C05-04 Check first open §The gap that Hume foundDavid Hume, 1739, noticed the unannounced step from is to ought
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Hume, *A Treatise of Human Nature* (1739), Book III, Part I, Section I
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-05 Check first open §The gap that Hume foundG. E. Moore named the naturalistic fallacy in *Principia Ethica*, 1903
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Moore, G. E. (1903) *Principia Ethica*, ch. 1. Note: Moore's own definition differs from the is-to-ought reading given here; check that the chapter's gloss is fair
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-06 Check first open §The gap that Hume foundBernard Davis, microbiologist, named the moralistic fallacy in *Nature*, 1978
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Davis, B. D. (1978) "The moralistic fallacy", *Nature* 272:390. Confirm volume, page and the exact wording of his definition
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-10 Check first open §The gap that Hume foundLarmuseau and colleagues matched Y-chromosome analyses to genealogical records over 500 years in the Low Countries; *Trends in Ecology & Evolution* 2016 and *Current Biology* 2019
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau, M. H. D. et al. (2016) *TREE*; Larmuseau et al. (2019) *Current Biology*. Confirm titles, volumes, and that the 2016 paper is a review rather than the primary data paper. First name and affiliation not in the library (marked in the text for checking)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-11 Check first open §The gap that Hume found; §Numbers to carryExtra-pair paternity about 1 to 2 per cent per generation over five centuries
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau et al. 2019 *Current Biology*. Confirm the range and the "per generation" framing
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-12 Check first open §The gap that Hume found; §Numbers to carryExtra-pair paternity about 0.4 per cent in tightly knit farming villages
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau et al. 2019. Confirm figure and the "surveillance" reading
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-13 Check first open §The gap that Hume found; §Numbers to carryExtra-pair paternity about 5.9 per cent among the poorest classes in crowded industrial cities
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Larmuseau et al. 2019. Confirm figure, class definition and period
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-19 Check first open §What heldCarney, Cuddy and Yap, *Psychological Science*, 2010: two minutes of expansive posture raised testosterone, lowered cortisol, increased financial risk-taking
- To check against
- SY-04. Primary: Carney, D. R., Cuddy, A. J. C., Yap, A. J. (2010) *Psychological Science* 21(10):1363–1368. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-20 Check first open §What held; §Numbers to carry; §In practiceRanehill and colleagues, *Psychological Science*, 2015, pre-registered, 200 participants: no effect on testosterone, cortisol or risk; felt-power effect survived
- To check against
- SY-04. N = 200 was stripped from the TXT and read from the PDF page image (SY-04 p. 7). Primary: Ranehill, E. et al. (2015) *Psychological Science* 26(5):653–656. Confirm N and pre-registration
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-21 Check first open §What heldThe original Carney 2010 sample was much smaller than 200
- To check against
- SY-04 says only "much larger" of Ranehill; original N not in the library ((to be checked)). Primary: Carney et al. 2010
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-23 Check first open §What heldPahlke, Hyde and Allison 2014: 184 studies, 1.6 million pupils, 21 countries; advantage of single-sex schooling shrinks to g = 0.10 (girls) and 0.06 (boys, mathematics) once selection is allowed for
- To check against
- SY-04. The g values were stripped from the TXT and read from the PDF page image (p. 7). Primary: Pahlke, E., Hyde, J. S., Allison, C. M. (2014) *Psychological Bulletin* 140(4):1042–1072. Confirm which outcomes the 0.10 and 0.06 refer to
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-25 Check first open §What heldSu, Rounds and Armstrong 2009: things-versus-people d = 0.93 across 503,188 respondents in 47 interest inventories; engineering d = 1.11
- To check against
- HC-07 (N, d, engineering) and SY-04 (47 inventories). Primary: Su, R., Rounds, J., Armstrong, P. I. (2009) *Psychological Bulletin* 135(6):859–884. First names from HC-07
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-30 Check first open §What held; §In practiceSpencer, Steele and Quinn 1999, *Journal of Experimental Social Psychology*: able women underperform on a hard maths test when told it shows sex differences, and match men when told it does not
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Spencer, S. J., Steele, C. M., Quinn, D. M. (1999) *JESP* 35(1):4–28. First names not in the library
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-31 Check first open §What held; §Numbers to carry; §Strongest case; §In practiceStoet and Geary 2012: 55 per cent of replication designs reproduced stereotype threat; half of those adjusted for prior maths scores in a way that manufactures the result; 30 per cent of clean replications worked
