THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 511 · HEALING · Synthesis, critique and method

The case against lay medicine

Its printed title: SY-01 The case against lay medicine: how amateurs kill, and whether manuals help

This report puts HEALING after the FALL on trial. It first gathers the strongest evidence that untrained and lightly trained people harm the sick, then sets against it the trials of lay care, the record of the best-known self-help manual and the question the harm literature rarely asks: what happens with no care at all. It ends with the rules the book must obey and what it must refuse to teach. Three warnings apply throughout.

Open the PDF 22 pages · 124 KB

Number
511
Letter code
SY-01
Book
HEALING after the FALL
Shelf
Synthesis, critique and method
File
511 SY-01 The case against lay medicine.pdf
Pages
22
Works cited
1

The rows that check it

  • 10 open
  • 6 marked for safety
  • 18-14 open Safety Never tie a band for a snakebite
  • 22-11 open Safety Never cut, suck, burn or ice a snakebite, never tie a band
  • 22-3 open Safety No injection below the district except adrenaline into the thigh for anaphylaxis and the birth attendant's magnesium. Never inject any other drug
  • 35-17 open Safety Bonesetter: tight splints stopped
  • 35-2 open Safety Never taught in the 300 hours: injection, surgery beyond wound care, the microscope, drugs off the list, diagnosis by name
  • 36-13 open Safety C10, the tourniquet: taught, never for snakebite. Owner's decision
  • 03-33 open Reused syringes gave about 21 million people hepatitis B in 2000. Madhya Pradesh 2010: correct diagnosis in 12 visits in 100, harmful or needless treatment in 42. 84 parents in …
  • 03-36 open Gadchiroli sepsis deaths 16.6 to 2.8 in 100. Tigray deaths under five down by 40 in 100. Nepal snakebite deaths 10.5 to 0.5 in 100. Southern Ethiopia bonesetter amputations 25 to …
  • 18-51 open Snakebite tourniquets in nearly half of victims across 71 studies. 39 of 100 trained nurses failed at 6 months
  • 35-57 open The case against lay medicine and its answer: in no trial found did trained lay people make outcomes worse

Its works cited 1

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 1 journal, university or public body
Show all 1
  1. Simonsen L, Kane A, Lloyd J, Zaffran M, Kane M. 1999. Unsafe injections in the developing world andtransmission of bloodborne pathogens: a review. Bulletin of the W orld Health Organization 77(10):789-800 pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2557743