THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 3: Judging a Remedy

50 claims, 16 marked for safety

03-20 Safety open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm. Numbers to Carry

Brussels slimming clinic from 1990: Aristolochia fangchi substituted under the name fang ji, more than 100 people lost their kidneys, 18 of 39 with kidneys removed had urinary tract cancer

To check against
Vanherweghem JL et al. (1993), Lancet 341:387. Nortier JL et al. (2000), NEJM 342:1686 to 1692
The verdict
OPEN
03-21 Safety open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm. Numbers to Carry

14 of 70 Ayurvedic products bought in Boston in a 2004 study held lead, mercury or arsenic (1 in 5)

To check against
Saper RB et al. (2004), JAMA 292:2868 to 2873
The verdict
OPEN
03-39 Safety open 03 Bench 03.1 rule 6

An effect about 10 times larger, fast, on a stable illness, can earn B without a trial

To check against
Glasziou P, Chalmers I, Rawlins M, McCulloch P (2007), BMJ 334:349 to 351
The verdict
OPEN
03-40 Safety open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm. Bench 03.1 grades line

St John's wort extract A for mild to moderate depression, tea D, X with the contraceptive pill or ciclosporin

To check against
Linde K, Berner MM, Kriston L (2008), Cochrane CD000448. Ruschitzka F et al. (2000), Lancet, on ciclosporin
The verdict
OPEN
03-41 Safety open 03 Bench 03.1 grades line

Grades line: willow extract A for back pain, decoction C. Senna A. Psyllium husk A, home seed C. Cranberry A for recurrent urinary infection. Argemone A (1 trial). Devil's claw extract B. Kava extract B with a liver warning. Echinacea D (TR-01 leans X). Ginkgo for dementia X. Hoodia X. Bald's salve not tested in people

To check against
SY-02 grade table and its Cochrane sources. TR-01 for echinacea
The verdict
OPEN
03-42 Safety open 03 Bench 03.2 step 9

Outcome day 7 for acute illness, day 28 for wounds and long illness. A new remedy's first 10 uses checked at days 1, 3 and 7

To check against
FO-03 village protocol (marked VERIFY against clinical practice there). SY-04
The verdict
OPEN
03-44 Safety open 03 Bench 03.2 step 19

Comparison by lot: review every 20 patients and stop if one arm has more deaths or harm

To check against
FO-03 checklist. A trials handbook on interim monitoring
The verdict
OPEN
03-45 Safety open 03 Bench 03.2 step 20

About 80 per arm are needed to see deaths halved from 40 to 20 in 100

To check against
FO-03 author's calculation. A standard sample size formula (80% power, 5% two-sided)
The verdict
OPEN
03-46 Safety open 03 Bench 03.2, reading the count

30 cured of 30 still allows failure in up to 1 in 10

To check against
TR-01 (Mali 30 of 30, 95% interval 88 to 100). Willcox et al. (2011b). The rule of three (Hanley JA, Lippman-Hand A, 1983)
The verdict
OPEN
03-47 Safety open 03 Bench 03.3 never line and grades line. Ledger

Never use foxglove, monkshood, autumn crocus, yew, oleander or thorn apple as medicine. Foxglove never at any rung (owner's decision, case in chapter 34)

To check against
SY-10 rule 11 and rows H9, H44, H26. ME-07. ME-14
The verdict
OPEN
03-48 Safety open 03 Bench 03.3 table

Never bleed anyone for fever, pneumonia or any illness of the whole body

To check against
TR-13 Protocol 1 forbidden list. Morabia (2004). Dietl (1849)
The verdict
OPEN
03-49 Safety open 03 Bench 03.3 table

Never give calomel or tartar emetic. Bury salvaged stock at least 50 m from a well and 1 m deep

To check against
TR-13 Protocol 1 step 3 (no primary source given there). A guideline on safe disposal of unwanted pharmaceuticals
The verdict
OPEN
03-5 Safety open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire

The dose of foxglove that helps a failing heart is about half the dose that stops it (therapeutic index about 2)

To check against
ME-07, citing ME-02. WikEM digoxin toxicity entry. A toxicology textbook
The verdict
OPEN
03-50 Safety open 03 Bench 03.3 table and danger sign

Never purge in diarrhoea or fever, or anyone under 5 or over 70. Never make anyone vomit. Never give birthwort, comfrey by mouth or pennyroyal. Danger sign: vomiting, yellow eyes, dark or scant urine, a pulse under 60 or irregular, confusion

