35-1 Safety open Clock line, Bench 35.2 table, Numbers300 hours make a healer: 4 blocks of 72 hours and 12 hours of certification, with the hours per topic as tabled. OR-01 calls this its own synthesis, not a tested course
- To check against
- OR-01 sections 1 and Protocol syllabus. Compare Alaska 16 weeks (about 640 hours), Werner 2 months (about 384), WHO 2018 guideline on training length
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-10 Safety open Bench 35.1 boundary step 1The village never cuts into a belly, chest, skull or eye
- To check against
- Chapter 23 (23.1), SY-10, OR-07 Protocols 4 and 5
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-11 Safety open Bench 35.1 boundary step 2, TurnThe village injects 2 things only: magnesium into muscle by the birth attendant (10.5) and adrenaline into the thigh for anaphylaxis (22.2)
- To check against
- SY-10 section 4 (injection below the district, two named exceptions), Concept Note section 12 default 10, MA-04, CH-13
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-12 Safety open Bench 35.1 boundary steps 3 and 4, Honest BrokerLidocaine, general anaesthesia and every operation in 23.1 belong to the district with 2 trained people. The infirmary healer is the lowest rung taught any other injection [OWNER on the training]. SY-10's table lists lidocaine under the village healer, and the chapter follows 23.2 instead
- To check against
- Chapter 23 (23.1, 23.2), SY-10 section 5 table, OR-01 section 10 (advanced modules at the district)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-13 Safety open Bench 35.5 never lineOne needle or blade per person. New, or steamed at 121 °C, for each
- To check against
- SY-10 row H4, FO-04 Protocol G, WO-12
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-14 Safety open Story (Ten beds), Honest Broker, Bench 35.5 table, NumbersC13 printed both ways: caesareans for 3,000 people 1 to 2 a year on absolute indications (OR-07) against about 6 from a 5% floor (FO-11). OR-07's Nordberg estimate about 7, register 1 to 7
- To check against
- OR-07 volume section, FO-11 section on IARH, SY-12 lines on C13. Do not settle
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-15 Safety open Honest BrokerC12 printed both ways: Pereira and colleagues 1996, Maputo, 958 of 2,071 caesareans by técnicos (MA-03) against 978 by técnicos and 1,113 by doctors (WO-08). SY-12's arithmetic favours MA-03 (958 + 1,113 = 2,071, 978 + 1,113 = 2,091), but neither report read the paper
- To check against
- Pereira 1996 full paper. MA-03, WO-08, SY-12, OR-07 (which could not settle it). Do not settle
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-16 Safety open Bench 35.6 tableMidwife: stop anything on the cord but chlorhexidine, pressing on the belly, anything to hurry labour
- To check against
- SY-10 never list items 1 and 7, section 4 (chlorhexidine), chapters 8 and 11
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-17 Safety open Bench 35.6 tableBonesetter: tight splints stopped
- To check against
- SY-01 section 1.3 (one-day courses cut gangrene amputations 25 to 7 in Ethiopia), chapter 19
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-18 Safety open Bench 35.6Grade C remedy helps about 1 time in 3, grade D about 1 in 10
- To check against
- TR-01 section 8 (author's synthesis), chapter 33
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-19 Safety open Bench 35.5 steps 4 and 5Women from far villages wait at the infirmary from 37 weeks. Transport by 4 bearers and a runner
- To check against
- OR-07 transport protocol, chapter 10
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-2 Safety open Bench 35.2 never lineNever taught in the 300 hours: injection, surgery beyond wound care, the microscope, drugs off the list, diagnosis by name
- To check against
- OR-01 (list of what is never in the 300 hours), SY-01 section 6, SY-10 row on injection below the district
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-3 Safety open Bench 35.2 steps 2 and 5, Honest BrokerLogged cases between blocks 20, 40 and 60. Probation 6 months with at least 100 cases. OR-01's own minimums
- To check against
- OR-01 Protocols B and D. Alaska field hours (ANTHC 2020)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-4 Safety open Bench 35.2 step 6The lay counsellor's hours (29) count toward the 300. A healer who did that course skips Block 4's 8 hours on mind and grief. Its 15 watched hours count as logged practice
- To check against
- MI-02 section 2 (PM+ 80 hours, 2 clients x 5 sessions, 15 hours supervised practice, WHO 2018). Chapter 29 when drafted. (the author's decision) on the crediting rule
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-5 Safety open Bench 35.2, who teachesWhen there is no teacher: 2 learners teach each other from the book. One trial found village leaders taught by trainers new to the place ran effective counselling groups
- To check against
- MI-02 section 8 (Bolton 2003, group IPT Uganda). The peer method itself is the chapter's proposal (the author's decision)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-6 Safety open Clock line, Bench 35.3 never line and table, NumbersA hand skill decays within 3 months. Rota: daily kit check 3 minutes, weekly paired drill 3 to 10 minutes never more than 2 weeks apart, monthly day never more than 6 weeks apart, quarterly stations with a failed skill suspended and retested within 2 weeks, yearly 10 to 15 days, recertification every 2 years
- To check against
