THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 1: The Clean Hand

60 claims, 30 marked for safety

01-1 Safety open 01, Honest Broker's Bar, Bench 01.5, Numbers to Carry

Disputed line (C24). Boil instruments 20 minutes from a full boil, lid on, printed with 10 minutes beside it. WO-12 gives 20, WO-03 and FO-11 give at least 10. SY-12 settles it for WO-12. Boiling disinfects and does not sterilise

To check against
Hesperian, Where There Is No Doctor. Conant and Fadem. Doh 2007. WHO 2016 Decontamination and Reprocessing of Medical Devices. SY-12 C24
The verdict
OPEN
01-10 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Bar

Caustic soda bar: 130 g of sodium hydroxide per kg of tallow or lard. FEASTING ch. 9 gives 140 g with no margin. Cross book, (the author's decision)

To check against
Codex or standard saponification values for tallow (135 to 144 g per kg) and lard. HY-05 arithmetic. FEASTING ch. 9
The verdict
OPEN
01-11 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Bar

Potash lye: 185 g pure potassium hydroxide per kg of fat, about 205 g of 90% grade. FEASTING ch. 17's "200 g potash" means pure KOH, and potash as carbonate is about a fifth short. Cross book, (the author's decision)

To check against
Saponification tables for KOH. FEASTING row B19. HY-05 arithmetic (1.23 g carbonate per 1 g KOH)
The verdict
OPEN
01-12 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3

Caustic into 300 to 350 ml of cold water, never water onto caustic. Cool to about 40 °C. Fat at 40 to 45 °C. Stir to trace, mould, cut at 1 to 2 days, cure 4 weeks

To check against
FEASTING ch. 17 and Bench. HY-05 cold process section. A standard soap making safety source
The verdict
OPEN
01-13 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3

Other fats: olive oil 125 to 130 g, coconut 168 g of sodium hydroxide per kg

To check against
Standard saponification value tables as HY-05 gives them
The verdict
OPEN
01-14 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, If it goes wrong

Soap test: pH paper 9 to 10 is sound, above 11 suggests free lye, laundry only

To check against
HY-05 soap testing section and its sources
The verdict
OPEN
01-15 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, Story

Egg test: half the egg above the surface is first strength (Geoffroy 1742). FEASTING's household mark is a coin sized patch. Grade C, a go or no go test. Feather test shows causticity, not strength, grade D

To check against
Geoffroy 1742, Philosophical Transactions. FEASTING ch. 17. HY-05 grade table
The verdict
OPEN
01-16 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, Honest Broker's Bar

Never taste lye or soap to test it. FEASTING's tongue test (row T10) to be removed. Cross book, (the author's decision)

To check against
FEASTING VERIFICATIONS row T10. HY-05
The verdict
OPEN
01-17 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, Story

Lye splash: brush off dry lime or ash, then water only. Skin 15 to 20 minutes, eye 15 to 30 minutes, lids held open. Never vinegar or any acid. Alkali burns can deepen over 48 to 72 hours. FEASTING row T1 keeps vinegar after water. Cross book, (the author's decision)

To check against
Gnaneswaran and others 2015. FEASTING VERIFICATIONS row T1. A current chemical eye injury guideline
The verdict
OPEN
01-18 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, Story

Swallowed caustic: nothing by mouth, never make them vomit, no acid, carry sitting up. Narrowing may show weeks later

To check against
SY-10 H12 and never list item 3. Ekpe and Ette 2012. ME-14
The verdict
OPEN
01-19 Safety open 01, Bench 01.3, 01.6, Story

Lye never in a drink bottle, cup or jug, and never in aluminium. A marked vessel that is not a bottle, high or locked. One soap house, named makers

To check against
SY-10 H12 and never list item 12. HY-05 storage section
The verdict
OPEN
01-2 Safety open 01, Honest Broker's Bar, Bench 01.2, Numbers to Carry

Disputed line. Handwash 60 seconds before a birth, a wound or an injection, to the elbow, nails brushed. At home at least 20. WHO health care 40 to 60, Karachi 45, HY-01 home 20 to 40

To check against
WHO Guidelines on Hand Hygiene in Health Care 2009. WHO and UNICEF 2025. Luby and others 2004
The verdict
OPEN
01-20 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4, 01.6, Numbers to Carry

Chlorine strengths and uses: 0.05% hands in outbreaks and births and linen soak up to 15 minutes, 0.2% floors and surfaces 15 minutes, 0.5% spills and objects 10 to 15 minutes, 1% stock for water only

To check against
CDC and MSF chlorine guidance. Lantagne as HY-05 gives it
The verdict
OPEN
01-21 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4

