THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 9: Who Keeps Children Alive

76 claims, 37 to check first

C09-01 Check first open §Forty-five populations, §Numbers to carry 1

Sear and Mace 2008, *Evolution and Human Behavior*: systematic review of 45 natural-fertility populations, historical and contemporary; described as "two anthropological demographers working in London" (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 key source 1 and DH-08: Sear & Mace 2008 Evol Hum Behav 29(1):1–18. Affiliation not in any document (general knowledge: LSHTM and UCL)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-02 Check first open §Forty-five populations, §In practice, §Numbers to carry 1

Mother improved child survival in 100% of studies, older siblings 83%, maternal grandmother 69%, father 32%; father effect in 2 of 4 hunter-gatherer and 5 of 18 horticultural populations

To check against
FA-03 (all five figures, "5 of 18" in text line 102); DH-08 table gives "1/3 of populations" for fathers; the CO and FA digest item 14. Chapter 2 said "about a third": consistent. Sear & Mace 2008
The verdict
OPEN
C09-11 Check first open §The devil in the house, §Numbers to carry 2

Krummhörn is in East Frisia, in the far north-west of Germany (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 gives only "the Krummhörn region of Germany"; the CO and FA digest item 5 gives "East Frisia"; "far north-west" is the narrator's. Check Voland & Beise 2002
The verdict
OPEN
C09-12 Check first open §The devil in the house, §Numbers to carry 2

Voland and Beise 2002: about 32,000 parish records, 18th–19th centuries; maternal grandmother alive and nearby lowered infant mortality; paternal grandmother in the household raised neonatal (first-month) mortality by a factor of 2.48

To check against
FA-03 (N ~32,000, 2.48, text says *Demographic Research*); FA-03 key source 7 gives Voland & Beise 2002 Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 52(6):435–443; the CO and FA digest items 15 and 5. Discrepancy: the Demographic Research paper is probably Beise & Voland 2002 Demographic Research 7:469–497 (multilevel event-history analysis, Krummhörn 1720–1874), a different paper from the BES one. Which carries 2.48 and which carries "nearby" vs "in the household" to be checked
The verdict
OPEN
C09-13 Check first open §The devil in the house, §Decoration

Title "The husband's mother is the devil in house" attributed to the same two authors' work on the same registers, the chapter's one quotation (seven words) (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 works cited 48 (ResearchGate entry: "... data on the impact of the mother-in-law on stillbirth mortality in historical Krummhörn (C18–C19 Germany) ...", no year or venue); the CO and FA digest attributes the title to "Voland & Beise 2002". Probably a separate chapter (Voland & Beise in *Grandmotherhood*, Rutgers 2005) on stillbirths, not the 2.48 neonatal paper. The quotation awaits the author's approval
The verdict
OPEN
C09-14 Check first open §The devil in the house, §Case against

Strassmann 2011 PNAS, Dogon of Mali, patrilocal, longitudinal: child under five living with paternal grandmother faced twice the hazard of death, HR 2.0; "an anthropologist at the University of Michigan" (to be checked); her reading that the grandmother hypothesis was sold on populations where it worked

To check against
FA-03 key source 5: Strassmann 2011 PNAS 108(27):10894–10899 ("A new twist on the grandmother hypothesis"); the CO and FA digest item 15. Affiliation not in any document
The verdict
OPEN
C09-16 Check first open §The devil in the house, §Case against

Chapman and colleagues: 32,000 people from Finnish parish records, 36 kinds of relative tested, *Current Biology* 2019 and *Proceedings of the Royal Society B* 2023; first name Simon (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 ("36 different types of relatives" is in the PDF p. 8 area, stripped from the text extraction); FA-03 works cited 50/51 = Proc R Soc B 290(1999):20230690 (2023, "Grandmother presence improved grandchild survival against ..."); works cited 49 and DH-08 ref 35 = "Close and more distant relatives are associated with child mortality risk in historical Finland", Evolutionary Human Sciences (2024/2025), which may be the paper with 36 relative types. No Current Biology 2019 reference in either works-cited list. Discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C09-17 Check first open §The devil in the house

