THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 16: Emancipation 2.0

72 claims, 15 to check first

C16-03 Check first open Opening; What the first half bought; Strongest case against; Load-bearing

350 hours a year more paid work by East German mothers; about 1,800 hours for an East German mother; no gap for fathers; 73 per cent of the gap attributable to stigma, none to wages or childcare prices

To check against
SY-06: Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg, *AEJ: Applied Economics*, 2025, 50 per cent sample of social-security records
The verdict
OPEN
C16-06 Check first open What the first half bought

Seven years after a first child an East German mother is at 70 per cent of her old earnings, a West German mother at 45

To check against
SY-06: Boelmann, Raute and Schönberg; the Preface notes the figure is cited to a 2021 working paper
The verdict
OPEN
C16-08 Check first open What the first half bought; The family; Load-bearing; Numbers to carry

45 natural-fertility populations: mother improved child survival in 100 per cent of studies, older siblings 83, maternal grandmother 69, father 32

To check against
FA-03, DH-08 via chapter 9: Sear and Mace 2008, *Evolution and Human Behavior*
The verdict
OPEN
C16-16 Check first open The couple; Contested; Numbers to carry

Heyman and Slep 2001: Gottman's prediction accuracy (90 per cent per SY-05; 93 or 94 per CO-01, CO-03, CO-04) was in-sample; positive predictive value about 29 per cent out of sample

To check against
SY-05 only for the 29 per cent (its source is the same blog); CO documents for 93/94; chapter 6 row carries the same marker. Discrepancy: 90 vs 93 vs 94
The verdict
OPEN
C16-23 Check first open The family; Contested

Hawkes et al. 1998, *PNAS*, Grandmother Hypothesis, demographic data N = 51,012

To check against
SY-05 only (its sources: a ResearchGate copy and a PMC review); DH-01, DH-03 via chapter 2 cite Hawkes 1998 without the sample. marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C16-32 Check first open The team; Numbers to carry; Load-bearing

Flory, Leibbrandt and List 2015, *Management Science*: opt-in 72.5 per cent of men and 46.7 per cent of women applied; opt-out 76.4 and 75.3; about 7,000 job seekers

To check against
OR-03 via chapter 10
The verdict
OPEN
C16-34 Check first open The team; Strongest case against; Load-bearing

Eagly and Wood 2023: 71 per cent of meta-analytic sex differences mirror the effects of experimental power manipulations

To check against
SY-01 ("Are many sex/gender differences really power differences?", PMC); no other document carries it
The verdict
OPEN
C16-37 Check first open The organisation; Numbers to carry; Load-bearing

Pega et al. 2021: 745,194 deaths in 2016 attributable to long working hours, 72 per cent male

To check against
OR-05 via chapter 11, *Environment International*
The verdict
OPEN
C16-44 Check first open The organisation; In practice

Marine Corps task force 2015: 93 of 134 tasks showed a significant sex difference, 88 favouring all-male teams

To check against
OR-07 via chapter 11
The verdict
OPEN
C16-52 Check first open The state; Load-bearing; Contested

Hudson, Caprioli, Bowen and McDermott 2012, *Sex and World Peace*: WomanStats database, more than 130,000 data points, 175 countries; physical security of women the best predictor of state peacefulness, ahead of wealth and democracy

To check against
SY-05 only for the figures (sources: Google Books, openDemocracy, Goodreads, Bookey); SO-01 via chapter 14 for the finding without the figures. marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C16-54 Check first open The state; In practice; Load-bearing

Dube and Harish 2020, *Journal of Political Economy*: 193 European reigns, 1480 to 1913, polity under a queen 39 percentage points more likely to be at war in a given year

To check against
SO-01 via chapter 14 (18 polities)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-58 Check first open The world; Contested

Caprioli 2000, *American Political Science Review*: women's substantive negotiating power (not observer roles) correlates with lasting peace provisions

To check against
SY-05 only. Its works-cited item for the claim is a different, later APSR article ("Power over presence: women's representation in comprehensive peace negotiations and gender provision outcomes"), author and year not given. marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C16-60 Check first open The world; In practice; Numbers to carry

Falk and Hermle 2018, *Science*: 80,000 people, 76 countries, six preferences; women's risk-taking 0.168 SD below men's; gap width correlates 0.56 with the gender-equality index

To check against
HC-07 via chapter 15; SY-05 and SY-03 for the sample
The verdict
OPEN
C16-69 Check first open In practice

d = 0.21 gives about 85 per cent overlap and a 42 in 100 chance the random woman outscores the random man

