The Library · Document 294 · GOVERNING · Nature's governance
Governance cut along the watershed: water boards, acequias and the bioregion
Examines governance cut to the watershed, from Dutch water boards and Valencia's Tribunal de las Aguas to New Mexican acequias, Japanese iriai and Powell's rejected watershed commonwealths of 1878. Finds the famous institutions oligarchic. Dutch water democracy is a later myth (Mostert 2020), and Valencia's auctioned canal officer kept a third of all fines (Peris Albentosa 2014). Names the main capture route as the state turning water into a saleable right that capital buys, as the Tierra Grande Corporation did on an acequia in 1982.
Open the PDF 21 pages · 398 KB
- Number
- 294
- Letter code
- NA-08
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Nature's governance
- File
- 294 NA-08 Governance cut along the watershed, water boards, acequias and the bioregion.pdf
- Pages
- 21
- Works cited
- 56
Used in
The rows that check it
- 47 open
- 19 to check first
- P-03 open Check first About a thousand years, through two religions, several dynasties, a civil war and a dictatorship
- P-08 open Check first Two colonial engineers, writing in 1864 and 1868, invented the "democratic peasant" image against their failures in Algeria and India
- P-09 open Check first The court's public, oral, immediate, weekly form was the feature that resisted capture
- P-22 open Check first At around fifty thousand, the watershed or market town, the arrangements thin out
- C14-01 open Check first A farmer outside the Door of the Apostles before noon on a Thursday, complaining that his neighbour opened the gate on a day not his, the neighbour denying it, the canal called …
- C14-03 open Check first Eight men in black smocks, one for each irrigation community drawing from the Turia, seated in a half circle in the open air. Owned here, Preface P-02
- C14-06 open Check first At this rung offices first become worth buying
- C14-09 open Check first Claimed descent from the caliphate of Córdoba in the tenth century, and a Christian king's confirmation dated 1238 by one account and 1239 by another
- C14-10 open Check first "About a thousand years" is the irrigators' figure and the archive does not support an unbroken line. Owned here, Preface P-03
- C14-16 open Check first Historians trace the democratic peasant image to two colonial engineers writing in 1864 and 1868, against their administrations in Algeria and India. Told in full in the Preface …
- C14-18 open Check first The bidder could not make the court sit in private, on another day, or delay a verdict. The oral, public, weekly form is what the archive leaves standing. Owned here, Preface P-09
- C14-19 open Check first The Dutch water boards date their origins to around 1255
- C14-22 open Check first For most of their history the boards were property-based oligarchies, fragmented and conservative
- C14-24 open Check first Residents without land got a vote with the law of 1991, direct elections in 2008, few turn out (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "few …
- C14-25 open Check first Farmers hold roughly twice the share of seats their share of the tax would give
- C14-36 open Check first Scale: water courts work at village and district, hold at town or watershed only with a state behind them, fail or untried above
- C14-81 open Check first In 1955 the water supply board on Oʻahu tunnelled into the mountain and took much of a valley stream's flow (the "up to half" moved to the data page at the edit pass of …
- C14-84 open Check first Key learning: no commons in the record has governed more than about 50,000 people on its own. Shared with chapter 15, cited from the Preface
- C14-88 open Check first What it needs: a syndic and a clerk who can read and reckon, a written record of turns, labour and fines, one meeting place, a morning a week in season plus the court hour, a …
- P-01 open The Tribunal de las Aguas sits every Thursday at noon outside the Door of the Apostles of Valencia cathedral
- P-02 open Eight judges, one for each of eight irrigation communities of the Turia
- P-04 open Purely oral court, verdict given on the spot before those present, nothing written down
- P-05 open Elinor Ostrom used the court in Governing the Commons, 1990, drawing on earlier scholars
- P-06 open Tomás Peris Albentosa found the vote in the irrigation assemblies tied to land ownership, tenants excluded