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Stoet, G., Geary, D. C. (2012) *Review of General Psychology* 16(1):93–102. Confirm the three percentages and the "adjusted for prior scores" characterisation
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-36 Check first open §The paradox; §ContestedFalk and Hermle, *Science*, 2018: 80,000 people in 76 countries; gaps in risk, patience, altruism, trust near zero in poor countries and largest in rich ones; r = 0.67 with log GDP per head
- To check against
- HC-07 (r = 0.67 log GDP, 0.56 equality index). Primary: Falk, A., Hermle, J. (2018) *Science* 362(6412):eaas9899. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-37 Check first open §The paradox; §The trust rules; §Numbers to carryStoet and Geary 2018, *Psychological Science*: 472,242 fifteen-year-olds in 67 countries (PISA); girls matched or beat boys in science in about two thirds of countries
- To check against
- HC-07 and SY-03 (472,242 / 67). Discrepancy: SY-05 (per SY distilled sheet) gives over 300,000 in 73 countries. Primary: Stoet, G., Geary, D. C. (2018) *Psychological Science* 29(4):581–593. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-38 Check first open §The paradox; §Numbers to carryFinland, Norway and Sweden: fewer than 25 per cent women among STEM graduates; Algeria, Tunisia and Turkey: 35 to 40 per cent
- To check against
- HC-07. Primary: Stoet and Geary 2018, Figure 3 and supplementary data (UNESCO graduate shares). Confirm the country figures and the year of the graduate data
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-40 Check first open §The paradox; §Numbers to carry; §ContestedRichardson and colleagues 2020, same journal: the STEM result rested on an undisclosed "propensity" measure; with the plain graduate share the correlation shrinks or vanishes; a correction was issued
- To check against
- HC-07 and SY-01. Primary: Richardson, S. S. et al. (2020) *Psychological Science* 31(3):338–341; Stoet and Geary (2020) corrigendum. First names not in the library
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-41 Check first open §The paradox; §ContestedBreda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault, *PNAS*, 2020: 300,000 pupils in 64 countries; the "maths is not for girls" stereotype is stronger in richer, more equal countries and explains away the wealth–STEM-gap link
- To check against
- SY-01 (N, countries), HC-07. Discrepancy: HC-07 gives Breda and Napp 2019 (PNAS) an identical sample (300,000 / 64); possibly the same PISA 2012 wave, possibly conflated. N = 300,000 confirmed from SY-04 PDF page image. Primary: Breda, T., Jouini, E., Napp, C., Thebault, G. (2020) *PNAS* 117(49):31063–31069. First name Thomas from SY-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-42 Check first open §The paradox; §Numbers to carry; §Load-bearing; §In practiceFors Connolly, Goossen and Hjerm 2020, *Sex Roles*: eight ESS rounds, 235,339 people, 32 countries; cross-section reproduced; no within-country widening as equality rose
- To check against
- HC-07. Primary: Fors Connolly, F., Goossen, M., Hjerm, M. (2020) *Sex Roles* 83:101–113. First names not in the library. Confirm "no divergence" is not overstated (HC-07 says "if anything, convergence")
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-47 Check first open §Strongest caseEliot and colleagues 2021: after allowing for the roughly 10 per cent larger male brain, sex explains about 1 per cent of variance in brain structure
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Eliot, L. et al. (2021) *Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews* 125:667–697. First name Lise from SY-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-50 Check first open §Strongest case; §In practiceZell, Krizan and Teeter 2015: more than twelve million people; mean d = 0.21; about 85 per cent overlap; a random woman outscores a random man on a "male" trait about 42 per cent of the time
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Zell, E., Krizan, Z., Teeter, S. R. (2015) *American Psychologist* 70(1):10–20. First names not in the library
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-53 Check first open §Strongest caseEagly and Wood 2023: 71 per cent of meta-analytic sex differences mirror the effects of experimental manipulations of power
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Eagly, A. H., Wood, W. (2023), journal not given in SY-01. First names Alice and Wendy from SY-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
*Testosterone Rex*, Cordelia Fine, 2017, argues that one molecule running the male half of the species is a myth
- To check against
- SY-03 shelf map (per the digest of SY-01, SY-03 and SY-05); concept note §4. Primary: Fine, C. (2017) *Testosterone Rex*, publisher and year to confirm
- The verdict
- OPEN
*T*, Carole Hooven, 2021, argues the molecule runs a great deal
- To check against
- SY-03 shelf map; concept note §4. Primary: Hooven, C. (2021) *T: The Story of Testosterone*, year to confirm
- The verdict
- OPEN
Fine and Hooven have each read the other's book and were not persuaded
