THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 24: The Sickroom

49 claims, 22 marked for safety

24-1 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.1 table, 24.6 step 1

Disputed line. Adult fever by mouth 37.5 °C (NU-01, Red Cross) against 37.7 °C (FO-07). Armpit 37.8 °C (OR-04). Printed both ways, not settled

To check against
NU-01 Protocol 2. FO-07. OR-04. Chapter 02.2 as printed
The verdict
OPEN
24-10 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.4 step 12

Tube length: nose to earlobe to tip of breastbone, plus 10 cm in an adult (NEX alone under 72.4 per cent accurate, NEX plus 10 cm 97.4 per cent)

To check against
NU-02 section on placement and its cited study
The verdict
OPEN
24-11 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Story (The mouth and the swallow), Bench 24.4 steps 15 to 17, Numbers

pH 5.5 or below on drawn fluid means stomach (98.9 per cent of 178 samples). No fluid: 10 to 20 ml of air, left side, wait up to 1 hour. A gurgle is never proof. Flush 20 to 30 ml before and after each feed

To check against
NU-02 Protocol 3 and the pH study it cites. NHS Improvement never event guidance on nasogastric tubes
The verdict
OPEN
24-12 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5 table and steps 1 to 3

Rectal fluid in adults: start 100 ml an hour, up to 250 ml, at most 400 ml an hour for 1 to 2 hours then rest 2 to 4 hours, about 1 litre a day. Left side during and 30 minutes after, never the right side. No rate found for children (the author's decision)

To check against
Bruera et al. 1998. NU-02 Protocol 5. Chapter 05.4
The verdict
OPEN
24-13 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5 step 4

Rectal tube soft, greased, pencil thick, in 20 to 40 cm, never forced

To check against
NU-02 Protocol 5. Its source for the depth
The verdict
OPEN
24-14 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5 table, Numbers

Fluid under the skin, adult, library's view: 1 ml a minute a site (60 ml an hour, about 20 drops a minute), 1.5 litres a site in 24 hours, 3 litres over 2 sites, never more than 1 litre in 2 hours. District method until the author rules (the author's decision)

To check against
Rochon et al. 1997. Broadhurst et al. 2020. NU-02 Protocol 4. SY-10 H42. Concept note decision 10
The verdict
OPEN
24-15 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5 table

Disputed line. Fluid under a child's skin: 20 ml for each kg over about 1 hour (StatPearls) against the adult 1 ml a minute a site. Grade C. As 05.4 (the author's decision)

To check against
NU-02 children section. StatPearls hypodermoclysis entry. Rouhani et al. 2011. Chapter 05.4
The verdict
OPEN
24-16 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5 Never line and steps 5 and 6, Broker

Fluid for under the skin or rectum: 9 g of plain salt weighed into 1 litre, boiled 15 minutes, covered, used within 24 hours, or sterile saline. Never sugar water. 2 teaspoons is about 12 g (1.2 per cent), washing water only

To check against
NU-02 Protocol 7 and section on IN-07's error. SY-10 H42
The verdict
OPEN
24-17 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5 steps 7 to 10

Needle 21 to 25 gauge, new every time, 45 to 60 degrees into a pinched fold. Sites thigh, belly away from the navel, below the collarbone, between the shoulder blades, never groin or breast. Lump at 1 hour: halve the rate. New site every 3 days. Not in shock, heart failure, breathlessness with crackles, bleeding disorders

To check against
NU-02 Protocol 4. SY-10 never list item 5
The verdict
OPEN
24-18 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.5

Stop all fluid by any route for new breathlessness, wet cough, puffy eyelids, cannot lie flat, breaths up 5 or pulse up 15

To check against
NU-02 overload signs and its source
The verdict
OPEN
24-19 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.6 table

Paracetamol adult bands copied from 06.2: 34 to under 50 kg 500 mg, 50 to under 67 kg 750 mg, 67 kg and over 1,000 mg. Every 4 to 6 hours, at most 4 doses and 60 mg/kg in 24 hours, adults at most 1 g a dose and 4 g a day. Under 34 kg to 06.2. 06.2's 10 ml syrup row (240 mg, not 250) not reproduced

