THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 438 · HEALING · Pharmacopoeias by biome

The deadly lookalikes

Its printed title: PH-10 The deadly lookalikes: a field identification safety guide for medicinal plants

Nobody knows the true rate, because the people who get it wrong are not always counted. What exists is poison-centre data, and it is enough to set priorities.

Open the PDF 21 pages · 127 KB

Number
438
Letter code
PH-10
Book
HEALING after the FALL
Shelf
Pharmacopoeias by biome
File
438 PH-10 The deadly lookalikes.pdf
Pages
21
Works cited
1

The rows that check it

  • 40 open
  • 32 marked for safety
  • 22-1 open Safety Water hemlock root: fits within 15 to 90 minutes
  • 22-25 open Safety Keep the jar, plant, food and vomit, labelled, for 72 hours
  • 22-28 open Safety Charcoal stirred into about 8 times its volume of water and given over 15 to 20 minutes. PH-10 gives 50 g in about 250 ml
  • 22-32 open Safety Death cap group: vomiting from 6 hours (6 to 24, mean 12), then a false calm. Watch 24 hours after any wild mushroom
  • 22-33 open Safety Autumn crocus: shorter delay means worse poisoning, watch 7 days
  • 22-35 open Safety Three separate confirmations before a wild plant is eaten, one species to a basket, grade C
  • 34-17 open Safety Colchicum poison survives cooking, and many Slovenian cases ate the leaves boiled
  • 34-18 open Safety Brvar's 32 cases: sickness 2 to 24 hours after the meal, late onset milder (over 9 hours)
  • 34-20 open Safety Austria (Arif 2023): 174 exposures, 163 accidental, 113 children under 15, 2 deaths
  • 34-22 open Safety Maine, 5 October 1992: two brothers, a root taken for wild ginseng, the younger died 3 hours after three bites
  • 34-24 open Safety Water hemlock, American record 1900 to 1975: about 30 in 100 died
  • 34-27 open Safety Deadly nightshade berry sweet, like a cherry. Children poisoned by the nightshades mostly live with care
  • 34-28 open Safety Silver and peeling tests tell nothing. Cooking does not make colchicum safe
  • 34-43 open Safety ME-14 and PH-10 differ on onset for foxglove (1 to 8 h, 2 to 8 h) and nightshades (1 to 4 h, 30 min to 2 h)
  • 34-45 open Safety About two in three Austrian crocus swallowings were by children (113 of 174 is 65 in 100, 113 of 163 is 69)
  • 34-46 open Safety Keep a sample of every wild meal for 72 hours
  • 34-47 open Safety Plate 1: wild garlic and crocus tells, 2 to 24 h, 2 dead of 174 in Austria
  • 34-48 open Safety Plate 2: lily of the valley, 2 leaves from a shared sheath, 1 to 6 h, death rare
  • 34-49 open Safety Plate 3: poison hemlock tells, 30 min to 2 h, lives if breathed for
  • 34-50 open Safety Plate 4: no tell on water hemlock or dropwort root, dropwort smells of celery, 15 to 90 min (dropwort 30 to 60), about 30 in 100 dead
  • 34-51 open Safety Plate 5: foxglove onset 1 to 8 h (ME-14) or 2 to 8 h (PH-10)
  • 34-53 open Safety Plate 6: monkshood, no tell on the root, 10 min to 2 h, lips tingle first, 1 of 6 dead at Marseille
  • 34-54 open Safety Plate 7: yew, flat needles in 2 rows, 1 to 24 h, no antidote
  • 34-55 open Safety Plate 8: nightshade onset 30 min to 2 h (PH-10) or 1 to 4 h (ME-14), bilberry under 50 cm
  • 34-56 open Safety Plate 8: children mostly live with care
  • 34-57 open Safety Plate 9: death cap tells, 6 to 24 h then false calm, 10 to 27 in 100 dead
  • 34-58 open Safety Plate 10: false hellebore, pleated clasping leaf, alternate against gentian's opposite, 15 min to 2 h, recovery usual
  • 34-60 open Safety 3 confirmations grade C
  • 34-61 open Safety Keep the plant, food and vomit 72 hours
  • 34-65 open Safety Watch 7 days after autumn crocus
  • 34-80 open Safety Watch 7 days after a wild garlic meal with crocus
  • 34-82 open Safety Crocus 2 to 24 hours, watch 7 days
  • 22-40 open Marseille, January 2002 to December 2023: 513,750 reports, 2,197 confusions, 190 in hospital, 1 death from monkshood, oleander for bay 289 times
  • 22-52 open Charcoal curves: 75 to 98 per cent at 5 minutes and about 10 at 60 (PH-10), about 47 at 30 and 21 at 180 (ME-14). Hearth charcoal a quarter to a fifth of the surface
  • 34-15 open Marseille 2002 to 2023: 2,197 confusions, 1 death, aconite taken for an edible mountain plant (Molopospermum), with a hospital
  • 34-19 open A man of 76 died on day 3. 8 of the 9 most severe cases were over 65
  • 34-21 open Two Italians took poison hemlock for fennel and survived (Restani 2009)
  • 34-23 open Santarém, May 2017: two men died of hemlock water dropwort
  • 34-25 open 1857 Dublin Medical Press: monkshood root as horseradish, three Scottish deaths, two clergymen
  • 34-26 open California, December 2016: 14 poisoned by death cap, 3 transplants

In the Index

Soil and compost The field and the rotation Safety

Its works cited 1

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 1 journal, university or public body
Show all 1
  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1994. W ater Hemlock Poison-ing, Maine, 1992. Morbidity and Mortality W eekly Report 43(13):229-231 cdc.gov/mmwR/preview/mmwrhtml/00026056.htm