THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 18: Stopping the Bleeding and Cleaning the Wound

51 claims, 32 marked for safety

18-1 Safety open 18 Stopping the Bleeding, Bench 18.1

Pulse over 100 and rising is the alarm. Loss of the wrist pulse is shock and the line between 90 and 10 per cent survival

To check against
Kragh 2009 Annals of Surgery (WO-01), ICRC Giannou and Baldan 2009 shock table
The verdict
OPEN
18-10 Safety open Bench 18.3

Write TQ and the time on forehead and band. Check every 15 minutes. Leave it uncovered

To check against
TCCC guidelines, WO-01 protocol 3
The verdict
OPEN
18-11 Safety open Bench 18.3, Numbers, clock line

Review by 2 hours. 2 to 6 hours convert only if allowed. Over 6 hours do not loosen. Dead limb, leave it on

To check against
TCCC, Wilderness Medical Society, ICRC Giannou and Baldan 2009, SY-07 table
The verdict
OPEN
18-12 Safety open Bench 18.3

Convert only with strong wrist pulse and clear mind, 2 hours of watching, no amputation, under 6 hours. Method: pack, press 3 minutes, bind, loosen over 1 minute, band left loose, watch 10 minutes, retighten and rewrite the time

To check against
TCCC tourniquet conversion guidance, WO-01 protocol 4
The verdict
OPEN
18-13 Safety open Bench 18.3, Story, Numbers

Never tie cloth without a rod. It fails 79 times in 80

To check against
Altamirano 2015 (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-14 Safety open Bench 18.3, Broker

Never tie a band for a snakebite

To check against
WHO SEARO snakebite guidelines, Maduwage 2024 (SY-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-15 Safety open Bench 18.4

Doubtful water brought to 0.025 per cent chlorine, about 5 ml of 5 per cent bleach per litre, for wound washing

To check against
ICRC War Surgery vol 1, Giannou and Baldan 2009 (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-16 Safety open Bench 18.4, Numbers

At least 0.5 litre for any wound, 1 to 3 litres for a deep one, pour until no dirt then as much again

To check against
ICRC (1 to 3 litres), FLOW 2015 (3 and 6 litres), WO-02's own rules
The verdict
OPEN
18-17 Safety open Bench 18.4

Trim loose skin 1 to 3 mm. Cutting dead muscle is the district's

To check against
ICRC debridement guidance (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-19 Safety open Bench 18.4

Never pour hydrogen peroxide into a deep wound (gas embolism, deaths reported)

To check against
WO-02 citing UK case reports
The verdict
OPEN
18-2 Safety open Bench 18.1

An adult with pulse 120 to 140 and no wrist pulse has lost 1.5 to 2 litres

To check against
ICRC Giannou and Baldan 2009, class III haemorrhage (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-20 Safety open Bench 18.4

Never use one blade or needle on two people

To check against
SY-10 never list item 5
The verdict
OPEN
18-21 Safety open Bench 18.4

Wash a bite 15 minutes, do not close, then chapter 22

To check against
WHO rabies guidance via WO-03
The verdict
OPEN
18-22 Safety open Bench 18.5

Stitch at once only a clean cut, body within 6 hours, face and scalp within 12. Hand cut under 2 cm needs no stitch

To check against
WO-03 own inference, Quinn 2002 RCT, Jaman 2021
The verdict
OPEN
18-23 Safety open Bench 18.5

Never close a bite or a dirty wound

To check against
SY-10 never list item 4, H7
The verdict
OPEN
18-24 Safety open Bench 18.5

Leave the dressing 4 to 5 days, open sooner for fever, rising pain or foul smell. Every wound smells by day 4

To check against
ICRC dressing guidance (WO-02, WO-03)
The verdict
OPEN
18-25 Safety open Bench 18.5, Numbers

Close face and neck about day 3, trunk and arm 4 to 5, leg 5 to 7, seldom after 8

