THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 211 · PAIRING · Couples

Conflict between men and women

Reviews conflict between partners in body, behaviour and culture. Schrodt et al. (2014, 74 studies, 14,255 people) tie the demand-withdraw pattern to dissatisfaction, r = .36. Wives more often demand, but Christensen et al. (2006) find the demander is whoever wants change, in gay and lesbian couples too. Hostile couples heal wounds at 60% of others' rate (Kiecolt-Glaser et al. 2005), and wives show stronger stress-hormone reactions to conflict. Gottman and Levenson's 93% divorce prediction is contested, resting on 21 divorces. Some figures were lost from the PDF text.

Open the PDF 17 pages · 357 KB

Number
211
Letter code
CO-04
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Couples
File
211 CO-04 Conflict between men and women.pdf
Pages
17

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 24 open
  • 11 to check first
  • C06-01 open Check first Gottman and Levenson recruited 79 couples in 1980 and followed them for 14 years, measuring interbeat interval, pulse transmission time, skin conductance and somatic activity, …
  • C06-03 open Check first Flooding threshold: above 100 bpm (CO-04) versus above 95 bpm, 85 for conditioned athletes (CO-01, cited to a clinical manual). Carried as range 95 to 100. Discrepancy logged
  • C06-05 open Check first Men flooded faster and stayed flooded longer than women, and took longer to return to baseline
  • C06-10 open Check first Prediction accuracy: up to 94 per cent (Gottman, Coan, Carrere & Swanson 1998 JMF, CO-01) versus 93 per cent (Gottman & Levenson 1999, CO-03, CO-04). Both carried as two papers
  • C06-11 open Check first The 93 per cent rests on N = 79 with only 21 divorces
  • C06-19 open Check first Schrodt, Witt & Shimkowski 2014 Communication Monographs: 74 studies, 14,255 participants, r = .360 overall, wife-demand/husband-withdraw r = .380 (majority), …
  • C06-21 open Check first 63 heterosexual, gay and lesbian couples: demander is whoever wants more change regardless of sex. CO-04 attributes this to the same 2006 reference. May be a different paper …
  • C06-23 open Check first Gottman & Levenson 2003 Journal of Homosexuality: 12-year study of 21 gay and 21 lesbian couples (42). CO-04 gives 106, which is Garanzini 2017's therapy sample. 42 carried, …
  • C06-30 open Check first Women show greater and more persistent rises in cortisol, adrenaline and noradrenaline after conflict, especially when husbands withdraw; 90 newlywed couples (Kiecolt-Glaser & …
  • C06-31 open Check first Kiecolt-Glaser et al. 2005 Archives of General Psychiatry: 42 married couples, suction blisters, 30-minute conflict, hostile couples healed at 60 per cent of the rate, IL-6 and …
  • C06-33 open Check first Ditzen et al. 2009 Biological Psychiatry: 47 couples (94 people), intranasal oxytocin raised positive:negative ratio (F = 4.18, p = .047) and lowered cortisol (F = 7.14, p = …
  • C06-04 open Flooding involves adrenaline (epinephrine) and cortisol release, raised blood pressure, down-regulation of prefrontal function
  • C06-06 open Stonewalling as escape conditioning, silence lowers the pulse
  • C06-17 open Christensen described demand-withdraw in 1988
  • C06-20 open Christensen, Eldridge, Catta-Preta, Lim & Santagata 2006 JCCP: same demand-withdraw asymmetry in Brazil, Italy, Taiwan and the USA
  • C06-22 open "Biology provides the mechanism (flooding), culture dictates who demands and who withdraws"
  • C06-29 open Kiecolt-Glaser 1996 JCCP paper titled "Marital Conflict and Endocrine Function: Are Men Really More Physiologically Affected Than Women?"
  • C06-35 open Robles, Slatcher, Trombello & McGinn 2014 Psychological Bulletin: 126 articles, more than 72,000 people, r = .07 to .21 (PS-07), mortality r = .11 and cardiovascular reactivity r …
  • C06-53 open Time-out of 20 to 30 minutes for adrenaline and cortisol to clear, blog-sourced in both documents
  • C16-17 open Five-to-one figure traceable in every library document only to a couples-app blog
  • C16-18 open Flooding: pulse above about 95 to 100 beats a minute, adrenaline and cortisol up, reduced frontal control
  • C16-19 open Gottman and Levenson 1985: men flooded faster and stayed flooded longer
  • C16-20 open Kiecolt-Glaser: women showed larger, longer rises in cortisol and adrenaline, especially when husbands withdrew
  • C16-21 open Demand-withdraw correlates with dissatisfaction at r = 0.360 across 14,255 people; the demander is whoever wants change