THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 19: Bones and Joints

40 claims, 28 marked for safety

19-1 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.2, Story (Plaster, and the two days after), Numbers

Fingers and toes checked every hour for 48 hours, then twice a day. Slabs or casts split to the skin only in the first 48 hours

To check against
SY-10 H11 and disagreement row C27 (FO-09 gives 24 h, WO-05 gives 48 h). King 2018 ch 59, ICRC (via WO-05). The "twice a day" after 48 hours is the chapter's
The verdict
OPEN
19-10 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.2

Full cast at day 3 to 5, split while soft

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018 ch 59, ICRC)
The verdict
OPEN
19-14 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3

Ribs: no splint, deep breaths and a cough each waking hour. Breathless: chapter 21

To check against
Not in WO-05 or WO-06. Draft's own. Check against the chest material used by chapter 21
The verdict
OPEN
19-15 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3

Ankle: swollen, raise 20 cm and set within 2 to 7 days. No weight 6 weeks if unstable, from 2 to 4 weeks if stable

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018)
The verdict
OPEN
19-18 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3, Broker

Children often taught as half the adult time. Hungry or old: add half again

To check against
WO-05 (no primary source for children, inference for the hungry). Arithmetic: 6 weeks plus half is 9 weeks
The verdict
OPEN
19-19 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4

Skin traction at most 5 kg. Gallows traction for a child up to 12 to 15 kg

To check against
WO-05 (ICRC)
The verdict
OPEN
19-2 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.2

After splitting a tight cast, look again in 1 hour. Not better: send for the district's knife

To check against
Draft's estimate, matched to the hourly check. WO-05 compartment section, King 2018
The verdict
OPEN
19-20 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4

Pin 2.5 to 3 cm below the tibial tubercle. Never a tibial pin in a child with open growth plates

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018, Giannou 2013)
The verdict
OPEN
19-21 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4, Story (A bed, a pin), Numbers

Traction weight table. ICRC 1 kg per 10 kg: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 kg. King one seventh, rounded to the nearest half kg: 40/7 is 5.7, printed 5.5. 50/7 is 7.1, printed 7. 60/7 is 8.6, printed 8.5. 70/7 is 10. 80/7 is 11.4, printed 11.5

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018 ch 67, Giannou 2013). Arithmetic is the chapter's
The verdict
OPEN
19-22 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4

Foot of the bed raised 4 cm for every kg of traction

To check against
WO-05
The verdict
OPEN
19-23 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4, Story

Aim for 1 cm overlap, accept 2 cm. No gap: a 2 mm gap prevents union

To check against
WO-05
The verdict
OPEN
19-24 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4

Off traction at 4 to 5 weeks (ICRC) or 6 to 8 (King). No weight for 8 to 12 weeks

To check against
WO-05 (Giannou 2013, King 2018)
The verdict
OPEN
19-26 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5

Stop rule: 40 or over with a first dislocation, bruised upper arm, fall from above own height, vehicle or large animal, a child's shoulder, grinding, new numbness, growing swelling, white or cold limb, out over 3 weeks

To check against
WO-06 Protocols 1 and 14 (Emond, Quebec rule, over-40 branch unvalidated)
The verdict
OPEN
19-27 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5, clock line, Numbers, Story

Shoulder: start within 90 minutes. Still out at 6 hours: the district

To check against
WO-06 (Widmer 2023: 93% within 90 min against 73%). The 6 hour line is the chapter's plan's. Pradhan 2006 (via WO-06) moves to intravenous help beyond 5 hours
The verdict
OPEN
19-28 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5

Scapular manipulation: 5 kg from the wrist, wait 5 to 10 minutes, push the tip of the shoulder blade, hold 60 seconds. Slow outward rotation over 5 to 10 minutes. Two attempts

To check against
WO-06 Protocols 2 and 3 (Alkaduhimi 2017, Gonai 2023)
The verdict
OPEN
19-3 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Story (Plaster), Bench 19.2, Numbers, clock line

Muscle damage under a tight splint in 6 to 8 hours on textbook teaching, reported within 3. The district must open the compartment within hours

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018, Ulmer 2002)
The verdict
OPEN
19-30 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5, Story, Numbers

Knee out of joint: about 1 in 4 tears the popliteal artery. Splint at 15°, watch the foot 3 days

To check against
WO-06 (WikEM, Helito 2025, Merck Manual)
The verdict
OPEN
19-31 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5, Story, Numbers

Hip: 3 or 4 people, within 6 hours, 2 tries, no weight 6 weeks. Head dies in under 1 in 10 within 6 hours, up to 4 in 10 overall

To check against
WO-06 Protocol 11 (Ahmed 2017)
The verdict
OPEN
19-32 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5, Numbers

Lidocaine 1% into the shoulder joint: 0.3 ml/kg, never over 20 ml, one dose, wait 15 to 20 minutes. Bands at the lower weight of each band: 30 kg 9 ml, 40 kg 12 ml, 50 kg 15 ml, 60 kg 18 ml, 67 kg and over 20 ml

