THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 35: The Healer, the Infirmary and the Commons

58 claims, 19 marked for safety

35-1 Safety open Clock line, Bench 35.2 table, Numbers

300 hours make a healer: 4 blocks of 72 hours and 12 hours of certification, with the hours per topic as tabled. OR-01 calls this its own synthesis, not a tested course

To check against
OR-01 sections 1 and Protocol syllabus. Compare Alaska 16 weeks (about 640 hours), Werner 2 months (about 384), WHO 2018 guideline on training length
The verdict
OPEN
35-10 Safety open Bench 35.1 boundary step 1

The village never cuts into a belly, chest, skull or eye

To check against
Chapter 23 (23.1), SY-10, OR-07 Protocols 4 and 5
The verdict
OPEN
35-11 Safety open Bench 35.1 boundary step 2, Turn

The village injects 2 things only: magnesium into muscle by the birth attendant (10.5) and adrenaline into the thigh for anaphylaxis (22.2)

To check against
SY-10 section 4 (injection below the district, two named exceptions), Concept Note section 12 default 10, MA-04, CH-13
The verdict
OPEN
35-12 Safety open Bench 35.1 boundary steps 3 and 4, Honest Broker

Lidocaine, general anaesthesia and every operation in 23.1 belong to the district with 2 trained people. The infirmary healer is the lowest rung taught any other injection [OWNER on the training]. SY-10's table lists lidocaine under the village healer, and the chapter follows 23.2 instead

To check against
Chapter 23 (23.1, 23.2), SY-10 section 5 table, OR-01 section 10 (advanced modules at the district)
The verdict
OPEN
35-14 Safety open Story (Ten beds), Honest Broker, Bench 35.5 table, Numbers

C13 printed both ways: caesareans for 3,000 people 1 to 2 a year on absolute indications (OR-07) against about 6 from a 5% floor (FO-11). OR-07's Nordberg estimate about 7, register 1 to 7

To check against
OR-07 volume section, FO-11 section on IARH, SY-12 lines on C13. Do not settle
The verdict
OPEN
35-15 Safety open Honest Broker

C12 printed both ways: Pereira and colleagues 1996, Maputo, 958 of 2,071 caesareans by técnicos (MA-03) against 978 by técnicos and 1,113 by doctors (WO-08). SY-12's arithmetic favours MA-03 (958 + 1,113 = 2,071, 978 + 1,113 = 2,091), but neither report read the paper

To check against
Pereira 1996 full paper. MA-03, WO-08, SY-12, OR-07 (which could not settle it). Do not settle
The verdict
OPEN
35-16 Safety open Bench 35.6 table

Midwife: stop anything on the cord but chlorhexidine, pressing on the belly, anything to hurry labour

To check against
SY-10 never list items 1 and 7, section 4 (chlorhexidine), chapters 8 and 11
The verdict
OPEN
35-17 Safety open Bench 35.6 table

Bonesetter: tight splints stopped

To check against
SY-01 section 1.3 (one-day courses cut gangrene amputations 25 to 7 in Ethiopia), chapter 19
The verdict
OPEN
35-18 Safety open Bench 35.6

Grade C remedy helps about 1 time in 3, grade D about 1 in 10

To check against
TR-01 section 8 (author's synthesis), chapter 33
The verdict
OPEN
35-19 Safety open Bench 35.5 steps 4 and 5

Women from far villages wait at the infirmary from 37 weeks. Transport by 4 bearers and a runner

To check against
OR-07 transport protocol, chapter 10
The verdict
OPEN
35-2 Safety open Bench 35.2 never line

Never taught in the 300 hours: injection, surgery beyond wound care, the microscope, drugs off the list, diagnosis by name

To check against
OR-01 (list of what is never in the 300 hours), SY-01 section 6, SY-10 row on injection below the district
The verdict
OPEN
35-3 Safety open Bench 35.2 steps 2 and 5, Honest Broker

Logged cases between blocks 20, 40 and 60. Probation 6 months with at least 100 cases. OR-01's own minimums

To check against
OR-01 Protocols B and D. Alaska field hours (ANTHC 2020)
The verdict
OPEN
35-4 Safety open Bench 35.2 step 6

The lay counsellor's hours (29) count toward the 300. A healer who did that course skips Block 4's 8 hours on mind and grief. Its 15 watched hours count as logged practice

To check against
MI-02 section 2 (PM+ 80 hours, 2 clients x 5 sessions, 15 hours supervised practice, WHO 2018). Chapter 29 when drafted. (the author's decision) on the crediting rule
The verdict
OPEN
35-5 Safety open Bench 35.2, who teaches

When there is no teacher: 2 learners teach each other from the book. One trial found village leaders taught by trainers new to the place ran effective counselling groups

To check against
MI-02 section 8 (Bolton 2003, group IPT Uganda). The peer method itself is the chapter's proposal (the author's decision)
The verdict
OPEN
35-6 Safety open Clock line, Bench 35.3 never line and table, Numbers

A hand skill decays within 3 months. Rota: daily kit check 3 minutes, weekly paired drill 3 to 10 minutes never more than 2 weeks apart, monthly day never more than 6 weeks apart, quarterly stations with a failed skill suspended and retested within 2 weeks, yearly 10 to 15 days, recertification every 2 years

To check against
OR-01 skill decay section (Riggs 2019) and Protocol E. The quarterly drill topics are the chapter's (the author's decision), pointing to 18.2, 18.3, 11.2, 9 and 4
The verdict
OPEN
35-7 Safety open Clock line, Bench 35.1 table, Numbers

A village of 300 needs 1 healer and 1 second, each with 300 hours

To check against
OR-01 Protocol A and section 10 (two healers plus a reserve), OR-08 Protocol C step 6 (one healer for 300, a second past 400 (to be checked) there), MI-12
The verdict
OPEN
35-8 Safety open Bench 35.1

Ratios in the library: 1 lay healer per 300 to 1,500 people (FO-04). 1 to 2 community health workers per 1,000 in camps (FO-11)

To check against
FO-04 Numbers item 10, FO-11 section on UNHCR staffing
The verdict
OPEN
35-9 Safety open Clock line, Story (Ten beds), Bench 35.1 table, 35.5 table and step 1, Numbers

A district of 3,000 needs 10 beds and 11 to 13 staff: 2 operators, 2 midwives, 4 to 5 ward keepers, 1 steriliser keeper, 2 to 3 others. Operators trained 3 years and 1 as intern

To check against
OR-07 roster and training grades (3.3 beds per 1,000, ICRC 1.7 staff per bed)
The verdict
OPEN
35-20 open Story (Three pence), Bench 35.4 step 3, Numbers

About 60 households in 300 people. One healer's keep about 1.7% of each household's keep, near Tredegar's 1.25%

To check against
OR-08 section 3 and Protocol A (its own arithmetic, five people a household (to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
35-21 open Story (Ten beds), Bench 35.5 step 8

About 24,000 hours of work a year for the infirmary, or 20 hours from each of about 1,200 adults

To check against
OR-07 roster arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
35-22 open Story (Ten beds)

Water 250 to 1,000 litres a day, wood 13 to 22 tonnes a year

To check against
OR-07 means section
The verdict
OPEN
35-23 open Bench 35.2 table

Mapping of the book's chapters onto the 4 blocks

To check against
Draft's own, against the Concept Note chapter list and OR-01's syllabus (the author's decision)
The verdict
OPEN
35-24 open Honest Broker, Bench 35.4

Key forms: OR-08 two keys held by two households, neither the healer's. SY-10 one keeper, a deputy and a sealed spare with the council. Chapter 32 to settle

To check against
OR-08 sections 1.8 and Protocol B, SY-10 Protocol 3, OR-06
The verdict
OPEN
35-25 open Story (barefoot)

June 1965: Mao Zedong attacked the urban bias of Chinese medicine (OR-08 gives a directive of 25 June 1965, first tried in Changyang county)

To check against
FO-04 section 1.1 (Zhang and Unschuld 2008), OR-08 section 1.3 (Liu Yueju et al. 2013)
The verdict
OPEN
35-26 open Story (barefoot)

In 1964 the state spent more on 8.3 million city people than on 500 million peasants

To check against
OR-01 (Zhang and Unschuld 2008)
The verdict
OPEN
35-27 open Story (barefoot)

The name "barefoot doctor" spread after a People's Daily article of 1968

To check against
FO-04 section 1.1 (WHO Bulletin 2008)
The verdict
OPEN
35-28 open Story (barefoot)

Course of 1 to 4 months, or 3 to 6, or a year in places. Half the day farming

To check against
FO-04 section 1.1, OR-01 (Lee and Kim 2018, NLM)
The verdict
OPEN
35-29 open Story (barefoot)

Manual in English 1974, more than 900 pages, over 400 on plants

To check against
FO-04 (about 942 pages, catalogue), OR-01 (NIH 1974, 960 pages). Plant pages (to be checked) in FO-04
The verdict
OPEN
35-30 open Story (barefoot), Honest Broker

More than a million trained by the 1970s. The Preface's "a million". OR-01 gives about 1.4 million served. 1.8 million untraced

To check against
FO-04 (NLM, Hesketh and Wei 1997), OR-01
The verdict
OPEN
35-31 open Story (barefoot)

Work points from the brigade, about half a regular doctor's pay. 1 yuan a year, 5 fen a visit, medicines free. About 9 villages in 10 at the peak

To check against
OR-08 section 1.3 (Liu Yueju et al. 2013, PAHO), OR-01
The verdict
OPEN
35-32 open Story (barefoot)

Infant deaths about 200 to 34 per 1,000 from 1962 to 1982, not creditable to the barefoot doctors alone

To check against
OR-01, FO-04 (Babiarz et al. 2015)
The verdict
OPEN
35-33 open Story (barefoot), Honest Broker

From 1981 an examination made village doctors. 643,022 passed by 1985, about half of those in post. The claim of "a third" not supported

To check against
OR-01, FO-04 section 1.1
The verdict
OPEN
35-34 open Story (barefoot), Honest Broker

The scheme shrank to a small fraction (about 90% to about 5% at an undated trough, or 85% in 1975 to 10% by 1997)

To check against
OR-08 section 1.3, FO-04
The verdict
OPEN
35-35 open Story (barefoot)

20,125 village prescriptions, 22.93% with an injection (printed as 23 in 100)

To check against
FO-04 section 1.11 (Dong et al. 2011)
The verdict
OPEN
35-36 open Story (barefoot)

1987 survey of three counties: the scheme was solvent where it survived, died where officials believed central backing had gone, and infant mortality, immunisation and infection worsened where it died

To check against
OR-08 section 1.3 (Zhu et al. 1989, abstract only)
The verdict
OPEN
35-37 open Story (Jamkhed)

Rajanikant and Mabelle Arole began at Jamkhed, Maharashtra, in 1970 in a leased cowshed. Villages chose the workers

To check against
OR-07, FO-04 section 1.3 (PRB 2007). OR-01 says early 1970s (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
35-38 open Story (Jamkhed)

Senior workers 1.6 years of school and 28.9 years of service. About 2 in 3 served over two decades. Weekly training

To check against
OR-01 (Kaysin 2024)
The verdict
OPEN
35-39 open Story (Jamkhed)

Infant deaths 176 per 1,000 in 1971, 18 in 2016 (project figures). Post-neonatal deaths 30% lower than control villages 1994 to 2007. Arole's 10 to 15 years

To check against
OR-01, FO-04 section 1.3
The verdict
OPEN
35-40 open Story (Jamkhed)

Jamkhed hospital 50 beds for over 500,000 people by 2011. About 80% of problems handled in the village

To check against
OR-07 (Penn CHIP 2012)
The verdict
OPEN
35-41 open Story (aides)

Alaska community health aides since 1968

To check against
Brief and Concept Note only. No report read gives the start year
The verdict
OPEN
35-42 open Story (aides)

About 500 aides in 178 communities. 16 weeks in 4 sessions over 2 to 3 years. 20 encounters, then 200 hours and about 60 patients, then 200 hours after each later session. 48 credits every 2 years

To check against
OR-01 section 1.4 (Landon 2004, UAF 2014, ANTHC 2020, YKHC)
The verdict
OPEN
35-43 open Story (aides)

1988: lost about a third, over 151 posts. 20% a year by 1999. Five retention factors from 15 villages

To check against
OR-01 section 1.4 (Landon 2004)
The verdict
OPEN
35-44 open Story (aides)

34 studies, 35,421 people: resuscitation skill fell within 3 months, then levelled

To check against
OR-01 (Riggs 2019)
The verdict
OPEN
35-45 open Story (aides)

835 birth attendants: 99% passed after training, 81% at about 7 months (6.7), knowledge 99%

To check against
OR-01 (Bang 2016)
The verdict
OPEN
35-46 open Story (aides), Bench 35.3, Numbers

Haydom, Tanzania, Mduma and colleagues 2015: 3 minutes of paired practice weekly, 40 minutes monthly, 4,814 and 4,894 births, first-day deaths 11.1 to 7.2 per 1,000, before and after, no control

To check against
OR-01 (Mduma 2015)
The verdict
OPEN
35-47 open Story (Three pence), Numbers

Tredegar Workmen's Medical Aid Society: from 1890, three pence in the pound (1.25%) by deduction, for doctors, medicine and appliances

To check against
OR-08 section 1.2 (Gwent Archives, search summary only). 1890 from the Preface
The verdict
OPEN
35-48 open Story (Three pence)

1901 contract: salary £900, all sums received as medical officer handed back less a commission

To check against
OR-08 section 1.2 (Gwent Archives, search summary only)
The verdict
OPEN
35-49 open Story (Three pence)

1911 ballot 2,584 to 1,804. By 1933, 95% of the town, five doctors, two dentists, dispensers and a nurse

To check against
OR-08 section 1.2 (Wikipedia, Gwent Archives)
The verdict
OPEN
35-50 open Story (Three pence)

Aneurin Bevan took the model to the National Health Service in 1948, and the society withered

To check against
OR-08 section 1.2 (Wikipedia)
The verdict
OPEN
35-51 open Story (Three pence)

US lodges about $2 a year, about a day's wage, doctors elected. County societies expelled contract doctors and denied hospital privileges. Gone by the end of the 1930s. 10 to 20% of applicants rejected, childbirth excluded by some

To check against
OR-08 section 1.2 (Beito 1994)
The verdict
OPEN
35-52 open Story (Three pence)

Dhaka volunteers expecting income almost twice as likely to stay (aOR 1.87). Paid peers lost none, volunteers lost 35%

To check against
OR-08 section 1.6 (Alam, Tasneem and Oliveras 2011), MI-02 section 9 (Vanobberghen 2020)
The verdict
OPEN
35-53 open Story (Ten beds)

Albert Napper, Cranleigh, 1859. About 294 cottage hospitals 1855 to 1898. Chinese commune hospitals 8 to 15 staff, 1 bed per 1,000

To check against
OR-07 small hospitals section
The verdict
OPEN
35-54 open Story (Ten beds), Bench 35.5 table, Numbers

For 3,000 a year: 90 to 120 births, about 30 major operations, about 5 hernias with about 1 strangulated, 100 to 150 other admissions, about 2 beds a night at 5 days, 7 or 8 of 10 beds empty

To check against
OR-07 volume section (Nordberg 1984), FO-11
The verdict
OPEN
35-55 open Story (Ten beds)

Six killers of small hospitals: loss of the payer, centralisation, loss of the one trained person, war, infection, fees at the door

To check against
OR-07
The verdict
OPEN
35-56 open Turn

Boston trial of 2008, 262 people with irritable bowel: adequate relief at 3 weeks 28, 44 and 62%, the warm visit 45 minutes

To check against
FO-10 section 6 (Kaptchuk et al. 2008)
The verdict
OPEN
35-57 open Turn

The case against lay medicine and its answer: in no trial found did trained lay people make outcomes worse

To check against
SY-01 sections 6 and 7, chapter 3
The verdict
OPEN