THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 20: Burns, Cold and Heat

62 claims, 44 marked for safety

20-1 Safety open 20 Burns, Cold and Heat, Opening, Bench 20.1, Numbers

The person's own hand with fingers is about 1% of the skin (adult nearer 0.7 to 0.8, palm alone 0.4 to 0.5)

To check against
Giannou and Baldan, ICRC War Surgery vol. 1 ch. 15, 2009. Rossiter 1996 (via WO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
20-10 Safety open Clock line, Opening, Story, Bench 20.2, Numbers

20 minutes of cool running water within 3 hours. 20 beat 5, 10 and 30 in pigs. Delay up to 1 hour still helped. Guidelines range from at least 10 (ILCOR 2015) to at least 20

To check against
Cuttle 2008. Griffin 2020. McLure 2021
The verdict
OPEN
20-11 Safety open Bench 20.2

Chemical burns: brush off powder, flood at least 20 minutes. Eyes: 20 minutes with lids held open

To check against
WHO 2023. ICRC 2009 (via WO-04 protocol 1)
The verdict
OPEN
20-12 Safety open Story, Bench 20.2

Cool the burn, not the person. Stop at shivering or blue lips

To check against
Venter. WHO 2023 (via WO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
20-16 Safety open Bench 20.3, If it goes wrong

Never plain water as the main drink. Drink is ORS as in 05.2. Plain water and even ORS in volume lower sodium

To check against
Kramer 2010. El-Sonbaty 1991. Moyer 1949
The verdict
OPEN
20-18 Safety open Bench 20.3, Numbers

Oral fluid: adults 2, children 3 ml × kg × % in 24 hours from the burn, half in 8 hours, a quarter in each next 8. Children add breast milk and usual drinks

To check against
ICRC 2009 (via WO-04 protocol 3)
The verdict
OPEN
20-19 Safety open Bench 20.3

Drink table, draft arithmetic: ml an hour = rate × kg × % ÷ 16, rounded to 5 ml. 10 kg: 20, 40, 55, 75. 20 kg: 40, 75, 110, 150. 50 kg: 125, 190, 250. 70 kg: 175, 260, 350. Worked example 70 kg, 30%: 4,200 ml a day, 2,100 in 8 h, about 260 ml/h. Cross-check against WHO 100 ml/kg over 20% (70 kg gives about 440 ml/h)

To check against
Recompute by two people. Leclerc 2021. WO-04 worked example
The verdict
OPEN
20-2 Safety open Bench 20.1

Rule of nines: head 9, arm 9, front 18, back 18, leg 18, genitals 1. Under 1 year: head 18, leg 14

To check against
Wallace 1951. ICRC 2009 Annex 15.A (via WO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
20-20 Safety open Bench 20.3

Day 2: about a quarter of day 1 plus usual drinks

To check against
WO-04 protocol 3 step 9. ICRC 2009
The verdict
OPEN
20-21 Safety open Bench 20.3

Urine aim adults 0.5 ml/kg/h (35 ml at 70 kg). Children about 1 ml/kg/h (WO-04: secondary source only). Nappy 1 g about 1 ml

To check against
ICRC 2009. A paediatric burns guideline for the child figure
The verdict
OPEN
20-22 Safety open Bench 20.3, If it goes wrong

Under the aim for 2 hours: raise by a quarter. Over it with a swelling face: reduce

To check against
WO-04 protocol 3 step 6 (source of the quarter not named)
The verdict
OPEN
20-23 Safety open Bench 20.3

Vomiting: pause 10 minutes, then sips. Over 2 hours: tube by trained hands or district

To check against
WO-04 protocol 3. Kramer 2010
The verdict
OPEN
20-24 Safety open Story, Bench 20.3 grades, Numbers

By mouth up to about 40%. No study over 55%. Hsiao 2024: 3 RCTs, 100 people, OR 1.33 (0.33 to 5.36). Animals worse than IV, better than none. Nepal pilot 9 of 15 switched

To check against
Hsiao 2024 (Burns Open 8(4))
The verdict
OPEN
20-25 Safety open Story (turn)

Cost of no drip: some people with burns of about 25 to 40% will die who would have lived with a drip. Draft's inference

To check against
Hsiao 2024. Kramer 2010. Owner decision (concept note default 10)
The verdict
OPEN
20-28 Safety open Bench 20.3