To check against
SY-01, SY-05 (Zell, Krizan and Teeter 2015); PS-01, BI-11 via chapter 4 (which gives 92 per cent shared area for d = 0.20 by a different overlap measure; the two measures differ by definition, not by error)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-70 Check first open In practice

Del Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012: Mahalanobis D = 2.71 on 10,261 adults, about 10 per cent overlap

To check against
SY-01, SY-03, SY-05; PS-01 via chapter 4 (Kaiser 2019 replication D = 2.06)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-01 open Opening; What the first half bought

Income splitting in the West German tax code since 1958 ("has had a view on the matter since 1958")

To check against
SY-06 via chapter 13 (Steiner and Wrohlich 2004); primary legal text not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C16-02 open Opening; What the first half bought

In the West, the year a wife's payslip overtakes her husband's, the household reacts (more housework, exit, divorce); not in the East

To check against
SY-06, HC-06: Lippmann, Georgieff and Senik, *The Economic Journal*, 2020, SOEP 1991 to 2012
The verdict
OPEN
C16-04 open Opening

Public crèches for under-threes a rumour in West Germany when the narrator was born (1975)

To check against
HC-05, SY-06 via the Preface; no primary figure named
The verdict
OPEN
C16-05 open What the first half bought

Pill: early legal access cut motherhood before 22 by 14 to 18 per cent and raised employment at 26 to 30 by about 8 per cent

To check against
SO-05 via chapter 15: Goldin and Katz, *Journal of Political Economy*, 2002
The verdict
OPEN
C16-07 open What the first half bought; In practice

Reunified Germany's family panel: couples who start symmetrical tip at the first birth, East and West alike, and do not tip back; the East kept the same woman doing most of the laundry

To check against
SY-06 (FReDA 2021 to 2023) via the Preface and chapter 7
The verdict
OPEN
C16-09 open What the first half bought; The world

Sex gaps in interest, risk and personality widened, not closed, in the richest and most equal countries

To check against
HC-07 via chapter 15: Falk and Hermle 2018; Schmitt et al. 2008; Stoet and Geary 2018 (SY-01, SY-03, SY-05)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-10 open What the first half bought

Paragraph 218 of the West German criminal code (abortion), repealed or reformed after 1971

To check against
HC-05 via the Preface; "to repeal" is the chapter's gloss, the Preface says "a crime under Paragraph 218"
The verdict
OPEN
C16-11 open What the first half bought

A husband's signature (consent to a wife's employment) abolished, 1977

To check against
HC-05 via the Preface, which carries (to be checked) on the 1977 date; no primary legal source in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C16-12 open What the first half bought; What she would recognise

Half-day school as West German design

To check against
SY-06 via chapter 13
The verdict
OPEN
C16-13 open What the first half bought

Men's federal sentences 63 per cent longer for the same file

To check against
SO-04 via chapter 14: Starr, *American Law and Economics Review*, 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C16-14 open What the first half bought; Decoration

Shelf map: Ridley, Geary, Buss (ultimate causes); Eliot, Rippon, Saini (constructivist); Fine, Hooven, Sapolsky (hormonal); Hrdy (cooperative breeding); Reeves (policy); Perel, Deida, Illich (relational); the gap as a book treating physiology as settled and climbing the scales

To check against
SY-03, whose works-cited lean on Wikipedia, Reddit and Goodreads; no citation carried, names and attributions only
The verdict
OPEN
C16-15 open The couple

Gottman 1994: stable couples at roughly 5:1 positive to negative interactions; "bids for connection"

To check against
SY-05 (sources: a couples-app blog, mosaicchats.com, and two app sites); CO-01 via chapter 6 also traces 5:1 to a blog
The verdict
OPEN
C16-18 open The couple

Flooding: pulse above about 95 to 100 beats a minute, adrenaline and cortisol up, reduced frontal control

To check against
CO-01 (95), CO-04 (100) via chapter 6; carried as a range
The verdict
OPEN
C16-19 open The couple

Gottman and Levenson 1985: men flooded faster and stayed flooded longer

To check against
CO-04 via chapter 6
The verdict
OPEN
C16-20 open The couple

Kiecolt-Glaser: women showed larger, longer rises in cortisol and adrenaline, especially when husbands withdrew

To check against
CO-04 via chapter 6; sample and year not given in this chapter
The verdict
OPEN
C16-21 open The couple

Demand-withdraw correlates with dissatisfaction at r = 0.360 across 14,255 people; the demander is whoever wants change

To check against
CO-04 via chapter 6 (74 studies)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-22 open The couple

Joel and colleagues 2020: relationship variables 45 per cent, individual 21 per cent, change over time at most 15 to 20 per cent; machine-learning method

