THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part I · The Levelling Floor

The numbers and sources

Chapter 1: Insulting the Meat

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 57 open
  • 13 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 57 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Dozens of societies, later more than a hundred: Boehm's coded sample of egalitarian foragers, in which the levelling ladder recurs. Boehm 1993, Current Anthropology, 48 societies, and Boehm 2012, Moral Origins, 150 Late Pleistocene appropriate foraging societies, as DT-01 gives them. DT-01, C01-08, citing the Preface's row P-13.
  2. A few in every hundred: the share of people in any population carrying dark triad traits in strong measure. CA-01 gives 1 to 4.5 per cent for psychopathy by threshold. CA-01, C01-17, citing the Preface's row P-14. Chapter 9 owns the exact figures.
  3. More than three times as likely to gain from the position as to lose by it: people in charge across the ethnographic record. Garfield, von Rueden and Hagen 2019, Leadership Quarterly, 59 societies, 1,212 eHRAF records, as DT-06 gives it. DT-06, C01-23.
  4. Up to a third of adult male deaths by homicide among the Gebusi of New Guinea. Knauft 1987, Current Anthropology, 35 per cent, as DT-01 gives it. DT-01, C01-44.
  5. 30 to 50 people: the band or hamlet where levelling worked, and 150 to 500, the village where it strained. Brief rung sizes and the scale ledgers of NA-03, DT-01, SY-07 and SY-08. C01-07, C01-41.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSource (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date)DocumentRowKindStatus
Dobe, Kalahari, an elandPlace and animal of the insulted meatLee's ethnography of the Dobe Ju/'hoansi as DT-01 and PS-01 give itDT-01, PS-01C01-01recordrobust
1960s and 1970sLee's fieldwork at DobeDT-01, SY-04 (1963 to 1979)DT-01C01-02recordrobust
"comes to think of himself as a chief or a big man"What the Ju/'hoansi said the custom preventsLee 1969 and 1979 as DT-01 and PS-04 give itDT-01C01-03saidopen, wording unchecked
"We are all headmen"How the !Kung described themselvesLee as DT-05 gives itDT-05C01-04saidrobust
30 to 50 peopleSize of a mobile foraging bandBrief rung sizes, NA-03 and PS-01 ledgersNA-03C01-07recordrobust
Dozens, later more than a hundredBoehm's sampleBoehm 1993, 1999, 2012 as DT-01 gives them (48, later 150)DT-01C01-08, P-13recordcontested, samples not reconciled
Reverse dominance hierarchyBoehm's termBoehm 1993, Current AnthropologyDT-01C01-09, P-17inferredrobust
Gossip, ridicule, disobedience, desertion, executionThe levelling ladderBoehm 1999, 2012 as DT-01 and PS-01 give itDT-01, PS-01C01-10recordrobust
Two camps, 1974Wiessner's recordings of fireside talkWiessner 2014, PNAS, 174 conversations, as DT-05 gives itDT-05C01-11recordcontested, day percentages disagree
Ituri forest, 1957The net hunter laughed back into lineTurnbull 1965, Wayward Servants, as DT-01 gives itDT-01C01-14recordrobust
A few in every hundredPrevalence of dark triad traitsCA-01, 1 to 4.5 per cent by thresholdCA-01C01-17, P-14recordcontested, varies by threshold
Levelling FloorHouse term, definedStyle sheet and concept notenoneC01-18designopen
Centuries beside herders and tradersWilmsen's case against the San as untouched foragersWilmsen 1989, Land Filled with Flies, as DT-05 and SY-04 give itDT-05C01-19inferredcontested
North-western Mato Grosso, 1944The Nambikwara chief, poorest in the bandLévi-Strauss 1944 as DT-06 gives itDT-06C01-20recordrobust
Several monthsDuration of the study in which dominance faded and prestige grewRedhead and colleagues, 16 weeks, as PS-01 gives itPS-01C01-22recordopen
Dozens of societies, more than three timesBenefits against costs of leadershipGarfield, von Rueden and Hagen 2019, Leadership Quarterly, 59 societies, 1,212 recordsDT-06C01-23recordrobust as presented
Tsimane, AmazonInfluential men, more surviving children, lower cortisolvon Rueden, Gurven and colleagues, 632 adults, 28 villages, 2009 to 2010, as DT-06 gives itDT-06C01-24recordrobust as presented
1963Sahlins's big manSahlins 1963, Comparative Studies in Society and HistoryDT-06C01-25inferredrobust
Kawelka moka, 1970sThe big man who gives more than rivals can returnDT-06, primary source not namedDT-06C01-26recordopen
Big men killed by followersThe assassinated would-be despotDT-06, sourced to a piece on Homeric basileisDT-06C01-29saidopen, weak source
Arnhem, Burgers' Zoo, 1974 to 1980De Waal's chimpanzee colonyde Waal 1982, Chimpanzee PoliticsNA-03C01-30recordrobust
1977, Yeroen, Luit, Mama, PuistLuit's rise by isolating Yeroende Waal 1982NA-03C01-31recordrobust
1978, NikkieThe pact of Nikkie and Yeroende Waal 1982NA-03C01-32recordrobust
September 1980Night attack in which Luit was killedde Waal 1982NA-03C01-33recordrobust
/Twi, killed more than onceThe man the band executedLee 1979 via Boehm, as PS-01 (two men) and DT-03 (three) give itPS-01C01-35recordcontested, count differs
Execution in every society of Boehm's larger sampleUniversality of the last rungBoehm 2012 as DT-01 gives itDT-01C01-38recordopen, single report
Inuit song duel and consented executionLevelling where people could not walk awayHoebel 1954 as DT-01 and DT-07 give itDT-01C01-39recordrobust
150 to 500The village where levelling strainedBrief rung sizes, NA-03 ledgerNA-03C01-41inferredrobust as presented
Half a century, higher than violent American cities of the 1970sJu/'hoansi homicide rateLee 1979 as PAIRING C02-67 gives itDT-01C01-43, C02-67recordcontested, counts differ
Up to a thirdGebusi homicide share of adult male deathsKnauft 1987, Current Anthropology, 35 per centDT-01C01-44recordrobust as presented
2021Graeber and Wengrow, The Dawn of EverythingDT-01DT-01C01-45inferredcontested
30 to 50The hamlet the In practice speaks toBriefnoneC01-48designopen