Maternal grandmother cut risk of death from smallpox by about 30% and from diarrhoeal disease by about 40%, HR 0.70 and 0.60

To check against
FA-03 (HR 0.70, 0.60); percentages are the narrator's arithmetic; Chapman et al. 2023 Proc R Soc B
The verdict
OPEN
C09-20 Check first open §The devil in the house, §Case against

Fox and colleagues 2010, title accusing grandmothers of playing favourites: grandparent shares a quarter of autosomal DNA; paternal grandmother shares 50% of X genes with granddaughters, 0% with grandsons; seven historical populations; paternal grandmother raised granddaughter survival and lowered grandson survival

To check against
FA-03 key source 6: Fox et al. 2010 Proc R Soc B 277(1681):567–573 ("Grandma plays favourites: X-chromosome relatedness and sex-specific childhood mortality")
The verdict
OPEN
C09-22 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §Numbers to carry 3

Duflo 2003, *World Bank Economic Review*; "the economist at MIT" (to be checked); South Africa extended the old-age pension to Black households in the early 1990s, worth roughly twice the median rural income per head, paid to the old person and not the household

To check against
FA-03 key source 8: Duflo 2003 WBER 17(1):1–25 ("twice the median rural per capita income", "older black South Africans"); "early 1990s" from the CO and FA digest item 6, not in FA-03; "paid to the old person not the household" is the narrator's gloss. Affiliation not in any document
The verdict
OPEN
C09-23 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §Case against, §Numbers to carry 3

Pension to a grandmother: granddaughters gained 1.19 SD in weight-for-height and 1.16 SD in height-for-age; grandsons nothing; pension to a grandfather: nothing for either sex

To check against
FA-03; Duflo 2003 WBER. the CO and FA digest item 6 rounds to "about 1.2 SD"
The verdict
OPEN
C09-24 Check first open §Case against; working notes assumption 4

"Still working in 1993 with cash": 1993 as the year of Duflo's data

To check against
NOT in FA-03 text or PDF (grep for 1993 and "early 199" returns nothing); the working note's claim that FA-03 gives the year is wrong. General knowledge: Duflo's data are the 1993 SALDRU/PSLSD household survey. Check against Duflo 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C09-26 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §In practice

Mikolajczak and Roskam and colleagues, International Investigation of Parental Burnout, 42 countries, published 2020 and 2021: strongest country-level predictor of parental burnout is individualism, not GDP, inequality or maternal workload; collectivist cultures burn out less even under harsher conditions; first names Moïra, Isabelle (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 key source 10: Mikolajczak et al. 2021, Parental Burnout Around the Globe: A 42-Country Study, New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development 2021(174):59–79; the 2020 item is works cited 62 (parental burnout in Africa)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-28 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter

Low neighbourhood connectedness among mothers: OR 1.50 for physically harsh parenting (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 works cited 71 ("Lack of Maternal Social Capital Increases the Likelihood of Harsh Parenting", PMC8774264), no author, year or journal named
The verdict
OPEN
C09-30 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §Case against, §In practice

Young adults forced to live with parents by housing costs and insecure work: mental health 4.03 points lower on a 100-point scale, 95% CI −5.93 to −2.14 (to be checked)

To check against
FA-03 works cited 69 ("Parental co-residence and young adults' mental health", PMC10686488), no author, year or journal named
The verdict
OPEN
C09-31 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §Case against, §In practice

Page 2019, Agta of the Philippines, proximity sensors, 1,701 child-carer pairs: kin give care in proportion to need, non-kin in proportion to reciprocity; reciprocity predicted care as strongly as relatedness

To check against
DH-08 key source 5: Page et al. 2019 Evol Hum Behav ("Why care for someone else's child?"). Discrepancy: FA-03 gives N = 1,701 child-alloparent dyads for Meehan et al. 2013 AJHB 25(1):42–51 among the Aka. One document has transferred the figure; body follows DH-08
The verdict
OPEN
C09-32 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §Case against, §In practice