Unsurvivable burn: often lucid for hours or days. Full pain relief, never withheld for fear of shortening life

To check against
WO-04. SY-07 card
The verdict
OPEN
20-3 Safety open Bench 20.1

Never guess size by eye. Count unburned skin as a check, estimates run up to 25% high

To check against
ICRC 2009 (via WO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
20-30 Safety open Bench 20.4

Honey 15 to 30 ml under gauze, changed every 2 days. ICRC: equal parts honey and ghee or oil over gauze. Whole dressing every 1 to 2 days, daily with pus or smell

To check against
Jull 2015 (Cochrane table). ICRC 2009
The verdict
OPEN
20-32 Safety open Bench 20.4

Banana leaf: midrib out, boiled 5 to 10 minutes, used within 3 days (WO-04 body text says 3 to 4)

To check against
Gore and Akolekar 2003
The verdict
OPEN
20-33 Safety open Bench 20.4

Never let a burned joint rest in the position of comfort. Neck no pillow, arm out about 90°, wrist back 20 to 30°, knuckles bent, fingers straight, knee straight, ankle 90°. Move twice a day. Angles graded D

To check against
Serghiou 2016. ICRC 2009. Chinese Burn Association 2015
The verdict
OPEN
20-36 Safety open Bench 20.4

Refuse silver sulfadiazine on clean partial burns (slower healing)

To check against
Wasiak 2022 (Cochrane). FO-09 (1A)
The verdict
OPEN
20-37 Safety open Story, Bench 20.5, Numbers

Never rub frostbite, never fire, stove or hot stone. Thaw in water at 37 to 39 °C

To check against
McIntosh 2024 (WMS frostbite guideline). Fuhrman and Crismon 1947. Mills 1960
The verdict
OPEN
20-38 Safety open Story, Bench 20.5

Never thaw if it may refreeze. Walking out on frozen feet is allowed. Never walk on a thawed foot

To check against
McIntosh 2024. FO-09
The verdict
OPEN
20-39 Safety open Bench 20.5, Numbers

No thermometer: water an unhurt hand tolerates for 30 seconds. About 30 minutes until red or purple, soft

To check against
McIntosh 2024 (via HY-11 protocol 3)
The verdict
OPEN
20-4 Safety open Bench 20.1

A deep burn round a limb or the chest goes to the district for cutting within 48 hours

To check against
ICRC 2009. FO-09 (escharotomy 1A)
The verdict
OPEN
20-40 Safety open Bench 20.5

Ibuprofen in frostbite 12 mg/kg/day in 2 doses, ceiling 2,400 mg/day, 400 mg twice daily at 70 kg. Weight-band table is draft arithmetic at 6 mg/kg per dose on the lower edge of each band (10 kg 60 mg, 15 kg 90, 20 kg 120, 30 kg 180, 40 kg 200, 50 kg 300, 70 kg 400). Syrup 100 mg in 5 ml, tablet 200 mg. Under 10 kg healer only

To check against
McIntosh 2024. HY-11 (resolving FO-09's apparent conflict). A children's formulary for under 10 kg and the syrup strength
The verdict
OPEN
20-41 Safety open Bench 20.5

No ibuprofen in pregnancy after 20 weeks, kidney disease, dehydration, bleeding

To check against
HY-11. Product label
The verdict
OPEN
20-43 Safety open Bench 20.6, If it goes wrong

Never hot bath, shower or heat to the limbs in hypothermia. Heat to chest, armpits and back

To check against
Dow 2019 (WMS hypothermia, 1B, 1C). SY-10 H52
The verdict
OPEN
20-44 Safety open Bench 20.6, 20.8

Applied heat hand-hot 40 to 42 °C, cloth between, skin checked every 10 minutes (NU-08). HY-11 says every 20 to 30 minutes. Draft takes the stricter

To check against
NU-08 (Goltsman 2015, NITE 2009). Dow 2019
The verdict
OPEN
20-45 Safety open Story, Bench 20.6

Hypothermic arrest: feel the neck pulse a full minute. Continue through fixed pupils and stiffness. Few rescuers: at least 5 minutes of compressions, pauses no longer than 5 minutes. Stop on exhaustion or asphyxia before cooling

To check against
Dow 2019. ERC 2021 (via HY-11)
The verdict
OPEN
20-49 Safety open Clock line, Opening, Story, Bench 20.7, Numbers