- To check against
- No primary source named. Narrator's inference from the shelf map. Confirm from either author's public comment or soften to "each has answered the other"
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-07 open §The gap that Hume foundThe German border moved a whole population of mothers by 350 hours a year (forward reference to chapter 13)
- To check against
- Preface and chapter 13 sources (not among this chapter's documents). Cross-check the 350-hour figure against chapter 13's verification rows when written
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-08 open §The gap that Hume foundRousseau's noble savage and Hobbes's nasty savage as the two shelves' creation myths; neither matches the archaeology
- To check against
- SY-02 (the two myths). No primary source named for the archaeological verdict beyond SY-02's summary of Fry and Söderberg, Bowles, Nataruk
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-09 open §The gap that Hume foundEvolutionary psychology's "dual mating strategy" hypothesis: provisioning from a reliable partner, better genes from more formidable men
- To check against
- SY-02. No primary source named for the hypothesis itself; check that the label and characterisation are fair (e.g. Gangestad and Thornhill, or the source SY-02 relied on)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-14 open §The sentence that survives"Given what we are, arrangement X under condition Y tends to produce Z" is the prehistory report's formulation
- To check against
- SY-02 (report's own phrasing, no primary source). Also quoted in the Preface; check the two chapters match word for word
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-15 open §The sentence that survivesSarah Blaffer Hrdy: human infants too costly for a mother and father alone; cooperative breeding with grandmothers and other kin
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Hrdy, S. B. (2009) *Mothers and Others*. Confirm that the "expect the bill" reading is Hrdy's and not the narrator's
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-16 open §The sentence that survivesRobert Sapolsky: testosterone lowers the threshold for whatever the culture already rewards with status
- To check against
- SY-02. Primary: Sapolsky, R. (2017) *Behave*, ch. 4. Confirm the formulation
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-17 open §The sentence that survives"Biology dictates the cost of a social arrangement, not its moral worth" is the report's phrase
- To check against
- SY-02 (report's own phrasing, no primary source)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-18 open §The sentence that survivesThe father's body is only adjusting in the first year (forward reference to chapter 8)
- To check against
- Chapter 8's sources (Gettler 2011 and successors). Cross-check when chapter 8 is written
- The verdict
- OPEN
Carney, lead author, later publicly disavowed the power-posing finding
- To check against
- SY-04 (no date or venue given). Primary: Carney's public statement on her faculty web page, 2016, to confirm date and wording
- The verdict
- OPEN
Upper-body strength d about 2 standard deviations, holds in every occupational cohort tested; women produce on average 60 to 75 per cent of men's
- To check against
- SY-04 (d > 2.0, 60–75%). Discrepancy: SY-02 gives grip d about 2.5. Primary: SY-04 names no single study; check e.g. Courtright et al. 2013 meta-analysis and Leyk et al. 2007
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-26 open §What held; §In practiceGettler 2011: 394 men in the Philippines followed for five years; fatherhood lowers testosterone; replicated since
- To check against
- SY-04. Primary: Gettler, L. T. et al. (2011) *PNAS* 108(39):16194–16199 (N = 624 in the full cohort; 394 may be the subsample; confirm)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-27 open §What held; §Strongest case; §ContestedHyde 2005: 78 per cent of psychological sex differences small (d < 0.35); Del Giudice: multivariate D = 2.71 with about 10 per cent overlap; both reproduce; the replication report calls the choice of metric ideological
- To check against
- SY-01 (78%, D = 2.71, 10,261 people), SY-04 ("choice of metric remains deeply ideological"). Discrepancy: SY distilled sheet gives Zell 85.5% small. Primary: Hyde, J. S. (2005) *American Psychologist* 60(6):581–592; Del Giudice, M., Booth, T., Irwing, P. (2012) *PLoS ONE* 7(1):e29265
- The verdict
- OPEN
Greenberg and colleagues, *PNAS*, 2018: more than 500,000 people on the Reading the Mind in the Eyes test; women score higher across ages and countries
- To check against
- SY-04. Effect size stripped, not recoverable from the PDF. Primary: Greenberg, D. M. et al. (2018) *PNAS* 115(48):12152–12157. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
Klein and Hodges 2001: paying men to be accurate removes the empathic-accuracy gap
- To check against
- SY-04. Primary: Klein, K. J. K., Hodges, S. D. (2001) *Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin* 27(6):720–730. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-32 open §What held; §In practiceMazei and colleagues, *Psychological Bulletin*, 2015: 10,888 participants; men obtain better economic outcomes in negotiation; gap disappears or reverses when women negotiate for others or the range is transparent
