THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 8: The Father’s Falling Tide

78 claims, 31 to check first

C08-01 Check first open §Opening, §What pregnancy takes

Saxbe et al. 2024, Cerebral Cortex: 38 first-time fathers scanned in partner's pregnancy and at 6 months postpartum, own-baby vs unknown-infant pictures

To check against
FA-02; Saxbe, Martínez-García et al. 2024 Cerebral Cortex
The verdict
OPEN
C08-03 Check first open §What the hormone answers, §Case against

Gettler 2011 Cebu: median testosterone fall 26% waking, 34% evening (or 20.5%); sample 394 to 683; sampled 2005 and 4.5 years later

To check against
BI-02, BI-06, DH-08, chapter 3 rows C03-25/27; Gettler, McDade, Feranil & Kuzawa 2011, PNAS 108:16194–16199. Discrepancy: N given as 394/465 (BI-02), 683 (BI-06), 624 (DH-08); drop 26/34 vs 20.5. Carried as ranges
The verdict
OPEN
C08-05 Check first open §What the hormone answers, §In practice

Cebu: fathers doing ≥3 hours/day childcare had the lowest T at follow-up

To check against
DH-08, BI-06; Gettler et al. 2011 PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C08-07 Check first open §What the hormone answers

Gettler, Boyette et al. 2020, American Journal of Human Biology: BaYaka (Congo Basin) fathers rated more reliable providers/sharers had lower T and higher oxytocin

To check against
DH-08; Gettler, Boyette et al. 2020 AJHB
The verdict
OPEN
C08-10 Check first open §What the hormone answers, §One network, §Case against

Baseline oxytocin does not differ between new mothers and new fathers, across several cohorts

To check against
FA-01; Feldman lab studies (Gordon et al. 2010 and later), no single primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C08-11 Check first open §One network

Abraham, Feldman et al. 2014, PNAS: 89 first-time parents, fMRI plus oxytocin; three groups (primary-caregiving mothers, secondary-caregiving fathers, primary-caregiving gay fathers)

To check against
FA-01; Abraham, Hendler, Shapira-Lichter, Kanat-Maymon, Zagoory-Sharon & Feldman 2014 PNAS 111:9792–9797. Place of study not given in document
The verdict
OPEN
C08-12 Check first open §One network, §Case against, §In practice

Abraham 2014: mothers' amygdala-centred emotional network (amygdala, vACC, insula, IFG, VTA) dominant and correlated with oxytocin and synchrony; secondary-caregiving fathers' STS/TPJ socio-cognitive network dominant; primary-caregiving gay fathers both, with amygdala–STS connectivity; across all fathers connectivity linear with childcare time

To check against
FA-01; Abraham et al. 2014 PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C08-14 Check first open §What pregnancy takes

Hoekzema et al., Nature Neuroscience: 25 primiparous women scanned pre-conception and postpartum vs 20 nulliparous women, 19 first-time fathers, 17 nulliparous men

To check against
FA-02; Hoekzema et al. 2016 (published online Dec 2016, print 2017). Discrepancy: FA-02 and the CO and FA digest say 2016, BI-06 and the BI digest say 2017. Text gives both
The verdict
OPEN
C08-15 Check first open §What pregnancy takes

Hoekzema: grey-matter reductions in hippocampus, amygdala, orbitofrontal and subgenual prefrontal cortex, right superior temporal gyrus, insula, fusiform gyrus; symmetrical

To check against
FA-02; Hoekzema et al. 2016 Nat Neurosci
The verdict
OPEN
C08-16 Check first open §What pregnancy takes, §Numbers to carry

Hoekzema: classifier sorted every mother from every non-mother (100%); change 6× cortex and 3× medial temporal lobe normal test–retest variability

To check against
FA-02; Hoekzema et al. 2016
The verdict
OPEN
C08-17 Check first open §What pregnancy takes, §Numbers to carry

Pregnancy hormones: oestradiol 3.42 → 12,400 pg/ml, progesterone 0.84 → 103 ng/ml

To check against
FA-02; Hoekzema et al. 2016 (the document attributes these ranges to the paper; check they are not from a different source cited within it)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-19 Check first open §What pregnancy takes, §Numbers to carry, §In practice

Martínez-García et al. 2021, Brain Sciences: same cohort at six years, 91.67% classification, changes still track attachment

To check against
FA-02; Martínez-García, Paternina-Die, Desco, Vilarroya, Hoekzema & Carmona 2021 Brain Sciences
The verdict
OPEN
C08-25 Check first open §What pregnancy takes, §Case against, §Numbers to carry

Saxbe 2024: cortical volume reduction and thinning, largest in precuneus, d > 0.5; larger reductions ↔ stronger own-baby response, stronger prenatal bonding, more planned leave, more interaction

To check against
FA-02; Saxbe et al. 2024 Cerebral Cortex
The verdict
OPEN
C08-26 Check first open §What pregnancy takes, §In practice

Saxbe 2024: larger reductions also ↔ more sleep problems, anxiety, distress, depression at 6 months, controlling for prenatal levels

To check against
FA-02; Saxbe et al. 2024
The verdict
OPEN
C08-28 Check first open §The tenth father, §Numbers to carry

Paulson & Bazemore 2010, JAMA: 43 studies, 28,004 participants; paternal perinatal depression 10.4% (95% CI 8.5–12.7)

To check against
FA-02, FA-01; Paulson & Bazemore 2010 JAMA 303:1961–1969. Note "28,004 participants" may include mothers, text says "fathers": check
The verdict
OPEN
C08-29 Check first open §The tenth father, §Case against, §In practice

Paulson: 25.6% (CI 17.3–36.1) at 3–6 months; interview 4.9% vs self-report 11.0%; US 14.1% vs international 8.2%

To check against
FA-02; Paulson & Bazemore 2010
The verdict
OPEN
C08-30 Check first open §The tenth father, §In practice, §Numbers to carry

Paternal–maternal depression correlation r = 0.308 (CI 0.228–0.384)

To check against
FA-02, FA-01 (figure recovered from FA-01 PDF p. 8); Paulson & Bazemore 2010
The verdict
OPEN
C08-33 Check first open §The tenth father, §In practice

Ramchandani et al. 2005, The Lancet (ALSPAC, >10,000 children): paternal depression at 8 weeks → adjusted OR 2.09 for emotional/behavioural problems at 3.5 years, 2.66 for conduct problems in boys, independent of maternal depression and later paternal depression

To check against
FA-01; Ramchandani, Stein, Evans, O'Connor & ALSPAC 2005 Lancet 365:2201–2205
The verdict
OPEN
C08-39 Check first open §The tenth father, §In practice

German Wochenbett: statutory midwife home visits up to 12 weeks after birth

To check against
FA-02 sources an insurance blog and a thesis. Check against SGB V §24d and Hebammenhilfe-Vertrag. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-44 Check first open §What a father is for, §Case against

Lucassen, van IJzendoorn et al. 2011: 95 studies, >3,000 children; infants slightly more secure with mothers, g = −0.07; mother–father attachment r = 0.32

To check against
FA-01 (figures recovered from PDF p. 3); Lucassen et al. 2011 J Fam Psychol 25:986–992
The verdict
OPEN
C08-45 Check first open §What a father is for, §Case against

Attachment antecedents meta-analysis: k = 174, N = 22,914 dyads; maternal sensitivity r = .26 (CI .22–.29), paternal r = .21 (CI .14–.27)

To check against
DH-08 (figures recovered from PDF p. 8); document names van IJzendoorn, probable primary Madigan et al. 2024 Psychological Bulletin or Deneault et al. Marked (to be checked) implicitly via "updated meta-analysis"
The verdict
OPEN
C08-49 Check first open §What a father is for, §Case against

Activation parenting meta-analysis: 40 studies, 3,607 fathers, 3,707 mothers, fathers higher g = 0.27, p < .001

To check against
FA-01 (figures recovered from PDF pp. 1, 4; sourced to a ResearchGate table, no author). Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-53 Check first open §What a father is for

Parenting–anxiety meta-analysis: k = 28 mothers N = 5,728, k = 12 fathers N = 1,019; paternal, not maternal, challenging parenting linked to less child anxiety

To check against
FA-01 (figures recovered from PDF p. 5); author not named, probable Möller et al. 2016. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-54 Check first open §What a father is for, §In practice

Pancsofar & Vernon-Feagans 2006, Child Development: rural dual-earner families, children at 24 months, language at 36 months; fathers fewer words, more word roots, more wh-questions, more clarification requests; paternal vocabulary diversity unique predictor after controls

To check against
FA-01; Pancsofar & Vernon-Feagans 2006 (document says Child Development; some versions in Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, check)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-61 Check first open §What a father is for

Meta-analysis of children of gay fathers: 54 effect sizes, 1,509 participants, adjustment within or above normal range

To check against
FA-01 text says Fedewa et al. 2015; reference list [57] is Carone et al. 2024 (Sexuality Research and Social Policy). Mismatch confirmed in PDF (text p. 8, reference p. 16). Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-62 Check first open §The other clock, §Numbers to carry, §In practice

Wallace & Kelsey 2010, PLoS ONE: 8 histological studies, 325 ovaries; age explains 81% of variance; peak ~300,000 NGFs per ovary at 18–22 weeks gestation (95% PI 35,000–2,534,000); 12% of reserve at 30, 3% at 40

To check against
FA-05 (81% recovered from PDF p. 1); Wallace & Kelsey 2010 PLoS ONE 5:e8772
The verdict
OPEN
C08-64 Check first open §The other clock, §Numbers to carry, §In practice

Habbema et al. 2015, Human Reproduction: 90% chance of 1/2/3 children means starting by 32/27/23 without IVF, 35/31/28 with

To check against
FA-05; Habbema, Eijkemans, Leridon & te Velde 2015 Hum Reprod 30:2215–2221
The verdict
OPEN
C08-67 Check first open §The other clock

Kong et al. 2012, Nature: paternal age main driver of de novo mutations

To check against
FA-05; Kong et al. 2012 Nature 488:471–475 (78 trios). Document's "over 1.4 million individuals across four populations" is not this paper's sample. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-68 Check first open §The other clock, §In practice

Reichenberg et al. 2006, Archives of General Psychiatry: 2,615,081 Swedish births; fathers ≥45 vs 20–24: HR 3.45 autism (CI 1.62–7.33), 13.13 ADHD, 24.70 bipolar

To check against
FA-05; Reichenberg et al. 2006 Arch Gen Psychiatry 63:1026–1032 was an Israeli cohort (autism only, OR 5.75 for ≥40). The Swedish 2.6 million figure with ADHD/bipolar HRs is D'Onofrio et al. 2014 JAMA Psychiatry. Document may have merged two papers. Check attribution
The verdict
OPEN
C08-70 Check first open §The other clock, §In practice

Kleven et al. 2019: long-run child penalty ~20% Denmark vs 60% Germany (FA-05), 61% West Germany (the HC digest)

To check against
FA-05 cites Kleven, Landais & Søgaard 2019 AEJ Applied (Denmark paper); HC-05 cites Kleven, Landais, Posch, Steinhauer & Zweimüller 2019 AEA P&P (six-country comparison, which is where the German figure comes from). Range 60–61 carried; author-list discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C08-74 Check first open §The other clock

South Korea TFR 0.72 in 2023; ~280 trillion won pronatal spending since 2006

To check against
FA-05 sources a news aggregator and an MDPI paper. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-02 open §Opening (one marker), whole chapter

First names supplied from general knowledge for all people the documents give by surname only (list in working notes assumption 3): Saxbe, Abraham, Gordon, Boyette, Hoekzema, Martínez-García, Kim, Luders, Paulson, Bazemore, Ramchandani, Hahn-Holbrook, Twenge, Campbell, Foster, Doss, Mitnick, Heyman, Smith Slep, Lucassen, Bögels, Phares, Pancsofar, Vernon-Feagans, Lamb, McLanahan, Tach, Schneider, Mitchell, Wallace, Kelsey, Steiner, Habbema, Dunson, Reichenberg, Levine, Kleven, Sobotka, Lutz, Bujard, Sulak, McDonald

To check against
no primary source named for first names; check each paper's author list
The verdict
OPEN
C08-04 open §What the hormone answers

Cebu: men with higher baseline T more likely to become partnered fathers by follow-up; fall came after

To check against
DH-08, FA-02; Gettler et al. 2011 PNAS
The verdict
OPEN
C08-06 open §What the hormone answers

Mating effort vs parenting effort trade-off as the mechanism (life-history framing)

To check against
DH-08; Gettler et al. 2011 discussion; no separate primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C08-08 open §What the hormone answers

Storey et al. 2000, Evolution and Human Behavior: fathers' prolactin and oxytocin rise to infant cues

To check against
FA-02; Storey, Walsh, Quinton & Wynne-Edwards 2000
The verdict
OPEN
C08-09 open §What the hormone answers

Gordon, Feldman et al. 2010: 43 fathers over first 6 months; oxytocin tracks affect synchrony, prolactin tracks coordinated exploratory play

To check against
DH-08; Gordon, Zagoory-Sharon, Leckman & Feldman 2010 (journal not named in document)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-13 open §One network

Oxytocin in mothers rises with affectionate touch and motherese, in fathers with stimulatory play

To check against
FA-01; Feldman, Gordon, Schneiderman, Weisman & Zagoory-Sharon 2010 (not named in document beyond lab)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-18 open §What pregnancy takes

Hoekzema: reduced regions overlap with regions activated by own-baby pictures; magnitude of change predicts postpartum attachment

To check against
FA-02; Hoekzema et al. 2016
The verdict
OPEN
C08-20 open §What pregnancy takes

Hoekzema 2022 (second pregnancy): first pregnancy's reductions cover 79% larger area, median change 3.1%, d > 1.0

To check against
FA-02; Hoekzema et al. 2022 (journal not named in document)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-21 open §What pregnancy takes

Authors describe the change as pruning/specialisation, not loss of function

To check against
FA-02, BI-06; Hoekzema et al. 2016 discussion
The verdict
OPEN
C08-22 open §What pregnancy takes, §Case against

Kim et al. 2010, Behavioral Neuroscience: 19 mothers, grey-matter increases in prefrontal, parietal and midbrain between 2–4 weeks and 3–4 months postpartum

To check against
FA-02; Kim, Leckman, Mayes, Feldman, Wang & Swain 2010 Behav Neurosci 124:695–700. Text says "second and fourteenth week", check the exact windows
The verdict
OPEN
C08-23 open §What pregnancy takes

Luders et al. 2020: grey-matter increases from 1–2 days to 4–6 weeks postpartum

To check against
FA-02; Luders, Gingnell, Poromaa, Engman, Kurth & Gaser 2020 (journal not named)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-24 open §What pregnancy takes, §Case against

Barrière et al. 2021 synthesis: biphasic model, gestational reduction driven by placental steroids then postpartum increase driven by infant stimuli; rodent evidence of transient swelling of emotion/reward regions

To check against
FA-02; Barrière et al. 2021 (journal not named)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-27 open §What pregnancy takes

UK Biobank, >30,000 participants, PNAS: more children parented ↔ higher functional connectivity in mid/later life, both sexes, inverse of ageing pattern

To check against
FA-02 names no author or year; probable Orchard et al. 2025 PNAS. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-31 open §The tenth father

Depressed fathers: long working hours OR 5.34, isolation OR 5.28; if mother depressed, father's risk up to 50% higher

To check against
FA-02 cites an unnamed systematic review. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-32 open §The tenth father

Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale validated on mothers, under-detects men's presentation

To check against
FA-02; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C08-34 open §The tenth father

Maternal postpartum depression prevalence: 10–13% developed countries, up to 20% developing (FA-02); 10–15% (DH-08). Both given

To check against
FA-02, DH-08; no single primary named. Report-to-report discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C08-35 open §The tenth father, §In practice

Hagen 1999, Evolution and Human Behavior: postpartum depression as bargaining / costly signal of low support or low infant viability

To check against
DH-08; Hagen 1999 Evol Hum Behav 20:325–359
The verdict
OPEN
C08-36 open §The tenth father

Kardum et al.: perceived lack of family support and low Apgar score strongest predictors of PPD onset (longitudinal)

To check against
DH-08 gives no year or journal
The verdict
OPEN
C08-37 open §The tenth father, §In practice

Hahn-Holbrook 2018: PPD as evolutionary mismatch (lost alloparental support)

To check against
DH-08; Hahn-Holbrook & Haselton (year and journal to confirm)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-38 open §The tenth father

Zuo yuezi (one month, China) and la cuarentena (40 days, Latin America) postpartum confinement customs

To check against
FA-02; no primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C08-40 open §The tenth father

Narrator grew up in the German Wochenbett system

To check against
biographical, passing reference; to be confirmed by the author
The verdict
OPEN
C08-41 open §The tenth father

Twenge, Campbell & Foster 2003, Journal of Marriage and Family: parents vs non-parents d = −0.19; 38% of mothers of infants vs 62% childless women high satisfaction

To check against
FA-02; Twenge, Campbell & Foster 2003 JMF 65:574–583
The verdict
OPEN
C08-42 open §The tenth father

Doss, Rhoades, Stanley & Markman 2009, JPSP: 218 couples over 8 years, sudden drop at birth

To check against
FA-02; Doss et al. 2009 JPSP 96:601–619
The verdict
OPEN
C08-43 open §The tenth father

Mitnick, Heyman & Smith Slep 2009, Journal of Family Psychology meta-analysis: non-parents also decline over the same period

To check against
FA-02; Mitnick et al. 2009 J Fam Psychol 23:848–852
The verdict
OPEN
C08-46 open §What a father is for

Van IJzendoorn's integrative hypothesis: multiple secure attachments as insurance

To check against
DH-08; van IJzendoorn, Sagi & Lambermon 1992 (not named in document)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-47 open §What a father is for

Disorganised attachment d = 0.77 higher in high-risk households

To check against
DH-08 (figure recovered from PDF p. 9); no primary named, probable Cyr et al. 2010. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-48 open §What a father is for, §In practice

Paquette's Risky Situation procedure: 12–18 months, intrusive stranger, stairs, forbidden toy; under-/over-activated profiles with later anxiety/impulsivity

To check against
FA-01; Paquette & Bigras 2010 (not named beyond Paquette)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-50 open §What a father is for

Overlap "about 89 per cent" for g = 0.27

To check against
narrator's arithmetic from the chapter 4 overlap formula (2Φ(−d/2)); not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C08-51 open §What a father is for

Rough-and-tumble play peaks around age four, more with sons; linked to emotion regulation and less aggression

To check against
FA-01; no primary named (probable Fletcher, StGeorge & Freeman 2013 or Paquette 2003)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-52 open §What a father is for

Bögels & Phares 2008, Clinical Psychology Review: fathers' evolutionary role as challenging parent

To check against
FA-01; Bögels & Phares 2008 Clin Psychol Rev 28:539–558
The verdict
OPEN
C08-55 open §What a father is for

Father-language meta-analysis: 41 studies, N = 5,563, moderate correlation

To check against
FA-01 (N recovered from PDF p. 6); meta-analysis not named, probable Rowe et al. or Cabrera et al. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-56 open §What a father is for

Bridge Hypothesis (father as less accommodating listener)

To check against
FA-01; Gleason 1975 "bridge" / Pancsofar & Vernon-Feagans
The verdict
OPEN
C08-57 open §What a father is for, §Case against, §In practice

Pleck's critique: play and language differences as artefacts of less time

To check against
FA-01; Pleck (year and work not named in document)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-58 open §What a father is for

Lamb, Pleck, Charnov & Levine 1985: engagement, accessibility, responsibility; responsibility barely shifted

To check against
FA-01; Lamb et al. 1985 American Zoologist 25:883–894
The verdict
OPEN
C08-59 open §What a father is for

McLanahan, Tach & Schneider 2013, Annual Review of Sociology: causal designs show smaller but consistent father-absence effects on high-school completion, social-emotional adjustment, adult mental health

To check against
FA-01; McLanahan et al. 2013 Annu Rev Sociol 39:399–427
The verdict
OPEN
C08-60 open §What a father is for

Mitchell et al. 2017: cohort of 879, father loss → shorter telomeres

To check against
FA-01 says Pediatrics and also PNAS; Mitchell, McLanahan, Schneper et al. 2017 Pediatrics 140:e20163245. Marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C08-63 open §The other clock, §In practice

Steiner et al. 2017, JAMA: AMH and FSH poor predictors of fecundability in women without infertility history

To check against
FA-05; Steiner et al. 2017 JAMA 318:1367–1376
The verdict
OPEN
C08-65 open §The other clock

Students overestimate IVF's power to rescue fertility in the forties

To check against
FA-05; survey not named
The verdict
OPEN
C08-66 open §The other clock

Dunson, Baird & Colombo 2004, Human Reproduction: male fertility declines from 35, markedly after 50

To check against
FA-05; Dunson et al. 2004 Hum Reprod 19:1548–1553 (text says "around 50", document says "severe after 50")
The verdict
OPEN
C08-69 open §The other clock

Levine et al. 2017: 185 studies, 42,935 men, 52.4% decline in sperm concentration 1973–2011

To check against
FA-05; Levine et al. 2017 Hum Reprod Update 23:646–659. Discrepancy with chapter 3 (BI-10: Levine 2022, 223 studies, 51.6%, to 2018): different papers, both carried
The verdict
OPEN
C08-71 open §The other clock

Germany TFR ~1.4; Europe 1.4–1.5; ideal family size 2.0–2.2; Sobotka & Lutz 2010 fertility gap 0.35

To check against
FA-05; Sobotka & Lutz 2010 Comparative Population Studies 35
The verdict
OPEN
C08-72 open §The other clock

Bujard & Sulak 2016, KZfSS: 68% of German fertility decline from fewer third and higher-order births

To check against
FA-05; Bujard & Sulak 2016 KZfSS 68:487–514
The verdict
OPEN
C08-73 open §The other clock

McDonald gender equity theory: fertility falls where public equity meets private inequity

To check against
FA-05; McDonald 2000 Population and Development Review 26:427–439
The verdict
OPEN
C08-75 open §The other clock

Luci-Greulich & Thévenon 2013: family policies add 0.2–0.3 children per woman across OECD

To check against
FA-05; Luci-Greulich & Thévenon 2013 European Journal of Population 29:387–416
The verdict
OPEN
C08-76 open §Case against

Sear & Mace 2008: father presence improves child survival in about one third of 45 populations; Barí 822 pregnancies, 80% vs 64% survival with secondary fathers

To check against
DH-08, chapter 2 rows; Sear & Mace 2008 Evol Hum Behav 29:1–18; Beckerman et al. 1998 Current Anthropology 39:164–167
The verdict
OPEN
C08-77 open §Case against

Vaughn & Bost / critics: single-caregiver model a Western construct; money not fully separated from father presence

To check against
FA-01; no specific primary for the money point
The verdict
OPEN
C08-78 open referred to via chapter 3 only, not restated

Grebe et al. 2019 meta-analysis (114 effects, 66 studies) confirms direction of fatherhood T decline

To check against
chapter 3 row C03-28
The verdict
OPEN