- OR-01 skill decay section (Riggs 2019) and Protocol E. The quarterly drill topics are the chapter's (the author's decision), pointing to 18.2, 18.3, 11.2, 9 and 4
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-7 Safety open Clock line, Bench 35.1 table, NumbersA village of 300 needs 1 healer and 1 second, each with 300 hours
- To check against
- OR-01 Protocol A and section 10 (two healers plus a reserve), OR-08 Protocol C step 6 (one healer for 300, a second past 400 (to be checked) there), MI-12
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-8 Safety open Bench 35.1Ratios in the library: 1 lay healer per 300 to 1,500 people (FO-04). 1 to 2 community health workers per 1,000 in camps (FO-11)
- To check against
- FO-04 Numbers item 10, FO-11 section on UNHCR staffing
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-9 Safety open Clock line, Story (Ten beds), Bench 35.1 table, 35.5 table and step 1, NumbersA district of 3,000 needs 10 beds and 11 to 13 staff: 2 operators, 2 midwives, 4 to 5 ward keepers, 1 steriliser keeper, 2 to 3 others. Operators trained 3 years and 1 as intern
- To check against
- OR-07 roster and training grades (3.3 beds per 1,000, ICRC 1.7 staff per bed)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-20 open Story (Three pence), Bench 35.4 step 3, NumbersAbout 60 households in 300 people. One healer's keep about 1.7% of each household's keep, near Tredegar's 1.25%
- To check against
- OR-08 section 3 and Protocol A (its own arithmetic, five people a household (to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-21 open Story (Ten beds), Bench 35.5 step 8About 24,000 hours of work a year for the infirmary, or 20 hours from each of about 1,200 adults
- To check against
- OR-07 roster arithmetic
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-22 open Story (Ten beds)Water 250 to 1,000 litres a day, wood 13 to 22 tonnes a year
- To check against
- OR-07 means section
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-23 open Bench 35.2 tableMapping of the book's chapters onto the 4 blocks
- To check against
- Draft's own, against the Concept Note chapter list and OR-01's syllabus (the author's decision)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-24 open Honest Broker, Bench 35.4Key forms: OR-08 two keys held by two households, neither the healer's. SY-10 one keeper, a deputy and a sealed spare with the council. Chapter 32 to settle
- To check against
- OR-08 sections 1.8 and Protocol B, SY-10 Protocol 3, OR-06
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-25 open Story (barefoot)June 1965: Mao Zedong attacked the urban bias of Chinese medicine (OR-08 gives a directive of 25 June 1965, first tried in Changyang county)
- To check against
- FO-04 section 1.1 (Zhang and Unschuld 2008), OR-08 section 1.3 (Liu Yueju et al. 2013)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-26 open Story (barefoot)In 1964 the state spent more on 8.3 million city people than on 500 million peasants
- To check against
- OR-01 (Zhang and Unschuld 2008)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-27 open Story (barefoot)The name "barefoot doctor" spread after a People's Daily article of 1968
- To check against
- FO-04 section 1.1 (WHO Bulletin 2008)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-28 open Story (barefoot)Course of 1 to 4 months, or 3 to 6, or a year in places. Half the day farming
- To check against
- FO-04 section 1.1, OR-01 (Lee and Kim 2018, NLM)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-29 open Story (barefoot)Manual in English 1974, more than 900 pages, over 400 on plants
- To check against
- FO-04 (about 942 pages, catalogue), OR-01 (NIH 1974, 960 pages). Plant pages (to be checked) in FO-04
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-30 open Story (barefoot), Honest BrokerMore than a million trained by the 1970s. The Preface's "a million". OR-01 gives about 1.4 million served. 1.8 million untraced
- To check against
- FO-04 (NLM, Hesketh and Wei 1997), OR-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-31 open Story (barefoot)Work points from the brigade, about half a regular doctor's pay. 1 yuan a year, 5 fen a visit, medicines free. About 9 villages in 10 at the peak
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.3 (Liu Yueju et al. 2013, PAHO), OR-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-32 open Story (barefoot)Infant deaths about 200 to 34 per 1,000 from 1962 to 1982, not creditable to the barefoot doctors alone
- To check against
- OR-01, FO-04 (Babiarz et al. 2015)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-33 open Story (barefoot), Honest BrokerFrom 1981 an examination made village doctors. 643,022 passed by 1985, about half of those in post. The claim of "a third" not supported
- To check against
- OR-01, FO-04 section 1.1
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-34 open Story (barefoot), Honest BrokerThe scheme shrank to a small fraction (about 90% to about 5% at an undated trough, or 85% in 1975 to 10% by 1997)
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.3, FO-04
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-35 open Story (barefoot)20,125 village prescriptions, 22.93% with an injection (printed as 23 in 100)
- To check against
- FO-04 section 1.11 (Dong et al. 2011)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-36 open Story (barefoot)1987 survey of three counties: the scheme was solvent where it survived, died where officials believed central backing had gone, and infant mortality, immunisation and infection worsened where it died
