THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 6: Flooding

54 claims, 19 to check first

C06-01 Check first open Opening, §The number on the strip

Gottman and Levenson recruited 79 couples in 1980 and followed them for 14 years, measuring interbeat interval, pulse transmission time, skin conductance and somatic activity, published 1985 JPSP and 1999 JMF "The Timing of Divorce"

To check against
CO-04; Gottman & Levenson 1985 J Pers Soc Psychol; Gottman & Levenson 1999 J Marriage Fam
The verdict
OPEN
C06-03 Check first open §The number on the strip, Numbers to carry

Flooding threshold: above 100 bpm (CO-04) versus above 95 bpm, 85 for conditioned athletes (CO-01, cited to a clinical manual). Carried as range 95 to 100. Discrepancy logged

To check against
CO-01 (clinical manual ref), CO-04; Gottman's primary definition of flooding
The verdict
OPEN
C06-05 Check first open §The number on the strip, Load-bearing

Men flooded faster and stayed flooded longer than women, and took longer to return to baseline

To check against
CO-04 citing Gottman & Levenson 1985 JPSP; CO-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-07 Check first open §The number on the strip, Contested

"About 85 per cent of stonewallers were men": Gottman's clinical claim, traced only to a couples-app blog (Connected Couples ref 6 in CO-01, PS-02, PS-03). Stated as unsourced impression, not fact

To check against
CO-01 ref 6 (blog), PS-02, PS-03; no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C06-10 Check first open §The number on the strip, Contested

Prediction accuracy: up to 94 per cent (Gottman, Coan, Carrere & Swanson 1998 JMF, CO-01) versus 93 per cent (Gottman & Levenson 1999, CO-03, CO-04). Both carried as two papers

To check against
CO-01, CO-03, CO-04; Gottman et al. 1998 J Marriage Fam; Gottman & Levenson 1999
The verdict
OPEN
C06-11 Check first open §The number on the strip, Numbers to carry

The 93 per cent rests on N = 79 with only 21 divorces

To check against
CO-04 PDF page 9 (N = 79 recovered from image layer); Gottman & Levenson 1999
The verdict
OPEN
C06-13 Check first open §The number on the strip, Strongest case

Heyman & Smith Slep 2001 JMF "The hazards of predicting divorce without crossvalidation": same-sample fitting, no cross-validation

To check against
CO-01; Heyman & Slep 2001 J Marriage Fam 63:473
The verdict
OPEN
C06-15 Check first open §The number on the strip, In practice, Numbers to carry

Cross-validated positive predictive value about 29 per cent. Figure is from SY-05 via the concept note, not in CO-01, CO-03 or CO-04 (CO-03 says only "often failing to exceed chance")

To check against
SY-05; Heyman & Slep 2001 Table of cross-validated results
The verdict
OPEN
C06-19 Check first open §Who wants the change, Load-bearing, Numbers to carry, In practice

Schrodt, Witt & Shimkowski 2014 Communication Monographs: 74 studies, 14,255 participants, r = .360 overall, wife-demand/husband-withdraw r = .380 (majority), husband-demand/wife-withdraw r = .392 (substantial minority), clinical r = .413

To check against
CO-04 (r = .360 recovered from PDF page 9 image layer); Schrodt, Witt & Shimkowski 2014 Commun Monogr 81:28
The verdict
OPEN
C06-21 Check first open §Who wants the change, Strongest case, Contested

63 heterosexual, gay and lesbian couples: demander is whoever wants more change regardless of sex. CO-04 attributes this to the same 2006 reference. May be a different paper (possibly Holley, Sturm & Levenson 2010). Logged as unresolved

To check against
CO-04; primary source to be identified
The verdict
OPEN
C06-23 Check first open §Who wants the change, Contested

Gottman & Levenson 2003 Journal of Homosexuality: 12-year study of 21 gay and 21 lesbian couples (42). CO-04 gives 106, which is Garanzini 2017's therapy sample. 42 carried, discrepancy logged

To check against
CO-06; CO-04; Gottman, Levenson, Gross et al. 2003 J Homosex 45:23
The verdict
OPEN
C06-27 Check first open §Who wants the change, Strongest case

