THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 451 · HEALING · Healing traditions and systems

Bloodletting purging and the heroic error

Its printed title: TR-13 Humours, bloodletting, purging and the therapies that killed: the cautionary history

This is the counterweight to the rest of the traditions domain. The tradition examined here is the book's own ancestor, and the finding is that it killed for two thousand years while every intelligent person involved believed it was saving lives. It builds on FO-05, cited as (THRIVING library, FO-05) rather than re-argued.

Open the PDF 18 pages · 116 KB

Number
451
Letter code
TR-13
Book
HEALING after the FALL
Shelf
Healing traditions and systems
File
451 TR-13 Bloodletting purging and the heroic error.pdf
Pages
18
Works cited
1

The rows that check it

  • 16 open
  • 4 marked for safety
  • 03-48 open Safety Never bleed anyone for fever, pneumonia or any illness of the whole body
  • 03-49 open Safety Never give calomel or tartar emetic. Bury salvaged stock at least 50 m from a well and 1 m deep
  • 03-50 open Safety Never purge in diarrhoea or fever, or anyone under 5 or over 70. Never make anyone vomit. Never give birthwort, comfrey by mouth or pennyroyal. Danger sign: vomiting, yellow eyes, …
  • 34-74 open Safety Bury calomel, tartar emetic and cantharides 50 m from any well, 1 m deep
  • 03-27 open Philadelphia 1793: 4,000 to 5,000 of 50,000 died. Rush bled nineteen in twenty from 10 September, 10 or 12 ounces rising to eighty, claimed over 99 recoveries in 100. Libel …
  • 03-30 open Calomel teething powders gave pink disease to about 1 child in 500. The disease vanished when the powders were withdrawn in 1953 and 1954
  • 03-31 open Dietl, Vienna 1849, 380 pneumonia patients: 20.0 in 100 died bled, 20.7 given antimony, 7.4 given diet and rest. Modern pooling 19.9 against 12.8
  • 34-1 open Washington rode out in cold rain, snow and hail on 13 December 1799, woke unable to breathe at about 2 a.m., and by 6 a.m. had a high fever and a raw throat
  • 34-2 open The hour by hour timeline: Rawlins 12 to 14 oz at 7.30, Craik's cantharides at 9, 18 oz at 9.30, a third at 11, enema and gargle at noon, 32 oz in the afternoon over Dick's …
  • 34-29 open Hammond's Circular No. 6, 4 May 1863. Sent away within months, dismissed August 1864, calomel restored
  • 34-3 open More than 80 oz, about 2.4 litres, in about 12 hours, about two fifths of his blood
  • 34-30 open Pink disease in about 1 exposed baby in 500, powders withdrawn in Britain 1953 to 1954
  • 34-35 open Saper 2008, online: 193 analysed, 20.7 in 100 with metals
  • 34-4 open Morens 1999 read epiglottitis and held the bleeding probably did not kill a man of his size
  • 34-42 open FO-05 puts the first sore throat on 12 December
  • 34-5 open Rush 1793: 4,000 to 5,000 of 50,000 died, up to 100 patients a day, calomel and jalap with heavy repeated bleeding, Doctor Sangrado, 5,000 dollars on 14 December 1799

Its works cited 1

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 1 other web page
Show all 1
  1. James Lind Library, “Pierre-Charles-Alexandre Louis and the evaluation of bloodletting” (Morabia A, 2004) jameslindlibrary.org/articles/pierre-charles-a…