From 5% bleach, per litre: 10 ml for 0.05%, 40 ml for 0.2%, 100 ml for 0.5%, 200 ml for 1%. This draft's arithmetic from the rule parts of water = (bleach % ÷ % wanted) minus 1

To check against
HY-05 dilution rule. CDC chlorine dilution tables
The verdict
OPEN
01-22 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4

HTH (65 to 70% available chlorine): 15 g per 20 litres for 0.05%, 60 g per 20 litres for 0.2%. Library gives no HTH figure for 0.5% or 1%

To check against
MSF and CDC guidance as HY-05 gives it
The verdict
OPEN
01-23 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4

Salvaged bleach: assume half its label and double the bleach. Labels off by about 35% on average

To check against
Lantagne 2009, American Journal of Public Health 99(11)
The verdict
OPEN
01-24 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4

Never mix chlorine with vinegar, acid, urine or ammonia. Bleach into water, in plastic, fresh every day

To check against
Rutala, Weber and HICPAC 2008. IN-07
The verdict
OPEN
01-25 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4

Blood spill: wipe up the bulk, then 0.5% for 10 minutes. If it cannot be wiped first, 1% for 3 minutes, then 0.5%

To check against
IN-07 Protocol 9 and its sources (CDC 2008, WHO)
The verdict
OPEN
01-26 Safety open 01, Bench 01.6

Sick linen: boil with soap 10 minutes, or soak in 0.05% up to 15 minutes, then wash. 3 days of sun for what cannot be boiled, partial only. Laundry standard 65 °C for 10 minutes or 71 °C for 3

To check against
HSE laundry guidance. MSF laundry rule. Amichai 2014
The verdict
OPEN
01-27 Safety open 01, Bench 01.4, Numbers to Carry

Water: 4 ml of 1% stock per 20 litres (shared number, chapter 13)

To check against
HY-02 and its sources. Chapter 13 rows
The verdict
OPEN
01-28 Safety open 01, Bench 01.2

WHO handrub per litre: 833 ml of 96% ethanol, 42 ml of 3% hydrogen peroxide, 14.5 ml of 98% glycerol, boiled water to 1 litre, stand 72 hours

To check against
WHO Guide to Local Production: WHO recommended handrub formulations (2010)
The verdict
OPEN
01-29 Safety open 01, Bench 01.2

Never methanol or the still's first runnings. Never drink the rub. Locked, labelled NOT TO DRINK, kept from flame (flash point about 17.5 °C). Methanol sanitiser deaths, Arizona 2020

To check against
WHO 2010 local production guide. CDC MMWR on methanol sanitiser poisoning 2020. IN-07
The verdict
OPEN
01-3 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5, Numbers to Carry, Story

Steam at 121 °C (15 psi gauge) for 20 minutes unwrapped, 30 wrapped. A stovetop cooker with a working weight passed all 128 indicators at 15 psi for 20 minutes

To check against
CDC Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization 2008 (Rutala, Weber, HICPAC). WHO 2003 Surgical Care at the District Hospital. Cook and others 2021
The verdict
OPEN
01-30 Safety open 01, Bench 01.1, 01.2

Spirit rub: ethanol 60 to 80%, wet for 20 to 30 seconds, rub dry. Weak on spores and norovirus, not on visible dirt or in diarrhoea

To check against
WHO 2009 hand hygiene guidelines. IN-07 grade table
The verdict
OPEN
01-4 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5, Honest Broker's Bar

Vent with the valve open until steam flows for 10 minutes. If pressure drops, restart the clock. No source found in the library

To check against
WHO 2016 Decontamination and Reprocessing. CDC 2008. Manufacturer instructions for stovetop sterilisers
The verdict
OPEN
01-5 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5, Honest Broker's Bar

Above 1,000 m double the time. Above 2,000 m untested. No source found in the library

To check against
Boiling point and pressure tables. WHO 2016. CDC 2008
The verdict
OPEN
01-6 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5

Cool the cooker by itself, never with water. Lid ajar 30 minutes to dry. A wet pack is not sterile. A dry, intact, closed pack keeps 4 weeks (ICRC rule, Thai data suggest 60 days)

To check against
ICRC surgical manuals. WHO 2016. WO-12 table of event related sterility
The verdict
OPEN
01-7 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5, Story

Never use one needle or one syringe on two people. Never change only the needle. Blood flows back into the barrel (Elista mechanism)

To check against
SY-10 H4 and never list item 5. WHO injection safety policy. Hauri and others 2004
The verdict
OPEN
01-8 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5

