The examination in a fixed order: wash, daylight, undress a child, 30 seconds of looking from the door, the danger questions, breaths, pulse, warmth of hands and feet, refill, temperature, colour, arm strip and feet, neck and the rest as needed, then written with red flags circled
The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter
Chapter 2: The Count
60 claims, 36 marked for safety
- 60 open
- 36 marked for safety
Never sweep or vacuum spilt mercury. Keep children out, lift beads with card and tape, air the room 24 hours
- To check against
- EPA 2017 mercury spill guidance (via OR-04)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Thermometer check: reference glass and up to 5 others in water near 38 °C for 3 minutes. Off by over 0.2 °C: out of use. Every 3 months and after a fall
- To check against
- OR-04 Protocol 2 (tolerance and method marked as inference). A clinical thermometry standard for the tolerance
- The verdict
- OPEN
Resting pulse: baby 100 to 140, child 80 to 100, adult 60 to 80. Felt with 2 or 3 fingers, not the thumb
- To check against
- Werner and others 2020. Fleming and others 2011, Lancet (centiles by age)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Adult pulse too fast: over 120 (SY-07 card), over 100 after a birth or with bleeding. The library gave no single too fast line for a baby or child
Disputed line. Fever raises a child's pulse about 10 a minute for each 1 °C (FO-07), against 20 (Werner). Teach 10. Printed both ways
- To check against
- Davies and Maconochie 2009 (21,033 children). Werner and others 2020
- The verdict
- OPEN
Too slow: no general line in the library. Under 60 stops a heart remedy
A wrist pulse does not prove a safe pressure (the old rule is grade X). Standing test referred to chapter 21
- To check against
- Deakin and Low 2000, BMJ 321:673. McGee, Abernethy and Simel 1999
- The verdict
- OPEN
Count breaths 60 seconds, never 30 doubled. 2 people count. More than 5 apart: count again, keep the higher
Adult breathing at rest 12 to 20. Red flag: 30 or more, or 22 or more with new confusion. Child lines 60, 50, 40 referred to 04.1
- To check against
- Werner and others 2020. Seymour and others 2016 (qSOFA). SY-07 section 1.4
- The verdict
- OPEN
Refill: press a nail 5 seconds until pale, breastbone if hands are cold. Over 2 seconds watch, over 3 seconds in a warm room a red flag. Cold and age slow it
- To check against
- Schriger and Baraff 1988. Clifton and others 2012. WHO ETAT. FO-07 marks the 5 second press (to be checked)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Act at once on any 1 red flag. Commonest: cannot drink, vomits everything, a fit, will not wake, fast breathing, refill over 3 seconds with cold hands
Rash with fever that is still seen through a pressed glass: act now
- To check against
- Thompson and others 2006, Lancet 367:397. NICE meningitis guidance. FO-02 red flag 4
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pressure: seated 5 minutes, bare arm at heart level, bag most of the way round, pump to 30 mmHg past the pulse, let down about 2 mmHg a second, pulse returns at the upper pressure and reads a little low, 2 readings a minute apart
Pressure lines: pregnant 140/90 or more to chapters 8 and 10. Upper pressure 100 or less with fast breathing or new confusion to chapter 21
Never measure a dose with a kitchen spoon (oral syringe or weighed amount instead). Never give a strong drug in drops (ml from a syringe instead)
Scale: set to 0 before each child. Each day 7 litres of water in a tied bag reads 7 kg. Not 7 kg: turn the screw, still wrong out of use. Read at eye level to 100 g. Range 0 to 25 kg
- To check against
- MSF Unicat, Salter type hanging scale (daily check with a test weight of at least 7 kg). OR-04 (7 litres is physics, 1 litre about 1 kg)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Weight comes first. Age is only if no scale, and worse: guesses put about half of children within 10%
Paracetamol 15 mg/kg every 4 to 6 hours, at most 4 doses and 60 mg/kg in 24 hours, adult at most 1 g a dose and 4 g a day. Bands 8 to under 12 kg 120 mg 5 ml, 12 to under 17 kg 180 mg 7.5 ml, 17 to under 25 kg 250 mg 10 ml, syrup 120 mg in 5 ml. Rows copied from 06.2 and must match it
- To check against
- SY-10 Numbers to carry 2. WHO model formulary for children. A national children's formulary. Chapter 06.2
- The verdict
- OPEN
Arithmetic: 15 × 13 = 195 mg, band gives 180 mg, 7.5 ml of 120 mg in 5 ml (24 mg/ml). Note: 10 ml of 120 mg in 5 ml holds 240 mg, not 250 mg. The same mismatch stands in 06.2
- To check against
- Arithmetic. Chapter 06.2 table
- The verdict
- OPEN
Work every dose twice, with two people. A moved decimal point gives ten times the dose
Instrument checks: arm strip against a master strip each month (the author's decision), thermometer every 3 months and after a fall, scale each day, cuff dial every 3 months at 100 and 150 mmHg, out of use if out by more than 4 mmHg
