THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 365 · HEALING · Foundations, evidence and the lay healer

The manuals that worked

Its printed title: FO-06 The manuals that worked: Where There Is No Doctor, the Ship Captain's Medical Guide, military and mission handbooks

This report treats manuals for treating the sick without a doctor as one genre with a track record. No study has measured whether readers of any of these books had patients who did better. The evidence therefore comes from three places: what the books say they assume and how their editions changed, the few audits and user surveys, and trials of nearby interventions (printed materials, lay health workers, algorithms, checklists, tourniquets). The reference list says which sources were read in full and which only as abstracts or summaries.

Open the PDF 21 pages · 123 KB

Number
365
Letter code
FO-06
Book
HEALING after the FALL
Shelf
Foundations, evidence and the lay healer
File
365 FO-06 The manuals that worked.pdf
Pages
21
Works cited
1

The rows that check it

  • 9 open
  • 1 marked for safety
  • 36-25 open Safety The chapter's own rules for correcting the book: a figure the register contradicts is wrong until shown otherwise, but only on counts over a season with every case written, never …
  • 18-40 open As late as 2001 American army medical teams were taught not to use tourniquets. 77 of 232 preventable deaths had no tourniquet
  • 36-47 open Werner a biologist without medical training. Notes and pencil sketches for Sierra Madre villagers. Piaxtla project at Ajoya, Sinaloa, more than 100 villages, some 2 days by mule. …
  • 36-48 open Donde no hay doctor: 1970 (mimeographed) by some sources, 1973 by others. English edition October 1977
  • 36-51 open Buchan's Domestic Medicine, 1769, 19 editions and about 80,000 copies. In the 1791 twelfth edition, later corrections went into notes, partly to prevent fatal mistakes
  • 36-52 open Babu and Eisenberg 2010: early WHO, UNICEF and Christian Medical Commission reviewers called the book unrealistic and dangerous. Three physicians reviewed Prevention in the 2007 …
  • 36-53 open Treatment current in 62 in 100 sections (Prevention) and 88 (First Aid). Prevention advice correct in 96 and 100. Errors as listed. About 28 in 100 under-fives stunted. Only honey …
  • 36-54 open The 2009 reprint adopted 44 corrections fully or in part. The auditors called it a stop-gap and proposed a field trial, none found. The order of dates (2009 reprint, 2010 …
  • 36-63 open No outcome study or field trial exists for Where There Is No Doctor or any lay manual

Its works cited 1

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 1 journal, university or public body
Show all 1
  1. Babu E, Eisenberg DTA. What to do, “Where There Is No Doctor”? A systematic evaluation of thebook “Where There Is No Doctor”. Manuscript with supplementary table, March 2010. A shortversion was published as a book review in JAMA 2010 … faculty.washington.edu/dtae/manuscripts/wtind%…