PAIRING · Part II · The Campfire Contract
The numbers and sources
Chapter 9: Who Keeps Children Alive
The narrated edition tells this chapter with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 76 open
- 37 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- 45 natural-fertility populations: the mother's presence improved child survival in 100 per cent of studies, older siblings' in 83, the maternal grandmother's in 69, the father's in 32 (Sear and Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior, per FA-03 and DH-08). Rows C09-01, C09-02.
- Krummhörn, about 32,000 parish records, eighteenth and nineteenth centuries: a paternal grandmother in the household raised neonatal mortality 2.48 times, a maternal grandmother lowered infant mortality (Voland and Beise 2002, per FA-03, which names the journal two ways). Row C09-12.
- South Africa, early 1990s: a pension to a grandmother raised granddaughters' weight-for-height by 1.19 standard deviations and height-for-age by 1.16, with no effect on grandsons and none from grandfathers (Duflo 2003, World Bank Economic Review, per FA-03). Rows C09-22, C09-23.
- Toy preference: boys for boy-typical toys d = 1.83, girls for girl-typical toys d = 1.60, 113 effect sizes, 75 studies (Todd et al. 2018, per the FA-04 PDF). Parents' control of boys versus girls: d = 0.08, autonomy support 0.03, 126 studies, 15,034 families (Endendijk et al. 2016, PLoS ONE, per AN-10). Rows C09-42, C09-47.
- Single-sex schooling after controls: g = 0.10 for girls and 0.06 for boys in mathematics, 0.06 and 0.04 in science, 184 studies, 1.66 million pupils, 21 countries (Pahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014, Psychological Bulletin, per the FA-04 PDF). Teachers' marks: girls ahead at d = 0.225 overall, 0.374 in languages, 0.069 in mathematics, 502 effect sizes (Voyer and Voyer 2014, per the FA-04 PDF). Rows C09-55, C09-50.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding in the data edition's chapter, whether or not the narrated edition kept it. Layer says whether it belongs to physiology, behaviour or culture. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Study (authors, year, venue, N) | Document | Row | Layer | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 45 populations, 2008 | Natural-fertility populations, historical and living, in which a child's survival could be matched against which relatives were alive and nearby | Sear and Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior 29(1), 45 populations. "Working in London" is general knowledge, not in the documents | FA-03, DH-08 | C09-01 | behaviour | robust, affiliation open |
| 100 per cent | Share of populations in which the mother's presence improved child survival | Sear and Mace 2008 | FA-03, DH-08 | C09-02 | behaviour | robust |
| 83 per cent | Share in which older siblings improved a younger child's survival | Sear and Mace 2008 | FA-03 | C09-02 | behaviour | robust |
| 69 per cent | Share in which the maternal grandmother improved child survival | Sear and Mace 2008 | FA-03 | C09-02 | behaviour | robust |
| 32 per cent, 2 of 4 hunter-gatherer, 5 of 18 horticultural | Share in which the father's presence improved child survival | Sear and Mace 2008. DH-08 gives "one third" | FA-03, DH-08 | C09-02 | behaviour | robust |
| Mother's death the single most reliable predictor | Which death most reliably predicts a child's | Sear and Mace 2008 | DH-08 | C09-03 | behaviour | robust |
| Variable, negative in some populations | Paternal grandmother's effect on child survival | Sear and Mace 2008 | DH-08 | C09-04 | behaviour | robust |
| Without contraception, mostly without doctors, parish registers to field notes | The narrator's gloss on "natural fertility" | No document says "without doctors" | none | C09-05 | culture | open |
| Decades past the last birth, almost no other land mammal | Human post-reproductive lifespan | FA-03 ("30 to 40 years beyond", unique among terrestrial mammals, present in some toothed whales) | FA-03 | C09-06 | physiology | robust |
| Grandmother hypothesis | Old women fed their daughters' weaned children so the daughters could bear again sooner | Hawkes, O'Connell and Blurton Jones 1997, Current Anthropology, and 1998, PNAS | FA-03 | C09-07 | physiology | contested |