No cooker: boiled needle and syringe as a fallback, used the same day (WO-12), against SY-10 H15, which keeps boiling for what touches skin. Marked (the author's decision)

To check against
WO-12 rule. SY-10 H15. WHO 2016
The verdict
OPEN
01-9 Safety open 01, Bench 01.5, Story

Electric multicookers do not sterilise (3 of 4 failed at 300 minutes). Alcohol does not kill spores, deaths followed alcohol soaks (1940). Flame on a needle or lancet tip in emergencies only, grade D, no source

To check against
Swenson and others 2018. Bigger 1940. WO-12 grade table
The verdict
OPEN
01-31 open 01, Bench 01.3, Honest Broker's Bar

Soap yields per kg of fat: soft soap about 2 kg, salted hard soap 1.2 to 1.3 kg, caustic soda bar 1.25 to 1.35 kg. HY-05's arithmetic, not weighed

To check against
HY-05 arithmetic. A weighing
The verdict
OPEN
01-32 open 01, Bench 01.3

Hard soap by salting out: salt at a quarter of the soap's weight, boil until a ladleful sets hard in cold water (South Carolina newspaper, 1841)

To check against
USC historic newspapers, 1841. FEASTING ch. 17
The verdict
OPEN
01-33 open 01, Bench 01.3

Soft soap: 3 to 4 litres of egg floating lye per kg of fat (FEASTING), about 4 litres (NPS Fort Scott). Use 50 g per 10 litres of wash water

To check against
FEASTING ch. 17. NPS Fort Scott. HY-05
The verdict
OPEN
01-34 open 01, Bench 01.3, Story

Ash lye: hardwood ash only, pine gives a weak tarry lye. Rainwater through the barrel for 12 to 48 hours

To check against
Jefferson Farm Book p. 117. FEASTING ch. 17. Practical Action
The verdict
OPEN
01-35 open 01, Bench 01.2, 01.6, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Bar

Water for washing: 0.5 to 2 litres a wash, budget about 1 litre. A family of 6 washing 6 times a day needs about 36 litres, about 6 litres a person a day. The chapter's plan's 20 litres a person a day not found in HY-05

To check against
WHO and UNICEF 2025 as HY-01 gives it. HY-01 arithmetic. Chapter 13
The verdict
OPEN
01-36 open 01, Bench 01.6, Numbers to Carry, Story turn

Soap use 4.4 g a person a day (Karachi), 1.3 kg a day for a village of 300, about half a tonne a year

To check against
Luby and others 2004. HY-01 arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
01-37 open 01, Bench 01.6, Story

A household of 4 uses 10 to 15 kg of soap a year. A dispensary at 100 washes a day uses about 55 kg, from about 45 kg of fat

To check against
FEASTING. HY-05 arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
01-38 open 01, Story, Two clinics in Vienna

Vienna: two clinics, admission on alternate days. 1840 to 1846: 98.4 against 36.2 per 1,000. 1846: 459 of 4,010 against 105 of 3,754

To check against
Loudon 2013. Carter 1983 translation of Semmelweis 1861
The verdict
OPEN
01-39 open 01, Story, Honest Broker's Bar

Kolletschka cut at a post mortem and died, 1847. Cadaverous particles. Chlorinated lime from mid-May 1847, chosen for the smell. Strength unknown

To check against
Loudon 2013. Semmelweis 1861 (Carter 1983)
The verdict
OPEN
01-40 open 01, Story

Monthly counts: April 1847 57 of 312, June 6 of 268, July 3 of 250, autumn back to about 4 in 100, stricter control January 1848, no deaths in March and August 1848. 1848: 45 of 3,556, midwives' clinic 1.3%

To check against
Carter 1983 tables as HY-01 gives them
The verdict
OPEN
01-41 open 01, Honest Broker's Bar

Known error named: the 18 to under 2 per cent comparison of a month with a year, and Cureus 2024's 18.27% as the 1847 annual rate. 1847 was 5.0% (176 of 3,490). Fair comparison 11.4% against 1.27%, a fall of about 89 in 100, about one mother in ten births

To check against
Paul and others 2024, Cureus. Carter 1983. HY-01 arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
01-42 open 01, Honest Broker's Bar

January to March 1847 already low before washing: 3.2, 1.9 and 3.6%

To check against
Carter 1983
The verdict
OPEN
01-43 open 01, Story

Klein credited ventilation, post not renewed 1849. Book of 1861. Died 13 August 1865 in an asylum at Döbling of a septic wound of the hand. First Clinic 35.7 per 1,000 over 1848 to 1859

To check against
Loudon 2013. A Semmelweis biography
The verdict
OPEN
01-44 open 01, Story