Van IJzendoorn and colleagues: 174 studies, 22,914 parent–child pairs; maternal sensitivity r = .26 (CI .22–.29), paternal r = .21 (CI .14–.27), overlapping intervals, "equivalently"

To check against
DH-08 (figures recovered from PDF p. 8); DH-08 refs 62 (Simply Psychology) and 63 (VU research page) name no paper. Probable primary: Deneault, Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 2024/2025 or Madigan et al. 2024 Psychological Bulletin. Same claim as C08-45; chapter 8 marked it (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-34 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter

Disorganised attachment rises with effect size 0.77 in families under severe economic and social strain

To check against
DH-08 (figure recovered from PDF p. 9; "high-risk, isolated socioeconomic conditions"); DH-08 ref 65 = Cyr, Euser, Bakermans-Kranenburg & van IJzendoorn 2010 Development and Psychopathology. Same as C08-47
The verdict
OPEN
C09-35 Check first open §The pension and the granddaughter, §In practice, §Contested

Vermeer and van IJzendoorn 2006: nine studies, 303 children; cortisol rose morning to afternoon at centre-based daycare, not at home; r = .18, CI .06–.29; strongest under 36 months; "has replicated"; first name Harriet (to be checked)

To check against
DH-08 (n = 303, r = .18, CI, p = .003 recovered from PDF p. 3); Vermeer & van IJzendoorn 2006 Early Childhood Research Quarterly (volume not given). the DH digest flags the effect size as lost in extraction
The verdict
OPEN
C09-38 Check first open §Trucks, dolls, §In practice, §Load-bearing

CAH girls exposed to adrenal androgens from about the seventh week of gestation; Pasterski 2005: parents on camera praised CAH daughters more for playing with dolls than unaffected daughters; girls kept choosing trucks when alone; more severe condition, stronger preference (dose-response)

To check against
FA-04 (seventh week; Pasterski et al. 2005 *Archives of Sexual Behavior*; dose-response sourced to ref 5, a d-nb.info thesis) and AN-10 (Pasterski et al. 2005 *Child Development*, 81 CAH children aged 3–10 (43 girls, 38 boys), 72 unaffected siblings). Journal discrepancy logged; Child Development 76(1):264–278 is correct. Chapter 3 rows carry the numbers
The verdict
OPEN
C09-41 Check first open §Trucks, dolls

Alexander 2009: eye-tracking of 30 infants aged three to eight months; girls looked at doll over truck at d > 1.0, boys at truck d = 0.78

To check against
AN-10; Alexander 2009 Archives of Sexual Behavior (volume not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-42 Check first open §Trucks, dolls, §Case against, §In practice, §Numbers to carry 4

Todd and colleagues 2018: 113 effect sizes, 75 studies; boys for boy-typical toys d = 1.83, girls for girl-typical toys d = 1.60; detectable by twelve months; first name Brenda (to be checked)

To check against
FA-04 (113/75 in text; d = 1.83 and 1.60 recovered from PDF p. 5); journal not named (Infant and Child Development 27(2):e2064); "by 12 months" is cited in FA-04 to ref 20, an MRI meta-analysis, which cannot be its source. Misattribution logged
The verdict
OPEN
C09-44 Check first open §Trucks, dolls, §Case against

Baron-Cohen's group 2000: 102 newborns under a day old; boys looked longer at a mobile, girls at a face

To check against
AN-10: Connellan, Baron-Cohen et al. 2000 Infant Behavior & Development (volume not given). Chapter names Baron-Cohen, not first author Connellan
The verdict
OPEN
C09-45 Check first open §Trucks, dolls, §Case against

Meta-analysis of 31 studies, 40 experiments, 1,936 newborns: no sex difference in looking at faces, g = 0.076, p = 0.321; both sexes prefer faces

To check against
AN-10 ref 25 (ResearchGate page titled "Sex Differences in Human Neonatal Social Perception"); meta-analysis authors, year and journal not named. AN-10's own summary table attributes g = 0.076 to "Escudero et al. (2013)", which is a single eye-tracking study, not the meta-analysis: internal discrepancy logged. the AN digest repeats 1,936 and g = 0.076
The verdict
OPEN
C09-47 Check first open §Trucks, dolls, §Case against, §In practice, §Numbers to carry 4

Endendijk and colleagues 2016, *PLoS ONE*: 126 observational studies, 15,034 families, post-industrial societies; parents slightly more controlling with boys d = 0.08; autonomy support d = 0.03; first name Joyce (to be checked)

To check against
AN-10 key source 4: Endendijk et al. 2016 PLoS ONE ("Gender-differentiated parenting revisited"); the AN digest repeats the figures
The verdict
OPEN
C09-49 Check first open §Trucks, dolls, §A school built for one of them, §Case against, §In practice

Else-Quest, Hyde and colleagues 2006: effortful control favours girls d = 1.01, surgency favours boys 0.55, negative affectivity 0.06, in the older cohorts; gap in self-regulation widens through childhood; first name Nancy (to be checked)

To check against
FA-04 (figures recovered from PDF p. 4, table says "in specific older cohorts"; ages 3 months to 13 years); Else-Quest, Hyde, Goldsmith & Van Hulle 2006 Psychological Bulletin (volume not given). "Widens through childhood and is at its widest at desk age" is an inference from "older cohorts", not stated in FA-04. Chapter 4 carries inhibitory control 0.41 and activity 0.33
The verdict
OPEN
C09-50 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §Case against, §In practice, §Numbers to carry 5

Voyer and Voyer 2014, *Psychological Bulletin*: 502 effect sizes from 369 samples, teacher-assigned marks from primary school to university; girls ahead in every subject, mean d = 0.225, languages 0.374, mathematics 0.069; lead historically stable "as far back as the samples go"; first names Daniel and Susan (to be checked)

To check against
FA-04 (502/369 in text; d values recovered from PDF p. 6); Voyer & Voyer 2014 Psychol Bull 140(4):1174–1204; FA-04 works cited 22 gives the first names Daniel and Susan
The verdict
OPEN
C09-53 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §Contested

PISA 2025 round: steepest declines in the test's history; boys' reading −17 points vs girls −12 on OECD average; girls ahead in reading in 89 of 90 systems; 37% of boys vs 25% of girls below baseline reading level; boys' slight maths lead carried by a small top group while the median boy struggled (to be checked)

To check against
FA-04 refs 23 (OECD, PISA 2025 Results Volume I), 24 (Visual Capitalist data-journalism page) and 25 (table.media PDF). "Then came the pandemic" framing is the narrator's: PISA 2022 was the first post-pandemic round, and "steepest declines in history" is FA-04's wording for 2025. Publication date of Volume I to be confirmed
The verdict
OPEN
C09-55 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §Case against, §In practice, §Numbers to carry 5

Pahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014, *Psychological Bulletin*: 184 studies, 1.66 million pupils, 21 countries; single-sex schools disproportionately selective, private, well-off; after controls g = 0.10 girls and 0.06 boys in mathematics, 0.06 and 0.04 in science

To check against
FA-04 (184/1.66 million/21 in text; g values recovered from PDF p. 7); Pahlke, Hyde & Allison 2014 Psychol Bull 140(4):1042–1072. Discrepancy: Preface says "1.6 million"; chapter 5 gives 0.10 and 0.06 only
The verdict
OPEN
C09-58 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §In practice

Dee 2007, *Journal of Human Resources*, matched pupils and teachers: boy with male teacher did better, rated better, more engaged, closing up to a third of the English gap; mirror for girls in science and mathematics with a female teacher

To check against
FA-04 (refs 38, a Fruehwirth working draft, and 39, NBER w11660); Dee 2007 J Hum Resour 42(3):528–554. "Up to a third" to be checked against the paper
The verdict
OPEN
C09-59 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §In practice

