THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 492 · HEALING · Nursing, rehabilitation and dying

Nursing as the main medicine

Its printed title: NU-01 Nursing as the main medicine: Nightingale's statistics and the care of the bedridden

This report sets the frame that NU-02 (fluids and feeding), NU-03 (the sickroom), NU-04 (rehabilitation) and NU-09 (the long-term patient) build on. Three things are kept apart throughout: what the tradition claims, what the record shows, and what modern science infers. Two leads in the brief could not be used: Gill and Gill's 2005 reexamination is paywalled, and Hampton's Nursing: Its Principles and Practice (1893) was reached only through a 1906 review of a later edition.

Open the PDF 18 pages · 110 KB

Number
492
Letter code
NU-01
Book
HEALING after the FALL
Shelf
Nursing, rehabilitation and dying
File
492 NU-01 Nursing as the main medicine.pdf
Pages
18
Works cited
1

The rows that check it

  • 25 open
  • 9 marked for safety
  • 24-1 open Safety Disputed line. Adult fever by mouth 37.5 °C (NU-01, Red Cross) against 37.7 °C (FO-07). Armpit 37.8 °C (OR-04). Printed both ways, not settled
  • 24-22 open Safety Adult enema: warm soapy or salty water at 40 to 43 °C, 1 to 2 litres (draft's rounding of 2 to 4 pints, which is 1.1 to 2.3 litres), left side. 2 days without stool: water and …
  • 24-3 open Safety Disputed line. Turning: hard bed every 2 hours by day and night, sheepskin, deep pallet or foam every 3 to 4 hours by day and 1 or 2 turns at night. The two-hourly rule rests on …
  • 24-5 open Safety Room about 18 to 20 °C. Bath water about 40 °C
  • 24-6 open Safety Heat for pain at 40 to 42 °C, cloth between, skin looked at every 10 minutes. Never in an infant's bed (the author's decision). Numb skin burns at 44 °C in hours (3 to 6 h) and 50 …
  • 24-7 open Safety Adult who cannot take meals: 180 to 240 ml of liquid food every 2 to 3 hours (draft's conversion of the Red Cross 6 to 8 oz)
  • 24-8 open Safety Swallow test: fully upright, 3 teaspoons of water one at a time before every meal. Cough, wet voice or changed breathing means nothing thin. Half a teaspoon at a time. Upright 30 …
  • 28-1 open Safety Clock line: bladder emptied every six hours or damaged in days. A sore starts in two hours on one spot. The old who do not walk within a month after a hip break mostly die within …
  • 28-56 open Safety Never a ring cushion. Never massage over bone. Turn 2 hours on a hard bed, 2 to 3 on a sheepskin. Chair lift every 15 (brief) against 15 to 30 minutes (NU-05). Chair up to 2 hours …
  • P13 open Scutari: deaths fell from about four in ten (February 1855) to about two in a hundred (June 1855)
  • 24-23 open Bed about 2 m by 90 cm at 60 to 65 cm high: the chapter's conversion of NU-01's 6 ft 6 in by 36 in at 24 to 26 in
  • 24-24 open Village of 300: about 3 to 6 bedfast at any time, about 8 hours of care a day each (6 direct plus 2), NU-01's estimates from nursing-home rates
  • 24-25 open Nightingale reached Scutari in November 1854 with 38 nurses. February 1855 her own figure nearly 43 per cent of cases treated. About 2 per cent by June 1855
  • 24-26 open Sanitary Commission under Dr John Sutherland reached Scutari in March 1855: sewers flushed, ventilation opened, the Stable Hospital and two ships closed, 202 cartloads of filth …
  • 24-27 open June 1854 to June 1856, deaths over admissions: Scutari 11.9 per cent, Koulali 25.9, Renkioi 3.8 (open from October 1855)
  • 24-28 open Of 12,518 men sent to Scutari October 1854 to April 1855, 4,522 died (36 per cent), against 5,341 of 41,395 who stayed in the Crimea (13 per cent). Selection confounds it …
  • 24-29 open The Scutari dispute printed both ways: nursing cut the deaths, or drains, air and space did. Library's verdict the second. Nightingale blamed sanitary defects and never claimed …
  • 24-30 open Animal experiments 1961: steady pressure for about 2 hours (70 mmHg) did damage, the same pressure lifted every few minutes did not
  • 24-37 open Pooled mouth-care trials: pneumonia RR about 0.61 ("about four in ten")
  • 24-38 open Swallow screening after stroke: pneumonia OR about 0.60. HeadPoST, 11,093 people: feeding cut back after a failed screen OR 4.06
  • 24-40 open William Osler, Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, by 1893: 229 typhoid cases, 22 deaths (9.6 per cent), 7.1 per cent after the cold bath. Untreated typhoid about 15 per cent. His estimate: …
  • 28-21 open Bed rest helped in none of 15 conditions across 39 trials (1999). Ten days in bed costs an old person about 1 kg leg muscle and an eighth of knee strength
  • 28-37 open Advanced dementia: 323 people, more than half dead in 18 months, nearly nine in ten eating problems, two in five pneumonia. Tube feeding never shown to help
  • 36-65 open The Preface credits Scutari's fall in deaths to the nurses, where NU-01 shows it followed the Sanitary Commission. First line of the correction page
  • S-10 open

Its works cited 1

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 1 journal, university or public body
Show all 1
  1. Aiken LH, Clarke SP, Sloane DM, Sochalski J, Silber JH. Hospital nursestaffing and patient mortality, nurse burnout, and job dissatisfaction. JAMA2002, 288:1987 to 1993. Read as abstract and multiple secondary summaries nmlegis.gov/handouts/LHHS%20081312%20Item%200%…