The capture test

  • Reverse dominance and the levelling ladder. Captor: a dominant or manipulative man, a few in every hundred. First move: monopolise a large kill or a flow of goods and give selectively to build a following of debtors. Resisted by: ridicule of the meat, gossip that forms opinion before he notices, exit to another band, and in the end execution, made cheap by universal lethal weapons and the need to sleep. Historical case: Lee's Dobe Ju/'hoansi, /Twi. Where it failed: once storage made exit costly and outside goods (cattle, wages, rifles) arrived. DT-01, DT-05, the SY research summary.
  • Headman and big man. Captor: the patient giver. First move: give more than anyone until the camp owes him, then stop giving back and keep young men close. Resisted by: families walking away, and, in tellings on a thin source, assassination by followers. Historical case: Nambikwara chiefs left by their bands, Melanesian big men, Kawelka moka. Where it failed: once a big man held a bottleneck (Earle) the following became a chiefship. DT-06.
  • Coalitional execution. Captor: a violent bully. First move: kill or frighten anyone who faces him alone. Resisted by: secret consensus of the whole band including his kin, ambush from several sides so no one bears the killing, family consent among the Inuit. Historical case: /Twi, Inuit executions, Luit at Arnhem as the primate parallel. Where it fails: a bully with a bodyguard, or weapons the coalition cannot match. DT-01, PS-01, NA-03, SY-10.

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Reverse dominance and the levelling ladderworked, though SY-07 finds patriarchal violence inside the household unsanctionedworked, everyone sees everyone and any family can leavestrained, needs cross-cutting clans and councils, executions risk feudfailed, the target can pay a retinuenever triednever triednever triednever triedDT-01, NA-03, SY-07, SY-08
Headman with prestige and no powernot neededworked, followers walk away from a mean chiefstrained, a following becomes a factionfailed, prestige turns to control of bottlenecksnever triednever triednever triednever triedDT-06, PS-01
Big man and competitive feastingnot neededworked as long as he gaveworked and strained, debts bind followers, wives and kin payfailed, becomes chiefship once a bottleneck is heldnever triednever triednever triednever triedDT-06
Coalitional execution of the bullynot neededworked, ambush of a sleeping man with poisoned arrowsstrained, kin consent must be negotiated to avoid feud, as among the Inuitfailed, bodyguard turns execution into civil warfailedfailedfailednever triedDT-01, NA-03, PS-01
Primate coalition against an alphanot neededworked in a captive colony of about two dozennot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicablenot applicableNA-03

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

  • Equality among mobile foragers was enforced by a ladder of sanctions, not given: Boehm 1993, 1999, 2012 (C01-08 to C01-10), Lee (C01-01 to C01-06), Turnbull 1965 (C01-14), DT-01, PS-01.
  • Gossip is how the many coordinate before the few notice: Wiessner 2014 (C01-11), DT-05, PS-01.
  • Influence by prestige is freely given and can be withdrawn, and lasts better than dominance: Henrich and Gil-White 2001 (C01-21), Redhead and colleagues (C01-22), PS-01, DT-06.
  • Headmen and big men paid for their standing by giving, and were left when they stopped: Lévi-Strauss 1944 (C01-20), Sahlins 1963 (C01-25), DT-06.
  • Alpha rule rests on coalitions in chimpanzees too: de Waal 1982 (C01-30 to C01-34), NA-03.
  • Coalitional execution is the last rung and may have shaped the species: Wrangham 2019 (C01-36), Boehm 2012 (C01-38), Hoebel 1954 (C01-39), DT-01, NA-03.
  • Levelling needs rough parity of force: DT-01 capture test (C01-40), SY-10 (C01-56).