To check against
Chapter 06.2 and its rows. IN-02. SY-10 H24. BNF paracetamol monograph
The verdict
OPEN
24-2 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.6 step 2

Under 2 months, 37.5 °C or more, or cold, is a danger sign

To check against
SY-07 section 7 (child under 2 months). Chapter 6
The verdict
OPEN
24-20 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Story (Nursing the stroke), Bench 24.7 step 2

Stroke: drowsy person on the side, airway clear (CH-02 says weak side up, itself marked VERIFY). Awake: any position. Flat or 30 degrees for the first day made no difference

To check against
CH-02 Protocol 6. Anderson et al. 2017 (HeadPoST)
The verdict
OPEN
24-21 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Story (Nursing the stroke), Bench 24.7 steps 5 and 6

Stroke: sit out from about day 2 in short spells. No hard getting up within 24 hours (AVERT: 46 against 50 per cent favourable, OR 0.73, 2,104 people). Do not lower raised pressure with tablets in the first days

To check against
Bernhardt et al. 2015 (AVERT). Bath and Krishnan 2014. CH-02 Protocol 6
The verdict
OPEN
24-22 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.8 steps 1 to 3

Adult enema: warm soapy or salty water at 40 to 43 °C, 1 to 2 litres (draft's rounding of 2 to 4 pints, which is 1.1 to 2.3 litres), left side. 2 days without stool: water and movement. 5 days with swelling or vomiting: manual removal

To check against
NU-01 Protocol 5. Delano and Strong 1918
The verdict
OPEN
24-3 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Story (What the bed does), Bench 24.3 table, Numbers

Disputed line. Turning: hard bed every 2 hours by day and night, sheepskin, deep pallet or foam every 3 to 4 hours by day and 1 or 2 turns at night. The two-hourly rule rests on no trial. CH-02 prints 2 to 4 hours, NU-08 prints 2 hours for the dying. Any fixed interval grade D

To check against
Gillespie et al. 2020 Cochrane (repositioning). Defloor et al. 2005. Bergstrom et al. 2013. NU-01 Protocol 1 step 9 and 16
The verdict
OPEN
24-4 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.2 step 6

Air the sickroom 2 times a day: 30 minutes with 2 openings on different walls, 90 minutes with 1

To check against
NU-03 section on air (25 to 50 minutes cross, 90 or more single). Escombe et al. 2007
The verdict
OPEN
24-5 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.2 step 7, 24.3 step 3

Room about 18 to 20 °C. Bath water about 40 °C

To check against
WHO Housing and Health Guidelines 2018 (18 °C). NU-01 means ledger (room 20 °C, basin 40 °C, 105 °F)
The verdict
OPEN
24-6 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.2

Heat for pain at 40 to 42 °C, cloth between, skin looked at every 10 minutes. Never in an infant's bed (the author's decision). Numb skin burns at 44 °C in hours (3 to 6 h) and 50 °C in minutes (2 to 3 min). Never against skin, never under the person, out before sleep

To check against
NU-08 Protocol 6 and burn thresholds (Moritz and Henriques 1947 as read in NU-08). NU-01 hot water bottle rule
The verdict
OPEN
24-7 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.4 step 7

Adult who cannot take meals: 180 to 240 ml of liquid food every 2 to 3 hours (draft's conversion of the Red Cross 6 to 8 oz)

To check against
Delano and Strong 1918, American Red Cross textbook on home hygiene. NU-01 Protocol 1 step 10
The verdict
OPEN
24-8 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.4 steps 3 to 6, 24.7, Numbers

Swallow test: fully upright, 3 teaspoons of water one at a time before every meal. Cough, wet voice or changed breathing means nothing thin. Half a teaspoon at a time. Upright 30 minutes after. A failed test changes the food, it never stops feeding

To check against
NU-01 Protocol 4. Swallow screening meta-analysis (OR 0.60) as read in NU-01. HeadPoST secondary analysis
The verdict
OPEN
24-9 Safety open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.4 steps 9 to 11

Nasogastric tube sizes: adult 8 to 12 Fr, under 5 years 5 to 8 Fr, school age 8 Fr. Never if cannot cough, after a caustic, after a head blow with fluid from the nose, against resistance