- P-07 open The sequier's post was sold to the highest bidder, who kept the surplus of dues over maintenance plus one third of fines
- C12-94 open The acequias of New Mexico still turn out each spring to clean their ditches
- C14-02 open The Tribunal de las Aguas sits every Thursday at noon outside the Door of the Apostles of Valencia cathedral. Owned here, carried by the Preface as P-01
- C14-04 open Questions in Valencian, verdict on the spot, no lawyer, no fee, no appeal, nothing written down. Owned here, Preface P-04
- C14-11 open A historian of medieval Valencia in 1970, two American irrigation scholars later in the decade, and in 1990 the political economist of the commons. Owned here, Preface P-05
- C14-12 open Tomás Peris Albentosa found the vote in the canal assemblies tied to land, tenants and labourers excluded. Owned here, Preface P-06
- C14-13 open The sequier's post auctioned to the highest bidder, who kept dues above maintenance and a third of every fine. Told in full in the Preface (P-07), a clause here
- C14-17 open A property-based oligarchy whose peasant democracy is largely a nineteenth-century myth
- C14-20 open Interest, pay, say
- C14-21 open Dutch poets of 1812 and 1833 sang the boards as the cradle of freedom, and a historian has shown the water-and-democracy story was largely made by the late eighteenth-century …
- C14-23 open Thousands of boards merged since the mid-nineteenth century into fewer than two dozen
- C14-26 open The boards work inside a state and were never the democracy their poets described
- C14-35 open Key learning: cut the unit along the water and the people who share it can govern it themselves
- C14-80 open Donald Alexander in 1990: the watershed polity as naturalistic fallacy, identities that ignore ridge lines, small scale no bar to feudalism or militarism, blood and soil
- C14-82 open A perfectly drawn watershed is useless if the law lets capital tunnel through the mountain and sell the river
- C14-83 open The acequias of the American Southwest lost water once rights were quantified and made saleable
- C14-85 open Every success above the village had a state behind it: Valencia, the Dutch boards, the subak under the rajas' tax collectors, Mondragon
- C14-87 open Elected canal officers and a public oral court at a fixed hour are historical practice in Valencia, elected ditch-bosses in the acequias
- C14-89 open Proposal: rights to water tied to land in the basin and not saleable out of it
- C14-90 open Proposal: the vote to everyone who works the land
- C14-96 open First failure: the upstream villages' syndics collude to dominate the court and fine the tail
- C14-98 open Second failure: free-riding on ditch work
- C14-99 open Between watersheds, in every case on record, a state stepped in
In the Index
Its works cited 56
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 24 journals, universities and public bodies
- 4 books, archives and patents
- 4 document-sharing sites
- 1 encyclopaedia
- 3 blogs
- 20 other web pages
Show all 56
- The Institutional Dimensions of Environmental Change: Fit, Interplay books.google.com/books/about/The_Institutional…
- The Problem of Fit among Biophysical Systems, Environmental and researchgate.net/publication/251543261_The_Pro…
- Spatial fit and water politics: d-nb.info/1217250050/34
- Water Governance—An Historical Perspective on Current Debates academia.edu/30767979/Water_Governance_An_Hist…
- Finding Continuity in Climate Adaptation in - Brill brill.com/view/journals/joah/7/2/article-p131_…
- the institutional development of the Dutch water boards, 1953-present d-nb.info/1109945353/34
- Water and national identity in the Netherlands; the history of an idea researchgate.net/publication/346533291_Water_a…
- Water and national identity in the Netherlands; the history of an idea pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7671572/
- Water and Ground Governance on Multiple Levels studenttheses.uu.nl/bitstreams/6eaba260-862e-4…
- Water governance regimes: Dimensions and dynamics journals.open.tudelft.nl/ijwg/article/download…
- Wild Waters - arno arno.uvt.nl/show.cgi?fid=137613
- Governing the Commons - The Ted K Archive thetedkarchive.com/library/elanor-ostrum-et-al…
- (PDF) Water Management, Spanish Irrigation Communities and researchgate.net/publication/259553002_Water_M…
- Ostrom - Governing the Commons.pdf - Wasabi s3.us-west-1.wasabisys.com/luminist/EB/O-P-Q/O…
- Convivencia and Medieval Spain: Essays in Honor of Thomas F dokumen.pub/convivencia-and-medieval-spain-ess…
- Not only peasants: the myth of continuity in the irrigation cambridge.org/core/journals/continuity-and-cha…
- Acequia: Water Sharing, Sanctity, and Place | Request PDF researchgate.net/publication/262415111_Acequia…
- Irrigation and Society in the Upper Río Grande Basin, U.S.A wcrg.nmsu.edu/documents/UNM_Rivera_Irrigation_…
- Elements of Resilience in a Coupled Natural and Human System pubs.nmsu.edu/acequias/index.html
- Acequias – Coyote Gulch coyotegulch.blog/category/colorado-water/acequ…
- Legal Politics and Emergent Water Collectives in the Middle Rio escholarship.org/content/qt5qk0s64s/qt5qk0s64s…
- The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo as a Living Document: Water and digitalrepository.unm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?…
- Eric P. Perramond's research works | Colorado College and other researchgate.net/scientific-contributions/Eric…
- Measuring acequia functionality : developing a tool for assessing digitalrepository.unm.edu/context/wr_sp/articl…
- Impacts of 150 Years of Modernization Policies on the Management researchgate.net/publication/336910773_Impacts…
- Sha p e Sh iftin g A F IL M B Y E L K E M A R H Ö F E R A N D M IK gupea.ub.gu.se/bitstreams/74f8290b-6649-494b-8…
- Full text of "The mushroom at the end of the world" - Internet Archive archive.org/stream/themushroomattheendofthewor…
- A Companion to Japanese History - PDF Free Download - EPDF epdf.pub/a-companion-to-japanese-history.html
- Imperializing Forestry | Stanford Humanities Center shc.stanford.edu/arcade/interventions/imperial…
- E KŪPAʻA MA KE ALOHA I KA ʻĀINA: THE HAWAIIAN LAND HUI scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu/bitstreams/36fab…
- Reppun v. Board of Water Supply (Haw. 1982) - Justia Law law.justia.com/cases/hawaii/supreme-court/1982…
- Liberty University Malama Aina in Hawaii digitalcommons.liberty.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi…
- EFFECTS OF AMERICAN COLONIALISM ON THE HAWAIIAN digitalcommons.ncf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art…
- Waiahole Decision Part 1 - University of Hawaii System hawaii.edu/ohelo/courtdecisions/WaiaholeDecisi…
- HTF - Hawaii's Thousand Friends hawaiis1000friends.org/htf.html
- John Wesley Powell : his life and legacy / by James M. aton dokumen.pub/download/john-wesley-powell-his-li…
- California's evolution toward integrated regional water management repository.geologyscience.ru/server/api/core/b…
- Dividing line: The past, present and future of the 100th Meridian earthmagazine.org/article/dividing-line-past-p…
- The United Watershed States of America: A Biography of John brandonletsinger.com/biography/the-united-wate…
- Community Acequias in Colorado's Rio Culebra Watershed lawreview.colorado.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025…
- Geotechnics and regionalism: the lineage of thought ... - SciSpace scispace.com/pdf/geotechnics-and-regionalism-t…
- Planning and managing water resources at teh river-basin level horizon.documentation.ird.fr/exl-doc/pleins_te…
- History - Department of Bioregion deptofbioregion.org/bioregionalism/history/
- Bioregionalism - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioregionalism
- Kirkpatrick Sale - OpenCivics Commons commons.opencivics.co/Kirkpatrick-Sale-2f706d2…
- Bioregionalism - The Upper New uppernew.org/bioregionalism/
- What is Bioregionalism? | Cascadia Underground cascadiaunderground.org/what-is-bioregionalism…
- A Bioregional Reader — Cascadia Department of Bioregion cascadiabioregion.org/a-bioregional-reader
- Alexander, D. (1990). Bioregionalism: Science or - VIURRSpace viurrspace.ca/bitstream/10613/2725/1/Alexander…
- Bioregioning: the defining practice of regenerative cultures designforsustainability.medium.com/bioregionin…
- Inland Waterway Transport - Max-EuP 2012 max-eup2012.mpipriv.de/index.php/Inland_Waterw…
- Managing Floods in Large River Basins in Europe: The Rhine River researchgate.net/publication/324125447_Managin…
- Mind the Gap! Reconciling Environmental Water Requirements with mdpi.com/2073-4441/14/2/208
- Australia's mass fish kills as a crisis of modern water - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/338882494_Austral…
- Australia: Menindee fish kill incident highlights environmental wsws.org/en/articles/2023/05/05/lhao-m05.html
- Confronting a 'Post-Truth Water World' in the Murray-Darling Basin water-alternatives.org/index.php/alldoc/articl…