To check against
ICRC delayed primary closure guidance (WO-02, WO-03)
The verdict
OPEN
18-26 Safety open Bench 18.5

Never raw honey on a fresh deep wound. Honey only on a cleaned wound

To check against
WO-02 honey section, spore risk sources
The verdict
OPEN
18-27 Safety open Bench 18.6

Spreading redness over 5 cm, temperature over 38.5 °C, pulse over 110

To check against
Stevens 2014 IDSA skin infection guideline (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-28 Safety open Bench 18.6

In necrotising infection a delay over 24 hours raised deaths about 9 times

To check against
Wong 2003 (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-29 Safety open Bench 18.7

Tetanus toxoid 0.5 ml into muscle, 0.5 ml a dose, schedule as chapter 17, by the healer

To check against
WHO tetanus vaccine position paper 2017 (WO-14), chapter 17
The verdict
OPEN
18-3 Safety open Bench 18.1, 18.3

Below 35 °C blood clots poorly. Warm with bottles no hotter than 40 to 42 °C. Never warm a limb under a tourniquet

To check against
WO-01 hypothermia section, Wilderness Medical Society tourniquet guidance
The verdict
OPEN
18-30 Safety open Bench 18.7

Toxoid potency 3 to 7 years at 4 to 8 °C, 1.5 years at 18 °C, 6 to 12 months at 24 °C, 2 to 6 months at 37 °C. Freezing ruins it, shake test

To check against
WHO thermostability data (WO-14)
The verdict
OPEN
18-31 Safety open Bench 18.7, Numbers

Tetanus appears 3 to 21 days after the wound, under 7 days is worse

To check against
WHO 2017, WO-14
The verdict
OPEN
18-32 Safety open Bench 18.7, Story

Stick test: bitten in 94 per cent with tetanus, none without, 400 patients. With hands alone more than 8 in 10 may die

To check against
Apte and Karnad 1995, WO-14 ledger estimate, Osler 1892
The verdict
OPEN
18-4 Safety open Bench 18.2, Numbers

Never lift the cloth before 10 minutes. Press at least 3 minutes, aim for 10

To check against
TCCC guidelines (3 minutes), Stop the Bleed (3 to 8), UK trainer (10), all via WO-01
The verdict
OPEN
18-5 Safety open Bench 18.2

Pack until the cloth stands 2.5 to 5 cm above the skin, press 3 minutes more. Never pack chest, belly or skull. Count strips in and out

To check against
TCCC wound packing guidance (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-6 Safety open Bench 18.2

Soak and remove packing after 24 to 48 hours

To check against
WO-01's own inference, needs a primary surgical source
The verdict
OPEN
18-7 Safety open Bench 18.3, Broker, Numbers

Band at least 5 cm, a hand's width better, 1 to 1.5 m long. Library floor 3.8 cm untraced. SY-07 card says 4 cm

To check against
Graham 1993 (width and occlusion pressure), WO-01 kit list, SY-07, the second-round review of disputed lines list in SY-12
The verdict
OPEN
18-8 Safety open Bench 18.3

Rod of hardwood or iron, 15 to 20 cm

To check against
Kragh, Wallum and others 2015 windlass breakage (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-9 Safety open Bench 18.3

Band 5 to 7.5 cm above the wound on bare skin, never over knee or elbow

To check against
TCCC guidelines (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-33 open Story, Broker

Paré tied cut vessels with thread at amputations instead of searing them

To check against
Paré, Dix livres de la chirurgie and Les oeuvres 1575. Draft's own knowledge, in no wound report
The verdict
OPEN
18-34 open Story

Paré about 27, siege of Turin 1537 (or 1536), the oil ran out, the cold digestive of egg yolk, oil of roses and turpentine

To check against
Paré 1575 via James Lind Library (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-35 open Story

A German field surgeon drew a tourniquet in 1517, a windlass by the end of the century, Besançon 1674