| Mother hypothesis, 2008 | Late births risk maternal death and orphaning, so reproduction stops as a stop-loss | Pavard, Metcalf and Heyer 2008, American Journal of Physical Anthropology. First name Samuel from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-08 | physiology | contested |
| Reproductive conflict hypothesis, 2008, a quarter of genes | Female-biased dispersal: the incoming wife is unrelated to her mother-in-law, who shares a quarter of her genes with the wife's children, so the older woman yields | Cant and Johnstone 2008, PNAS 105(14). First names from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-09, C09-10 | physiology | contested |
| Krummhörn, East Frisia, far north-west of Germany | Location of the parish registers | FA-03 gives only "the Krummhörn region of Germany", the CO and FA digest gives East Frisia, "far north-west" is the narrator's | FA-03 | C09-11 | culture | open |
| About 32,000 records, 18th and 19th centuries, 2.48 times | Parish reconstructions: maternal grandmother alive and nearby lowered infant mortality, paternal grandmother in the household raised neonatal mortality 2.48 times | Voland and Beise 2002, Demographic Research in FA-03's text, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 52(6) in its key sources. First names from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-12 | behaviour | robust, journal open |
| "The husband's mother is the devil in house" | Title of the same authors' work on the registers, the chapter's one quotation | FA-03 works cited 48, a ResearchGate entry on stillbirth mortality, which may be a different paper from the one carrying the 2.48 | FA-03 | C09-13 | culture | open |
| Dogon of Mali, hazard ratio 2.0, under five | Child living with a paternal grandmother faced twice the hazard of death, patrilocal, longitudinal | Strassmann 2011, PNAS 108(27). Michigan affiliation is general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-14 | behaviour | robust, affiliation open |
| Girls grew faster without the maternal grandmother | Dogon girls spared weeding, the old woman as another mouth when calories are short | Strassmann 2011, PNAS | FA-03 | C09-15 | behaviour | robust |
| Finland, 32,000 people, 36 kinds of relative, 2019 and 2023 | Historical parish records tested relative by relative against child mortality | Chapman et al. 2019, Current Biology, and 2023, Proceedings of the Royal Society B. FA-03 also lists a 2024/2025 Evolutionary Human Sciences paper. First name from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-16 | behaviour | robust, which paper open |
| Hazard ratios 0.70 and 0.60, about 30 and 40 per cent | Maternal grandmother's effect on death from smallpox and from diarrhoeal disease | Chapman et al. 2023. The percentages are the narrator's arithmetic | FA-03 | C09-17 | behaviour | robust |
| Paternal grandmothers and cousins raised mortality, most in the wealthiest families | The inheritance reading | Chapman et al., paper not specified in FA-03 | FA-03 | C09-18, C09-75 | behaviour | robust, narrator's sharpening |
| 1,857 adults, 1996 | Care received from each grandparent: maternal grandmother, maternal grandfather, paternal grandmother, paternal grandfather, in that order. Paternity-uncertainty explanation | Euler and Weitzel 1996, Human Nature. First names from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-19 | behaviour | robust |
| A quarter autosomal, half of X genes with a granddaughter, none with a grandson, seven populations, 2010 | X-chromosome relatedness as the mechanism of grandmother favouritism, paternal grandmother raising granddaughters' and lowering grandsons' survival | Fox et al. 2010, Proceedings of the Royal Society B 277(1681), "Grandma plays favourites". First name from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-20 | physiology, effect is behaviour | contested |
| "The devil in the house was a hungry house" | Mechanism is food and inheritance, so not operative with vaccines and a supermarket | Narrator's synthesis. FA-03 lists the mechanism as its own open question | FA-03 | C09-21 | culture | open |