To check against
WO-06 Protocol 6, SY-10 (3 mg/kg, 200 mg). Default 10 bars injection below the district, so the owner decides. Arithmetic is the chapter's
The verdict
OPEN
19-33 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5

King's haematoma block of 10 ml of 2% is 200 mg, over 3 mg/kg for anyone under 67 kg (200 divided by 3 is 66.7)

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018), SY-10
The verdict
OPEN
19-34 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.6

A wound under 1 cm over an undisplaced break may be treated as closed

To check against
WO-05 (Omololu 2008 triage)
The verdict
OPEN
19-35 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.6, Broker

Open fracture antibiotic only on a written sign, by mouth, from the dispensary holder. ICRC injected regimen not printed for the village. WO-05's question mislabelled for WO-06

To check against
SY-10 H48, SY-12, WO-05 (ICRC regimen), IN-05. Drug and dose by mouth not given by the library
The verdict
OPEN
19-36 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.6

Pelvis: sheet tied at the hip bones, legs bound, flat and warm, carried flat

To check against
WO-01 (CoTCCC, TCCC Module 9)
The verdict
OPEN
19-4 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.1

Colour check: a pressed nail pinks as fast as on the other side

To check against
WO-06 Protocol 1. No village refill threshold in seconds was found, so the chapter compares sides
The verdict
OPEN
19-5 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.1, Story (The hand that finds the break)

Ottawa rule: 4 points and 4 steps. 27 studies, 15,581 patients, sensitivity 97.6%. Used backwards without X-ray

To check against
WO-06 (Bachmann 2003), WO-06 Protocol 13
The verdict
OPEN
19-6 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.1, Story

When unsure, splint as broken for 2 weeks and look again

To check against
WO-05 (marked as inference there), WO-06 Protocol 13
The verdict
OPEN
19-8 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.2

Padding: arm 2 to 3 layers, leg 3 to 4 (about 1 cm). Pad the head of the fibula

To check against
WO-05 (ICRC)
The verdict
OPEN
19-9 Safety open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.2

Slab covers at most two thirds of the girth. 4 layers (King) or 6 to 8 (ICRC), never more than 8. Dip water no warmer than 24 °C. Never set on a pillow

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018, ICRC), NU-05 (Lavalette 1982, Hutchinson 2008)
The verdict
OPEN
19-11 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3, Story (Walking in plaster)

Wrist: cast 3 weeks, 6 if unstable. Over 60: slab as it lies, move at 4 weeks

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018, Arora 2011, CROSSFIRE 2021)
The verdict
OPEN
19-12 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3

Forearm and upper arm: 6 to 8 weeks

To check against
WO-05 (GPnotebook, upper limb). No bone-specific figure in the library
The verdict
OPEN
19-13 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3

Collarbone sling 2 to 3 weeks (WO-05) against 1 week as for a shoulder (WO-06). Both printed

To check against
WO-05 (King 2018 ch 61, Andersen 1987), WO-06 (Paterson 2010)
The verdict
OPEN
19-16 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3

Shin: 17 weeks on average in a brace (17.4 closed, 21.7 open)

To check against
WO-05 (Sarmiento 1989)
The verdict
OPEN
19-17 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.3, Numbers, Broker

Perkins: arm spiral 3 weeks to join, 6 firm. Leg spiral 6. Leg across 12, firm 24. GPnotebook: arm 6 to 8, leg double

To check against
WO-05 (King quoting Perkins, GPnotebook)
The verdict
OPEN
19-25 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.4

District infirmary keeps 4 to 6 traction beds

To check against
WO-05 (marked (to be checked) there)
The verdict
OPEN
19-29 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.5

Sling 1 week after a shoulder reduction

To check against
WO-06 (Paterson 2010)
The verdict
OPEN
19-37 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.7, Story (Plaster)

Plaster from gypsum: slow oven at 120 to 130 °C for 1 to 2 hours. A test spoonful sets in 5 to 15 minutes

To check against
WO-05 (CBRI 2024, NZIC). The setting time is marked (to be checked) in WO-05
The verdict
OPEN
19-38 open 19 Bones and Joints, Story (A bed, a pin)

Hugh Owen Thomas, a Liverpool surgeon from a family of Welsh bonesetters

To check against
Not in the library. Robinson 2009 (via WO-05) and any history of the Thomas splint
The verdict
OPEN
19-39 open 19 Bones and Joints, Story (A bed, a pin)

George Perkins taught at St Thomas' Hospital, London, from the 1930s to the 1950s

To check against
Not in the library. Perkins, Fractures and Dislocations (about 1958), obituary
The verdict
OPEN
19-40 open 19 Bones and Joints, Story (Walking in plaster)

Augusto Sarmiento worked in Miami in the 1960s on the functional below-knee cast

To check against
Not in the library. Sarmiento, functional below-the-knee cast, JBJS 1967
The verdict
OPEN
19-7 open 19 Bones and Joints, Bench 19.1

Severe sprain: raised 2 to 3 days, then a below-knee cast for 10 days. Ice X

To check against
WO-06 Protocol 13 (Lamb 2009 CAST trial), WO-06 grades
The verdict
OPEN