten yearslength of exile by ostracism, property keptthe recordPS-04, HI-01C06-22recordrobust
411 BCthe Four Hundredthe record as HI-01 and SY-01 give itHI-01, SY-01C06-27recordrobust
404 and 403 BCthe Thirty and the restorationthe recordHI-01, SY-09C06-28recordrobust
322 BCMacedonian garrison and property franchisethe recordHI-01C06-29recordrobust
About thirty thousandadult male citizens, fourth centuryHansen 1991HI-01, ME-01, CA-01C06-30inferredcontested
About three hundred thousand (data page only)people in Atticaestimates as the documents give themCA-01, SY-01, SY-02C06-30inferredcontested
Tens of thousands enslaved (80,000 to 100,000, data page only)the enslaved populationestimates as SY-01 gives themSY-01C06-31inferredopen
Most of two centuries508 to 322 BC, 186 yearscomputed from the recordHI-01, ME-01C06-33recordrobust
About 150 BCPolybius on the mixed constitutionPolybius, Histories Book VIHI-02, HI-14C06-34saidrobust
Two consuls, one yearthe consulshipthe record, Lintott 1999HI-02C06-36recordrobust
Ten tribunes, one yearthe tribunate of the plebsthe record, Lintott 1999HI-02C06-37recordrobust
139, 137, 131 BCthe secret ballot lawsa Wikipedia page, Elections in the Roman RepublicHI-02C06-38recordopen
59 BCBibulus and the dungno primary namedHI-02C06-39recordopen
133 BC, hundreds killedTiberius Gracchus and his supportersthe record as HI-02 and CA-02 give it, no primary namedHI-02, CA-02C06-40recordopen
For centuriesthe taboo on political killing before 133HI-02, internally inconsistentHI-02C06-41inferredopen
Six months, one taskthe dictatorshipLintott 1999, Rossiter 1948HI-13, HI-02C06-42recordrobust
About three centuriesthe dictatorship in use and returnedHI-13HI-13C06-43inferredopen
202 BCthe office falls out of usethe recordHI-13C06-45recordrobust
121 BCthe Senate's final decree against Gaius Gracchusthe record, Lintott 1999HI-02, HI-13C06-46recordcontested
End of the second century BCpropertyless legionsa Reddit thread in HI-02, unsourced in SY-09HI-02, SY-09C06-47inferredopen
82 BC, no time limitSulla's dictatorship to write laws and settle the commonwealththe record, Lintott 1999HI-13, HI-02C06-48recordrobust
49 and 44 BCCaesar crosses into Italy, dictator for lifethe recordHI-02, HI-13C06-49recordrobust
427 BC, the next dayMytilene decree and its reversalThucydides Book 3HI-01, SY-01C06-54recordrobust
Tenth centurya boy drawing palm-leaf tickets at Uttaramerur (919 and 921 CE)the Uttaramerur inscriptionsME-01C06-59recordrobust
A village of about three hundred, a council of a dozen (prose says "a small council")the In practice proposaldesignHI-01, ME-01C06-62designopen
An hour or two a week, a day a week for councillorsimplementabilitydesignnoneC06-66designopen

Figures kept in the prose after the edit pass of 2026-10-23, years not counted: a few hundred (the line at the stone, the juries and the village rung in the ledger sentence, counted once), 500, a quarter to a third, ten years, about 30,000 (the citizens, and the city-state in the ledger sentence), most of two centuries, six months, about three centuries, about 300, a few thousand. Ten in all. Terms of office (one year, a day and night, twice in a life and never two years running) and the counts that define offices (two consuls, ten tribunes, ten generals, ten tribes, the Four Hundred, the Thirty, the two keepers of the district roll) are part of naming the office. Moved to this page at that pass: the 501, the eight generals, within a month, three days, six thousand sherds, Attica's three hundred thousand, the enslaved tens of thousands, the two interruptions and the "twice" of the case against, the council of a dozen.