To check against
TR-13 Protocol 1 step 1. SY-10 rule 3 (H17). Nortier (2000) and SY-02 on birthwort and comfrey. TR-05 on pennyroyal. ME-07 stopping rule from Withering (1785)
The verdict
OPEN
03-6 Safety open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire. Ledger

In August 1977 a couple in Washington State drank tea from foxglove taken for comfrey, and the wife died. Known error not reproduced: SY-02 and PH-01 say the couple died

To check against
CDC (1977), Foxglove tea mistaken for comfrey, MMWR, 12 August 1977
The verdict
OPEN
03-7 Safety open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire

Untreated significant poisoning with the leaf kills 20 to 30 in 100

To check against
WikEM n.d., as ME-07 cites it. A toxicology textbook
The verdict
OPEN
03-1 open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire. Ledger. Numbers to Carry

Withering gave foxglove to 163 people between 1775 and 1784, and wrote every case down, failures included. Disputed: 1775 to 1785 (FO-03), about 160 (TR-01)

To check against
Withering W (1785), An Account of the Foxglove, case list. ME-07, FO-03, TR-01
The verdict
OPEN
03-10 open 03 Story, Like beside like. Ledger

A Danish series watched 91 people with duodenal ulcers and about a third had healed in two weeks. FO-03's 52 healed by six weeks, given as 75 in 100, does not match 91 and is not printed

To check against
Moerman DE (2000), Medical Anthropology Quarterly 14(1):51 to 72, and the Danish paper it reports
The verdict
OPEN
03-11 open 03 Story, Like beside like

Beecher in 1955 claimed dummy pills relieved about 35 in 100, and ten of his fifteen studies counted recoveries that would have come anyway

To check against
Beecher HK (1955), The powerful placebo, JAMA. Kienle GS, Kiene H (1997), Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 50(12):1311 to 1318
The verdict
OPEN
03-12 open 03 Story, Like beside like

Haygarth, January 1799, wooden copies of Perkins's tractors, four of five felt relief. Boston 2008, 262 adults with irritable bowel, relief 28, 44 and 62 in 100. 114 trials of dummy against none found no effect on cure or death

To check against
Haygarth J (1800), Of the imagination. Kaptchuk TJ et al. (2008), BMJ 336:999 to 1003. Hróbjartsson A, Gøtzsche PC (2001), NEJM 344
The verdict
OPEN
03-13 open 03 Story, What the old remedies found. Numbers to Carry

Fabricant and Farnsworth, Chicago 2001: 122 plant compounds from 94 species, 80 in 100 from a plant already used for something like the same purpose

To check against
Fabricant DS, Farnsworth NR (2001), Environmental Health Perspectives 109 Suppl 1:69 to 75
The verdict
OPEN
03-14 open 03 Story, What the old remedies found. Numbers to Carry

NCI 1960 to 1974, over 20,000 species, about 1 random species in 10 active (10.4%), folk plants 1.4 to 2.6 times as often, worm remedies 29 in 100, arrow and ordeal poisons 46. Sinai 83 against 42. Belize 4 of 31 against 0 of 32

To check against
Spjut RW (2005), SIDA 21(4):2205 to 2241. The Sinai and Belize papers as TR-01 cites them
The verdict
OPEN
03-15 open 03 Story, What the old remedies found

The largest modern screens, Vietnam and Laos in 2012 and Madagascar in 2017, found little advantage or none

To check against
Gyllenhaal C et al. (2012), Pharmaceutical Biology 50:30 to 41. Applequist WL et al. (2017), Economic Botany
The verdict
OPEN
03-16 open 03 Story, What the old remedies found. Ledger. Bench 03.1 rule 8. Numbers to Carry

Working odds: grade C about 1 chance in 3 of doing something useful at the traditional dose, grade D about 1 in 10. TR-01's synthesis, not a measurement

To check against
TR-01's derivation, checked against Spjut (2005), Saslis-Lagoudakis CH et al. (2012) PNAS 109(39):15835 to 15840, Willcox ML et al. (2011a) Malaria Journal
The verdict
OPEN
03-17 open 03 Story, What the old remedies found

Daisy family at or near the top and grasses at or near the bottom in four northern floras. Reading and Kew 2012 found medicinal plants of Nepal, New Zealand and the Cape on the same branches. A quarter to a third of living plant uses in southern Italy trace to Dioscorides and Galen. Wide use of antimalarial plants did not predict parasite clearance