Gordon in Aberdeen in the 1790s and Holmes in Boston in 1843 traced the fever to the attendant's hands

To check against
Gordon 1795. Holmes 1843. Chapter 10 rows
The verdict
OPEN
01-45 open 01, Story

Karachi 2002 to 2003: 36 neighbourhoods by lot, 25 promoted and 11 control, weekly visits for a year, 45 seconds, five moments, 3.3 bars of 90 g a week

To check against
Luby and others 2004, Lancet
The verdict
OPEN
01-46 open 01, Story

Karachi results: diarrhoea down 53%, pneumonia under 5 down 50%, impetigo down 34%, antibacterial soap no better, no gain in the first 8 weeks, 97 against 28 in 100 with soap at 5 years. Reported by mothers, funded by Procter and Gamble

To check against
Luby and others 2004, 2005. Bowen and others 2013
The verdict
OPEN
01-47 open 01, Story, Honest Broker's Bar

Pooled trials: about 30% less diarrhoea, about 16 to 21% fewer chest infections, no trial measured deaths. Freeman 2014 adjusted 0.77 (0.32 to 1.86). WASH Benefits Kenya adherence above 70% to below 25%. Two of three large trials 2018 to 2019 found nothing

To check against
Cochrane 2021 review. Freeman and others 2014. Null and others 2018. Luby and others 2018. SHINE trial report
The verdict
OPEN
01-48 open 01, Story, Honest Broker's Bar

Nepal: 23,662 newborns, mother's handwashing 44% lower neonatal deaths, observational within a chlorhexidine trial

To check against
Rhee and others 2008, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine 162(7)
The verdict
OPEN
01-49 open 01, Story

About 19% wash with soap after the toilet worldwide. People wash from disgust, nurture and status

To check against
The global review and motive studies HY-01 cites
The verdict
OPEN
01-50 open 01, Story turn

Hospital staff compliance about 40% median, about 21% before patient contact

To check against
The compliance review HY-01 cites
The verdict
OPEN
01-51 open 01, Story

Pliny on Gallic soap from tallow and beech ash. Mappae Clavicula about 1130, soap worked 2 to 4 days

To check against
Pliny, Natural History. Dunn on the Mappae Clavicula
The verdict
OPEN
01-52 open 01, Story

Geoffroy 1742 to the Royal Society: the egg test and his own note that hens' eggs differ in weight

To check against
Geoffroy 1742, Philosophical Transactions
The verdict
OPEN
01-53 open 01, Story

British soap use about 3 kg a head in 1800 (7 lb) and about 6 kg in 1880 (14 lb). Leblanc soda from salt, France, 1791

To check against
The economic history sources HY-05 cites
The verdict
OPEN
01-54 open 01, Story

Uyo, November 2006 to November 2010: 16 children, caustic soda in nearly all (93.7%), soap making mother in 14 of 16, most aged 1 to 3, half with strictures, 7 gastrostomies, 1 death, vomiting worsened injury. Accra: caustic stored in soft drink bottles

To check against
Ekpe and Ette 2012. Daily Graphic via myjoyonline 2008
The verdict
OPEN
01-55 open 01, Story

Chevalier Jackson and the Federal Caustic Poison Act, usually 1927, also given as 1925 and 1929. Story says the 1920s

To check against
Mütter Museum. The Act's text
The verdict
OPEN
01-56 open 01, Story

Chamberland's autoclave, 1879. Koch, Gaffky and Löffler on steam, 1881. Von Bergmann's steamed dressings, 1886. With Schimmelbusch, the Berlin congress of 1890

To check against
Institut Pasteur. Deutsche Biographie. Schimmelbusch 1892
The verdict
OPEN
01-57 open 01, Story

Spores of tetanus and gas gangrene survive boiling. 1940 report of deaths after alcohol soaked instruments

To check against
Bigger 1940. CDC 2008
The verdict
OPEN
01-58 open 01, Story

2021 stovetop cooker of about four litres (4 quart), 128 indicators passed. 2018 electric multicookers, 3 of 4 failed at 300 minutes

To check against
Cook and others 2021. Swenson and others 2018
The verdict
OPEN
01-59 open 01, Story

Unsafe injections in 2000: 21 million hepatitis B, 2 million hepatitis C, 260,000 HIV. 39.3% with reused equipment

To check against
Hauri and others 2004
The verdict
OPEN
01-60 open 01, Story

Elista 1988 to 1989, needle changed, syringe reused, children infected with HIV. Roka, Cambodia, 242 infected 2014 to 2015

To check against
Russian sources as WO-12 gives them (75 children and 4 adults). Roka outbreak reports
The verdict
OPEN