Heat stroke: cool first, carry second. Below 39 °C within 30 minutes of collapse. Stop at 39 °C

To check against
Casa (Falmouth). Lipman 2019. SY-10 H52
The verdict
OPEN
20-5 Safety open Bench 20.1

Airway burn signs (closed room, face or neck burns, singed nose hairs, soot, hoarse voice). The throat may swell shut within hours

To check against
ICRC 2009 (via WO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
20-50 Safety open Story, Bench 20.7

Immersion from the neck down in water 1 to 26 °C. One named person holds the head. Tarpaulin with 4 people. Ice to cheeks, palms, soles if no water. Rates 0.11 against 0.02 °C/min, ice packs at neck, groin and armpits no better than fan

To check against
Douma 2020. ILCOR first aid review. Luhring 2016. Hosokawa 2017
The verdict
OPEN
20-51 Safety open Bench 20.7

Never ice packs straight on bare skin (a toddler needed grafts)

To check against
Rittblat 2025 (via NU-08)
The verdict
OPEN
20-52 Safety open Bench 20.7

No antipyretics in heat stroke

To check against
Lipman 2019 (2B)
The verdict
OPEN
20-53 Safety open Story (Broker), Bench 20.7, Numbers

Disputed line C21: heat stroke mortality about 10%, 33% with low pressure (HY-11), against about 5% (FO-09, Nelson 2025). Printed both, not settled

To check against
Lipman 2019 or the 2024 WMS heat guideline. Nelson 2025. SY-12 C21
The verdict
OPEN
20-54 Safety open Bench 20.7

Heat exhaustion under 40 °C with clear mind. Too much water: normal temperature, confused, after much drinking: salt, no more water

To check against
Lipman 2019. HY-11 protocol 5
The verdict
OPEN
20-57 Safety open Opening, Story (turn), Bench 20.8, Numbers

Never a hot-water bottle, hot stone or brick on numb, sleeping or cold skin. Skin burns at 44 °C in hours, 50 °C in 2 to 3 minutes. A bottle stays above 50 °C for 3 hours. No unattended heat for the sleeping, drunk, sedated, numb, confused, babies

To check against
Moritz and Henriques 1947. NITE Japan 2009. Goltsman 2015. SY-10 H14
The verdict
OPEN
20-59 Safety open Bench 20.8

Heat work: 8 to 14 days to acclimatise. Drink to thirst with salt (loss under 2% of weight)

To check against
Lipman 2019
The verdict
OPEN
20-6 Safety open Opening, Bench 20.1, 20.3, Numbers

Drink from 10% burn in a child, 15% in an adult. Opening's "fifteen of an adult's hands" rests on this

To check against
ICRC 2009. Kramer 2010
The verdict
OPEN
20-7 Safety open Story (Broker), Bench 20.1, Numbers

Beyond the village: over about 40% in a young adult, about 20% deep over 60, age plus per cent near 100, or serious smoke injury. WO-04's own inference

To check against
Bull and Squire 1949, Bull 1954. Osler 2010. Tyson 2013 (Lilongwe, LA50 39%). SY-07 card
The verdict
OPEN
20-8 Safety open Bench 20.1

Household rule: any burn bigger than the child's palm goes to the healer (the author's decision)

To check against
WO-04 (household rule)
The verdict
OPEN
20-9 Safety open Story, Bench 20.2, If it goes wrong

Never ice, iced water, butter, oil, toothpaste or paste. Ice cooled fastest and healed worst in pigs

To check against
Cuttle 2008. Venter (UCT). Sawada 1997. WHO burns fact sheet 2023. McLure 2021
The verdict
OPEN
20-13 open Story

Queensland 2013 to 2016: 2,495 children, 90.6% some water, 71.3% full first aid, OR 0.6 for grafting. ANZ adults 2009 to 2012: 2,897, grafts down 13%, ICU down 48%, dose response

To check against
Griffin 2020 (Ann Emerg Med). Wood 2016 (PLoS One)
The verdict
OPEN
20-14 open Story

Cuttle 2008 pig design: 15 °C running water against 2 °C, ice, none

To check against
Cuttle 2008 (Wound Repair Regen 16:626)
The verdict
OPEN
20-15 open Story

Tannic acid: Davidson, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, 1925. Liver damage worst in tanned patients by 1944. Cocoanut Grove, Boston, 28 November 1942, 492 dead, petrolatum gauze at MGH