The capture test

ArrangementCaptorFirst moveWhat resistedCaseDocument
Lot, Council and juriesthe orator and the elected generalgo around the lot through the elected command and the Assembly's floorallotment at the last moment, the one-day chair, the audit at exitPericles, Alcibiades and Sicily, 415 to 413 BCHI-01, SY-02
Ostracismtwo threatened rivalscombine their followers on a third namenothing, the device was abandonedHyperbolus, 416 or 415 BCHI-01, CA-01, CA-02
The whole constitutionarmed conspiratorsmurder speakers, then suspend the graphe paranomonthe lot could not be rigged, so it had to be set aside, and it was restored each timethe Four Hundred 411 BC, the Thirty 404 BCHI-01, SY-01
Collegiality and the tribune's vetoa consul with armed followers, a Senate that buys a tribuneintimidate the colleague, buy a vetolittle once force was usedBibulus 59 BC, Octavius 133 BCHI-02, CA-02
The dictatorshipa general with a personal armyhave the office conferred without a time limitthe six-month sunset, the specific task, the Senate's control of money, until removedSulla 82 BC, Caesar 49 to 44 BCHI-02, HI-13

In the chapter the test is used once, as a turn, on the lot: the patient person cannot beat the kleroterion and so goes around it.

The scale ledger

Verdicts as the documents give them. W worked, S strained or mixed, F failed, N never tried.

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Lot (kleroterion, Council, juries)N (HI-01 proposes it), F (SY-02)W (HI-01), F (SY-02)WWW (Athens)S (modern advisory assemblies only)S (modern advisory assemblies only)NHI-01, ME-01, SY-02
Rotation (one year, never running)NWWWWFFNHI-01, ME-06
Audit at exit (dokimasia, euthyna)W (informal)WWWWW (professional auditors)SFHI-01, ME-06
Graphe paranomon and ostracismNNNF (tried and failed as HI-01 has it)WNNNHI-01
Mass assemblyWWWWS (SY-01) or F (HI-01)FFNHI-01, SY-01
Roman collegiality and the vetoWWW (HI-02), F (SY-09)W (HI-02), F (SY-09)WFFNHI-02, SY-09
Roman dictator with six monthsW (HI-02)WWWF (HI-02), W (HI-13)FFNHI-02, HI-13

The chapter's sentence: lot, rotation and the audit at exit worked from the village to a city-state of about 30,000 citizens (tens of thousands in the documents), the mass assembly strained at that size, and nothing like them has held a region or a nation except modern citizens' assemblies that only advise. HI-02 and HI-13 disagree on whether the dictatorship worked at the scale of the city (HI-13 says it did, which matches the three centuries the chapter gives).

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

Lot, rotation and audit at exit are the oldest complete design against capture on record. They held a city of tens of thousands of citizens for most of two centuries. They were not beaten from inside. They were bypassed through the offices the lot did not fill and twice switched off by armed men. Rome had no lot but kept capture at bay by pairing every office and by a single emergency office with a six-month limit, and lost both when force became available to individuals and the limit came off. Aristotle, Athenaion Politeia, Hansen 1991, Ober 2008, Manin 1997, Polybius Book VI, Lintott 1999, Rossiter 1948, Flower 2010.

The case against

Equal chance of selection is not political equality, and the drawn answer to no one (Lafont and Urbinati 2024, Umbers, Landa and Pevnick, via SY-02). Athens' lot worked inside a division of labour in which the wealthy and the eloquent proposed and the posts needing skill were elected (Hansen 1991, Ober 1989). The Assembly was swayed at Mytilene, Arginusae and Sicily (Thucydides, Xenophon, via SY-01). Plato's pilot, Aristotle's Politics Book VI. Turnover made the state amateur and hand to mouth (Demosthenes, via ME-06). The citizen body was 12 to 15 per cent of Attica, slavery funded the free time (SY-01, SY-02, SY-09). Rome was an oligarchy of a few dozen families in Aristotle's sense, rule by the wealthy few, and its assemblies a stage for senatorial competition (Mouritsen 2001, Syme 1939, via HI-02 and SY-09). Athens scores high on anti-capture features and still fell (SY-09).

