THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 17: Vaccination Without a Factory

45 claims, 24 marked for safety

17-11 Safety open 17 Story, What a village cannot make. Bench 17.5 grades

Nerve tissue rabies vaccines (Fermi, Semple): neurological complications 0.1 to 7 per 1,000, rabies from incompletely inactivated batches. WHO asks for replacement everywhere. Supports the never line at 17.5

To check against
HY-10. WHO position paper on rabies vaccines 2018, Bangkok 1984 series
The verdict
OPEN
17-16 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.2 table, 17.3 step 4

Stability: toxoid over 3 years at 2 to 8 °C, about 1.5 years at 18 °C, months at 37 °C. Hepatitis B over 4 years, months, weeks. Measles dry 2 years, 1 month, 1 week. Mixed measles discarded at 6 hours. BCG dry 1 to 2 years, months, a fifth lost a month at 37 °C. Oral polio up to 1 year, weeks, 2 days. Rabies cell culture vaccine 3.5 years or more at 2 to 8 °C, 1 month at 37 °C

To check against
HY-10 (WHO Table 9 and cited studies). WHO Temperature sensitivity of vaccines 2006
The verdict
OPEN
17-17 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.2 never line and table

Toxoid and hepatitis B vaccine are ruined by freezing. After 1 freezing toxoid kept about 85 per cent potency, after 2 about 39 per cent

To check against
HY-10. WHO 2006, the freeze thaw study HY-10 cites
The verdict
OPEN
17-18 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.2 under the table, 17.4 example

A temperate cellar reads 8 to 13 °C in summer, and toxoid there keeps about 1.5 years or more. Tropical cellars cannot fall much below the mid twenties

To check against
HY-10 (inference), OR-06 (secondary soil temperature sources)
The verdict
OPEN
17-19 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.2 table, Numbers

No published study has tested tetanus toxoid potency after its printed date. Printed as unknown, probably not zero, never counted as protection

To check against
HY-10, SY-12 (R2-06). A literature search for any post expiry potency study
The verdict
OPEN
Found
Known unknown. R2-06 can only confirm
17-20 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.4 order and table. Numbers

2 doses of toxoid in pregnancy, 4 weeks apart, the 2nd at least 2 weeks before the birth, cut newborn tetanus deaths by about 94 in 100

To check against
HY-10, WO-14. Blencowe and others 2010 (Cochrane or IJE review)
The verdict
OPEN
17-22 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.4

Toxoid given at the moment of a wound does not protect a never vaccinated person in time for that wound. It protects for the next

To check against
HY-10. WHO tetanus position paper 2017
The verdict
OPEN
17-23 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.4 order

1 vial of rabies vaccine, given in small doses into the skin, treats 1 bitten person

To check against
HY-10 (2-2-2-0-0 regimen, about 1 vial). WHO rabies position paper 2018. Chapter 22
The verdict
OPEN
17-24 Safety open 17 Story, When the memory fades. Bench 17.4 table

Toxoid ladder: dose 2 at least 4 weeks after dose 1, dose 3 at least 6 months later, doses 4 and 5 at least 1 year apart. Protection 1 to 3 years after 2 doses, about 5 after 3, about 10 after 4, most of adult life after 5. A full course protects about 10 years

To check against
Draft's own, from general knowledge of the WHO five dose schedule for women. WHO tetanus position paper 2017
The verdict
OPEN
17-30 Safety open 17 Story, When the memory fades. Bench 17.1 no help branch

Before antitoxin a quarter to a third of those with diphtheria died

To check against
IN-12 (Weaver 1924)
The verdict
OPEN
17-32 Safety open 17 Bench 17.1 sign 1

Newborn tetanus: a baby 3 to 14 days old stops sucking, the jaw clenches, the body arches at a touch

To check against
Chapter 11, HY-10 (day 7 red flag), WHO newborn tetanus case definition
The verdict
OPEN
17-33 Safety open 17 Bench 17.1 no help branch

Without care, most newborns with tetanus die

To check against
Chapter 11 and its rows, WHO. Case fatality untreated
The verdict
OPEN
17-34 Safety open 17 Bench 17.1 sign 3

Diphtheria: a grey patch in the throat that bleeds when scraped, a swollen neck

To check against
IN-12 (MSF, CDC)
The verdict
OPEN
17-35 Safety open 17 Bench 17.1 sign 5

Polio: fever, then a limb that goes floppy

To check against
HY-10 red flags, WHO acute flaccid paralysis definition
The verdict
OPEN
17-36 Safety open 17 Bench 17.1 sign 8

A stiff neck or wasting in the weeks after a vaccine means suspect the lot (the Lübeck signature)