To check against
Gersdorff 1517, Fabry about 1593, Morel 1674 or 1678 (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-36 open Story, Numbers

Kragh: 7 months 2006 in Baghdad, 2,838 casualties, 232 with 428 tourniquets on 309 limbs, 90 against 10, 5 without all died, nerve palsy under 2 per cent, no extra harm to about 2 hours. 499 people, 96 against 4

To check against
Kragh 2008 and 2009 Annals of Surgery, Kragh 2011
The verdict
OPEN
18-37 open Story

Boston Marathon 15 April 2013: 27 improvised tourniquets, no deaths among the wounded who reached hospital alive

To check against
King 2015 (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-38 open Story, Broker

Sahel of Burkina Faso: 100 casualties, nearly 12 hours to care, about 1 tourniquet in 20 needed and well placed, over half of 24 amputations higher, 3 of 5 deaths from the tourniquet. An urban study found no benefit

To check against
Nacanabo 2026, Taghavi 2026 (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-39 open Story

With a stick improvised straps failed about 1 in 3, craft sticks broke in half the tests

To check against
Altamirano 2015, Kragh and Wallum 2015 (WO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
18-40 open Story, Broker

As late as 2001 American army medical teams were taught not to use tourniquets. 77 of 232 preventable deaths had no tourniquet

To check against
Butler and Blackbourne 2012, Kelly 2008 (FO-06)
The verdict
OPEN
18-41 open Story

June 1915: excision and open wounds cut open thigh fracture deaths from about 8 in 10 to under 2

To check against
Gray, Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps 1915, Milligan BMJ 1915 (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-43 open Story, Broker

Trueta, Barcelona 1936 to 1939, 2,200 casualties in 3 days of 1938, 1,073 open fractures, 6 deaths, gas gangrene seldom. 976 good and 91 poor (WO-02) against 4 amputations (WO-03)

To check against
Trueta 1939, Rendle Short 1939, Coni 2002, Manring
The verdict
OPEN
18-44 open Story

Northern Italy 1944, about 25,000 wounds closed late, about 1 in 20 failed. Korea, gas gangrene under 1 in 1,000

To check against
Churchill 1944 reports, Korean War series (WO-03)
The verdict
OPEN
18-45 open Story

A single stitch lowers the infecting dose many times over. Gas gangrene can appear within 6 hours, usually within a day

To check against
Elek and Conen 1957, ICRC (WO-03)
The verdict
OPEN
18-46 open Story

FLOW trial 2,551 open fractures, pressure made no difference, soap 14.8 against saline 11.6 per cent reoperation. Tap water equals saline

To check against
FLOW investigators NEJM 2015, Cochrane 2022 (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-47 open Story

The quote: "If you can drink it, you can put it into a dirty wound"

To check against
ICRC War Surgery, exact wording and page (WO-02)
The verdict
OPEN
18-48 open Story

Bruce: about 9 per 1,000 wounded in September 1914, about 1.5 per 1,000 by December after antitoxin from mid October. Half or more of cases still died

To check against
Bruce 1918 and 1920 primaries, not read by WO-14
The verdict
OPEN
18-49 open Story

US Army toxoid 1941, 12 cases in the Second World War. Manila 1945, 473 cases, 389 deaths. Tetanus gives no immunity

To check against
WO-14, MSMR 2025, Giannou and Baldan 2009
The verdict
OPEN
18-50 open Story

Tetanus deaths: intensive care 1 to 2 in 10, African hospitals about 4 in 10

To check against
WHO 2017, Woldeamanuel 2016 (WO-14)
The verdict
OPEN
18-51 open Broker

Snakebite tourniquets in nearly half of victims across 71 studies. 39 of 100 trained nurses failed at 6 months

To check against
Maduwage, Gamage and Gutiérrez 2024 (SY-01), WO-01 training study
The verdict
OPEN