Thumb on both feet for 3 seconds, a pit is swelling
- To check against
- WHO 2014, IMCI chart booklet (bilateral pitting oedema). FO-07 Protocol 1 step 12 marks the 3 seconds (to be checked)
- The verdict
- OPEN
A weight on a string about 25 cm long swings there and back once a second
- To check against
- Physics: period 2π√(L/g) = 2π√(0.25/9.81) ≈ 1.00 s. FO-07
- The verdict
- OPEN
Water U-tube: 1 mmHg holds up 13.6 mm of water, so 100 mmHg is 1.36 m and 150 mmHg 2.04 m between the 2 sides
- To check against
- Arithmetic from the density of mercury (about 13.6 g/ml). OR-04 section 4
- The verdict
- OPEN
Natural course, 9 in 10 better by: croup 2 days, sore throat 2 to 7, earache 7 to 8 (6 in 10 better in 24 hours), common cold 15, bronchiolitis 21, cough 25. Back pain mostly better by 6 weeks. Fever with no red flag past 3 days: find the cause
- To check against
- Thompson and others 2013, BMJ 347:f7027. Cochrane review of antibiotics for acute otitis media. Menezes Costa and others 2012, CMAJ. Chapter 06 (3 days)
- The verdict
- OPEN
No antibiotic for a cold, most earaches, most sore throats, back pain
- To check against
- FO-02 Protocol 1. Cochrane reviews (otitis, sore throat, common cold)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Do not wait with: a baby under 2 months with fever or fast breathing, a stiff neck, a rash that stays under the glass, bleeding after a birth, a child who cannot drink, pain low on the right past 36 hours
- To check against
- FO-02 section 5 and Protocol 4. Bickell and others 2006 (rupture 2% or less in 36 hours, then about 5% each 12 hours). WHO 2014
- The verdict
- OPEN
Help too late: count breaths, pulse and refill every 15 minutes while waiting, and write each
- To check against
- SY-07 Protocol 2 step 5
- The verdict
- OPEN
Anyone with a red flag: counts at least 4 times a day on the same page
Fever by hand: back of 1 hand on the forehead, the other on a healthy person's. Not hotter and well: fever unlikely
- To check against
- Whybrew, Murray and Morley 1998, BMJ 317:321. Li and others 2017. Werner and others 2020, Where There Is No Doctor
- The verdict
- OPEN
Shake the glass below 35 °C. Armpit under 5 years and in anyone confused or fitting, otherwise under the tongue
- To check against
- OR-04 Protocol 3 (armpit rule marked (to be checked) there). Werner and others 2020
- The verdict
- OPEN
Leave a glass thermometer 3 to 4 minutes
Disputed line. Under 2 months: fever 37.5 °C or more, cold below 35.5 °C (SY-07, FO-07), against below 36 °C for cold (Werner, NICE). Printed both ways, not settled
- To check against
- Young Infants Clinical Signs Study Group 2008, Lancet 371:135. Werner and others 2020. NICE neonatal infection guidance. SY-07 section 1.4
- The verdict
- OPEN
Disputed line. Older child and adult: fever 37.8 °C or more in the armpit (OR-04), against above 37.7 °C by mouth (FO-07). Printed both ways, not settled
- To check against
- Whybrew and others 1998, BMJ 317:321. Mackowiak, Wasserman and Levine 1992, JAMA 268:1578
- The verdict
- OPEN
Over 65, a normal temperature rules nothing out. New confusion outweighs it
- To check against
- Hyernard and others 2019 (abstract). Laborde and others (via OR-04)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Grades printed: danger signs A, refill B, the hand B, checked glass B, pulse rate B, organ map D, wrist pulse means safe pressure X, pressure by feel C, checked cuff B, checked spring scale B, steelyard C, Pinard horn B, arm strip B
The Hippocratic saying that those seized by tetanus die within four days, or recover if they pass them (paraphrase)
- To check against
- Hippocrates, Aphorisms, as quoted in Osler 1892, The Principles and Practice of Medicine (via FO-02)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Herophilus timed the pulse against a water clock (said to). Galen described 27 qualities of the beat in some 18 books. Sanctorius built a pendulum to count it
- To check against
- FO-07 section 1.3. A history of the pulse (primary or standard secondary)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pulse diagnosis agrees poorly: one study of 15 doctors found agreement from below chance to moderate (weighted kappa below 0 to 0.56)
- To check against
- FO-07 section 1.3 (secondary, references not confirmed). UTS thesis 2012
- The verdict
- OPEN
Sir John Floyer of Lichfield published The Physician's Pulse-Watch in 1707, with a watch made to carry a seconds hand (by Samuel Watson), kept Galenic theory and drew on Chinese pulse books
- To check against
- Floyer history 2016, PMC5195217 (via FO-07). Floyer 1707
- The verdict
- OPEN
In 20 shocked patients measured directly, 10 of 12 with all pulses present had an upper pressure below 80
- To check against
- Deakin and Low 2000, BMJ 321:673