To check against
HY-10 red flags
The verdict
OPEN
17-37 Safety open 17 Bench 17.1 no help branch

Diphtheria without help: keep the person lying flat and still

To check against
IN-12 (Weaver 1924 on cardiac deaths when sitting up)
The verdict
OPEN
17-38 Safety open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.2 step 3

Vial square: inner square lighter than its circle, usable. Same or darker, discard. The square does not show freezing

To check against
HY-10. WHO VVM guidance
The verdict
OPEN
17-39 Safety open 17 Bench 17.2 step 8, picture

Shake test: compare a suspect vial with one of the same lot frozen on purpose, faster settling means frozen. A handling test for the healer

To check against
HY-10. WHO shake test procedure (10 to 15 seconds, watch 15 to 30 minutes)
The verdict
OPEN
17-40 Safety open 17 Story, The Honest Broker's Weighing. Bench 17.2 step 9

Frozen toxoid printed both ways: WHO says discard any vial known frozen. HY-10 and WO-14 say a full frozen course beats none for the never vaccinated (Menon's recruits)

To check against
HY-10, WO-14, WHO. Menon and others (study of recruits)
The verdict
OPEN
Found
Disputed, not settled
17-41 Safety open 17 Bench 17.3 step 3

Live vaccines (measles, BCG, oral polio) never in pregnancy or in weak immunity

To check against
HY-10 contraindications. WHO position papers
The verdict
OPEN
17-42 Safety open 17 Bench 17.3 step 5

Opened liquid vial discarded at session end. WHO's multidose vial policy allows 28 days under its conditions, among them storage at 2 to 8 °C, which a cellar does not meet

To check against
HY-10 Protocol 4. WHO multidose vial policy 2014
The verdict
OPEN
17-43 Safety open 17 Bench 17.3

The same vaccine dose at every weight

To check against
WHO position papers for each vaccine
The verdict
OPEN
17-44 Safety open 17 Bench 17.3 table

Dose table: toxoid 0.5 ml into muscle. Measles 0.5 ml from 9 months, from 6 months in an outbreak, 2nd dose at least 4 weeks later. BCG 0.05 ml under 1 year, 0.1 ml from 1 year. Hepatitis B 0.5 ml within 24 hours of birth. All by the healer

To check against
HY-10 Protocols 3 and 4. WHO position papers. Chapter 16 for BCG and hepatitis B
The verdict
OPEN
17-45 Safety open 17 Bench 17.4

A woman with 2 doses in an earlier pregnancy needs 1 more in this one

To check against
Draft's own, general knowledge. WHO tetanus position paper 2017
The verdict
OPEN
17-1 open 17 Story, The scab and the scratch

Powdered smallpox scab blown into the nose in China, in writing by the sixteenth century

To check against
HY-10 (Wan Quan, 1549, secondary). Needham 1980 or Fenner 1988 for the primary dating
The verdict
OPEN
17-10 open 17 Story, The cowpox chain

Rivalta, June 1861: 63 children vaccinated from 1 infant with congenital syphilis, 41 to 46 infected (Pacchiotti 46, modern reviews 44, Wikipedia 41), several died, mothers and nurses infected. Britain banned arm to arm vaccination in 1898

To check against
HY-10 (secondary). Pacchiotti 1862, Vaccination Act 1898
The verdict
OPEN
17-12 open 17 Story, What a village cannot make

Lübeck 1929 to 1930: 251 infants given oral BCG, 77 died, 67 of tuberculosis. Kiel strain kept in the same room. No animal test. 2 doctors imprisoned

To check against
HY-10. Fox and others 2016 (Lübeck review), trial record 1931 to 1932
The verdict
OPEN
17-13 open 17 Story, What a village cannot make

Punjab (Mulkowal) 1902: 19 inoculated against plague from 1 bottle (53N), all 19 died of tetanus. Date given as March or 30 October

To check against
HY-10. Indian Plague Commission, Haffkine inquiry 1907
The verdict
OPEN
17-14 open 17 Story, What a village cannot make

St Louis 1901: antitoxin from a horse with tetanus killed 13 children. Bundaberg, January 1928: 12 of 21 children died after injections from 1 opened bottle grown with Staphylococcus aureus. Same mechanism with reconstituted measles vaccine in India in the 1990s (Himachal Pradesh) and 2008 (Tamil Nadu)

To check against
HY-10. Royal Commission on Bundaberg 1928, WHO reports on the Indian events
The verdict
OPEN
17-15 open 17 Story, What a village cannot make