Rosenfeld 2014: controlling for marital status, same-sex and different-sex couples have nearly identical break-up rates

To check against
CO-06; Rosenfeld 2014 J Marriage Fam 76:905
The verdict
OPEN
C06-30 Check first open §The sex that reacts more, Load-bearing

Women show greater and more persistent rises in cortisol, adrenaline and noradrenaline after conflict, especially when husbands withdraw; 90 newlywed couples (Kiecolt-Glaser & Newton 2001)

To check against
CO-04; Kiecolt-Glaser & Newton 2001 Psychol Bull 127:472
The verdict
OPEN
C06-31 Check first open §The sex that reacts more, Load-bearing

Kiecolt-Glaser et al. 2005 Archives of General Psychiatry: 42 married couples, suction blisters, 30-minute conflict, hostile couples healed at 60 per cent of the rate, IL-6 and TNF-alpha raised

To check against
CO-04; Kiecolt-Glaser et al. 2005 Arch Gen Psychiatry 62:1377
The verdict
OPEN
C06-33 Check first open §The sex that reacts more, Contested

Ditzen et al. 2009 Biological Psychiatry: 47 couples (94 people), intranasal oxytocin raised positive:negative ratio (F = 4.18, p = .047) and lowered cortisol (F = 7.14, p = .011). Statistics recovered from CO-04 PDF page 3 image layer

To check against
CO-04 PDF page 3; Ditzen et al. 2009 Biol Psychiatry 65:728
The verdict
OPEN
C06-37 Check first open §The ledger, Strongest case, Numbers to carry

Pierce, Dahl & Nielsen 2013 PSPB "In Sickness and in Wealth": more than 200,000 married Danish couples 1997 to 2006, ED medication up 0.06 percentage points at the point where wife's income passes husband's (p < .01), wives more insomnia and anxiety prescriptions, no discontinuity for cohabiting couples or where she out-earned him before marriage

To check against
CO-07; Pierce, Dahl & Nielsen 2013 Pers Soc Psychol Bull 39:359
The verdict
OPEN
C06-42 Check first open §The ledger, Contested

Killewald 2016 ASR, PSID 46 years, more than 6,300 couples: pre-1975 marriages with 50-50 housework 36 per cent more likely to divorce than wife-75 per cent; post-1975 housework loses predictive power; husband without full-time job 3.3 versus 2.5 per cent annual divorce (33 per cent in CO-06 and CO-07, about 30 per cent in CO-02); wife's income no effect. Discrepancy logged

To check against
CO-06, CO-07, CO-02; Killewald 2016 Am Sociol Rev 81:696
The verdict
OPEN
C06-47 Check first open §The tide and the bond, Numbers to carry

Frankenbach et al. 2022 Psychological Bulletin: 211 studies, 621,463 people, g = 0.69, 95 per cent CI 0.58 to 0.81, adjusted for response bias g = 0.54. Point estimates recovered from PS-06 PDF page 5 image layer (stripped in TXT). Overlap figures (about 73 and 79 per cent) computed by me from the overlap coefficient

To check against
PS-06 PDF page 5; Frankenbach et al. 2022 Psychol Bull 148:621
The verdict
OPEN
C06-52 Check first open §The tide and the bond, Strongest case, Load-bearing

Joel et al. 2020 PNAS: 43 datasets, more than 11,000 couples, relationship variables about 45 per cent of current quality, individual differences about 21 per cent, change over time at most 15 to 20 per cent, perceived partner responsiveness strongest predictor. "85 colleagues" is my count of the author list and needs checking

To check against
CO-01, PS-07; Joel et al. 2020 Proc Natl Acad Sci 117:19061
The verdict
OPEN
C06-02 open §The number on the strip

Gottman's and Levenson's 1980 affiliations (Illinois, Indiana)

To check against
Not in documents, general knowledge, marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-04 open §The number on the strip

Flooding involves adrenaline (epinephrine) and cortisol release, raised blood pressure, down-regulation of prefrontal function

To check against
CO-01, CO-04; no primary source named for the prefrontal claim
The verdict
OPEN
C06-06 open §The number on the strip

