THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Preface: Before the First Patient

13 claims, 4 marked for safety

P5 Safety open 00 Preface, What the hands can do

Breath count above 50 a minute means pneumonia, and amoxicillin by weight in lay hands cut deaths from 13.5 to 0.8 per cent

To check against
Bang et al., Lancet 1990 and 1999 (Gadchiroli); WHO IMCI breath thresholds by age (60, 50, 40)
The verdict
OPEN
P6 Safety open 00 Preface, What the hands can do

ORS: 1 litre, half a level 5 ml teaspoon of salt, 6 level teaspoons of sugar

To check against
HY-03's sources (UNICEF, IFRC, Hesperian) against WHO's "one level teaspoon" of 3 g; disputed line for the second-round review of disputed lines
The verdict
OPEN
P9 Safety open 00 Preface

Misoprostol 600 µg by mouth after the birth

To check against
WHO PPH recommendations 2012 and 2018, FIGO
The verdict
OPEN
P10 Safety open 00 Preface

Tourniquet before shock about 90 per cent survival, after about 10

To check against
WO-01's source (Kragh 2009, Annals of Surgery)
The verdict
OPEN
P1 open 00 Preface, opening

Amoxicillin made in fermentation halls in Shandong or Gujarat

To check against
Any account of the penicillin G or 6-APA supply chain (India and China as the main producers); generalise if not supportable
The verdict
OPEN
P2 open 00 Preface, opening

Fleming 1928, Peoria 1943, the cantaloupe strain

To check against
Standard history (NRRL, Mary Hunt, Penicillium chrysogenum NRRL 1951)
The verdict
OPEN
P3 open 00 Preface, What the hands can do

A village of 300 loses 5 to 9 a year, 7 to 9 tropical, 5 to 7 temperate, three or four children

To check against
SY-05, SY-08, SY-09 and the demographic sources they cite (crude death rates in pre-transition populations)
The verdict
OPEN
P4 open 00 Preface, What the hands can do

Twenty interventions avert about a third of deaths in the tropics and a fifth in temperate places, 8 to 40 hours each

To check against
SY-05's ledger and its sources
The verdict
OPEN
P7 open 00 Preface

Cholera deaths fall from one in two to one in a hundred with rehydration

To check against
SY-08 and its sources (WHO cholera case-fatality untreated against treated)
The verdict
OPEN
P8 open 00 Preface

A baby not breastfed in its first six months dies at 14 times the rate

To check against
IN-01, MA-05 and the Lancet breastfeeding series (Victora 2016, Sankar 2015)
The verdict
OPEN
P11 open 00 Preface, The good news

Mahalanabis at Bongaon 1971: oral rehydration, about 3 per cent died where about 30 had been

To check against
Mahalanabis et al., Johns Hopkins Medical Journal 1973 (3,700 patients, 3.6 per cent)
The verdict
OPEN
P12 open 00 Preface, The good news

Tredegar: three pence in the pound, 95 per cent of the town by 1933; China's barefoot doctors about a million; Alaska aides 16 weeks over 2 to 3 years

To check against
OR-08, FO-04, OR-01 and their sources
The verdict
OPEN
P13 open 00 Preface, The good news

Scutari: deaths fell from about four in ten (February 1855) to about two in a hundred (June 1855)

To check against
NU-01's sources; Nightingale's own returns and the Sanitary Commission's dates (the fall is attributed in part to the Commission's works)
The verdict
OPEN