| South Africa, early 1990s, twice the median rural income per head, paid to the old person | Extension of the old-age pension to Black households | Duflo 2003, World Bank Economic Review 17(1). MIT affiliation is general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-22 | culture | robust, affiliation open |
| 1.19 and 1.16 standard deviations, grandsons nothing, grandfathers nothing | Weight-for-height and height-for-age of granddaughters living with a pensioner grandmother | Duflo 2003 | FA-03 | C09-23 | physiology | robust |
| 1993 | Year of Duflo's data, given in the data edition's case against | Not in FA-03 text or PDF. Dropped from the narrated edition | none | C09-24 | culture | open |
| Single purse | The unitary-household model that Duflo's finding overturns | FA-03 ("unitary entity"), no primary named | FA-03 | C09-25 | culture | robust |
| 42 countries, 2020 and 2021 | Strongest country-level predictor of parental burnout was individualism, not wealth, inequality or mothers' work hours | Mikolajczak, Roskam et al. 2021, International Investigation of Parental Burnout. First names from general knowledge | FA-03 | C09-26 | behaviour | robust |
| 25 studies, 77 communities | Cohousing review in rich countries: more mutual support, less isolation | FA-03 works cited 70, no author or year | FA-03 | C09-27 | behaviour | open |
| Odds ratio 1.50 | Low neighbourhood connectedness among mothers and physically harsh parenting | FA-03 works cited 71, no author named | FA-03 | C09-28 | behaviour | open |
| 3.1 million couples, US census 1900 to 1910, 2016 | Kin proximity raised fertility in historical populations, mixed or negative effects of kin in modern high-income societies | Sear 2016, Comparative Population Studies | FA-03 | C09-29 | behaviour | robust |
| 4.03 points on a 100-point scale, CI 5.93 to 2.14 | Mental health of young adults forced to co-reside with parents by housing costs and insecure work | FA-03 works cited 69, no author, year or journal | FA-03 | C09-30 | behaviour | open |
| 1,701 child-carer pairs, 2019 | Agta: kin give care by the child's need, non-kin by reciprocity, reciprocity as strong a predictor as blood | Page et al. 2019, Evolution and Human Behavior. FA-03 gives the same N for Meehan 2013 among the Aka | DH-08, FA-03 | C09-31, C09-76 | behaviour | robust, N open |
| 174 studies, 22,914 pairs, r = .26 and .21 | Maternal and paternal sensitivity as predictors of infant attachment security, overlapping confidence intervals | Van IJzendoorn and colleagues, paper not named in DH-08. Figures recovered from the PDF | DH-08 | C09-32 | behaviour | robust, paper open |
| Network of attachments | The multiple caretaker paradox and its integrative resolution | Van IJzendoorn, Sagi and Lambermon 1992, not named in DH-08 | DH-08 | C09-33 | behaviour | robust |
| d = 0.77 | Rise in disorganised attachment in families under severe economic and social strain | Cyr, Euser, Bakermans-Kranenburg and van IJzendoorn, per DH-08 ref 65, figure recovered from the PDF | DH-08 | C09-34 | behaviour | robust |
| Nine studies, 303 children, r = .18, CI .06 to .29, under 36 months, 2006 | Cortisol rising from morning to afternoon at centre-based daycare and not at home | Vermeer and van IJzendoorn 2006, Early Childhood Research Quarterly. First name from general knowledge | DH-08 | C09-35 | physiology | robust, modest |
| Later-life meaning unknown, flat comparison never run | What the cortisol rise means and which comparison is missing | Narrator's assertion. DH-08 calls the finding an evolutionary mismatch | DH-08 | C09-36 | culture | open |
| 50 Aka and 48 Ngandu children, until four or five, 2016 | Adults dominate teaching only until four or five, then other children | Boyette 2016, Child Development | DH-08 | C09-37, C09-70 | behaviour | robust |
| Seventh week of gestation, 2005, cameras | CAH girls exposed to adrenal androgens, parents praised them more for playing with dolls, girls chose trucks anyway, dose-response with severity | Pasterski et al. 2005, Archives of Sexual Behavior in FA-04, Child Development in AN-10 | FA-04, AN-10 | C09-38 | physiology, parents' behaviour is culture | robust, journal open |
| 135 rhesus macaques, 34 juveniles, 2008 | Males to wheeled toys consistently, females to both | Hassett, Siebert and Wallen 2008, Hormones and Behavior. First names from general knowledge | AN-10 | C09-39 | behaviour | robust |
| 63 vervet monkeys, 2002 | Same pattern | Alexander and Hines 2002, Evolution and Human Behavior. First names from general knowledge | AN-10 | C09-40 | behaviour | robust |
| 30 infants, three to eight months, d above 1.0 and 0.78, 2009 | Eye-tracking: girls look at a doll over a truck, boys at the truck | Alexander 2009, Archives of Sexual Behavior | AN-10 | C09-41 | behaviour | robust |
| 113 effect sizes, 75 studies, d = 1.83 and 1.60, by twelve months, 2018 | Toy preferences, boys for boy-typical and girls for girl-typical toys | Todd et al. 2018, Infant and Child Development. d values recovered from the FA-04 PDF. First name from general knowledge | FA-04 | C09-42 | behaviour | robust |
| Same league as height, overlapping | Size of the toy difference against chapter 4's yardstick | FA-04 ("among the largest psychological sex differences documented") | FA-04 | C09-43 | behaviour | robust |
| 102 newborns, under a day old, 2000 | Boys looked longer at a mobile, girls at a face | Connellan, Baron-Cohen et al. 2000, Infant Behavior and Development | AN-10 | C09-44 | behaviour | fallen |
| 31 studies, 40 experiments, 1,936 newborns, g = 0.076, p = 0.321 | Meta-analysis: no sex difference in newborn looking at faces | AN-10 ref 25, a ResearchGate page, authors and year not given | AN-10 | C09-45 | behaviour | robust |
| Between the newborn null and the twelve-month difference | What happens in the first year is unknown | AN-10's own open question | AN-10 | C09-46 | behaviour | open |
| 126 studies, 15,034 families, d = 0.08 and 0.03, 2016 | Observed parental control and autonomy support of sons against daughters, post-industrial societies | Endendijk et al. 2016, PLoS ONE. First name from general knowledge | AN-10 | C09-47 | culture | robust |
| Children sort themselves, marketing sells to the sort | Self-socialisation reading of the null | AN-10's own interpretation, no primary | AN-10 | C09-48 | culture | contested |
| d = 1.01 effortful control, 0.55 surgency, 0.06 negative affectivity, older cohorts, 2006 | Childhood temperament factors by sex, gap widening through childhood | Else-Quest, Hyde and colleagues 2006. Figures recovered from the FA-04 PDF. First name from general knowledge | FA-04 | C09-49 | behaviour | robust |
| 502 effect sizes, 369 samples, d = 0.225, 0.374 languages, 0.069 mathematics, 2014 | Teachers' marks, primary school to university, girls ahead in every subject, as far back as samples go | Voyer and Voyer 2014, Psychological Bulletin 140(4). d values recovered from the PDF. First names from FA-04 works cited | FA-04 | C09-50 | behaviour | robust |
| d = 0.20 is 92 per cent shared area | Overlap arithmetic | Chapter 4's formula, not in FA-04 | none | C09-51 | behaviour | robust |
| Boys' historical small lead on standardised tests in mathematics and science | Test against mark | FA-04, no primary named | FA-04 | C09-52 | behaviour | open |
| PISA 2025: boys' reading down 17 points against 12, girls ahead in 89 of 90 systems, 37 against 25 per cent below baseline, boys' maths lead carried by a top group | Post-pandemic international test results by sex | OECD PISA 2025 Results Volume I per FA-04 refs 23 to 25, a data-journalism page among them | FA-04 | C09-53 | behaviour | open |
| Prefrontal cortex matures later, start boys a year later, 2022 | Structural reading of the boy gap and the redshirting proposal, untested at scale | Reeves 2022, Of Boys and Men, Brookings. FA-04 refs are a podcast page and a Reddit thread | FA-04 | C09-54 | physiology, proposal is culture | open |
| 184 studies, 1.66 million pupils, 21 countries, g = 0.10 and 0.06 mathematics, 0.06 and 0.04 science, 2014 | Single-sex schooling after controls for selection | Pahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014, Psychological Bulletin 140(4). g values recovered from the PDF | FA-04 | C09-55 | culture | robust, raw advantage fallen |
| Sax and Gurian against Hyde and Halpern | Advocates' and critics' arguments on single-sex schooling | FA-04 refs 32 and 33, a German thesis and a US principals' survey, no primary named | FA-04 | C09-56 | culture | contested |
| A tenth of a standard deviation is a good night's sleep | Comparison | Not a cited figure | none | C09-57 | behaviour | open |
| Up to a third of the English gap, 2007 | Boy with a male teacher did better, rated better, more engaged, mirror for girls in science and mathematics | Dee 2007, Journal of Human Resources 42(3). FA-04 refs are a working draft and NBER w11660 | FA-04 | C09-58 | culture | robust |
| 55 to 70 evaluations, more than 25,000 young people, d = 0.18 to 0.21, 2011 | Youth mentoring effects | DuBois et al. 2011, Psychological Science in the Public Interest. d values recovered from the PDF. First name from general knowledge | FA-04 | C09-59 | behaviour | robust |
| More than a year against inside six months | Mentor duration: long mentoring helped, short mentoring did measurable harm | FA-04 attributes this to ref 36 (PMC8198211), not to DuBois. The classic source is Grossman and Rhodes 2002. The narrated edition states it without a name | FA-04 | C09-60 | behaviour | robust, attribution open |
| Eleven and fourteen, 1982 | Loss of voice in adolescent girls | Gilligan 1982, In a Different Voice. The ages are the narrator's | FA-04 | C09-61 | culture | contested |
| Theran 2003 | Loss of voice tied to girls' depression and eating disorders | FA-04, venue stripped in extraction, ref 43 may be Smolak and Munstertieger 2002 | FA-04 | C09-62 | behaviour | open |
| Thirteen and fourteen, seventeen, hundreds of interviews, 2011 | Boys' intimate friendships in early adolescence, lost by late adolescence, the mask, tracking depression, isolation and suicide | Way 2011, Deep Secrets. NYU affiliation is general knowledge | FA-04 | C09-63 | culture | robust, affiliation open |
| 2023 | The ethic of care is human, coded feminine and taken from boys | Gilligan 2023, In a Human Voice, Polity | FA-04 | C09-64 | culture | robust |
| About 1 per cent of variance, three decades, 2021 | Sex and human brain structure after correcting for size, task-based imaging not replicated | Eliot et al. 2021, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, "Dump the dimorphism" | AN-10 | C09-65 | physiology | robust |
| 2015 | Cooperative breeding does not buy cognition, against Hrdy and Burkart | Thornton and McAuliffe 2015, Journal of Zoology 295. Burkart, Hrdy and van Schaik 2009 | DH-08 | C09-66 | behaviour | contested |
| "The ration in that house was not short" | Narrator's assertion about Duflo's households, kept in the narrated edition as the narrator's opinion ("I would not call that house a hungry one") | Not in FA-03. Duflo's outcome measures were chosen because the children were at risk of malnutrition, so the claim may contradict the study's premise | FA-03 | C09-67 | culture | open |
| Grandmother within an hour lowers burnout | In practice extrapolation from a country-level finding | FA-03's burnout finding is country-level, not about grandmother proximity. The narrated edition says only "more hands in the room" | FA-03 | C09-68 | behaviour | open |
| Two adults and nobody else appear in none of the 45 populations | In practice inference | Sear and Mace 2008 and DH-08 ("evolutionarily unprecedented"), not stated as such in either | FA-03, DH-08 | C09-69 | behaviour | open |
| Children raised by other children for most of the time there have been children | In practice extension of Boyette | DH-08 (Boyette 2016, Page et al. 2021 on Agta playgroups), the phrase is the narrator's | DH-08 | C09-70 | behaviour | open |
| "Let him wrestle" | Rough-and-tumble play as where boys already are | AN-10's rat and human rough-and-tumble literature, no human primary named here | AN-10 | C09-71 | behaviour | open |
| First names and affiliations from general knowledge | Pavard, Cant, Johnstone, Voland, Beise, Chapman, Euler, Weitzel, Fox, Mikolajczak, Roskam, Vermeer, Hassett, Siebert, Wallen, Alexander, Hines, Todd, Endendijk, Else-Quest, Voyer, DuBois. Affiliations: Sear and Mace, Strassmann, Duflo, Way | No document gives them except Voyer and Hines | none | C09-74 | culture | open |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- The grandmother is the person other than the mother who most reliably keeps a child alive across the human record, and the father's presence matters in about a third of populations (Sear and Mace 2008, FA-03, DH-08, C09-02).
- Which grandmother matters: the maternal grandmother lowers mortality, the paternal grandmother raises it in Krummhörn, among the Dogon and in Finland, and most where there is most to inherit (Voland and Beise 2002, Strassmann 2011, Chapman 2019 and 2023, FA-03, C09-12 to C09-18).
- The mechanism is food and inheritance, with X-chromosome favouritism as a candidate, not malice, so it does not transfer to a flat with a fridge (Fox 2010, FA-03, C09-20, C09-21).
- Money in a grandmother's hand reaches the child, measured on the child's body, and money in a grandfather's hand does not (Duflo 2003, FA-03, C09-23).
- A mother's work does not harm a child when someone else is in the room: individualism, not mothers' hours, predicts parental burnout across countries (Mikolajczak et al. 2021, FA-03, C09-26), fathers' sensitivity predicts attachment as well as mothers' (van IJzendoorn, DH-08, C09-32), the infant forms a network of attachments and suffers when the network collapses (DH-08, C09-33, C09-34).
- Kin help when voluntary and harm when forced, and reciprocity predicts care as strongly as blood (Sear 2016, Page 2019, FA-03, DH-08, C09-29 to C09-31).
- The nursery cortisol rise is real, modest and of unknown consequence, and the comparison with an isolated flat has not been run (Vermeer and van IJzendoorn 2006, DH-08, C09-35, C09-36).
- Boys and girls arrive alike on the first day and differ a great deal by the first birthday, and parents' observed treatment does not explain it (Pasterski 2005, Todd 2018, Endendijk 2016, FA-04, AN-10, C09-38 to C09-47).
- Girls lead on effortful control and in teachers' marks, always have, and the single-sex school does not help (Else-Quest 2006, Voyer and Voyer 2014, Pahlke 2014, FA-04, C09-49, C09-50, C09-55).
- What helps boys is a man who reads and does not leave (Dee 2007, DuBois 2011 and the duration finding, FA-04, C09-58 to C09-60).
- Girls lose their voice and boys lose their friends in adolescence, and the voice is human (Gilligan 1982 and 2023, Way 2011, FA-04, C09-61 to C09-64).
- The clause is a design, and the modern two-adult flat is the first household built without the person it was written for (narrator's synthesis, C09-69).
The case against
- The grandmother hypothesis was sold on the populations where it worked: under scarcity and patrilocality the old woman is another mouth, doubling child mortality (Strassmann 2011, FA-03, C09-14, C09-15).
- The paternal effect is strongest among the rich, so it is an inheritance story, which is culture (Chapman, FA-03, C09-18).
- The X-chromosome result is a correlation with no observed mechanism (Fox 2010, FA-03, C09-20).
- In high-income societies kin have mixed or negative effects (Sear 2016, FA-03, C09-29), and forced co-residence lowers young adults' mental health by 4.03 points (FA-03, C09-30).
- The child does not care about the sex of the hands (van IJzendoorn, DH-08, C09-32) and the Agta show reciprocity, not blood, predicts care (Page 2019, DH-08, C09-31): the clause reduces to "get help".
- Sex explains about 1 per cent of brain structure after size, and task imaging has not replicated (Eliot 2021, AN-10, C09-65).
- The newborn study fell to a meta-analysis of 1,936 newborns (AN-10, C09-44, C09-45).
- Endendijk's null can be read as proof that peers, screens and shops make the difference (AN-10, C09-47).
- The grade gap is a fifth of a standard deviation, 92 per cent shared, and single-sex schools deliver g = 0.10 and 0.06 (Voyer and Voyer 2014, Pahlke 2014, FA-04, C09-50, C09-51, C09-55).
- Cooperative breeding does not even buy cognition (Thornton and McAuliffe 2015, DH-08, C09-66).
- The narrator's answer rests on Duflo's pension, and on the assertion that the ration in that house was not short, which no document supports (C09-67).
Where the sources disagree
The data edition's Contested list:
- Why menopause exists: Hawkes against Pavard against Cant and Johnstone (FA-03, C09-07 to C09-10).
- Whether the paternal grandmother's effect is X-chromosome favouritism, calorie competition or patrilocal power (FA-03, its own open question, C09-20, C09-21).
- Whether the daycare cortisol rise means anything for outcomes (DH-08, C09-35, C09-36).
- Whether cooperative breeding bought cognition: Hrdy and Burkart against Thornton and McAuliffe (DH-08, C09-66).
- What happens between the newborn's null and the one-year-old's d above 1.0 (AN-10, its own open question, C09-46).
- Whether Endendijk's null on parenting means the difference is in the child or in the agents not measured (AN-10, C09-47, C09-48).
- The PISA 2025 figures, pending the primary volume (FA-04, C09-53).
Report-to-report discrepancies logged in the data edition's working notes:
- Voland and Beise 2002 journal: Demographic Research in FA-03's text, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 52(6) in its key-sources list. The devil-in-the-house title is cited to a ResearchGate entry on stillbirth mortality, which may be a different paper from the one carrying the 2.48 neonatal figure (C09-12, C09-13).
- Pasterski 2005 journal: Child Development in AN-10, Archives of Sexual Behavior in FA-04 (C09-38).
- Gettler 2011 sample: 624 (DH-08, FA-03 initial) against 966 in later waves (FA-03) against 394 to 683 in chapters 3 and 5. Not used in either edition of this chapter.
- 1,701 dyads: FA-03 gives N = 1,701 for Meehan 2013 among the Aka, DH-08 gives 1,701 dyads for Page 2019 among the Agta. Both editions follow DH-08 (C09-31).
- Chapman: FA-03 gives 2019 Current Biology and 2023 Proceedings of the Royal Society B, and its works cited also point to a 2024/2025 Evolutionary Human Sciences paper on close and distant relatives (C09-16).
- Pahlke: the Preface says "a rounding error" and 1.6 million, chapter 5 gives 0.10 and 0.06, the FA-04 PDF gives 1.66 million. The data edition of this chapter uses 1.66 and adds the science figures (C09-55, C09-72).
- Sear and Mace father: FA-03 gives 32 per cent and "2 of 4 hunter-gatherer, 5 of 18 horticultural", DH-08 gives "one third", chapter 2 said "about a third". Consistent (C09-02).
Open questions
The data edition's marks for checking, 25, each with its row:
- Sear and Mace affiliation, "working in London" (C09-01).
- Pavard first name (C09-08).
- Cant and Johnstone first names (C09-09).
- Krummhörn location, East Frisia and "far north-west" (C09-11).
- Voland and Beise first names (C09-12).
- Whether the devil-in-the-house title and the 2.48 belong to the same paper (C09-13).
- Strassmann affiliation, Michigan (C09-14).
- Chapman first name (C09-16).
- Euler and Weitzel first names (C09-19).
- Fox first name (C09-20).
- Duflo affiliation, MIT (C09-22).
- Mikolajczak and Roskam first names (C09-26).
- The harsh-parenting odds ratio 1.50, no author named (C09-28).
- The co-residence 4.03 points, no author named (C09-30).
- Vermeer first name (C09-35).
- Hassett, Siebert and Wallen first names (C09-39).
- Alexander and Hines first names (C09-40).
- Todd first name (C09-42).
- Endendijk first name (C09-47).
- Else-Quest first name (C09-49).
- Voyer first names (C09-50).
- PISA 2025 figures against Volume I (C09-53).
- DuBois first name (C09-59).
- Theran first name and venue (C09-62).
- Way affiliation, New York University (C09-63).
Further open points from the verification rows and the chapter note for the narrated edition:
- 1993 as the year of Duflo's data is in no document. Dropped from the narrated edition (C09-24).
- The mentor-duration finding is attributed by FA-04 to a different paper, not to DuBois 2011. The narrated edition states it without a name (C09-60).
- "The ration in that house was not short" is the narrator's assertion and may contradict Duflo's premise. The narrated edition keeps it as the narrator's opinion (C09-67).
- The In practice extrapolations: grandmother proximity and burnout (C09-68), two adults appearing in none of the 45 populations (C09-69), children raised by children for most of the human record (C09-70), "let him wrestle" (C09-71).
- "Without doctors" as a gloss on natural fertility (C09-05).
- Whether the devil-in-the-house title, seven words, attributed, is acceptable as the chapter's one quotation. The narrated edition paraphrases it without quotation marks.
- Whether the Hagen bargaining model of postpartum depression, left out of the body as contested and nearer chapter 8's register, should be mentioned at all. Not in the narrated edition.
- Whether the last In practice paragraph, to the woman at the sink, oversteps the rule that the narrator does not tell the reader what to want. Kept in the narrated edition as written.
Figures stripped in extraction and recovered from the PDFs by rendering pages, per the data edition's working notes: FA-04 page 4 (Else-Quest d = 1.01, 0.55, 0.06, with inhibitory control 0.41, perceptual sensitivity 0.38, activity 0.33, high-intensity pleasure 0.30), page 5 (Todd d = 1.83 and 1.60), page 6 (Voyer d = 0.225, 0.374, 0.069), page 7 (Pahlke g values, DuBois d = 0.18 to 0.21). DH-08 page 3 (Vermeer n = 303, r = .18, CI .06 to .29, p = .003), page 6 (Boyette n = 50 and 48), page 8 (van IJzendoorn k = 174, N = 22,914, r = .26 and .21), page 9 (disorganised attachment d = 0.77). Not used in either edition: Konner nursing interval 13.19 plus or minus 1.28 minutes, Sellen weaning 2.80 plus or minus 1.32 years, Gettler p below 0.001. Dropped per the chapter note: the 16-month vocabulary of 95 against 25 words, cited in FA-04 only to an unnamed systematic review.
The documents
- FA-03 Grandmothers, alloparents and the extended household: Sear and Mace, the three menopause hypotheses, Euler and Weitzel, Fox, Strassmann, Voland and Beise, Chapman, Duflo, Sear 2016, parental burnout, co-residence and cohousing.
- FA-04 Raising boys and raising girls: CAH and Pasterski, Else-Quest, Todd, Voyer and Voyer, PISA 2025, Reeves, Pahlke, Dee, DuBois, Gilligan, Way.
- AN-10 Sex differences in juvenile mammals: Connellan and its meta-analytic fall, Alexander, Hassett, Pasterski, Endendijk, Eliot.
- DH-08 Ancestral child-rearing and alloparenting: Sear and Mace, Page, Boyette, van IJzendoorn, Vermeer, Thornton and McAuliffe.