DuBois and colleagues 2011: 55 to 70 evaluations of youth mentoring, more than 25,000 young people, d = 0.18 to 0.21; first name David (to be checked)

To check against
FA-04 (55–70 and 25,000 in text; d = 0.18–0.21 recovered from PDF p. 7); DuBois et al. 2011 Psychological Science in the Public Interest 12(2):57–91
The verdict
OPEN
C09-60 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §In practice

Mentor who stayed more than a year reduced behaviour problems and raised self-worth; mentor who left inside six months did measurable harm, "less than no mentor at all"

To check against
FA-04 attributes the duration finding to ref 36 (PMC8198211, "Unpacking Community-Based Youth Mentoring Relationships"), not to DuBois 2011; the classic source is Grossman & Rhodes 2002 American Journal of Community Psychology. Chapter attributes it to DuBois: attribution to be fixed or checked
The verdict
OPEN
C09-62 Check first open §A school built for one of them

Theran 2003 tied loss of voice to the rise in girls' depression and eating disorders (to be checked)

To check against
FA-04 ("Theran, 2003, [venue stripped in extraction]"); FA-04 ref 43 is a ResearchGate entry "The Relationship of Gender and Voice to Depression and Eating Disorders", which is the title of Smolak & Munstertieger 2002 Psychology of Women Quarterly, not Theran. Probable: Theran 2003 is a dissertation or Sex Roles paper. Attribution to be checked against the FA-04 PDF
The verdict
OPEN
C09-63 Check first open §A school built for one of them, §Case against, §In practice

Way, "a developmental psychologist at New York University" (to be checked), *Deep Secrets* 2011, hundreds of longitudinal interviews: boys at thirteen and fourteen loved best friends, shared secrets, would go to pieces without them; "less like boys stranded on an island and more like a love story"; by seventeen stopped; mask; readable as feminine or gay; tracks depression, isolation, suicide; crisis of connection enforced from outside

To check against
FA-04 (early and middle vs late adolescence; "more like Love Story than Lord of the Flies"; "go wacko"; "no homo"; "mask of masculinity"; ref 47 gives Harvard University Press 2011). Ages 13–14 and 17 are the narrator's specification; the island/love-story line is a paraphrase of Way's. In practice says her boys were "interviewed, not followed into adulthood with controls", while FA-04 calls the interviews longitudinal: tension to check
The verdict
OPEN
C09-65 Check first open §Case against

Eliot 2021 synthesis of three decades of human brain imaging: after size, sex explains about 1% of variance in brain structure; task-based imaging of sex-specific circuits has not replicated

To check against
AN-10 key source 1: Eliot et al. 2021 Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews ("Dump the dimorphism"); the AN digest item 16 (11% size difference)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-67 Check first open §Case against

"The ration in that house was not short" (Duflo's households)

To check against
narrator's assertion, not in FA-03. Duflo's outcome measures (weight-for-height, height-for-age) were chosen because the children were at risk of malnutrition; FA-03 describes the pension as going to poor rural households. The claim may contradict the study's premise: check Duflo 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C09-74 Check first open whole chapter (22 markers)

First names supplied from general knowledge, each (to be checked) on first use: Samuel Pavard, Michael Cant, Rufus Johnstone, Eckart Voland, Jan Beise, Simon Chapman, Harald Euler, Barbara Weitzel, Molly Fox, Moïra Mikolajczak, Isabelle Roskam, Harriet Vermeer, Janice Hassett, Alexander Siebert, Kim Wallen, Gerianne Alexander, Melissa Hines, Brenda Todd, Joyce Endendijk, Nancy Else-Quest, Daniel and Susan Voyer, David DuBois

To check against
no document gives these first names except FA-04 works cited 22 (Daniel and Susan Voyer) and FA-04 text (Melissa Hines, in the CAH passage); check each paper's author list
The verdict
OPEN
C09-03 open §Forty-five populations

Mother's death the single most reliable predictor of her child's death

To check against
DH-08 table ("maternal death highly predicts child death"); Sear & Mace 2008
The verdict
OPEN
C09-04 open §Forty-five populations

