The Library · Document 439 · HEALING · Healing traditions and systems
How often is the old remedy right
Its printed title: TR-01 How often is the old remedy right? The ethnobotanical hit rate and the test of convergence
HEALING after the FALL trusts neither the herbal nor the hospital until each has been tested. After the Fall most remedies cannot be tested before the healer must act. The healer needs a starting number: the probability that a traditional remedy does what it is said to do, before anyone has tested it. Statisticians call this a prior. FO-03's evidence ladder uses grade C for "convergent traditional use across unrelated cultures with plausible pharmacology".
Open the PDF 21 pages · 114 KB
- Number
- 439
- Letter code
- TR-01
- Book
- HEALING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Healing traditions and systems
- File
- 439 TR-01 How often is the old remedy right.pdf
- Pages
- 21
The rows that check it
- 9 open
- 3 marked for safety
- 03-41 open Safety Grades line: willow extract A for back pain, decoction C. Senna A. Psyllium husk A, home seed C. Cranberry A for recurrent urinary infection. Argemone A (1 trial). Devil's claw …
- 03-46 open Safety 30 cured of 30 still allows failure in up to 1 in 10
- 35-18 open Safety Grade C remedy helps about 1 time in 3, grade D about 1 in 10
- 03-1 open Withering gave foxglove to 163 people between 1775 and 1784, and wrote every case down, failures included. Disputed: 1775 to 1785 (FO-03), about 160 (TR-01)
- 03-14 open NCI 1960 to 1974, over 20,000 species, about 1 random species in 10 active (10.4%), folk plants 1.4 to 2.6 times as often, worm remedies 29 in 100, arrow and ordeal poisons 46. …
- 03-16 open Working odds: grade C about 1 chance in 3 of doing something useful at the traditional dose, grade D about 1 in 10. TR-01's synthesis, not a measurement
- 03-18 open Ge Hong's handbook of about the year 340 told the healer to soak sweet wormwood and wring out the juice. Tu Youyou's team in Beijing followed it to artemisinin in 1971
- 03-22 open Colchicum luteum corm for gout: one uncontrolled series of 20 patients, relief in 94 in 100
- 03-24 open Hoodia tested and failed against hunger and raised blood pressure. Periwinkle led to two leukaemia drugs. Echinacea against colds tested in 24 trials, none showing prevention. …