To check against
Davidson 1925. Cope 1943. Nature 1944 (secondary in WO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
20-26 open Story

Oral history: Lima 1956, 111 people at 110 ml/kg, over half under-resuscitated. 1966 vomiting 30% children, 51% adults. Sørensen, Denmark 1968, 26 people to 45%, 5 g salt and 2.5 g baking soda per litre, 150 to 200 ml/kg day 1, 80% no drip. Ahnefeld 1975: 4 of 58 within 1 hour, 16 of 23 after 2 hours could not drink

To check against
Kramer 2010 and the primary papers (Markley 1956, Jackson and Chen 1966, Sørensen 1968, Ahnefeld 1975)
The verdict
OPEN
20-27 open Story

Parkland: Baxter and Shires, Dallas, 1968, 3.5 to 4 ml/kg/% in 24 h, half in 8. Pruitt 2000 "fluid creep". Engrav: 58% over Parkland against 12% in Baxter's series

To check against
Baxter and Shires 1968. Pruitt 2000. Engrav 2000
The verdict
OPEN
20-31 open Story (Broker), Bench 20.4 grades

Honey: 4.68 days faster than conventional (2 trials, 992, high quality). 5.12 days against SSD (very low quality). Grafting 13.6 days better (1 trial of 50). Most trials by Subrahmanyam. Wijesinghe 2009: every trial Jadad 1. Grades A partial with caveat, D full

To check against
Jull 2015. Wijesinghe 2009. Newswise 2015 for Jull's warning. Dates of Subrahmanyam's trials not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
20-34 open Bench 20.4

Feeding within 24 hours. Protein 2 g/kg adult, 3 g/kg child. No raw eggs

To check against
ICRC 2009
The verdict
OPEN
20-35 open Bench 20.4

Still granulating at 3 weeks needs a graft

To check against
ICRC 2009
The verdict
OPEN
20-42 open Story

Mills, Alaska 1960 to 1961, 130 cases and 400 records, bath 38 to 45 °C later capped at 42. Amputation figures untraced. 27% amputation in 182 severe cases. Napoleon's surgeon 1812 credited with snow-rubbing. Fuhrman and Crismon 1947

To check against
Mills 1960s papers. HY-11 sources
The verdict
OPEN
20-46 open Story, Bench 20.6

Shivering in insulation rewarms 3 to 4 °C an hour. Water conducts heat about 24 times better than air. Glass thermometers read no lower than about 35.6 °C

To check against
Dow 2019. Lipman 2019
The verdict
OPEN
20-47 open Story

Narvik, May 1999, about 80 minutes, 13.7 °C, survived on bypass (details conflict). 6 h 30 min CPR survived. Tromsø 9 of 24, 1999 to 2013

To check against
Gilbert 2000 (Lancet). HY-11 sources
The verdict
OPEN
20-48 open Story

Fox 1973: about 1 in 10 old people at home below 35.5 °C, winter 1972

To check against
Fox 1973 (BMJ)
The verdict
OPEN
20-55 open Story

Falmouth: 274 heat strokes over 18 years, no deaths. 454 by 2019, no deaths

To check against
DeMartini 2015. Later Falmouth series
The verdict
OPEN
20-56 open Story

Chicago July 1995: 485 to 514 heat deaths, 696 to 739 excess. Odds: bed 8.2, not leaving home 6.7, top floor 4.7, alone 2.3, air conditioner 0.3, transport 0.3. Europe August 2003 over 70,000

To check against
Semenza 1996 (NEJM). Robine 2008
The verdict
OPEN
20-58 open Story (turn)

Rotterdam: 6 men with diabetes, burns found a median 27 days late, 5 lost part of a foot or leg. Stoke Mandeville banned bottles in 1976

To check against
Dijkstra 1997. Guttmann 1976 (via NU-09)
The verdict
OPEN
20-60 open Story (Broker)

Dachau 1942, 80 to 90 killed. Data falsified (1990)

To check against
Berger 1990 (NEJM). Alexander 1945
The verdict
OPEN
20-61 open Story (Broker)

FEASTING after the FALL's vinegar after lye is unsupported

To check against
WO-04. The FEASTING text itself
The verdict
OPEN
20-62 open Story

Order of burn death, leak normalising in 24 to 48 hours, the middle zone

To check against
ICRC 2009
The verdict
OPEN