Paternal grandmother's effect variable across populations, negative in some

To check against
DH-08 table ("Variable / Negative ... occasionally increases mortality ... in patrilocal systems"); Sear & Mace 2008
The verdict
OPEN
C09-05 open §Forty-five populations

The 45 populations "all without contraception and mostly without doctors", sources "from parish registers to anthropologists' field notes"

To check against
narrator's gloss on "natural fertility populations"; neither document says "without doctors". Check Sear & Mace 2008 inclusion criteria
The verdict
OPEN
C09-06 open §Forty-five populations

Human women live decades past their last birth; almost no other land mammal does (toothed whales excepted)

To check against
FA-03 ("30 to 40 years beyond ... uniquely derived among terrestrial mammals, though observed in certain toothed whales"); no primary named. Preface says "another thirty years"
The verdict
OPEN
C09-07 open §Forty-five populations

Hawkes's grandmother hypothesis: the old woman fed her daughter's weaned children so the daughter could bear again sooner

To check against
FA-03; Hawkes, O'Connell & Blurton Jones 1997 Current Anthropology and 1998 PNAS 95(3):1336–1339. Chapter 2 rows carry the Hadza detail
The verdict
OPEN
C09-08 open §Forty-five populations

Mother hypothesis, Pavard and colleagues 2008: late birth risks maternal death and orphaning, menopause as stop-loss

To check against
FA-03; Pavard, Metcalf & Heyer 2008 American Journal of Physical Anthropology (volume not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-09 open §Forty-five populations, §In practice

Reproductive conflict hypothesis, Cant and Johnstone 2008 PNAS: female-biased dispersal, incoming wife unrelated to mother-in-law while mother-in-law shares a quarter with the wife's children; asymmetry makes the older woman yield; "the people who do this for a living have not agreed"

To check against
FA-03 key source 4: Cant & Johnstone 2008 PNAS 105(14):5332–5336; FA-03's own open question on the origin of menopause
The verdict
OPEN
C09-10 open §Forty-five populations, §In practice

The hypothesis predicts that the grandmother who yields is the husband's mother, rivals "by construction"

To check against
FA-03 (female-biased dispersal model); narrator's inference from Cant & Johnstone 2008
The verdict
OPEN
C09-15 open §The devil in the house, §Case against

Dogon girls grew faster when the maternal grandmother was absent, spared weeding; old woman as another mouth where calories are short

To check against
FA-03; Strassmann 2011 PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C09-18 open §The devil in the house, §Case against, §In practice

Paternal grandmothers and paternal cousins raised child mortality; effect strongest in the wealthiest families; inheritance reading

To check against
FA-03 (no paper specified for the wealth interaction; probably the Evolutionary Human Sciences paper, works cited 49)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-19 open §The devil in the house

Euler and Weitzel 1996: 1,857 adults surveyed; order maternal grandmother, maternal grandfather, paternal grandmother, paternal grandfather; paternity-uncertainty explanation

To check against
FA-03; Euler & Weitzel 1996 Human Nature (volume not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-21 open §The devil in the house, §In practice

"The devil in the house was a hungry house": mechanism is food and inheritance, so not operative in a city with vaccines and a supermarket

To check against
narrator's synthesis; FA-03 lists the mechanism (X favouritism vs calorie competition vs patrilocal dominance) as its own open question. No primary
The verdict
OPEN
C09-25 open §The pension and the granddaughter

Economists had modelled the household as a single purse (unitary household)

To check against
FA-03 ("unitary entity"); no primary named (Becker not cited)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-27 open §The pension and the granddaughter, §In practice

Review of cohousing in rich countries, 25 studies and 77 communities: more mutual support, less isolation

To check against
FA-03 works cited 70 ("Cohousing as a model for social health: a scoping review", ResearchGate, no author or year given); FA-03's own open question on self-selection
The verdict
OPEN
C09-29 open §The pension and the granddaughter, §Case against, §In practice

Sear 2016 review of kin and fertility: kin proximity raised fertility in historical populations including 3.1 million couples in the US census 1900–1910; in modern high-income societies kin effects mixed or negative

To check against
FA-03; Sear 2016 Comparative Population Studies (volume not given). The 3.1 million dataset is works cited 59 (PMC8670560), a study Sear's review cites, not Sear's own. In practice's gloss "help that comes with a view on how the child should be raised" differs from FA-03's "negative pressure from their own parents regarding the costs of childbearing"
The verdict
OPEN
C09-33 open §The pension and the granddaughter

Van IJzendoorn's "multiple caretaker paradox" and integrative hypothesis: infant builds a network of attachments

To check against
DH-08; van IJzendoorn, Sagi & Lambermon 1992 not named in document (ref 64 is a Dagan review)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-36 open §The pension and the granddaughter, §In practice

What the cortisol rise means for later life is not known; no study has compared a nursery with an isolated flat and one exhausted adult

To check against
narrator's assertion; DH-08 does not say so (it calls the finding "a profound evolutionary mismatch"). No primary
The verdict
OPEN
C09-37 open §The pension and the granddaughter, §In practice

Boyette 2016: Aka (50 children) and Ngandu (48) observed; adult teaching dominant only until age four or five, then learning from other children

To check against
DH-08 (n = 50 and 48 recovered from PDF p. 6); Boyette 2016 Child Development (volume not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-39 open §Trucks, dolls

Hassett, Siebert and Wallen 2008: wheeled and plush toys, troop of 135 rhesus macaques, 34 juveniles analysed; males consistently to wheeled toys, females both; first names (to be checked)

To check against
AN-10 key source 7: Hassett, Siebert & Wallen 2008 Hormones and Behavior (volume not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-40 open §Trucks, dolls

Alexander and Hines 2002: 63 vervet monkeys, same pattern; first names (to be checked)

To check against
AN-10; Alexander & Hines 2002 Evolution and Human Behavior (volume not given)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-43 open §Trucks, dolls

Toy preferences among the largest behavioural sex differences measured, "in the same league as height", and overlapping

To check against
FA-04 ("among the largest psychological sex differences documented"); height comparison is chapter 4's yardstick (d about 1.7–2.0), not in FA-04
The verdict
OPEN
C09-46 open §Trucks, dolls, §Contested

What happens between the newborn null and the twelve-month difference is unknown

To check against
AN-10's own open question ("Neonatal Precursors")
The verdict
OPEN
C09-48 open §Trucks, dolls, §Contested

Reading that children sort themselves (self-socialisation) and marketing sells to the sort

To check against
AN-10's own interpretation ("self-socialization of biological predispositions"); no primary. "Marketing then sells to the sort" is the narrator's
The verdict
OPEN
C09-51 open §A school built for one of them, §Case against

d = 0.20 means the two bells share 92% of their area

To check against
chapter 4 overlap formula (2Φ(−d/2)); not in FA-04 (FA-04 says d = 0.5 overlaps about 80%)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-52 open §A school built for one of them

Boys historically held a small lead on standardised tests in mathematics and science

To check against
FA-04; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C09-54 open §A school built for one of them, §In practice, §Decoration

Reeves, Brookings Institution, *Of Boys and Men* 2022: boys' prefrontal cortices mature later; proposal to start boys a year later (redshirting), untested at scale

To check against
FA-04 (Brookings affiliation given; refs 27 and 28 are a podcast page and a Reddit thread, not the book); FA-04's own open question on redshirting
The verdict
OPEN
C09-56 open §A school built for one of them

Sax and Gurian hold that boys and girls need different temperatures, lighting, confrontation vs collaboration; Hyde and Halpern answer overlap is vast, separation teaches stereotype, poor preparation for mixed workplaces

To check against
FA-04 (refs 32, a German thesis, and 33, a US principals' survey); no Sax, Gurian or Halpern primary named (probable Halpern et al. 2011 Science "The pseudoscience of single-sex schooling")
The verdict
OPEN
C09-57 open §A school built for one of them, §Decoration