The case against

  • Levelling was purchased with very high homicide: Lee 1979 (C01-43, PAIRING C02-67), Knauft 1987 (C01-44), DT-01, DT-05.
  • The capacity that kills the bully plans the raid: Wrangham 2019 (C01-42), DT-01, NA-03. Bowles 2009 and Keeley 1996 on high violent death (DT-07, SY-04), contested by Fry and Söderberg 2013 (DT-07, SY-04).
  • The deep past was not a uniform block of equality, and Boehm picked his sample: Graeber and Wengrow 2021 (C01-45), DT-01, DT-06, SY-04.
  • Living foragers are refugia populations shaped by contact: Wilmsen 1989 (C01-19), DT-05, SY-04.
  • "Egalitarian" is enforced conformity that levels the gifted and the eccentric and fears witches: NA-03, PS-01 (C01-46, C01-50).
  • Feminist critics argue that the model ignores female coalitions and carries a patriarchal bias: Camilla Power as DT-01 gives her. Not used in the prose. PAIRING carries women's coalitions.
  • Leaders in the ethnographic record gained more than they gave: Garfield, von Rueden and Hagen 2019 (C01-23), DT-06.
  • The noble savage and naturalistic fallacy: SY-04.

Where the sources disagree

  • Boehm's sample: 48 (DT-01 for 1993, PS-01), "48 to 50" (NA-03), 53 (SY-01, SY-04, PAIRING C02-16), 150 (DT-01 for 2012). The chapter cites the Preface's "dozens, later more than a hundred". Rows C01-08, P-13.
  • Wiessner's day talk: 31 per cent economic and 34 per cent complaint (DT-01, PAIRING C02-19), reversed in DT-07, 94 per cent economic, complaint and gossip against 6 per cent stories (DT-05). The chapter gives no figure. Row C01-11.
  • Lee's homicide count: 22 over 50 years and 29.3 to 41.9 per 100,000 (DT-01), 22 over 35 years among 350 to 450 and about 29 (DT-05), 29.3 for 1920 to 1955 (PS-02), 25 among about 1,500 for 1920 to 1970 (PAIRING C02-67). The chapter cites PAIRING's row and gives no figure. Row C01-43.
  • /Twi: two men killed and an ambush (PS-01) against a three-time murderer executed in broad daylight by the whole community (DT-03). The chapter says "more than once" and keeps the ambush. Row C01-35.
  • Timing of levelling: Boehm far back, Wrangham after language (NA-03). Row C01-37.
  • Reverse dominance as the deep-time default: Boehm against Graeber and Wengrow, Knauft and Power (DT-01 and the other DT documents). Row C01-45.
  • Nambikwara seasons: DT-04 and DT-06 differ. Not used. Row C01-20.
  • Göbekli Tepe placed in the Pleistocene by DT-01, doubtful. The chapter says "ancient". Row C01-45.

Open questions

  • C01-03: exact wording of Lee's quotation to be checked against Lee 1969 and 1979. PS-01 reaches Lee through a secondary website.
  • C01-26: the primary source for Ongka and the Kawelka moka is not named in DT-06 (Strathern to be checked).
  • C01-29: the assassinated big man rests on a single weak source in DT-06.
  • C01-38: the universality of execution across Boehm's 150 rests on DT-01 alone.
  • DT-06's "288 studies" meta-analysis on dominance and prestige is doubtfully sourced and its effect size garbled. Not used.
  • PS-01 carries Kakkar and Sivanathan 2017 and Laustsen and Petersen, which are priming studies, without caveats. The chapter flags them (C01-55).
  • DT-01's Aché clubbing of bullies cites a weak source ("Google Sports Data"). Not used.
  • DT-12, the quantitative test of what predicts leader choice, was never delivered. The chapter says nothing about it.
  • The reports' own open question, and the chapter's: can levelling work without execution as its last sanction (PS-01), and does it survive unequal weapons (SY-10, the kinetic parity dilemma). Row C01-56.
  • Whether forager equality is ancient or a product of contact and marginalisation (Wilmsen against Lee). Row C01-19.

The documents

  • DT-01 Reverse dominance hierarchy and levelling among foragers: Boehm, Lee, Turnbull, Hoebel, Wrangham, Knauft, Graeber and Wengrow.
  • DT-06 Headmen, big men and the price of prestige: Lévi-Strauss, Sahlins, Garfield, von Rueden and Hagen, the Tsimane, the moka.
  • PS-01 Dominance and prestige, the two roads to status: Henrich and Gil-White, Cheng, Redhead, Maner and Mead, Kakkar and Sivanathan, the /Twi account.
  • NA-03 Primate coalitions and the alpha: de Waal at Arnhem, minimal winning coalitions, female veto, Sapolsky's Forest Troop.
  • CA-01 The dark triad and its prevalence (prevalence section only).
  • Consulted: DT-05 (Wiessner, hxaro, Wilmsen), DT-07 (violence among foragers, Hoebel), SY-07 (principles), SY-08 (scale ledger), SY-10 (implementability, kinetic parity), SY-04 (the case against deep time).

Its documents in the Library

240 242 243 244 245 246 289 295 321 322 324 350 353 356 357 359