Where the sources disagree

  1. Citizen numbers. About 30,000 in the fourth century (HI-01, ME-01, CA-01, Hansen), about 21,000 (CA-11, citing Manin), about 60,000 in 431 BC (HI-01), 30,000 to 40,000 (SY-01, SY-02). Total population about 300,000 (CA-01), 250,000 to 300,000 (SY-01, SY-02). The chapter carries about thirty thousand and says the reckonings differ. Attica's three hundred thousand is on this page only since the edit pass of 2026-10-23.
  2. Duration. HI-01 says approximately 180 years for 508 to 322 BC, which is 186. ME-01 says nearly two centuries. The chapter and the Preface say most of two centuries.
  3. HI-01 says 70 per cent of those who sat on the Council sat twice. That cannot be squared with a quarter to a third of citizens sitting once in a body of 500 a year. Not used.
  4. The kleroterion's device. HI-01 says black and white dice. ME-01 says dice or bronze balls, and the Agora finds include nine bronze balls. The chapter says balls.
  5. The ostracism of Hyperbolus. HI-01 dates it 416 BC, CA-01 415 BC. CA-01 reads it as capture of the device, CA-02 treats ostracism as the defence that worked against elected demagogues. The chapter gives no year and says both readings are in the documents.
  6. The Four Hundred. HI-01 calls it an elected council of the conspirators' faction. The chapter says taken entirely from their own faction.
  7. Jurors. The figure of 6,000 jurors drawn daily, common in summaries, is not in the documents. HI-01 has 6,000 as the Assembly quorum for sensitive matters, ME-01 juries of 201 to 501 and occasionally 6,000. The chapter says juries of several hundred and 501.
  8. Socrates at Arginusae. HI-01 makes him the epistates of the day. Xenophon and Plato are usually read as placing him among the presiding committee. The chapter says he was in the chair.
  9. The first use of the Senate's final decree. HI-13 dates it to 133 BC against Tiberius Gracchus, HI-02 to 121 BC against Gaius. The chapter names 121 without calling it the first.
  10. The taboo on political killing before 133 BC. HI-02 gives both 300 years and nearly four centuries. The chapter says for centuries.
  11. The propertyless legions. HI-02's Marian reforms rest on a Reddit thread and SY-09 repeats the date 107 BC unsourced. The chapter names no reformer and no year.
  12. Sulla. HI-02's death toll for the proscriptions rests on a Fandom wiki. Not used. Sulla's resignation of the dictatorship is not in the documents and is not told.
  13. HI-02 invents a 30-day commander and places Pompey's great commands before his quaestorship. Neither is used.
  14. SY-09 says Rome lacked emergency term limits, against HI-02 and HI-13 on the six months. The chapter follows HI-02 and HI-13 and reads SY-09 as meaning the late republic after the clock came off.
  15. The scene of the allotment is often set on the Pnyx, where the Assembly met. Jury allotment took place at the courts in and near the agora, immediately before the trials (ME-01), so the chapter sets it there.

Open questions

  1. Did the lot itself resist capture, or did the audit at exit do most of the work, with the lot only making the auditors unpredictable?
  2. How small can a body drawn by lot be before one family can fill it by chance, and what does that mean for a village council of a dozen?
  3. Could the generalship have been put under the lot, or under a one-year bar on re-election, without losing the war?
  4. What would have stopped the men of 411, short of an armed citizen body loyal to the procedure?
  5. Can an emergency office keep its clock where there is no Senate to hold the purse, and who sets the date in a village?
  6. Is the spoken audit before an assembly of people who cannot read strong enough against a clever officer, or does it need a second record keeper from another faction?

The documents

  1. Aristotle, Athenaion Politeia (The Constitution of the Athenians), chapters 63 to 69.
  2. Xenophon, Hellenica 1.7. Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, Books 3 and 8.
  3. Hansen, Mogens Herman (1991). The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes. Oxford: Blackwell.
  4. Ober, Josiah (1989). Mass and Elite in Democratic Athens. Princeton University Press.
  5. Ober, Josiah (2008). Democracy and Knowledge. Princeton University Press.
  6. Manin, Bernard (1997). The Principles of Representative Government. Cambridge University Press.
  7. Carusi, Cristina (2024), on Athenian public accounts in stone, as HI-01 cites it.
  8. Polybius, Histories, Book VI.
  9. Lintott, Andrew (1999). The Constitution of the Roman Republic. Oxford University Press.
  10. Flower, Harriet I. (2010). Roman Republics. Princeton University Press.
  11. Mouritsen, Henrik (2001). Plebs and Politics in the Late Roman Republic. Cambridge University Press.
  12. Rossiter, Clinton (1948). Constitutional Dictatorship. Princeton University Press.
  13. Lafont, Cristina, and Urbinati, Nadia (2024). The Lottocratic Mentality: Defending Democracy against Lottocracy.

Its documents in the Library

273 274 285 286 295 296 305 307 310 312 323 324 350 351 358