To check against
NU-02 Protocol 2. SY-10 H42
The verdict
OPEN
24-23 open 24 The Sickroom, Bench 24.2 step 3, Broker

Bed about 2 m by 90 cm at 60 to 65 cm high: the chapter's conversion of NU-01's 6 ft 6 in by 36 in at 24 to 26 in

To check against
NU-01 means ledger. Nightingale 1860 and Delano and Strong 1918 for the original measures
The verdict
OPEN
24-24 open 24 The Sickroom, Broker, Bench 24.8

Village of 300: about 3 to 6 bedfast at any time, about 8 hours of care a day each (6 direct plus 2), NU-01's estimates from nursing-home rates

To check against
NU-01 village section and its reasoning
The verdict
OPEN
24-25 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (A barracks above the Bosphorus)

Nightingale reached Scutari in November 1854 with 38 nurses. February 1855 her own figure nearly 43 per cent of cases treated. About 2 per cent by June 1855

To check against
Nightingale's figures as read in NU-01. McDonald, Collected Works. Gill and Gill 2005 (not read by NU-01)
The verdict
OPEN
24-26 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Sanitary Commission under Dr John Sutherland reached Scutari in March 1855: sewers flushed, ventilation opened, the Stable Hospital and two ships closed, 202 cartloads of filth removed in the first week

To check against
NU-01 Scutari section and its sources. The Sanitary Commission report as cited in NU-01
The verdict
OPEN
24-27 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

June 1854 to June 1856, deaths over admissions: Scutari 11.9 per cent, Koulali 25.9, Renkioi 3.8 (open from October 1855)

To check against
NU-01 Scutari section
The verdict
OPEN
24-28 open 24 The Sickroom, Story, Working notes (Small unnamed in the text)

Of 12,518 men sent to Scutari October 1854 to April 1855, 4,522 died (36 per cent), against 5,341 of 41,395 who stayed in the Crimea (13 per cent). Selection confounds it (McDonald's rebuttal)

To check against
Small 1998, 2020. McDonald's rebuttal as read in NU-01
The verdict
OPEN
24-29 open 24 The Sickroom, Story, Broker, verification notes

The Scutari dispute printed both ways: nursing cut the deaths, or drains, air and space did. Library's verdict the second. Nightingale blamed sanitary defects and never claimed the fall. The Preface line and Style Sheet sample 14 repeat the first reading and need correcting

To check against
NU-01 verdict and sources. 00 Preface. STYLE SHEET sample 14
The verdict
OPEN
24-30 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (What the bed does)

Animal experiments 1961: steady pressure for about 2 hours (70 mmHg) did damage, the same pressure lifted every few minutes did not

To check against
Kosiak 1961 (read secondarily in NU-01)
The verdict
OPEN
24-31 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

19,889 American nursing-home residents: 11.3 per cent arrived with a sore, 21.6 per cent had one by 2 years

To check against
Brandeis et al. 1990
The verdict
OPEN
24-32 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Belgium 2005, 838 nursing-home residents: grade II or worse 3.0 per cent on 4-hourly foam against 14.3 to 24.1 per cent in other groups. "Belgium" is the chapter's placing

To check against
Defloor, de Bacquer and Grypdonck 2005
The verdict
OPEN
24-33 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

More than 900 residents on good foam, 2, 3 or 4-hourly, no difference, about 2 per cent incidence. Cochrane 2020: 3 trials, 1,074 people, 2 against 4-hourly no difference, lowest certainty. 30 degree tilt at least as good (3 of 99 against 13 of 114)

To check against
Bergstrom et al. 2013. Gillespie et al. 2020. Moore et al. 2011
The verdict
OPEN
24-34 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Melbourne 2000, 441 hospital patients: sores 9.6 per cent with sheepskin, 16.6 without, open label

To check against
Jolley et al. 2004
The verdict
OPEN
24-35 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Bed rest: 39 trials, 15 conditions, 5,777 people, none improved, several worse. 10 days of bed rest cost older adults about 0.95 kg of leg lean mass

To check against
Allen, Glasziou and Del Mar 1999. Kortebein et al. 2007
The verdict
OPEN
24-36 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (The mouth and the swallow), Broker