Stonewalling as escape conditioning, silence lowers the pulse

To check against
CO-04; no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C06-08 open §The number on the strip

Four Horsemen: criticism, contempt, defensiveness, stonewalling, contempt most destructive

To check against
CO-01; Gottman 1994 Why Marriages Succeed or Fail (not in documents)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-09 open §The number on the strip, Decoration

5:1 positive to negative during conflict and 20:1 outside conflict, blog-sourced

To check against
CO-01 refs 6 and 9 (blogs); no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C06-12 open §The number on the strip

Extreme-group samples of 60 to 79 couples (CO-01 PDF page 4, recovered from image layer) versus 60 to 130 (CO-03). Both carried

To check against
CO-01 PDF page 4, CO-03; Heyman & Slep 2001
The verdict
OPEN
C06-14 open §The number on the strip

Heyman and Slep at Stony Brook University

To check against
Not in documents, marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-16 open §The number on the strip, Strongest case

Heyman & Slep 2002: sex-typed sequences (husband's rejection of influence, wife's negative start-up, failure to de-escalate) failed to replicate on a community sample, constructs remained risk factors, "equifinal"

To check against
CO-01; Heyman & Slep 2002 (journal not named in CO-01)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-17 open §Who wants the change

Christensen described demand-withdraw in 1988

To check against
CO-04; Christensen 1988 chapter (not named precisely in CO-04)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-18 open §Who wants the change

Christensen at UCLA

To check against
Not in documents, marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-20 open §Who wants the change

Christensen, Eldridge, Catta-Preta, Lim & Santagata 2006 JCCP: same demand-withdraw asymmetry in Brazil, Italy, Taiwan and the USA

To check against
CO-04; Christensen et al. 2006 J Consult Clin Psychol 74:1029
The verdict
OPEN
C06-22 open §Who wants the change

"Biology provides the mechanism (flooding), culture dictates who demands and who withdraws"

To check against
CO-04's own consensus line; no primary source
The verdict
OPEN
C06-24 open §Who wants the change

Same-sex couples: more affection and humour at start-up, less belligerence, domineering and fear, unhappy couples abnormally low arousal

To check against
CO-06; Gottman et al. 2003
The verdict
OPEN
C06-25 open §Who wants the change

Garanzini et al. 2017 JMFT: 106 gay and lesbian couples, uncontrolled

To check against
CO-06; Garanzini et al. 2017 J Marital Fam Ther
The verdict
OPEN
C06-26 open §Who wants the change

Rosenfeld at Stanford; HCMST 2017 wave N = 3,510 (recovered from CO-06 PDF page 3 image layer)

To check against
CO-06 PDF page 3; affiliation not in documents, marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-28 open §The sex that reacts more

Kiecolt-Glaser at Ohio State University College of Medicine

To check against
Not in documents, marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-29 open §The sex that reacts more

Kiecolt-Glaser 1996 JCCP paper titled "Marital Conflict and Endocrine Function: Are Men Really More Physiologically Affected Than Women?"

To check against
CO-04 ref 14; Kiecolt-Glaser et al. 1996 J Consult Clin Psychol 64:324
The verdict
OPEN
C06-32 open §The sex that reacts more

Ditzen then at University of Zurich

To check against
Not in documents, marked (to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-34 open §The sex that reacts more

Ditzen 2013 Psychoneuroendocrinology: oxytocin lowered salivary alpha-amylase in women, raised it in men, rise in men correlated with more positive communication

To check against
CO-03; Ditzen et al. 2013 Psychoneuroendocrinology
The verdict
OPEN
C06-35 open §The sex that reacts more

Robles, Slatcher, Trombello & McGinn 2014 Psychological Bulletin: 126 articles, more than 72,000 people, r = .07 to .21 (PS-07), mortality r = .11 and cardiovascular reactivity r = −.13 (CO-04 PDF page 3, image layer), comparable to diet and exercise

To check against
CO-01, CO-04 PDF page 3, PS-07; Robles et al. 2014 Psychol Bull 140:140
The verdict
OPEN
C06-36 open §The sex that reacts more, In practice

KORA-Age: lonely married men have a flatter diurnal cortisol slope

To check against
CO-01; KORA-Age paper not named in CO-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-38 open §The ledger, Decoration

Syrda 2020 PSPB: PSID, 6,035 households, male distress U-shaped, minimum at wife's share about 40 per cent, maximum at 100 per cent

To check against
CO-07; Syrda 2020 Pers Soc Psychol Bull
The verdict
OPEN
C06-39 open §The ledger, Contested

Bertrand, Kamenica & Pan 2015 QJE cliff at 50 per cent; Binder & Lam 2022 J Human Resources: cliff vanishes removing about 0.25 per cent exactly-equal earners

To check against
CO-07; Bertrand et al. 2015 Q J Econ 130:571; Binder & Lam 2022 J Hum Resour
The verdict
OPEN
C06-40 open §The ledger

Murray-Close & Heggeness 2018 Demography: CPS versus IRS, 15.9 percentage points more likely to misreport when wife just out-earns, men +5.8, women −5.1

To check against
CO-07; Murray-Close & Heggeness 2018 Demography
The verdict
OPEN
C06-41 open §The ledger, Decoration

Munsch 2015 ASR, NLSY N = 2,750: fully dependent men about 15 per cent annual infidelity versus about 5 per cent for dependent women, male minimum at about 70 per cent of income, 85 per cent of dependent men do not cheat in a year

To check against
CO-07; Munsch 2015 Am Sociol Rev 80:469
The verdict
OPEN
C06-43 open §The ledger

The author born 1975; parents' household under the older contract

To check against
Supplied biography (the author b. 1975, father 1943 to 2001, mother Barbara 1946 Lobberich to 2021); passing reference only
The verdict
OPEN
C06-44 open §The ledger, Strongest case

Gonalons-Pons & Gangl 2021 ASR, 29 countries: male unemployment raises separation only where breadwinner norm is strong

To check against
CO-07; Gonalons-Pons & Gangl 2021 Am Sociol Rev
The verdict
OPEN
C06-45 open §The ledger, Strongest case

Sprengholz et al. 2022: female-breadwinning life-satisfaction penalty in West Germany, absent in East

To check against
CO-07; Sprengholz et al. 2022 (journal not named in CO-07)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-46 open §The tide and the bond, Decoration

Klusmann 2002 Archives of Sexual Behavior: 1,865 people, cross-sectional, desire declines with duration in women only, men stable

To check against
PS-06; Klusmann 2002 Arch Sex Behav 31:275
The verdict
OPEN
C06-48 open §The tide and the bond, In practice

Conley & Yang 2024 critique: orgasm rates above 90 per cent for men versus 35 to 65 per cent for women, pain and fear; Frankenbach 2024 reply concedes suppression of reported desire

To check against
PS-06; Conley & Yang 2024 Psychol Bull; Frankenbach et al. 2024 reply
The verdict
OPEN
C06-49 open §The tide and the bond, In practice

Muise, Schimmack & Impett 2016: well-being plateau at about once a week; Muise et al. 2020 SPPS: total desire matters more than matching

To check against
PS-06; Muise et al. 2016 Soc Psychol Pers Sci 7:295; Muise et al. 2020
The verdict
OPEN
C06-50 open §The tide and the bond, In practice

Del Giudice 2011 Psychological Bulletin: 113 samples, 66,132 people, men more avoidant and less anxious, D = .28 community (about 78 per cent overlap), .12 college, −.07 web

To check against
PS-07; Del Giudice 2011 Psychol Bull 137:193 (chapter 04 also cites)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-51 open §The tide and the bond, In practice

Chopik, Edelstein & Grimm 2019 JPSP: 628 people over 59 years, anxiety peaks in young adulthood, avoidance declines linearly

To check against
PS-07; Chopik et al. 2019 J Pers Soc Psychol
The verdict
OPEN
C06-53 open §In practice, Decoration

Time-out of 20 to 30 minutes for adrenaline and cortisol to clear, blog-sourced in both documents

To check against
CO-01, CO-04 ref 8 (empathi.com blog); no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C06-54 open Opening

Resting pulse typically 60 to 80 beats a minute; 100 as the pulse of a brisk walk

To check against
General physiology, no document source
The verdict
OPEN