"A tenth of a standard deviation is the size of a good night's sleep"

To check against
comparison, not a cited figure (working notes assumption 7)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-61 open §A school built for one of them, §In practice

Gilligan 1982 *In a Different Voice*: loss of voice in adolescent girls; girl who argued at eleven learns at fourteen to keep objections to herself

To check against
FA-04 (refs 40–42: Wikipedia, EBSCO, a PDF of the book); the ages eleven and fourteen are the narrator's (Brown & Gilligan 1992 *Meeting at the Crossroads* is the usual source for the age pattern, not named)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-64 open §A school built for one of them, §Case against, §In practice

Gilligan 2023 *In a Human Voice*: the ethic of care is human, coded feminine by culture and taken from boys

To check against
FA-04 (ref 41 EBSCO; ref 45 civic.ai); Gilligan 2023 Polity
The verdict
OPEN
C09-66 open §Case against, §Contested

Thornton and McAuliffe 2015: cooperative breeding does not buy cognition, cooperatively breeding monkeys no cleverer than their cousins; against Hrdy (and Burkart)

To check against
DH-08 (ref 77, PMC4982024); journal not named (Journal of Zoology 295:12–22); Burkart, Hrdy & van Schaik 2009 Evolutionary Anthropology 18(5):175–186
The verdict
OPEN
C09-68 open §In practice

"The panel data say [a grandmother within an hour] tends to lower parental burnout"

To check against
extrapolation: FA-03's burnout finding is country-level (individualism vs collectivism), not about grandmother proximity, and the IIPB is a survey, not a panel. No primary
The verdict
OPEN
C09-69 open §In practice

Two adults and nobody else is "an arrangement that appears nowhere in 45 populations"

To check against
inference from Sear & Mace 2008 and DH-08 ("isolated nuclear family ... evolutionarily unprecedented"); not stated as such in either document
The verdict
OPEN
C09-70 open §In practice

Children raised in groups of other children "for most of the time there have been children"; adults leave the frame at four or five

To check against
DH-08 (Boyette 2016; Page et al. 2021 Phil Trans B on Agta playgroups); the "most of the time there have been children" is the narrator's extension
The verdict
OPEN
C09-71 open §In practice

"Let him wrestle": rough-and-tumble play as where boys already are

To check against
AN-10 (rat and human rough-and-tumble literature; Marquardt 2023 cut from this chapter); no human primary named here
The verdict
OPEN
C09-72 open whole chapter

Cross-chapter consistency: Preface (killer whale, thirty years, single-sex schooling among the fallen, "rounding error"), chapter 1 (whales), chapter 2 (campfire, Efe, Aka, "about a third", Hawkes at the digging stick, dozen carers a day), chapter 3 (Pasterski numbers), chapter 4 (Else-Quest trait level, overlap formula, height yardstick), chapter 5 (Pahlke 0.10/0.06), chapter 8 (Gettler, father's hormones, attachment rows C08-44 to C08-47)

To check against
the named chapters and their verification files; figures must match (Pahlke 1.6 vs 1.66 million already logged)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-73 open §Opening, §In practice

Opening scene composed, not reported (generic German flat, nursery, tram); "my mother's generation" and "my mother's country" the only biographical references

To check against
working notes assumption 3; to be confirmed by the author
The verdict
OPEN
C09-75 open §The devil in the house, §Case against

Chapman Finnish cohort: "wealthiest families" effect "is what a story about inheritance predicts"

To check against
FA-03 ("resource competition over shared wealth and inheritance practices"); narrator's sharpening; Chapman (which paper unspecified)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-76 open §The pension and the granddaughter, §In practice

Agta: "nobody in that camp was trapped with anybody"; unrelated households that traded childcare "did as well as kin"

To check against
DH-08 ("reciprocal exchange was an equally powerful driver"); "did as well as kin" is a gloss on "equally powerful predictor", not an outcome comparison. Page et al. 2019
The verdict
OPEN