THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 5: The Dry Child

32 claims, 24 marked for safety

05-1 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Honest Broker's Spoon, Bench 05.2 step 3, Numbers to Carry

Disputed line (the second-round review of disputed lines, C9). The book prints half a level 5 ml teaspoon of fine salt, about 3 g, per litre, with WHO's "one level teaspoon" of about 3 g beside it. WHO's wording fits only a 2.5 ml spoon. Not settled by the chapter

To check against
WHO 2005a, The Treatment of Diarrhoea (recipe annex). UNICEF home ORS recipe. IFRC recipe (3.5 g). Hesperian, Where There Is No Doctor. SY-12 the second-round review of disputed lines
The verdict
OPEN
05-10 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.1

Any dehydration under 4 months or under 4 kg goes to the dispensary the same day

To check against
MSF Clinical Guidelines, Appendix 14 (admission under 4 months or 4 kg)
The verdict
OPEN
05-11 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.3 Plan A

Plan A after each loose stool: under 5 kg 50 ml, 5 to 9.9 kg 100 ml, 10 to 19.9 kg 200 ml, 20 kg and over 300 ml. If no scale, under 2 years 50 to 100 ml, 2 to 10 years 100 to 200 ml. Stop if the eyelids puff. Not better in 3 days: dispensary

To check against
MSF Appendix 14. WHO 2005a Plan A. WHO 2005b
The verdict
OPEN
05-12 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.3 Plan B, Numbers to Carry

Plan B: 75 ml/kg over 4 hours, and the WHO weight and age band table (200 to 400 ml up to 1,200 to 2,200 ml)

To check against
WHO 2005a Plan B table
The verdict
OPEN
05-13 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.3 Plan B, If it goes wrong

Child ceiling 20 ml/kg an hour. Under 2 years a 5 ml spoonful every 1 to 2 minutes, after vomiting wait 5 to 10 minutes then every 2 to 3 minutes. Reassess at 4 hours

To check against
WHO 2005a
The verdict
OPEN
05-14 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.3 zinc table, Numbers to Carry

Zinc 10 mg a day under 6 months, 20 mg a day from 6 months, for 10 to 14 days, once a day, after the first 4 hours. Grade A over 6 months, no benefit found under 6 months

To check against
WHO and UNICEF joint statement 2004. WHO 2005a. Lazzerini and Wanzira 2016 (Cochrane)
The verdict
OPEN
05-15 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.4 step 1, three branches

If a drip can be reached within 30 minutes, go, giving solution on the way

To check against
WHO 2005a, Plan C without a drip
The verdict
OPEN
05-16 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.4 steps 2 to 5 and table, Numbers to Carry

Without a drip: solution by mouth or nasogastric tube at 20 ml/kg an hour for 6 hours, ceiling 120 ml/kg, reassess hourly, transfer if no better at 3 hours. The weight-band hourly volumes are the chapter's arithmetic (20 ml × kg). Tube only in a child who coughs

To check against
WHO 2005a. MSF cholera guideline 5.3 (dissent on the tube in shock). Nager and Wang 2002. NU-02
The verdict
OPEN
05-17 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.4 step 6

Rectal route for a child who cannot cough: 9 g/L weighed saline, no sugar, left side. The library found no child rate or child study. Grade D

To check against
Rouhani et al. 2011 (no rectal studies). Bruera et al. 1998. Macy et al. 2023. NU-02
The verdict
OPEN
05-18 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.4 step 7

Fluid under the skin: maintenance only, never for shock. Sterile saline, or 9 g weighed into 1 litre, boiled 15 minutes, used within 24 hours. Never sugar water. Grade C in children

To check against
Gill et al. 2001. Broadhurst et al. 2020. NU-02. Whether home-boiled saline is acceptable under the skin given the pyrogen record (Li et al. 2011)
The verdict
OPEN
05-19 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.4 step 7

Disputed rate for fluid under a child's skin: 20 ml/kg over about 1 hour (StatPearls) against the adult 1 ml a minute a site. Both printed, not settled

To check against
StatPearls, Hypodermoclysis. Gill et al. 2001. William Osler Health Centre protocol. SY-12 open question
The verdict
OPEN
05-2 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Honest Broker's Spoon

A level 5 ml teaspoon of fine salt holds about 5.9 g, a 7.3 ml spoon about 8.6 g (draft's arithmetic), so "one level teaspoon" can give twice to nearly three times the 3 g intended. Household teaspoons 2.5 to 7.3 ml, Sri Lankan homes 2.9 to 7.8 ml

To check against
USDA FoodData Central, table salt sodium per teaspoon (2,325 mg). ME-02 source for the 2.5 to 7.3 ml range. Jayasinghe et al. 2026
The verdict
OPEN
05-20 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.4 never line

Never put anything home-made into a vein or a bone

To check against
NU-02. Seibert 1923. Li, Wilbur and Mintz 2011 (endotoxin kinetics)
The verdict
OPEN
05-21 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.5 never line

Never make a child vomit, never give salt water

To check against
SY-10 never 3 (H17). ME-08 salt emesis review (7 of 14 died). Türk 2005
The verdict
OPEN
05-22 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.5 never line, The turn to the present

Never give opium, codeine, loperamide or any anti-diarrhoeal drug to a child with diarrhoea. Loperamide: serious harm in 8 of 927 children, all under 3

To check against
WHO 2005a. Li et al. 2007 (PLoS Medicine meta-analysis). SY-10 never 6 (H6)
The verdict
OPEN
05-23 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.5 never line