To check against
Moerman DE et al. (1999). Saslis-Lagoudakis et al. (2012). Leonti M et al. (2015), Frontiers in Pharmacology. Willcox et al. (2011a)
The verdict
OPEN
03-18 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm

Ge Hong's handbook of about the year 340 told the healer to soak sweet wormwood and wring out the juice. Tu Youyou's team in Beijing followed it to artemisinin in 1971

To check against
Tu Y (2015), Nobel lecture. Lasker Foundation (2011). TR-01's translation note
The verdict
OPEN
03-19 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm. Ledger

Of 51 Cochrane reviews of Chinese herbal medicines, one reached a firm positive verdict. Disputed: 5 positive of 104 reviews of Chinese medicine, 70 herbal (SY-02, authors unconfirmed)

To check against
Hu J et al. (2011), PLoS One 6(12):e28696
The verdict
OPEN
03-2 open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire. Ledger

In one patient the pulse fell to 44 and then 35 beats a minute. Disputed: 40 and 35 (TR-01)

To check against
Withering W (1785), the case notes
The verdict
OPEN
03-22 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm

Colchicum luteum corm for gout: one uncontrolled series of 20 patients, relief in 94 in 100

To check against
The Unani series as SY-02 or TR-01 cites it
The verdict
OPEN
03-23 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm. Bench 03.1 grades line

Mali: Argemone mexicana decoction against the imported drug in about 300 people with uncomplicated malaria, 89 in 100 needed no second treatment against 95

To check against
Willcox ML et al. (2011b), Malaria Journal 10 Suppl 1:S8, and the Graz B trial it reports
The verdict
OPEN
03-24 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm

Hoodia tested and failed against hunger and raised blood pressure. Periwinkle led to two leukaemia drugs. Echinacea against colds tested in 24 trials, none showing prevention. Kava infusion calmed anxiety a little in seven small trials, extracts injured the liver

To check against
SY-02 and TR-01, and the trials and reviews they cite
The verdict
OPEN
03-25 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm

The Hippocratic case notes record about 25 deaths in 42 patients. TR-05's own count

To check against
Adams F (1849b), The Genuine Works of Hippocrates, Epidemics I and III
The verdict
OPEN
03-26 open 03 Story, Theory, remedy, harm

Pitjantjatjara Council won an order in 1976 stopping sale of an anthropologist's book in the Northern Territory. Tohunga Suppression Act 1907 to 1962

To check against
SY-04 and its sources (Foster v Mountford, 1976. The Tohunga Suppression Act 1907 and its repeal in 1962)
The verdict
OPEN
03-27 open 03 Story, The heroic cures

Philadelphia 1793: 4,000 to 5,000 of 50,000 died. Rush bled nineteen in twenty from 10 September, 10 or 12 ounces rising to eighty, claimed over 99 recoveries in 100. Libel verdict 14 December 1799, 5,000 dollars

To check against
TR-13 and its sources on Rush and Cobbett
The verdict
OPEN
03-28 open 03 Story, The heroic cures. Ledger

Washington's physicians took more than 80 ounces, about 2.4 litres, in some twelve hours. Disputed: 80 to 124 ounces (SY-03)

To check against
Morens DM (1999), Death of a president, NEJM 341:1845 to 1849. Vadakan, as SY-03 cites
The verdict
OPEN
03-29 open 03 Story, The heroic cures

Hammond struck calomel and tartar emetic from the supply table on 4 May 1863, was court-martialled on another charge and dismissed on 18 August 1864

To check against
Hammond WA, Circular No. 6, 4 May 1863, Buffalo Medical and Surgical Journal 1863, 2(11):354. Court-martial record
The verdict
OPEN
03-3 open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire

Withering's words "imprudent and unlimited use", at least one patient died, thirteen colleagues added 55 cases, later readers put benefit at 65 to 80 in 100 in heart dropsy, twelve patients were children

To check against
Withering W (1785). Wettrell G (2019), Hektoen International, on the children. Aronson JK (1985), as Wettrell cites it
The verdict
OPEN
03-30 open 03 Story, The heroic cures

Calomel teething powders gave pink disease to about 1 child in 500. The disease vanished when the powders were withdrawn in 1953 and 1954

To check against
Warkany J, Hubbard DM (1948). Curtis HA et al. (1987). Shandley K, Austin DW (2011), as TR-13 cites
The verdict
OPEN
03-31 open 03 Story, The heroic cures. Story, The turn. Numbers to Carry

Dietl, Vienna 1849, 380 pneumonia patients: 20.0 in 100 died bled, 20.7 given antimony, 7.4 given diet and rest. Modern pooling 19.9 against 12.8

To check against
Dietl J (1849), via the 1851 Western Lancet summary. The modern pooling as TR-13 cites it
The verdict
OPEN
03-32 open 03 Story, The heroic cures

Holmes, 30 May 1860, Massachusetts Medical Society: drugs sunk in the sea, better for mankind and worse for the fishes

To check against
Holmes OW (1860), Currents and counter-currents in medical science
The verdict
OPEN
03-33 open 03 Story, The two cases against

Reused syringes gave about 21 million people hepatitis B in 2000. Madhya Pradesh 2010: correct diagnosis in 12 visits in 100, harmful or needless treatment in 42. 84 parents in 100 mismeasured a dose by more than a fifth. Where There Is No Doctor up to date in 62 of 100 prevention sections, right diagnosis in fewer than 1 in 5

To check against
SY-01 and its sources: Das J et al. (2012), Health Affairs 31. Babu E, Eisenberg DTA (2010). The WHO injection safety estimate
The verdict
OPEN
03-34 open 03 Story, The two cases against

Alternative medicine alone for curable cancers: death at 2.5 times the rate, 54.7 in 100 alive at five years against 78.3

To check against
Johnson SB, Park HS, Gross CP, Yu JB (2018a), JNCI 110(1):121 to 124
The verdict
OPEN
03-35 open 03 Story, The two cases against

Of established hospital practices put to a fair test in one journal over a decade, about 40 in 100 were reversed

To check against
Prasad V et al. (2013), A decade of reversal, Mayo Clinic Proceedings 88(8):790 to 798
The verdict
OPEN
03-36 open 03 Story, The two cases against

Gadchiroli sepsis deaths 16.6 to 2.8 in 100. Tigray deaths under five down by 40 in 100. Nepal snakebite deaths 10.5 to 0.5 in 100. Southern Ethiopia bonesetter amputations 25 to 7. West Bengal trained 304 informal practitioners

To check against
Bang AT et al. (1999), Lancet 354:1955 to 1961. Kidane G, Morrow RH (2000), Lancet 356:550 to 555. Sharma SK et al. (2013), AJTMH. Das J et al. (2016), Science 354. The Ethiopian bonesetter study as SY-01 cites
The verdict
OPEN
03-37 open 03 Story, The turn to the present

EU law since 2004 registers a herbal product on 30 years of use, 15 in the Union. The US regulator found 776 supplements with hidden drugs between 2007 and 2016

To check against
Directive 2004/24/EC, EMA overview. Tucker J et al. (2018), JAMA Network Open
The verdict
OPEN
03-38 open 03 Bench 03.1, table

Grade definitions as printed: A randomised trials or systematic reviews, B consistent observational or clinical series, C convergent traditional use across unrelated cultures with plausible pharmacology, D one tradition, anecdote or theory, X shown ineffective or harmful

To check against
SY-02's grade wording and the instructions file. FO-03's wording for comparison
The verdict
OPEN
03-4 open 03 Story, The receipt from Shropshire

The Shropshire woman's name is lost. The name and portrait of Mother Hutton were made up in 1928 for a drug company's advertising

To check against
Krikler DM (1985), Withering and the foxglove: the making of a myth, British Heart Journal 54(3):256 to 257
The verdict
OPEN
03-43 open 03 Bench 03.2 steps 13 to 15

N-of-1 test: at least 3 pairs of periods, 1 to 2 weeks each, coin for order, keep only if it wins all 3

To check against
Guyatt G et al. (1986), NEJM 314:889 to 892. Guyatt GH et al. (1990). FO-03 checklist
The verdict
OPEN
03-8 open 03 Story, Like beside like

On 20 May 1747 aboard HMS Salisbury, James Lind gave twelve sailors with scurvy six different additions, two men to each. The orange and lemon pair recovered fastest, one fit for duty within six days

To check against
Lind J (1753), A Treatise of the Scurvy, via the James Lind Library. FO-03
The verdict
OPEN
03-9 open 03 Story, Like beside like

Pierre Louis, Paris 1835, 77 patients with pneumonia gave no sign that early bleeding helped

To check against
Morabia A (2004), Pierre-Charles-Alexandre Louis and the evaluation of bloodletting, James Lind Library. Chapter 2's row
The verdict
OPEN