THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING

The numbers and sources

Preface: What Grows Back

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 42 open
  • 11 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 42 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. One third of every fine, kept by the sequier who bought his post at auction, on top of the surplus of water dues over maintenance. Peris Albentosa 2014, Continuity and Change, as NA-08 gives it. NA-08, P-07.
  2. A few in every hundred: the prevalence of dark-triad traits in the general population, the figure the book takes as given. CA-01 gives 1 to 4.5 per cent by threshold, and three reports give three corporate figures. CA-01, P-14. Chapter 9 owns the exact figures.
  3. About 150: the size at which a Hutterite colony splits and Dunbar's layer. PS-02, ME-11, P-20. Chapter 11 owns the row.
  4. Twelve years: the length of the suspension of the Weimar constitution under the Reichstag Fire Decree, in Agamben's reading. HI-13, P-28.
  5. 117 of 120: the research reports behind the book. Project record, P-31.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
Every Thursday at noon, Door of the Apostles, Valencia cathedralWhen and where the Tribunal de las Aguas sitsOstrom 1990 via Glick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978, as NA-08 gives themNA-08P-01recordrobust
Eight judges, eight irrigation communities of the TuriaComposition of the courtSameNA-08P-02recordrobust
About a thousand years, origin claimed around 960 CEAge of the court as claimedTraditional historiography as NA-08 reports it, contested by Peris Albentosa 2014NA-08P-03saidcontested
Purely oral, verdict on the spotForm of the courtNA-08NA-08P-04recordrobust
Ostrom 1990Governing the Commons used the Tribunal as a caseNA-08NA-08P-05recordrobust
Vote tied to land ownership, tenants excludedFranchise in the irrigation assembliesPeris Albentosa 2014 as NA-08 gives itNA-08P-06recordrobust
Sequier post sold to the highest bidder, keeps surplus of dues over maintenance plus one third of finesCapture of the executive officePeris Albentosa 2014 as NA-08 gives itNA-08P-07recordrobust
1864 and 1868, two colonial engineers (Aymard, Scott-Moncrieff), Algeria and IndiaOrigin of the "democratic peasant" imageNA-08 citing modern scholarshipNA-08P-08inferredrobust as presented
The public, oral, weekly, immediate form as the resisting featureWhat limited the captured sequierNA-08's own capture testNA-08P-09inferredopen
Stationary banditOlson's name for the ruler who taxes rather than lootsOlson 1993 as CA-06 gives itCA-06P-10inferredrobust
Several hundred villages mapped (650)Study area in eastern CongoSanchez de la Sierra 2020, Journal of Political EconomyCA-06P-11recordrobust
More than a hundred villages (108), forty-five thousand people (45,747), about two thousand fighters (2,075), end of 2016The NDC-R militia's territorySanchez de la Sierra 2020 as CA-06 gives itCA-06P-12recordrobust
Dozens of societies, later more than a hundred (48, later 150)Boehm's coded sampleBoehm 1993, 1999, 2012 as DT-01 gives themDT-01P-13recordcontested, samples not reconciled
Ridicule, gossip, disobedience, desertion, executionThe levelling repertoireBoehm as DT-01 gives himDT-01P-13recordrobust
A few in every hundredPrevalence of dark-triad traitsCA-01: 1 to 4.5 per cent by thresholdCA-01P-14recordcontested across reports
The three traits namedNarcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathyCA-01CA-01P-15recordrobust
About 150, a Hutterite colony splitsThreshold onePS-02 citing Dunbar, ME-11PS-02, ME-11P-20recordrobust
A few thousand, open assembly failsThreshold twoHI-05 and HI-12 via HI-b (Ladner 5,000 to 8,000), SY-08's 1,500HI-05, HI-12P-21inferredcontested
Around fifty thousand, the watershed or market townThreshold threeNA-08's ledger (watershed worked, region failed), GL-06 and GL-08 (no commons above about 50,000 on its own), SY-08's readingNA-08, GL-08P-22inferredopen
Somewhere in the millionsThreshold four, the regionSY-08's reading of NO-07, HI-05, MO-05NO-07, HI-05P-23inferredsynthesis, open
A chest with three keysNamed in the route as chapter 12's subjectME-14 and SY-10 (the parish chest)ME-14P-24recordopen, chapter 12 owns it
1975, West GermanyNarrator's birthThe author's own factnoneP-25saidrobust
Article 48, 1930 to 1933, three chancellors ruling by decreeWeimar decree ruleHI-13HI-13P-26recordrobust
February 1933, the Reichstag fire, the decree with no end date, twelve yearsThe suspensionHI-13 citing Agamben 2005HI-13P-27 (the fire and the decree), P-28 (the twelve years)recordrobust
Six monthsThe Roman dictator's termHI-13 citing Lintott, HI-02HI-13P-29recordrobust, chapter 6 owns it (C06-42)
117 of 120 reportsThe libraryProject recordnoneP-31recordrobust
1911, MichelsPolitical Parties and the iron lawCA-03CA-03P-32recordrobust
Three centuries, no executive officer, 1262, the king of Norway, a handful of families bought the chieftainciesThe Icelandic Commonwealth's endNO-07 citing Byock, SY-10 citing Byock 2001 and Friedman 1979NO-07P-33recordrobust, family count contested
Jesse ByockHistorian namedNO-07NO-07P-34recordrobust
Most of two centuriesAthens 508 to 322 BCHI-01 ("approximately 180 years")HI-01P-36recordrobust, chapter 6 owns it (C06-33)
One year, never twice, audit at exitAthenian council rulesHI-01HI-01P-36recordrobust, chapter 6 owns it
A thousand years against any one man, lost to a classVenice and the Serrata 1297 to 1323HI-03HI-03P-37recordrobust, chapter 7 owns it
Clan mothers remove a chiefHaudenosaunee recallIN-01, IN-11IN-01P-38recordrobust, chapter 13 owns it