To check against
CO-01 via chapter 6
The verdict
OPEN
C16-24 open The family; Load-bearing

Abraham, Feldman et al. 2014, *PNAS*: 89 first-time parents; amygdala-cortex connectivity linear with fathers' hours of care; primary-caregiving gay fathers show both networks

To check against
FA-01 via chapter 8
The verdict
OPEN
C16-25 open The family

Gettler et al. 2011, Cebu: fathers' testosterone down 26 per cent waking and 34 per cent evening at the median over 4.5 years

To check against
BI-02, BI-06 via chapters 3 and 8; discrepancy: one report gives 20.5 per cent, sample given as 394 to 683
The verdict
OPEN
C16-26 open The family; In practice

Voland and Beise 2002, Krummhörn, about 32,000 parish records: paternal grandmother in the household raised neonatal mortality 2.48 times; maternal grandmother lowered infant mortality

To check against
FA-03 via chapter 9, which names the journal two ways
The verdict
OPEN
C16-27 open The family; In practice

Daycare cortisol rise as an open question

To check against
DH-08 via chapter 9
The verdict
OPEN
C16-28 open The family

Market childcare substitutes for kin at an unmeasured cost

To check against
SY-05's stated counter-evidence; no source named
The verdict
OPEN
C16-29 open The team

Woolley et al. 2010, *Science*: collective intelligence factor c, weakly tied to members' IQ, tied to equal turn-taking and Reading the Mind in the Eyes scores; more women, higher c

To check against
OR-01, PS-05 via chapter 10; SY-05
The verdict
OPEN
C16-30 open The team; Contested

Credé and colleagues' meta-analysis: 857 groups, 22 to 35 per cent variance extracted, eigenvalue 1.05, r = 0.26 with criterion tasks

To check against
OR-01 via chapter 10 (Credé and Howardson 2017, *Journal of Applied Psychology*); SY-05 dates it 2019 (its source is a CI conference paper). Discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C16-31 open The team; In practice

Hardt, Mayer and Rincke 2024, *Management Science*: men said almost 70 per cent more words than women in 342 four-person audio-only teams

To check against
OR-01 via chapter 10 (1,368 people)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-33 open The team; In practice

Gillen, Snowberg and Yariv 2019: the tournament-entry gap as risk and confidence measured with error

To check against
OR-03 via chapter 10
The verdict
OPEN
C16-35 open The organisation; The library

SY-05's organisation principle cites no primary source ("research in the financial services sector and broader economic models")

To check against
SY-05, whose reference for the claim is an IMF working paper on unpaid work
The verdict
OPEN
C16-36 open The organisation; In practice

Kivimäki et al. 2015, *The Lancet*: 55 hours or more a week, stroke relative risk 1.33 across 528,908 people

To check against
OR-05 via chapter 11 (CI 1.11 to 1.61)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-38 open The organisation

Eagly and Johnson 1990: leadership style task-oriented d = 0.00, interpersonal 0.04, 162 studies

To check against
OR-02 via chapter 11; PS-03 gives 161 studies
The verdict
OPEN
C16-39 open The organisation; Strongest case against

Japan's menstrual leave used by 0.9 per cent of women entitled to it

To check against
OR-04 via chapter 11
The verdict
OPEN
C16-40 open The organisation

Schoep et al. 2019, *BMJ Open*: 80.7 per cent of 32,748 Dutch women worked through menstrual pain at about a third less output

To check against
OR-04 via chapter 11
The verdict
OPEN
C16-41 open The organisation

Gruber 1994: a mandated benefit for one group tends to come out of that group's wages

To check against
OR-04 via chapter 11
The verdict
OPEN
C16-42 open The organisation; Decoration

Fontevraud: monks under an abbess from 1101 to 1790 (689 years); authority put in writing

To check against
OR-06, OR-07 via chapter 11
The verdict
OPEN
C16-43 open The organisation

Kibbutzim re-established a sex division of labour within two generations; cause disputed (Tiger and Shepher 1975 against critics)

To check against
OR-06, HC-06 via chapters 11 and 13
The verdict
OPEN
C16-45 open The city; Contested

SY-05's city principle cites no primary source; women do "20 to 1000 per cent" more unpaid work, credited to global time-use surveys via an IMF working paper (2019)

To check against
SY-05 only (works-cited 62, 63: IMF WP/19/225). marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C16-46 open The city; In practice; Numbers (via chapter 12)

Ravensbergen et al. 2023, *Transport Policy*: care trips 28 per cent of all trips in Montréal, 32 per cent of women's and 25 per cent of men's

