THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 197 · PAIRING · Cultures in history

Feminisms of sameness and difference, the German story

Contrasts feminisms of sameness (Beauvoir, Butler) and difference (Gilligan, Irigaray, the Milan collective), then tells the German story. West German wives need a husband's permission to work until the late 1970s. In 1971, 374 women declare their abortions in Stern, and in 1975 the constitutional court strikes down first-trimester abortion. The GDR brings women into paid work but leaves them a double burden. A decade after a first child, West German mothers earn about 61% less (Kleven 2019). The STEM gender-equality paradox is disputed.

Open the PDF 16 pages · 360 KB

Number
197
Letter code
HC-05
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Cultures in history
File
197 HC-05 Feminisms of sameness and difference, the German story.pdf
Pages
16

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 21 open
  • 11 to check first
  • P-01 open Check first Stern cover of 6 June 1971, 374 women, "Wir haben abgetrieben!", Romy Schneider among them, organised by Alice Schwarzer after the French manifesto of 343
  • P-02 open Check first West German wife needed husband's consent to take a job until the 1977 marriage-law reform
  • P-34 open Check first Del Giudice, Booth & Irwing 2012: 16PF, N = 10,261, Mahalanobis D = 2.71, overlap about 10 per cent
  • C08-70 open Check first Kleven et al. 2019: long-run child penalty ~20% Denmark vs 60% Germany (FA-05), 61% West Germany (the HC digest)
  • C13-05 open Check first Hausfrauenehe: wife needed husband's consent to work, revocable if the job interfered with her duties in the home, until the 1977 reform
  • C13-07 open Check first Stern cover 6 June 1971, 374 women, Romy Schneider among them, organised by Alice Schwarzer after the French Manifeste des 343; led to Emma
  • C13-08 open Check first 1974 Fristenlösung (legal in the first three months); 1975 Federal Constitutional Court struck it down, BVerfGE 39, 1, reading Article 2 of the Basic Law; fallback to indications
  • C13-09 open Check first GDR legalised abortion on demand in the first twelve weeks in 1972, "three years earlier" than 1975
  • C13-10 open Check first 1993 compromise: abortion remains an offence under §218, unpunished in the first twelve weeks after counselling and a waiting period; still in force
  • C13-11 open Check first 1977 "partnership marriage" reform struck the housewife marriage from the law
  • C13-32 open Check first Kleven, Landais, Posch, Steinhauer and Zweimüller, AEA Papers and Proceedings, 2019: long-run child penalty about 61 per cent in West Germany, about 20 in the United States, 21 to …
  • P-35 open Kaiser et al. 2019 replication: D = 2.06, overlap about 30 per cent
  • C13-04 open The GDR took the opposite bet "for forty-one years"; western rules laid over the whole country in 1990
  • C13-06 open Abortion a crime under Paragraph 218 of the criminal code, with prison
  • C13-26 open Trappe and Rosenfeld documented the double burden from GDR surveys; men's domestic hours did not move; the state "did not challenge male privilege at home"
  • C13-33 open Kleven 2024 NBER working paper: mothers socialised in the East carry a smaller child penalty than those socialised in the West, regardless of current residence
  • C13-52 open Kleven's method: follow a woman's earnings through her first birth against a man's and call the long-run gap the child penalty
  • C16-04 open Public crèches for under-threes a rumour in West Germany when the narrator was born (1975)
  • C16-10 open Paragraph 218 of the West German criminal code (abortion), repealed or reformed after 1971
  • C16-11 open A husband's signature (consent to a wife's employment) abolished, 1977
  • C16-63 open Narrator's mother born 1946, died 2021; the 1971 cover