The capture test

Tribunal de las Aguas: the captor is the wealthy urban landowner who bids for the sequier's post. First move: buy the post, underfund the canals, fine the desperate. What resisted: the weekly public oral verdict in front of the community. Historical case: the early modern auctions found by Peris Albentosa. NA-08.

Stationary bandit: the captor is the bandit himself, the capture is the arrangement. First move: settle where output can be watched and taxed. What resisted: nothing inside the arrangement, only an outside state or a price collapse. Historical case: NDC-R, eastern Congo, 2016. CA-06.

Article 48: the captor is the executive who outlasts the emergency. First move: decree rule when parliament deadlocks, each decree lawful. What resisted: the Reichstag's theoretical power to revoke, useless once fragmented and intimidated. Historical case: 1930 to 1933 and the Reichstag Fire Decree. HI-13.

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Tribunal de las Aguasnot neededworked (secondary canals)workedworked (the eight communities)worked (the huerta)failed (the river's reach)never triednever triedNA-08
Stationary banditfailsfailsnot neededworksworks (NDC-R)worksworksneverCA-06
Levelling floorworkedworkedstrainedfailedfailednever triednever triednever triedDT-01
Article 48 emergency rulenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablefailednot applicableHI-13
Roman dictatornever triednever triedworkedworkedworkedfailedfailednever triedHI-13

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

  • Equality in small societies was enforced by the many against the few (Boehm 1993, 1999, 2012, DT-01).
  • The ruler who stays is a bandit who found taxing paid better than looting, and he returns first after collapse (Olson 1993, Sanchez de la Sierra 2020, CA-06).
  • Dark-triad traits are present at a few per cent and over-represented among those who seek office (CA-01, CA-02).
  • The emergency without a sunset is how a constitution dies lawfully (HI-13, Agamben 2005, Rossiter 1948).
  • The public, oral, immediate form of a court resists capture even when its offices are bought (NA-08).

The case against

  • Every lasting organisation becomes an oligarchy (Michels 1911, CA-03).
  • A stateless order cannot enforce and ends in submission or private force (Byock, NO-07, SY-10).
  • The famous self-governing water institutions were oligarchies, and their "peasant democracy" is a nineteenth-century invention (Peris Albentosa 2014, Mostert 2020, NA-08).
  • Small is not gentle: in a village "tyranny is intimate, absolute, and inescapable" (HI-13). The Commonwealth was an oligarchy with thralls (Thorlaksson 2001, NO-07).
  • Forager equality held only without storage and was enforced by execution (SY-04, DT-02).

Where the sources disagree

  • Boehm's sample: 48 societies (1993) against 150 (2012), not reconciled in DT-01. The Preface says "dozens, later more than a hundred".
  • Prevalence of psychopathy among executives: 3.9 per cent (CA-01, Babiak, Neumann and Hare 2010, N 203), 5.75 to 13.5 per cent (CA-02, same paper via a secondary source), about 3.5 per cent (CA-06, via Goodreads). The "21 per cent of CEOs" figure is retracted (CA-01). The Preface gives no executive figure and chapter 9 owns the question.
  • Iceland's concentration: three families (NA-01), five (DT-07), six (NO-07). The Preface says "a handful".
  • The thresholds: SY-08 reads them as about 150, 1,500, 50,000 and 5 million. The library beneath gives Dunbar's 150 (PS-02), Ladner's 5,000 to 8,000 for direct assembly (HI-b), and no clean source for 50,000 or 5 million. The Preface rounds and says the chapters will quarrel. The claim in the concept note's register that the watershed is "the largest rung shown holding without a standing army" was not found in SY-08 or SY-10 by search and the Preface does not make it.
  • The Tribunal's age: about 960 CE claimed, contested as continuity by Peris Albentosa (NA-08).

Open questions

  • P-03 ⚠ The thousand years rest on the irrigators' own tradition as NA-08 reports it.
  • P-08 ⚠ The engineers' names and years come from NA-08's summary of "modern scholarship" without a direct citation in the extracted text.
  • P-09 ⚠ The claim that the public oral form resisted capture is NA-08's inference in its own capture test, not a finding of Peris Albentosa's.
  • P-14 ⚠ Three reports, three prevalence figures (section above).
  • P-21 to P-23 ⚠ Thresholds from a synthesis report, rounded.
  • P-24 ⚠ The three-lock parish chest is named as a historical practice on the strength of ME-14 and SY-10. Chapter 12 must source it from the reports or the Preface changes the example.
  • P-25 and the Weimar school lesson: the author's own facts, not in the documents. The personal anchor in the Preface awaits the author's word.
  • P-27 ⚠ "Within a day" of the fire is not in HI-13, which gives February 1933. The Preface says "In February 1933 the Reichstag burned, and a decree" without a day.
  • P-33 ⚠ NO-07's Iceland figures come partly from Wikipedia, guidetoiceland.is and a Facebook post (NO-07's own reference list).
  • The naming of the stationary bandit's return as "the default after the Fall" is the book's inference from CA-06, not a finding.

The documents

Primary: NA-08 Governance cut along the watershed: water boards, acequias and the bioregion. CA-06 The stationary bandit, limited access orders and the absent Leviathan. DT-01 Reverse dominance and the levelling of would-be chiefs. CA-01 The dark triad in leadership: prevalence, emergence and effectiveness. HI-13 Emergency powers: from the Roman dictator to Article 48 and the pandemic. CA-03 Michels' iron law of oligarchy. NO-07 The Icelandic Commonwealth.

Consulted: PS-02, ME-11, HI-01, HI-03, IN-01, IN-11, ME-14, SY-04, SY-08, SY-10, and the summaries of the DT, CA, NA, NO, IN, HI and SY documents.

Works the reports name that a reader should go to: Elinor Ostrom, 1990, Governing the Commons. Tomás Peris Albentosa, 2014, Not only peasants: the myth of continuity in the irrigation communities of Valencia, Spain, Continuity and Change. Thomas Glick, 1970, Irrigation and Society in Medieval Valencia. Mancur Olson, 1993, Dictatorship, Democracy, and Development, American Political Science Review. Raúl Sánchez de la Sierra, 2020, On the Origins of the State: Stationary Bandits and Taxation in Eastern Congo, Journal of Political Economy. Christopher Boehm, 1999, Hierarchy in the Forest, and 2012, Moral Origins. Giorgio Agamben, 2005, State of Exception. Clinton Rossiter, 1948, Constitutional Dictatorship. Robert Michels, 1911, Political Parties. Jesse Byock, 2001, Viking Age Iceland.

Its documents in the Library

240 241 246 258 261 271 273 274 275 277 284 285 287 294 295 296 297 300 317 320 322 334 347 349 353 357 359