Cutter, April 1955: incompletely killed polio virus. About 200 cases (204) and 11 deaths by the surveillance count. Offit: 51 paralysed and 5 dead among the vaccinated, 113 paralysed and 5 dead among contacts

To check against
HY-10. Nathanson and Langmuir 1963, Offit 2005
The verdict
OPEN
17-2 open 17 Story, The scab and the scratch

Boston 1721: Boylston inoculated over 200 (247 to 287 by source), about 6 died, about 2 in 100 (sources 1 to 2.5). Town: 5,759 of about 10,600 infected, 844 died, about 14 in 100. Onesimus in Mather's household

To check against
HY-10 (secondary). Boylston's Historical Account 1726, Fenner 1988, Blake 1959
The verdict
OPEN
17-21 open 17 Story, The last vials. Bench 17.4 arithmetic

A village of 300 sees about 6 to 9 births a year. Stock arithmetic: 100 doses at 16 a year last about 6 years

To check against
Draft's own arithmetic from a crude birth rate of 20 to 30 per 1,000. Check against the concept note's population figures
The verdict
OPEN
17-25 open 17 Story, When the memory fades

Memory by vaccine: measles lifelong in most, whooping cough protection fades within a few years, polio full course decades, hepatitis B decades once it has taken

To check against
Draft's own, general knowledge. The library gives no figure. WHO position papers for each vaccine
The verdict
OPEN
17-26 open 17 Story, When the memory fades

Mogadishu series: 50 tetanus patients, a quarter died even with a hospital (26 per cent)

To check against
HY-10. The Mogadishu series HY-10 cites
The verdict
OPEN
17-27 open 17 Story, When the memory fades. Numbers

Measles: a district of 3,000 gains about 100 susceptibles a year, an epidemic possible in about 2 years and large within 5

To check against
HY-10 (its own arithmetic), IN-12, SY-09
The verdict
OPEN
17-28 open 17 Story, When the memory fades

Britain: whooping cough coverage fell from about 77 per cent (1974) to 30 per cent (1978), followed by over 100,000 cases (102,500) and 36 deaths

To check against
HY-10. Gangarosa and others 1998
The verdict
OPEN
17-29 open 17 Story, When the memory fades

Diphtheria returns in 5 to 25 years. Former Soviet Union: 1,431 cases in 1990 to over 50,000 a year, about 4,000 deaths

To check against
HY-10, IN-12. Vitek and Wharton 1998
The verdict
OPEN
17-3 open 17 Story, The scab and the scratch

English inoculators (the Suttonian method, from the 1760s) claimed deaths below 1 in 500, disputed by historians

To check against
HY-10 (Razzell via Mark and Rigau-Pérez). Razzell 1977, Davenport 2015
The verdict
OPEN
17-31 open 17 Story, When the memory fades

Polio paralyses about 1 in 200 infected, and 5 to 10 in 100 of the paralysed die

To check against
HY-10. WHO polio fact sheet
The verdict
OPEN
17-4 open 17 Story, The scab and the scratch

A Madrid physician (Francisco Gil) pointed out in 1784 that the variolated are infectious

To check against
HY-10. Gil's Disertación físico-médica, 1784
The verdict
OPEN
17-5 open 17 Story, The scab and the scratch

Last natural smallpox case a hospital cook in Merca, Somalia, October 1977 (26 October). Eradication declared 1979 (certified 9 December 1979, endorsed by the World Health Assembly 8 May 1980)

To check against
HY-10. Fenner 1988, WHO
The verdict
OPEN
17-6 open 17 Story, The cowpox chain

Jenner, May 1796 (14 or 17 May by source), cowpox from Sarah Nelmes into James Phipps aged 8, smallpox challenge about 6 weeks later with no effect

To check against
HY-10. Jenner's Inquiry 1798, Baxby 1981
The verdict
OPEN
17-7 open 17 Story, The cowpox chain

Jenner's Inquiry of 1798 rested on 23 cases, 3 challenged with smallpox

To check against
HY-10. Jenner 1798 (primary)
The verdict
OPEN
17-8 open 17 Story, The cowpox chain

Balmis left Corunna November 1803 with 22 foundling boys aged 3 to 9, vaccinated 2 at a time, Isabel Zendal caring. About 62 children in all, 4 died

To check against
HY-10. Mark and Rigau-Pérez 2009, Franco-Paredes 2005
The verdict
OPEN
17-9 open 17 Story, The cowpox chain

About 100,000 vaccinated in New Spain, about 1 fifth coverage (Grajales claimed 400,000). Soldiers ordered to the needle at Veracruz (10, July 1804). Caracas board founded 1804

To check against
HY-10. Mark and Rigau-Pérez 2009
The verdict
OPEN