Never give honey under 12 months

To check against
SY-10 never 2 (H13). Infant botulism guidance (CDC)
The verdict
OPEN
05-24 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.5, Honest Broker's Spoon

Guava leaf and berberine: fewer stools in adults, grade B, never a cure, never instead of ORS. Neither under 12 years. Berberine X in infants and pregnancy. Charcoal X, kaolin no effect, antiemetics D

To check against
SY-12 C18. SY-06. IN-11. PH-05. Rabbani et al. 1987. Khin-Maung-U et al. 1985. Lozoya et al. 2002
The verdict
OPEN
05-3 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Honest Broker's Spoon, Numbers to Carry

7 g of salt in a litre gives about 120 mmol/L sodium, BRAC's danger line

To check against
Arithmetic (7 g ÷ 58.44 g/mol). Chowdhury 1986, BRAC grading (30 to 99 safe, 120 or more dangerous)
The verdict
OPEN
05-4 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.2 step 2

Never make the solution in less than 1 litre of water

To check against
SY-10 dose table (H2). WHO 2005a. Quereshi et al. 2010 (Kashmir packet in 200 ml)
The verdict
OPEN
05-5 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.2 step 6

Throw made-up solution away after 24 hours

To check against
Sett and Mitra 1994. WHO 2005a
The verdict
OPEN
05-6 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.2 cereal solution

Cereal solution: 50 to 80 g rice flour per litre, boiled 5 to 7 minutes, half a level 5 ml teaspoon of salt, sours within hours in heat

To check against
WHO 2005a (rice-based ORS, boiling time footnote). Hesperian. Gore et al. 1992
The verdict
OPEN
05-7 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.1 table and danger signs

Skin pinch back in more than 2 seconds means severe dehydration. 2 or more of 4 signs decide the class. Deficits under 5, 5 to 10, over 10 per cent

To check against
WHO 2005a assessment table. Steiner et al. 2004 (JAMA)
The verdict
OPEN
05-8 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.1 danger signs

Capillary refill over 3 seconds in a warm room is a danger sign. The 5 second press is the chapter's own

To check against
SY-07 source. WHO IMCI chart booklet. Steiner et al. 2004
The verdict
OPEN
05-9 Safety open 05 The Dry Child, Bench 05.1 danger signs

No wet nappy for 6 hours is a danger sign

To check against
SY-10 H31 source. WHO IMCI chart booklet
The verdict
OPEN
05-25 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, The water that leaves

Robert Allan Phillips, Cairo, September 1947: 40 treated by vein, 3 died, against about half untreated. Lasker citation 1967: over 60 per cent to under 1 per cent

To check against
Reynolds 2023. Lasker Foundation 1967 citation
The verdict
OPEN
05-26 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, A sugar that carries salt

Hemendra Nath Chatterjee, Calcutta, Lancet 1953: 186 patients treated by mouth, all survived, report overlooked. Phillips, Manila, September 1962: 5 of 30 died on a solution far too concentrated

To check against
Chatterjee 1953, Lancet 265(6795):1063. Reynolds 2023. Bhattacharya 1994 gives a different account of 1962 to 1964
The verdict
OPEN
05-27 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, A sugar that carries salt

Nalin and Cash, Dhaka, Lancet 17 August 1968: 51 adults, need for IV fluid down about 80 per cent. Cash, Matlab 1970: 350 patients, down 70 per cent

To check against
Nalin et al. 1968, Lancet. Cash et al. 1970a
The verdict
OPEN
05-28 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, A sugar that carries salt

Dhaka floods 2009: 42,000 patients in 9 weeks at the cholera hospital, no deaths from dehydration

To check against
HY-03 source (icddr,b report). Check the year
The verdict
OPEN
05-29 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, Bongaon 1971

Dilip Mahalanabis, Bongaon, about 8 weeks in July and August 1971: 22 g glucose, 3.5 g salt, 2.5 g bicarbonate per litre. 3,703 patients, 3.6 per cent died, 1 per cent of 1,190 in the demonstration unit, IV-only camps 20 to 30 per cent, half the deaths before rehydration began, 11 paise a litre

To check against
Mahalanabis et al. 1973. Fontaine and Newton 2001 (WHO Bulletin reprint). Hektoen International 2023. Reynolds 2023
The verdict
OPEN
05-30 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, The half seer, Bench 05.5

BRAC from July 1980: more than 12 million mothers, 7 points, 1 in 10 revisited at about a month, pay 4, 2, 1, 0 taka by grade, recipe a three-finger pinch and a fistful of gur in half a seer (about 467 ml), 87 per cent safe, dangerous solutions rising to 14.7, 18.2 and 25.6 per cent, by 1993 over 70 per cent able to make it and use in about 60 per cent of episodes

To check against
Chowdhury 1986. Chowdhury et al. 1997. Abed 1983 account via OR-09
The verdict
OPEN
05-31 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, The half seer

Olikoye Ransome-Kuti and Adepeju Bamisaiye, Lagos 1978: 34 per cent of 217 women mixed correctly, most errors too salty, nearly half of those four times too strong, three sixteen times

To check against
Ransome-Kuti and Bamisaiye 1978
The verdict
OPEN
05-32 open 05 The Dry Child, Story, The half seer

Official recipes in 16 African countries gave 9 to 116 mmol/L sodium. Natal 2001: 47 of 100 home solutions dangerous, 63.8 against 19.3 per cent correct with the double-ended spoon

To check against
Lukmanji 1988. Natal study 2001. Levine et al. 1980
The verdict
OPEN