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Mazei, J. et al. (2015) *Psychological Bulletin* 141(1):85–104. First names not in the library
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-33 open §The paradox; §The libraryCosta, Terracciano and McCrae 2001: 23,031 people in 26 cultures; women higher in neuroticism and agreeableness; gaps widest where sex roles are loosest
- To check against
- HC-07. Primary: Costa, P. T., Terracciano, A., McCrae, R. R. (2001) *JPSP* 81(2):322–331. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
Schmitt, Realo, Voracek and Allik 2008: 17,637 people in 55 nations; personality gap predicted by wealth, health and education
- To check against
- SY-01 (N, nations), HC-07 (r = 0.73 with Costa). First names from HC-07. Primary: Schmitt, D. P. et al. (2008) *JPSP* 94(1):168–182
- The verdict
- OPEN
Lee and Ashton 2020: 347,192 people in 48 countries; emotionality d = 0.84 in the HEXACO model
- To check against
- HC-07. Primary: Lee, K., Ashton, M. C. (2020) *Journal of Personality* 88(6):1075–1090. First names not in the library ((to be checked))
- The verdict
- OPEN
"The most equal societies on the index used" refers to the Global Gender Gap Index
- To check against
- HC-07 (index named as WEF GGGI). Confirm
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-43 open §The paradox; §Contested; §The libraryHerlitz and colleagues 2024: re-analysis of 27 large studies (54 articles reviewed); paradox holds for personality and reverses for mathematics and partner preferences
- To check against
- HC-07. Primary: Herlitz, A. et al. (2024), journal not given in HC-07. First names not in the library
- The verdict
- OPEN
The research library is 81 machine-written reports, each briefed to give the case against
- To check against
- Preface; the book's instructions and the research spreadsheet (the author's own material). Confirm count
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-45 open §The trust rules; §In practice; §The librarySY-01 was briefed to steelman the biological thesis and instead argued the constructivist case
- To check against
- SY-01 text (its framing calls the biological case "the steelman" and argues against it) and the prompt it was written from. The author's own material
- The verdict
- OPEN
Library discrepancy: Hyde 78 per cent (SY-01, SY-02, SY-04) against Zell 85.5 per cent (SY distilled sheet)
- To check against
- the digest of SY-01, SY-03 and SY-05 discrepancy list. Primary: Hyde 2005; Zell, Krizan, Teeter 2015 *American Psychologist* 70(1):10–20
- The verdict
- OPEN
Jordan-Young 2010: more than 300 studies reviewed; dose-response rule fails; CAH girls confounded by surgery and medical stress
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Jordan-Young, R. (2010) *Brain Storm*. First name Rebecca from SY-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
C05-49 open §Strongest case; §Contestedvan Anders 2011, *Psychoneuroendocrinology*: testosterone as dependent variable; infant care lowers it in men, competition and authority raise it in both sexes
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: van Anders, S. M. et al. (2011) *Psychoneuroendocrinology*, volume to confirm. First name Sari from SY-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
Lindberg and colleagues 2010: mathematics d = 0.05 across 1,286,350 people
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Lindberg, S. M., Hyde, J. S., Petersen, J. L., Linn, M. C. (2010) *Psychological Bulletin* 136(6):1123–1135
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hyde and Linn 1988: verbal ability d = 0.11 favouring women
- To check against
- SY-01 (given as -0.11). Primary: Hyde, J. S., Linn, M. C. (1988) *Psychological Bulletin* 104(1):53–69
- The verdict
- OPEN
Fausto-Sterling: caregivers embed sex roles in the first fifteen months of life
- To check against
- SY-01 (birth to 15 months). Primary: Fausto-Sterling, A. et al., specific paper not given. First name Anne from SY-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hyde 2005 warned that inflated claims of difference carry a social cost
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Hyde 2005 *American Psychologist*, closing section
- The verdict
- OPEN
Byrnes 1999: men take more risk in 14 of 16 domains
- To check against
- SY-01. Primary: Byrnes, J. P., Miller, D. C., Schafer, W. D. (1999) *Psychological Bulletin* 125(3):367–383
- The verdict
- OPEN
A d of 0.2 means two distributions sharing about 85 per cent of their area
- To check against
- SY-01 (Zell 85% overlap at d = 0.21). Standard overlap arithmetic; confirm the overlap measure used
- The verdict
- OPEN
The ovulatory-shift literature fell when hormones were measured rather than inferred from calendar days
- To check against
- Preface's sources (not among this chapter's documents). Cross-check against the Preface's verification rows
- The verdict
- OPEN
Two of the chapter's figures (Ranehill N, Pahlke g) were stripped from the TXT extraction and read from the PDF page image
- To check against
- Working note: SY-04 PDF page 7 rendered as an image on 2026-09-30. To be re-checked against the PDF
- The verdict
- OPEN