THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 4: The Breathing Child

31 claims, 17 marked for safety

04-1 Safety open 04 The Breathing Child, Bench 04.1 table, Story, Numbers

Fast breathing is 60 or more under 2 months, 50 or more at 2 to 12 months, 40 or more at 1 to 5 years, counted for 1 full minute. SY-07 notes the library splits on 2 to 11 or 2 to 12 months

To check against
WHO 2014 IMCI chart booklet and WHO 2014 revised classification of childhood pneumonia (policy brief). SY-07 card
The verdict
OPEN
04-10 Safety open 04, Bench 04.4 See, Numbers

Newborn signs printed: a count of 60 or more, deep indrawing, 37.5 °C or more, below 35.5 °C (the full 7 belong to chapter 11)

To check against
Young Infants Clinical Signs Study Group 2008 Lancet. SY-07 card
The verdict
OPEN
04-11 Safety open 04, Bench 04.4 step 2

Under 7 days old, or under 2 kg: carry to the district

To check against
WHO 2015 guideline on possible serious bacterial infection when referral is not feasible. North et al 2024
The verdict
OPEN
04-12 Safety open 04, Bench 04.4 step 3 and table

Fast breathing alone at 7 to 59 days, feeding well: amoxicillin 50 mg/kg every 12 hours for 7 days. Bands by the chapter: 2 to under 3 kg 2.5 ml, 3 to under 4 kg 3.5 ml, 4 to under 6 kg 5 ml of 250 mg in 5 ml. Arithmetic: 125/2 = 62.5, 125/3 = 42, 175/3 = 58, 175/4 = 44, 250/4 = 62.5, 250/6 = 42 mg/kg. No age column

To check against
WHO 2015 PSBI guideline. AFRINEST group 2015 Lancet 385:1767 (fast breathing arm, 1,451 infants, 100 mg/kg a day)
The verdict
OPEN
04-13 Safety open 04, Bench 04.4 step 4, Story (The tablet in the house)

Where no district can be reached, the sick newborn gets the same oral course for 7 days. The chapter found no trial of oral treatment alone in possible serious bacterial infection, and every AFRINEST regimen for the sicker infants included injected gentamicin

To check against
AFRINEST 2015. WHO 2015 PSBI guideline. Any later trial of oral only regimens
The verdict
OPEN
04-14 Safety open 04, Bench 04.5

Fluid by mouth only to maintenance, breast milk included: 500 ml at 5 kg, 1,000 ml at 10 kg, 1,500 ml at 20 kg (100 ml/kg for the first 10 kg, 50 ml/kg for the next 10). Stop extra fluid at puffy eyelids or harder breathing

To check against
MSF Clinical Guidelines. WHO Pocket Book of Hospital Care for Children 2013 (check whether it advises restricting fluid in severe pneumonia)
The verdict
OPEN
04-15 Safety open 04, Bench 04.5 step 7, never line 4.4

Honey for cough over 12 months, 2.5 ml before sleep. Never under 12 months

To check against
Oduwole et al 2018 Cochrane. Paul et al 2007 (dose by age, from the chapter's own knowledge). Infant botulism guidance
The verdict
OPEN
04-16 Safety open 04, clock line, Story, Numbers

Clock line: pneumonia kills a child in 2 to 3 days from the first fast breath

To check against
IN-01 sources (reviews stating death can come within three days). WHO pneumonia fact sheet
The verdict
OPEN
04-17 Safety open 04, Bench 04.2 to 4.5

Never lines printed: nothing by mouth to a child who cannot swallow, no amoxicillin after a penicillin reaction, no honey or other feed under 6 months, no opium, morphine or codeine for a child's cough, no charcoal in a closed room

To check against
SY-10 never list (items 2, 6, 8, 9) and H6, H48. FDA Drug Safety Communication April 2017 on codeine in children
The verdict
OPEN
04-2 Safety open 04, Bench 04.1 step 4

Two counts more than 5 apart: count again and use the higher

To check against
SY-07 protocol tolerance line. Khan et al 2022 review of lay breath counting
The verdict
OPEN
04-3 Safety open 04, Bench 04.1 Do step 2

Indrawing without a danger sign is treated at home with oral amoxicillin for 5 days, counted daily, sent to the district if near. Note: EMPIC screened out hypoxaemic children with an oximeter, which the village lacks

To check against
WHO 2014 revised classification. Hazir et al 2008 (NO-SHOTS). EMPIC Study Group 2022
The verdict
OPEN
04-4 Safety open 04, Bench 04.2 See