To check against
SO-03 via chapter 12
The verdict
OPEN
C16-47 open The city

Bovens and Marcoci 2020: toilet service time 178.9 seconds for women against 118.4 for men; fixture ratio 2:1 to 3.25:1 equalises the queue

To check against
SO-03 via chapter 12, *Behavioural Public Policy*
The verdict
OPEN
C16-48 open The city

Eva Kail's Vienna exhibition of 1991; Vienna counted the care loop before building for it

To check against
SO-03 via chapter 12 (municipal and secondary sources)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-49 open The city; Strongest case against; In practice

Alesina, Giuliano and Nunn 2013: historical plough use predicts present sex roles ("a thousand years")

To check against
SO-05 via chapters 12 and 15; "a thousand years" is the chapter's rounding
The verdict
OPEN
C16-50 open The city; In practice

Proximity priced by the market becomes a luxury; carers commute in from the edge

To check against
SY-05's stated counter-evidence (gentrification); SO-03 via chapter 12 (Kern)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-51 open In practice

Vienna satisfaction figure rests on a press release

To check against
SO-03 via chapter 12 (Aspern, 93 per cent)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-53 open The state

Legal polygyny breeds a surplus of unmarried young men and instability

To check against
SY-05 (Goodreads quotations as source); the commissioned document SO-02 is missing; carried as open, see chapter 14 (SO-02, still to be written)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-55 open The state

Bhalotra and Clots-Figueras 2014: a ten-point rise in women's share of an Indian state legislature cut neonatal mortality by 2.1 percentage points, a third of the baseline

To check against
SO-01 via chapter 14
The verdict
OPEN
C16-56 open The state; In practice

Finestone et al. 2005 and 2014: stress fractures 23.9 per cent in women against 11.2 in men under identical Israeli training; 12.0 against 1.3 in light infantry

To check against
SO-04 via chapter 14 (*Military Medicine*, relative risks 2.13 and 9.23)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-57 open The state; In practice

Critics hold the Hudson correlation may be consequence or a third factor

To check against
SO-01's own critics via chapter 14
The verdict
OPEN
C16-59 open The world

Accra peace talks on Liberia, 2003, as the example of women's influence on a settlement

To check against
SY-05 only, same source as C16-58. marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C16-61 open The world; In practice; Numbers to carry

Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault 2020, *PNAS*: 300,000 15-year-olds, 64 countries; "maths is not for girls" stereotype stronger in richer countries; paradox vanishes once controlled

To check against
SY-01, HC-07 via chapter 15
The verdict
OPEN
C16-62 open The world; In practice

Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020, *Sex Roles*: no within-country divergence in values as equality rose, 235,339 people, 32 countries

To check against
HC-07 via chapters 5 and 15
The verdict
OPEN
C16-63 open What she would recognise

Narrator's mother born 1946, died 2021; the 1971 cover

To check against
The author's biographical facts of 2026-09-30; HC-05 via the Preface for the cover
The verdict
OPEN
C16-64 open What she would recognise

Grandmothers in the human design "for two hundred thousand years"

To check against
DH-01, DH-03, DH-08 via chapter 2 (the figure is the Preface's and chapter 2's rounding for the foraging era)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-65 open Strongest case against

Eliot et al. 2021: male brains about 10 per cent larger; sex explains about 1 per cent of structural variance after volume correction

To check against
SY-01 (Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews); BI-11 via chapter 4
The verdict
OPEN
C16-66 open Strongest case against; Load-bearing

van Anders et al. 2011, *Psychoneuroendocrinology*: testosterone as a dependent variable; infant care lowers it, competition and authority raise it in both sexes

To check against
SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C16-67 open Strongest case against; Load-bearing

Mazei et al. 2015, *Psychological Bulletin*: 10,888 participants; male negotiation advantage disappears or reverses with advocacy for others, transparency or experience

To check against
SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C16-68 open Strongest case against

Fausto-Sterling 2012: caregivers embed gender in infants from birth to 15 months

To check against
SY-01 (*Sex/Gender: Biology in a Social World*)
The verdict
OPEN
C16-71 open Contested

Stoet and Geary 2018 sample: 472,242 adolescents in 67 countries against over 300,000 in 73 countries

To check against
HC-07 and SY-03 (472,242) against SY-05 (300,000, 73 countries). Not in prose; discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C16-72 open Contested

Lassek and Gaulin 2009 muscle mass: about 60 per cent more in men (Preface) against 65 per cent (SY-05)

To check against
Preface via SY-02/SY-04; SY-05 (Frontiers 2022 secondary). Not in prose; discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN