THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 5: Two Shelves and a Trap

59 claims, 23 to check first

C05-04 Check first open §The gap that Hume found

David Hume, 1739, noticed the unannounced step from is to ought

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Hume, *A Treatise of Human Nature* (1739), Book III, Part I, Section I
The verdict
OPEN
C05-05 Check first open §The gap that Hume found

G. E. Moore named the naturalistic fallacy in *Principia Ethica*, 1903

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Moore, G. E. (1903) *Principia Ethica*, ch. 1. Note: Moore's own definition differs from the is-to-ought reading given here; check that the chapter's gloss is fair
The verdict
OPEN
C05-06 Check first open §The gap that Hume found

Bernard Davis, microbiologist, named the moralistic fallacy in *Nature*, 1978

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Davis, B. D. (1978) "The moralistic fallacy", *Nature* 272:390. Confirm volume, page and the exact wording of his definition
The verdict
OPEN
C05-10 Check first open §The gap that Hume found

Larmuseau and colleagues matched Y-chromosome analyses to genealogical records over 500 years in the Low Countries; *Trends in Ecology & Evolution* 2016 and *Current Biology* 2019

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau, M. H. D. et al. (2016) *TREE*; Larmuseau et al. (2019) *Current Biology*. Confirm titles, volumes, and that the 2016 paper is a review rather than the primary data paper. First name and affiliation not in the library (marked in the text for checking)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-11 Check first open §The gap that Hume found; §Numbers to carry

Extra-pair paternity about 1 to 2 per cent per generation over five centuries

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau et al. 2019 *Current Biology*. Confirm the range and the "per generation" framing
The verdict
OPEN
C05-12 Check first open §The gap that Hume found; §Numbers to carry

Extra-pair paternity about 0.4 per cent in tightly knit farming villages

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau et al. 2019. Confirm figure and the "surveillance" reading
The verdict
OPEN
C05-13 Check first open §The gap that Hume found; §Numbers to carry

Extra-pair paternity about 5.9 per cent among the poorest classes in crowded industrial cities

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau et al. 2019. Confirm figure, class definition and period
The verdict
OPEN
C05-19 Check first open §What held

Carney, Cuddy and Yap, *Psychological Science*, 2010: two minutes of expansive posture raised testosterone, lowered cortisol, increased financial risk-taking

To check against
SY-04. Primary: Carney, D. R., Cuddy, A. J. C., Yap, A. J. (2010) *Psychological Science* 21(10):1363–1368. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-20 Check first open §What held; §Numbers to carry; §In practice

Ranehill and colleagues, *Psychological Science*, 2015, pre-registered, 200 participants: no effect on testosterone, cortisol or risk; felt-power effect survived

To check against
SY-04. N = 200 was stripped from the TXT and read from the PDF page image (SY-04 p. 7). Primary: Ranehill, E. et al. (2015) *Psychological Science* 26(5):653–656. Confirm N and pre-registration
The verdict
OPEN
C05-21 Check first open §What held

The original Carney 2010 sample was much smaller than 200

To check against
SY-04 says only "much larger" of Ranehill; original N not in the library ((to be checked)). Primary: Carney et al. 2010
The verdict
OPEN
C05-23 Check first open §What held

Pahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014: 184 studies, 1.6 million pupils, 21 countries; advantage of single-sex schooling shrinks to g = 0.10 (girls) and 0.06 (boys, mathematics) once selection is allowed for

To check against
SY-04. The g values were stripped from the TXT and read from the PDF page image (p. 7). Primary: Pahlke, E., Hyde, J. S., Allison, C. M. (2014) *Psychological Bulletin* 140(4):1042–1072. Confirm which outcomes the 0.10 and 0.06 refer to
The verdict
OPEN
C05-25 Check first open §What held

Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009: things-versus-people d = 0.93 across 503,188 respondents in 47 interest inventories; engineering d = 1.11

To check against
HC-07 (N, d, engineering) and SY-04 (47 inventories). Primary: Su, R., Rounds, J., Armstrong, P. I. (2009) *Psychological Bulletin* 135(6):859–884. First names from HC-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-30 Check first open §What held; §In practice

Spencer, Steele and Quinn 1999, *Journal of Experimental Social Psychology*: able women underperform on a hard maths test when told it shows sex differences, and match men when told it does not

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Spencer, S. J., Steele, C. M., Quinn, D. M. (1999) *JESP* 35(1):4–28. First names not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C05-31 Check first open §What held; §Numbers to carry; §Strongest case; §In practice

Stoet and Geary 2012: 55 per cent of replication designs reproduced stereotype threat; half of those adjusted for prior maths scores in a way that manufactures the result; 30 per cent of clean replications worked

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Stoet, G., Geary, D. C. (2012) *Review of General Psychology* 16(1):93–102. Confirm the three percentages and the "adjusted for prior scores" characterisation
The verdict
OPEN
C05-36 Check first open §The paradox; §Contested

Falk and Hermle, *Science*, 2018: 80,000 people in 76 countries; gaps in risk, patience, altruism, trust near zero in poor countries and largest in rich ones; r = 0.67 with log GDP per head

To check against
HC-07 (r = 0.67 log GDP, 0.56 equality index). Primary: Falk, A., Hermle, J. (2018) *Science* 362(6412):eaas9899. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-37 Check first open §The paradox; §The trust rules; §Numbers to carry

Stoet and Geary 2018, *Psychological Science*: 472,242 fifteen-year-olds in 67 countries (PISA); girls matched or beat boys in science in about two thirds of countries

To check against
HC-07 and SY-03 (472,242 / 67). Discrepancy: SY-05 (per SY distilled sheet) gives over 300,000 in 73 countries. Primary: Stoet, G., Geary, D. C. (2018) *Psychological Science* 29(4):581–593. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-38 Check first open §The paradox; §Numbers to carry

Finland, Norway and Sweden: fewer than 25 per cent women among STEM graduates; Algeria, Tunisia and Turkey: 35 to 40 per cent

To check against
HC-07. Primary: Stoet and Geary 2018, Figure 3 and supplementary data (UNESCO graduate shares). Confirm the country figures and the year of the graduate data
The verdict
OPEN
C05-40 Check first open §The paradox; §Numbers to carry; §Contested

Richardson and colleagues 2020, same journal: the STEM result rested on an undisclosed "propensity" measure; with the plain graduate share the correlation shrinks or vanishes; a correction was issued

To check against
HC-07 and SY-01. Primary: Richardson, S. S. et al. (2020) *Psychological Science* 31(3):338–341; Stoet and Geary (2020) corrigendum. First names not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C05-41 Check first open §The paradox; §Contested

Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault, *PNAS*, 2020: 300,000 pupils in 64 countries; the "maths is not for girls" stereotype is stronger in richer, more equal countries and explains away the wealth–STEM-gap link

To check against
SY-01 (N, countries), HC-07. Discrepancy: HC-07 gives Breda and Napp 2019 (PNAS) an identical sample (300,000 / 64); possibly the same PISA 2012 wave, possibly conflated. N = 300,000 confirmed from SY-04 PDF page image. Primary: Breda, T., Jouini, E., Napp, C., Thebault, G. (2020) *PNAS* 117(49):31063–31069. First name Thomas from SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-42 Check first open §The paradox; §Numbers to carry; §Load-bearing; §In practice

Fors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020, *Sex Roles*: eight ESS rounds, 235,339 people, 32 countries; cross-section reproduced; no within-country widening as equality rose

To check against
HC-07. Primary: Fors Connolly, F., Goossen, M., Hjerm, M. (2020) *Sex Roles* 83:101–113. First names not in the library. Confirm "no divergence" is not overstated (HC-07 says "if anything, convergence")
The verdict
OPEN
C05-47 Check first open §Strongest case

Eliot and colleagues 2021: after allowing for the roughly 10 per cent larger male brain, sex explains about 1 per cent of variance in brain structure

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Eliot, L. et al. (2021) *Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews* 125:667–697. First name Lise from SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-50 Check first open §Strongest case; §In practice

Zell, Krizan and Teeter 2015: more than twelve million people; mean d = 0.21; about 85 per cent overlap; a random woman outscores a random man on a "male" trait about 42 per cent of the time

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Zell, E., Krizan, Z., Teeter, S. R. (2015) *American Psychologist* 70(1):10–20. First names not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C05-53 Check first open §Strongest case

Eagly and Wood 2023: 71 per cent of meta-analytic sex differences mirror the effects of experimental manipulations of power

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Eagly, A. H., Wood, W. (2023), journal not given in SY-01. First names Alice and Wendy from SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-01 open §Opening

*Testosterone Rex*, Cordelia Fine, 2017, argues that one molecule running the male half of the species is a myth

To check against
SY-03 shelf map (per the digest of SY-01, SY-03 and SY-05); concept note §4. Primary: Fine, C. (2017) *Testosterone Rex*, publisher and year to confirm
The verdict
OPEN
C05-02 open §Opening

*T*, Carole Hooven, 2021, argues the molecule runs a great deal

To check against
SY-03 shelf map; concept note §4. Primary: Hooven, C. (2021) *T: The Story of Testosterone*, year to confirm
The verdict
OPEN
C05-03 open §Opening

Fine and Hooven have each read the other's book and were not persuaded

To check against
No primary source named. Narrator's inference from the shelf map. Confirm from either author's public comment or soften to "each has answered the other"
The verdict
OPEN
C05-07 open §The gap that Hume found

The German border moved a whole population of mothers by 350 hours a year (forward reference to chapter 13)

To check against
Preface and chapter 13 sources (not among this chapter's documents). Cross-check the 350-hour figure against chapter 13's verification rows when written
The verdict
OPEN
C05-08 open §The gap that Hume found

Rousseau's noble savage and Hobbes's nasty savage as the two shelves' creation myths; neither matches the archaeology

To check against
SY-02 (the two myths). No primary source named for the archaeological verdict beyond SY-02's summary of Fry and Söderberg, Bowles, Nataruk
The verdict
OPEN
C05-09 open §The gap that Hume found

Evolutionary psychology's "dual mating strategy" hypothesis: provisioning from a reliable partner, better genes from more formidable men

To check against
SY-02. No primary source named for the hypothesis itself; check that the label and characterisation are fair (e.g. Gangestad and Thornhill, or the source SY-02 relied on)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-14 open §The sentence that survives

"Given what we are, arrangement X under condition Y tends to produce Z" is the prehistory report's formulation

To check against
SY-02 (report's own phrasing, no primary source). Also quoted in the Preface; check the two chapters match word for word
The verdict
OPEN
C05-15 open §The sentence that survives

Sarah Blaffer Hrdy: human infants too costly for a mother and father alone; cooperative breeding with grandmothers and other kin

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Hrdy, S. B. (2009) *Mothers and Others*. Confirm that the "expect the bill" reading is Hrdy's and not the narrator's
The verdict
OPEN
C05-16 open §The sentence that survives

Robert Sapolsky: testosterone lowers the threshold for whatever the culture already rewards with status

To check against
SY-02. Primary: Sapolsky, R. (2017) *Behave*, ch. 4. Confirm the formulation
The verdict
OPEN
C05-17 open §The sentence that survives

"Biology dictates the cost of a social arrangement, not its moral worth" is the report's phrase

To check against
SY-02 (report's own phrasing, no primary source)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-18 open §The sentence that survives

The father's body is only adjusting in the first year (forward reference to chapter 8)

To check against
Chapter 8's sources (Gettler 2011 and successors). Cross-check when chapter 8 is written
The verdict
OPEN
C05-22 open §What held

Carney, lead author, later publicly disavowed the power-posing finding

To check against
SY-04 (no date or venue given). Primary: Carney's public statement on her faculty web page, 2016, to confirm date and wording
The verdict
OPEN
C05-24 open §What held

Upper-body strength d about 2 standard deviations, holds in every occupational cohort tested; women produce on average 60 to 75 per cent of men's

To check against
SY-04 (d > 2.0, 60–75%). Discrepancy: SY-02 gives grip d about 2.5. Primary: SY-04 names no single study; check e.g. Courtright et al. 2013 meta-analysis and Leyk et al. 2007
The verdict
OPEN
C05-26 open §What held; §In practice

Gettler 2011: 394 men in the Philippines followed for five years; fatherhood lowers testosterone; replicated since

To check against
SY-04. Primary: Gettler, L. T. et al. (2011) *PNAS* 108(39):16194–16199 (N = 624 in the full cohort; 394 may be the subsample; confirm)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-27 open §What held; §Strongest case; §Contested

Hyde 2005: 78 per cent of psychological sex differences small (d < 0.35); Del Giudice: multivariate D = 2.71 with about 10 per cent overlap; both reproduce; the replication report calls the choice of metric ideological

To check against
SY-01 (78%, D = 2.71, 10,261 people), SY-04 ("choice of metric remains deeply ideological"). Discrepancy: SY distilled sheet gives Zell 85.5% small. Primary: Hyde, J. S. (2005) *American Psychologist* 60(6):581–592; Del Giudice, M., Booth, T., Irwing, P. (2012) *PLoS ONE* 7(1):e29265
The verdict
OPEN
C05-28 open §What held

Greenberg and colleagues, *PNAS*, 2018: more than 500,000 people on the Reading the Mind in the Eyes test; women score higher across ages and countries

To check against
SY-04. Effect size stripped, not recoverable from the PDF. Primary: Greenberg, D. M. et al. (2018) *PNAS* 115(48):12152–12157. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-29 open §What held

Klein and Hodges 2001: paying men to be accurate removes the empathic-accuracy gap

To check against
SY-04. Primary: Klein, K. J. K., Hodges, S. D. (2001) *Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin* 27(6):720–730. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-32 open §What held; §In practice

Mazei and colleagues, *Psychological Bulletin*, 2015: 10,888 participants; men obtain better economic outcomes in negotiation; gap disappears or reverses when women negotiate for others or the range is transparent

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Mazei, J. et al. (2015) *Psychological Bulletin* 141(1):85–104. First names not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C05-33 open §The paradox; §The library

Costa, Terracciano and McCrae 2001: 23,031 people in 26 cultures; women higher in neuroticism and agreeableness; gaps widest where sex roles are loosest

To check against
HC-07. Primary: Costa, P. T., Terracciano, A., McCrae, R. R. (2001) *JPSP* 81(2):322–331. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-34 open §The paradox

Schmitt, Realo, Voracek and Allik 2008: 17,637 people in 55 nations; personality gap predicted by wealth, health and education

To check against
SY-01 (N, nations), HC-07 (r = 0.73 with Costa). First names from HC-07. Primary: Schmitt, D. P. et al. (2008) *JPSP* 94(1):168–182
The verdict
OPEN
C05-35 open §The paradox

Lee and Ashton 2020: 347,192 people in 48 countries; emotionality d = 0.84 in the HEXACO model

To check against
HC-07. Primary: Lee, K., Ashton, M. C. (2020) *Journal of Personality* 88(6):1075–1090. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-39 open §The paradox

"The most equal societies on the index used" refers to the Global Gender Gap Index

To check against
HC-07 (index named as WEF GGGI). Confirm
The verdict
OPEN
C05-43 open §The paradox; §Contested; §The library

Herlitz and colleagues 2024: re-analysis of 27 large studies (54 articles reviewed); paradox holds for personality and reverses for mathematics and partner preferences

To check against
HC-07. Primary: Herlitz, A. et al. (2024), journal not given in HC-07. First names not in the library
The verdict
OPEN
C05-44 open §The trust rules

The research library is 81 machine-written reports, each briefed to give the case against

To check against
Preface; the book's instructions and the research spreadsheet (the author's own material). Confirm count
The verdict
OPEN
C05-45 open §The trust rules; §In practice; §The library

SY-01 was briefed to steelman the biological thesis and instead argued the constructivist case

To check against
SY-01 text (its framing calls the biological case "the steelman" and argues against it) and the prompt it was written from. The author's own material
The verdict
OPEN
C05-46 open §The trust rules

Library discrepancy: Hyde 78 per cent (SY-01, SY-02, SY-04) against Zell 85.5 per cent (SY distilled sheet)

To check against
the digest of SY-01, SY-03 and SY-05 discrepancy list. Primary: Hyde 2005; Zell, Krizan, Teeter 2015 *American Psychologist* 70(1):10–20
The verdict
OPEN
C05-48 open §Strongest case

Jordan-Young 2010: more than 300 studies reviewed; dose-response rule fails; CAH girls confounded by surgery and medical stress

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Jordan-Young, R. (2010) *Brain Storm*. First name Rebecca from SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-49 open §Strongest case; §Contested

van Anders 2011, *Psychoneuroendocrinology*: testosterone as dependent variable; infant care lowers it in men, competition and authority raise it in both sexes

To check against
SY-01. Primary: van Anders, S. M. et al. (2011) *Psychoneuroendocrinology*, volume to confirm. First name Sari from SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-51 open §Strongest case

Lindberg and colleagues 2010: mathematics d = 0.05 across 1,286,350 people

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Lindberg, S. M., Hyde, J. S., Petersen, J. L., Linn, M. C. (2010) *Psychological Bulletin* 136(6):1123–1135
The verdict
OPEN
C05-52 open §Strongest case

Hyde and Linn 1988: verbal ability d = 0.11 favouring women

To check against
SY-01 (given as -0.11). Primary: Hyde, J. S., Linn, M. C. (1988) *Psychological Bulletin* 104(1):53–69
The verdict
OPEN
C05-54 open §Strongest case

Fausto-Sterling: caregivers embed sex roles in the first fifteen months of life

To check against
SY-01 (birth to 15 months). Primary: Fausto-Sterling, A. et al., specific paper not given. First name Anne from SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-55 open §Strongest case

Hyde 2005 warned that inflated claims of difference carry a social cost

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Hyde 2005 *American Psychologist*, closing section
The verdict
OPEN
C05-56 open §Strongest case

Byrnes 1999: men take more risk in 14 of 16 domains

To check against
SY-01. Primary: Byrnes, J. P., Miller, D. C., Schafer, W. D. (1999) *Psychological Bulletin* 125(3):367–383
The verdict
OPEN
C05-57 open §In practice

A d of 0.2 means two distributions sharing about 85 per cent of their area

To check against
SY-01 (Zell 85% overlap at d = 0.21). Standard overlap arithmetic; confirm the overlap measure used
The verdict
OPEN
C05-58 open §In practice

The ovulatory-shift literature fell when hormones were measured rather than inferred from calendar days

To check against
Preface's sources (not among this chapter's documents). Cross-check against the Preface's verification rows
The verdict
OPEN
C05-59 open §The trust rules

Two of the chapter's figures (Ranehill N, Pahlke g) were stripped from the TXT extraction and read from the PDF page image

To check against
Working note: SY-04 PDF page 7 rendered as an image on 2026-09-30. To be re-checked against the PDF
The verdict
OPEN