Danger signs: cannot drink or breastfeed, vomits everything, fit, will not wake or limp, blue lips or tongue, grunting or head nodding, deep indrawing with a count of 70 or more, a falling count in a tiring child

To check against
WHO IMCI 2014 general danger signs. Usen et al 1999 BMJ 318:86. MA-07 red flags. SY-07 card
The verdict
OPEN
04-5 Safety open 04, Bench 04.3

Amoxicillin 40 mg/kg a dose every 12 hours, safe range 35 to 50 mg/kg (IN-03 gives 35 to 45, MA-07 35 to 50, the chapter prints the wider), above the range safer than below, ceiling in a child 1,000 mg a dose and 3,000 mg a day (ceiling inferred from the adult dose and MSF's 3 g a day maximum)

To check against
WHO 2014 policy brief. MSF Clinical Guidelines 2024. BNF for Children
The verdict
OPEN
04-6 Safety open 04, Bench 04.3 table, Honest Broker

Amoxicillin weight bands reworked by the chapter: 4 to under 7 kg 1 tablet of 250 mg or 5 ml of 250 mg in 5 ml, 7 to under 10 kg 1.5 or 7.5 ml, 10 to under 14 kg 2 or 10 ml, 14 to 19 kg 3 or 15 ml. Age if no scale 2 to 6 months, 6 to 12 months, 1 to 3 years, 3 to 5 years. Arithmetic in mg/kg: 250/4 = 62, 250/7 = 36, 375/7 = 54, 375/10 = 37.5, 500/10 = 50, 500/14 = 36, 750/14 = 54, 750/19 = 39. The library's chart (1, 2, 3 tablets at 4 to under 10, 10 to under 14, 14 to 19 kg) gives as little as 25 to 28 mg/kg and appears to be the older 25 mg/kg regimen

To check against
WHO 2014 IMCI chart booklet, amoxicillin dispersible 250 mg band table (the chapter's memory is 2, 3 and 4 tablets in the three WHO bands, unconfirmed). Age to weight mapping against WHO growth standards
The verdict
OPEN
04-7 Safety open 04, Bench 04.3 step 4

1 dispersible tablet of 250 mg in 5 ml of clean water gives 50 mg in each ml

To check against
Product leaflet for amoxicillin dispersible tablets. UNICEF supply guidance on amoxicillin DT
The verdict
OPEN
04-8 Safety open 04, Bench 04.3 step 5, Numbers

Days: 3 for fast breathing alone, 5 with indrawing

To check against
WHO 2014 policy brief (3 days in low HIV settings). ISCAP 2002
The verdict
OPEN
04-9 Safety open 04, Bench 04.3

Co-trimoxazole trimethoprim 4 mg/kg every 12 hours for 5 days, never under 6 weeks, ceiling 160 mg trimethoprim a dose. Bands: 4 to under 6 kg 2.5 ml of 40 mg with 200 mg in 5 ml or 0.25 adult tablet, 6 to under 10 kg 5 ml or 0.5, 10 to under 15 kg 7.5 ml or 0.75, 15 to 19 kg 10 ml or 1. Arithmetic: 20/4 = 5, 20/6 = 3.3, 40/6 = 6.7, 40/10 = 4, 60/10 = 6, 60/15 = 4, 80/15 = 5.3, 80/19 = 4.2 mg/kg. Bands are the chapter's own

To check against
Catchup Study Group 2002. WHO IMCI chart booklet co-trimoxazole table. BNF for Children
The verdict
OPEN
04-18 open 04, Story (The shelf and the winter), Numbers

Village of 300: about 45 children under five, about 13 pneumonias a year, about 20 tablets a course, about 300 tablets a year. Arithmetic: 45 × 0.28 = 12.6. 13 × 20 = 260

To check against
IN-01 and IN-03 arithmetic. Rudan et al 2008 incidence
The verdict
OPEN
04-19 open 04, Story (The shelf and the winter)

Breath count with amoxicillin ranks first of 20 skills: about 0.75 deaths averted a year in a tropical village, 8 to 13 training hours per life, worth about a fifth once amoxicillin is gone

To check against
SY-05 model and its inputs
The verdict
OPEN
04-20 open 04, Story (Gadchiroli), Honest Broker, Numbers

Gadchiroli 1988 onward: 58 villages against 44, village health workers, co-trimoxazole, 612 children treated, case fatality 0.8 against 13.5 per cent, drug cost US$0.025 per child a year. MA-07 gives 2,568 attacks at 0.9 per cent over 1988 to 1991