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.3 (Zhu et al. 1989, abstract only)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-37 open Story (Jamkhed)Rajanikant and Mabelle Arole began at Jamkhed, Maharashtra, in 1970 in a leased cowshed. Villages chose the workers
- To check against
- OR-07, FO-04 section 1.3 (PRB 2007). OR-01 says early 1970s (to be checked)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-38 open Story (Jamkhed)Senior workers 1.6 years of school and 28.9 years of service. About 2 in 3 served over two decades. Weekly training
- To check against
- OR-01 (Kaysin 2024)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-39 open Story (Jamkhed)Infant deaths 176 per 1,000 in 1971, 18 in 2016 (project figures). Post-neonatal deaths 30% lower than control villages 1994 to 2007. Arole's 10 to 15 years
- To check against
- OR-01, FO-04 section 1.3
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-40 open Story (Jamkhed)Jamkhed hospital 50 beds for over 500,000 people by 2011. About 80% of problems handled in the village
- To check against
- OR-07 (Penn CHIP 2012)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Alaska community health aides since 1968
- To check against
- Brief and Concept Note only. No report read gives the start year
- The verdict
- OPEN
About 500 aides in 178 communities. 16 weeks in 4 sessions over 2 to 3 years. 20 encounters, then 200 hours and about 60 patients, then 200 hours after each later session. 48 credits every 2 years
- To check against
- OR-01 section 1.4 (Landon 2004, UAF 2014, ANTHC 2020, YKHC)
- The verdict
- OPEN
1988: lost about a third, over 151 posts. 20% a year by 1999. Five retention factors from 15 villages
- To check against
- OR-01 section 1.4 (Landon 2004)
- The verdict
- OPEN
34 studies, 35,421 people: resuscitation skill fell within 3 months, then levelled
- To check against
- OR-01 (Riggs 2019)
- The verdict
- OPEN
835 birth attendants: 99% passed after training, 81% at about 7 months (6.7), knowledge 99%
- To check against
- OR-01 (Bang 2016)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-46 open Story (aides), Bench 35.3, NumbersHaydom, Tanzania, Mduma and colleagues 2015: 3 minutes of paired practice weekly, 40 minutes monthly, 4,814 and 4,894 births, first-day deaths 11.1 to 7.2 per 1,000, before and after, no control
- To check against
- OR-01 (Mduma 2015)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-47 open Story (Three pence), NumbersTredegar Workmen's Medical Aid Society: from 1890, three pence in the pound (1.25%) by deduction, for doctors, medicine and appliances
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.2 (Gwent Archives, search summary only). 1890 from the Preface
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-48 open Story (Three pence)1901 contract: salary £900, all sums received as medical officer handed back less a commission
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.2 (Gwent Archives, search summary only)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-49 open Story (Three pence)1911 ballot 2,584 to 1,804. By 1933, 95% of the town, five doctors, two dentists, dispensers and a nurse
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.2 (Wikipedia, Gwent Archives)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-50 open Story (Three pence)Aneurin Bevan took the model to the National Health Service in 1948, and the society withered
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.2 (Wikipedia)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-51 open Story (Three pence)US lodges about $2 a year, about a day's wage, doctors elected. County societies expelled contract doctors and denied hospital privileges. Gone by the end of the 1930s. 10 to 20% of applicants rejected, childbirth excluded by some
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.2 (Beito 1994)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-52 open Story (Three pence)Dhaka volunteers expecting income almost twice as likely to stay (aOR 1.87). Paid peers lost none, volunteers lost 35%
- To check against
- OR-08 section 1.6 (Alam, Tasneem and Oliveras 2011), MI-02 section 9 (Vanobberghen 2020)
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-53 open Story (Ten beds)Albert Napper, Cranleigh, 1859. About 294 cottage hospitals 1855 to 1898. Chinese commune hospitals 8 to 15 staff, 1 bed per 1,000
- To check against
- OR-07 small hospitals section
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-54 open Story (Ten beds), Bench 35.5 table, NumbersFor 3,000 a year: 90 to 120 births, about 30 major operations, about 5 hernias with about 1 strangulated, 100 to 150 other admissions, about 2 beds a night at 5 days, 7 or 8 of 10 beds empty
- To check against
- OR-07 volume section (Nordberg 1984), FO-11
- The verdict
- OPEN
35-55 open Story (Ten beds)Six killers of small hospitals: loss of the payer, centralisation, loss of the one trained person, war, infection, fees at the door
- To check against
- OR-07
- The verdict
- OPEN
Boston trial of 2008, 262 people with irritable bowel: adequate relief at 3 weeks 28, 44 and 62%, the warm visit 45 minutes
- To check against
- FO-10 section 6 (Kaptchuk et al. 2008)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The case against lay medicine and its answer: in no trial found did trained lay people make outcomes worse
- To check against
- SY-01 sections 6 and 7, chapter 3
- The verdict
- OPEN
New Zealand's Tohunga Suppression Act, 1907 to 1962
- To check against
- SY-04
- The verdict
- OPEN