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pierre Louis, Paris, published 1835: 77 previously healthy pneumonia patients, 41 bled on days 1 to 4 (about 44% died), 36 bled later (about 25% died), early group nearly twice as many over 50, concluded bleeding did less than believed. Reanalysis 2004: early bled did worse
- To check against
- Louis 1835, Recherches sur les effets de la saignée. Morabia 2004
- The verdict
- OPEN
Josef Dietl, Vienna, 1849: 380 pneumonias. 85 bled, 17 died (20.0%). 106 tartar emetic, 22 died (20.8%). 189 diet and rest, 14 died (7.4%). Not randomised. FO-05 spells the name Joseph, the chapter's plan Josef
- To check against
- Dietl 1849, Der Aderlass in der Lungenentzündung. Obloza and Goddard (via FO-05, summary only)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Carl Wunderlich, Leipzig, 1868: about a million readings from about 25,000 people, normal set at 37, 38 called probably febrile
- To check against
- Wunderlich 1868, Das Verhalten der Eigenwärme in Krankheiten. OR-04 marks the figures secondary
- The verdict
- OPEN
1992 study of 148 healthy adults: mean oral 36.8, upper limit 37.7 (37.2 early morning), daily swing about 0.5. Wunderlich's thermometer read high
- To check against
- Mackowiak, Wasserman and Levine 1992, JAMA 268:1578
- The verdict
- OPEN
Chikankata Hospital, Zambia, published 1998: 1,090 children, mothers felt 862, axillary glass 3 minutes, 37.8 or more as fever, mothers found 94%, "not hot" right 95% of the time
- To check against
- Whybrew, Murray and Morley 1998, BMJ 317:321 (OR-04 notes it is the BMJ, not the Lancet)
- The verdict
- OPEN
In people aged 75 and over with bacteraemia, a fifth (21.2% of 151) had none of the usual signs, linked to death
- To check against
- Hyernard and others 2019 (abstract, via OR-04)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Riva-Rocci described the cuff in a Turin journal in 1896 (Gazzetta Medica di Torino), reading where the wrist pulse vanished. An American surgeon (Cushing) sketched it in Pavia in 1901. The cuff widened. A Russian surgeon (Korotkoff) described the sounds in 1905
- To check against
- Riva-Rocci 1896. Bause, Cushing and Riva-Rocci (Wood Library-Museum). Korotkoff 1905. The bicycle tube story is not printed
- The verdict
- OPEN
In 200 surgical patients in India, a palpated reading came within 2 of the auscultated one in about half (51%)
- To check against
- Sahu and Bhaskaran 2010 (abstract)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Aneroid dials out by more than 4 mmHg: about 30% in an old British survey (mercury under 2%), 56.2% of 162 in São Paulo, about 54% in Iran
- To check against
- BMJ 1982 survey. Arquivos Brasileiros de Cardiologia (São Paulo). Sabzevar study (all via OR-04, search summaries)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Pinard horn is named for Adolphe Pinard (1890s, date unconfirmed). Harare 1994, 1,255 women in labour: Doppler found more abnormal rates, and across the trials led to more caesareans without healthier babies. Priced about 1 dollar
- To check against
- Mahomed and others 1994, BMJ. Cochrane review of intermittent auscultation. WHO 2018 intrapartum guideline. OR-04 section 2
- The verdict
- OPEN
2013 review: days by which 90% of children recovered (croup 2, sore throat 2 to 7, earache 7 to 8, cold 15, bronchiolitis 21, cough 25). Parents expected shorter
- To check against
- Thompson and others 2013, BMJ 347:f7027
- The verdict
- OPEN
Earache untreated: about 60% better within a day, 82% settled. Back pain 52 of 100 to 23 at 6 weeks and 12 at 6 months. Sprain better within 2 weeks, some ache at a year. Antipyretics did not change sepsis deaths (2017). Dummy pills change little
- To check against
- Cochrane otitis review (Venekamp). Menezes Costa 2012. Drewry 2017 (RR 0.93). Hróbjartsson and Gøtzsche 2010 (via FO-02)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pneumonia in hospital before antibiotics killed 20 to 40%, turning between days 5 and 9. Appendix rupture risk 2% or less in 36 hours, then about 5% each 12 hours. Diphtheria and tetanus decided in 2 to 4 days
- To check against
- Osler 1892. Bickell and others 2006. FO-02 Numbers to carry
- The verdict
- OPEN
Tanzania, published 2012: 466 febrile children, 34 died. Inability to drink odds ratio 8.9, refill over 3 seconds 9.0. Clinical signs predicted death better than laboratory results
- To check against
- Clifton and others 2012, Archives of Disease in Childhood 97:889
- The verdict
- OPEN
Trial among African children, 2011: fluid boluses raised deaths from 7.3% to 10.5%
- To check against
- Maitland and others 2011, FEAST, New England Journal of Medicine 364:2483
- The verdict
- OPEN
A village of 300 can expect five to nine deaths a year
Breath count with danger signs and a few tablets ranks first of twenty for lives saved per training hour, about 8 to 20 hours per life
Mothers in Niger measured arms as well as health workers after a short lesson. Lay breath counting agrees only moderately at first (kappa 0.41 to 0.49)