To check against
Bang AT, Bang RA, Tale O et al 1990 Lancet 336:201 to 206, full text. 1994 Bulletin of the WHO follow-up
The verdict
OPEN
04-21 open 04, Story (Gadchiroli), Numbers

Gadchiroli newborn care 1995 to 1998: 39 villages, sepsis treated from 1996 with oral co-trimoxazole and injected gentamicin, case fatality 16.6 to 2.8 per cent, neonatal deaths down 62 per cent, supervision every 2 weeks

To check against
Bang AT et al 1999 Lancet 354:1955 to 1961, full text. Journal of Perinatology 2005 supplement
The verdict
OPEN
04-22 open 04, Story (The drug and the count)

Shann, Hart and Thomas, Papua New Guinea 1984, 350 children, rate above 50 for antibiotics, indrawing for referral, mothers' report nearly as accurate. Cherian et al, Vellore 1988, 682 children, best under 3 years

To check against
Shann, Hart, Thomas 1984 Bulletin of the WHO 62:749 to 753. Cherian et al 1988 Lancet 2:125 to 128. Pio 2003
The verdict
OPEN
04-23 open 04, Story (The drug and the count)

Usen, Weber, Mulholland et al, the Gambia, published 1999: 1,072 children, 63 (5.9 per cent) hypoxaemic, died 12.7 against 2.6 per cent, sign accuracy (cyanosis about a quarter, flaring nearly all, grunting and nodding about half)

To check against
Usen et al 1999 BMJ 318:86 to 91, tables
The verdict
OPEN
04-24 open 04, Story (The drug and the count)

Evans and Gaisford, Dudley Road Hospital, Birmingham, March to June 1938, sulphapyridine: 8 of 100 died against 27 of 100

To check against
Evans GM, Gaisford WF 1938 Lancet
The verdict
OPEN
04-25 open 04, Story (What the lung does)

Osler 1892, crisis day 7 to 10, Montreal 20.4 per cent of 1,012, New Orleans 28 per cent of 3,969. Auenbrugger, Vienna 1761. Laennec, Necker Hospital, September 1816, published 1819

To check against
Osler, Principles and Practice of Medicine 1892. Laennec 1819
The verdict
OPEN
04-26 open 04, Story

Trials: Sazawal and Black 2003 (9 programmes, pneumonia deaths down about a third), Hazir et al 2008 (2,037, 7.5 against 8.6 per cent), EMPIC 2022 (4,013, 4.3 against 4.4), Jehan et al 2020 Karachi (4,002, 4.9 against 2.6, 44 treated per failure spared, 1 death each arm), AFRINEST 2015 (3,564), Theodoratou et al 2010 (35 per cent pooled, 70 per cent modelled)

To check against
The original papers
The verdict
OPEN
04-27 open 04, Story

Counting accuracy: Malawi 2009, 131 workers, 382 children, 30 per cent within 2 breaths, danger signs checked in 37 per cent (Gilroy 2013). Khan 2022, 16 studies, about 4 in 5 right as fast or not fast. Rees 2020, 15,029 children, sensitivity 0.92

To check against
Gilroy et al 2013. Khan et al 2022. Rees et al 2020
The verdict
OPEN
04-28 open 04, Story (The turn to the present)

Reimann 1961, 90 per cent of antimicrobial use unnecessary. Penicillin resistant pneumococci in the US 3.6 per cent in 1987 to 24 per cent in 1998. Codeine for children's cough forbidden by the FDA in 2017 after 24 deaths

To check against
Podolsky 2005. FDA Drug Safety Communication 2017
The verdict
OPEN
04-29 open 04, Story (Nursing the chest)

Mrs Winslow's Soothing Syrup, Bangor, Maine, from 1849. North Marston inquest 1847, eleven week old, Godfrey's Cordial. Camp Brooks, Brookline, autumn 1918, 13 tents, 351 sailors, 36 died

To check against
Berger 2019. North Marston History. Hobday and Cason 2009
The verdict
OPEN
04-30 open 04, Story (What the lung does)

England 1871 to 1880, chest diseases about a fifth (19.3 per cent) of deaths under five. 2015, about 920,000 child pneumonia deaths, about 1 in 6

To check against
Registrar General decennial reports via IN-01. Liu et al 2016 Lancet
The verdict
OPEN
04-31 open 04, Bench 04.6

Rationing rule suggested for the author: below 6 months of stock, danger signs, indrawing and babies under 12 months first (the author's decision)

To check against
SY-05 Protocol 4. MA-07 rationing note. Chapter 32
The verdict
OPEN