Takeyoshi Yoneyama, 11 Japanese nursing homes, 417 residents, published 2002 in J Am Geriatr Soc 50(3):430 (not the Lancet): pneumonia 11 against 19 per cent, febrile days 15 against 29 per cent, fewer pneumonia deaths. First name to confirm

To check against
Yoneyama et al. 2002
The verdict
OPEN
24-37 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Pooled mouth-care trials: pneumonia RR about 0.61 ("about four in ten")

To check against
The meta-analysis cited in NU-01
The verdict
OPEN
24-38 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Swallow screening after stroke: pneumonia OR about 0.60. HeadPoST, 11,093 people: feeding cut back after a failed screen OR 4.06

To check against
NU-01 swallow section. HeadPoST secondary analysis
The verdict
OPEN
24-39 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

England 2011 to 2016: 95 misplaced nasogastric tubes, 32 deaths, among more than 3 million tubes. Whoosh test dropped in 2005

To check against
NU-02 tube section. NPSA 2005 alert. NHS Improvement 2016
The verdict
OPEN
24-40 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (The fever nursed)

William Osler, Johns Hopkins, Baltimore, by 1893: 229 typhoid cases, 22 deaths (9.6 per cent), 7.1 per cent after the cold bath. Untreated typhoid about 15 per cent. His estimate: 3 in 4 recover anyway, nursing and stopping drugs save 15, the bath 3 to 8 (secondary)

To check against
Osler, The Principles and Practice of Medicine, 1892 and later editions. NU-01 typhoid section
The verdict
OPEN
24-41 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (Nursing the stroke)

Oxfordshire 1981 to 1986: 675 first strokes, 19 per cent died within 30 days. After infarction, more than half of deaths after the first week from immobility (51 per cent)

To check against
Bamford et al. 1990a and 1990b
The verdict
OPEN
24-42 open 24 The Sickroom, Story, Numbers

Peter Langhorne, Glasgow: components of stroke units 2002 (with Pollock). Cochrane 2020: 29 trials, 5,902 people, death OR 0.76, about 2 more alive and 6 more at home per 100

To check against
Langhorne and Pollock 2002. Langhorne and Ramachandra 2020
The verdict
OPEN
24-43 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (Water under the skin)

Fluid under the skin in the 1940s and 1950s, abandoned after infant deaths from salt-free or hypertonic fluid

To check against
Abbott 1952. Israels and Wylie 1959 (titles only in NU-02)
The verdict
OPEN
24-44 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

96 people, mean age 85.3: under the skin as good as a vein. 2020 review: at least as effective, fewer harms, serious harms with sugar solutions at 480 to 675 ml an hour

To check against
Slesak et al. 2003. Broadhurst et al. 2020
The verdict
OPEN
24-45 open 24 The Sickroom, Story, Bench 24.5 grades

1998: 78 dying people, about 1 litre a day by rectum, 5 per cent stopped. 2013: 129 hospice patients, 1 litre against 100 ml under the skin, no benefit

To check against
Bruera et al. 1998. Bruera et al. 2013
The verdict
OPEN
24-46 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Fever-causing residues survive boiling and 121 °C, so a village cannot make fluid for a vein

To check against
Seibert 1923 as read in NU-02
The verdict
OPEN
24-47 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (The turn to the present)

Acute illness treated at home: deaths no higher (six-month mortality RR 0.88). Each extra patient per nurse: death OR about 1.07

To check against
Edgar et al. 2024. Aiken et al. 2002
The verdict
OPEN
24-48 open 24 The Sickroom, Story (The turn to the present)

Strained carers: 63 per cent higher mortality over 4.5 years

To check against
Schulz and Beach 1999
The verdict
OPEN
24-49 open 24 The Sickroom, Story

Nightingale: a bed-sore is generally the fault of the nursing, thousands starved in the midst of plenty (Notes on Nursing 1860). A hospital should do the sick no harm (Notes on Hospitals 1863). Red Cross 1918: turn the wasted every waking hour

To check against
Nightingale 1860, 1863. Delano and Strong 1918
The verdict
OPEN