THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 4: Overlapping Bells

89 claims, 21 to check first

C04-02 Check first open §Opening

Cortisol rises 2 to 4 times resting level in 70 to 80 per cent of participants, within about 20 minutes

To check against
PS-04, no single primary named for the 70 to 80 per cent figure
The verdict
OPEN
C04-03 Check first open §Opening, §Cortisol, §Numbers to carry

Men's cortisol response to the TSST 1.5 to 2 times women's on average

To check against
PS-04, Kudielka and Kirschbaum 2005 (Biological Psychology)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-06 Check first open §The shape, §Numbers to carry, §In practice

Conversion table: d = 0.20 → 92 per cent overlap, 56 per cent probability of superiority; 0.50 → 80/64; 0.80 → 69/71; 1.00 → 62/76

To check against
BI-11 table, McGraw and Wong 1992 (Psychological Bulletin), Cohen 1988. PS-05 gives 67 per cent overlap at d = 0.5 and PS-01 gives "average woman above 69 per cent of men" (U3); discrepancy logged
The verdict
OPEN
C04-13 Check first open §The shape (to be checked)

HEXACO emotionality d ≈ −1.0, women higher

To check against
PS-01 PDF, no primary author named
The verdict
OPEN
C04-18 Check first open §The shape, §Contested

Mental rotation d = 0.73 (Voyer, Voyer and Bryden 1995); BI-07 range up to 1.0; Preface 0.57. Discrepancy across reports

To check against
BI-11 (Voyer et al. 1995, Psychological Bulletin), BI-07 (range stripped in text)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-23 Check first open §Where the gap goes

Kirkland et al. 2013: 42 samples, N = 4,290, RMET g = 0.177. Brief says d = 0.47 also appears; PDF gives only 0.177

To check against
PS-02 PDF pages 6 and 9, Kirkland et al. 2013 (North American Journal of Psychology)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-27 Check first open §Where the gap goes, §Numbers to carry

Mehl et al. 2007 (Science): 396 students, EAR 30 seconds every 12.5 minutes, women 16,215 and men 15,669 words a day, range about 500 to 47,000

To check against
PS-03, Mehl, Vazire, Ramírez-Esparza, Slatcher and Pennebaker 2007
The verdict
OPEN
C04-35 Check first open §Where the gap goes (to be checked), §Contested

85 per cent of stonewallers are men: blog-sourced only

To check against
PS-02 and PS-03 cite connectedcouples.app; no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C04-38 Check first open §Cortisol, §In practice

Kirschbaum, Klauer, Filipp and Hellhammer 1995: partner verbal support lowers men's cortisol, tends to raise women's

To check against
PS-04, Kirschbaum et al. 1995 (Psychosomatic Medicine)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-44 Check first open §Cortisol, §In practice

Martin, Neighbors and Griffith 2013: N = 5,692; male-type symptoms 26.3 vs 21.9 per cent; combined 30.6 vs 33.3, p = .57; Regier critique

To check against
PS-04, Martin et al. 2013 (JAMA Psychiatry)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-45 Check first open §Cortisol (to be checked)

Men die by suicide at 3 to 4 times the rate of women

To check against
PS-04, no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C04-48 Check first open §Cortisol, §Strongest case

Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009: Maasai 50 per cent men vs 26 per cent women; Khasi 54 per cent women vs 39 per cent men

To check against
OR-PS sheet (OR-03), Gneezy, Leonard and List 2009 (Econometrica); not in the PS documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-50 Check first open §Cortisol, §Contested

Dual-hormone meta-analysis: 33 studies, N = 8,538, r = −0.061. Attributed to Geniole 2016 in PS-05 and to Dekkers 2019 in BI-11 and OR-02

To check against
PS-05 PDF (Geniole et al. 2016), BI-11 (Dekkers et al. 2019, Psychoneuroendocrinology)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-51 Check first open §Cortisol

Frankenbach et al. 2022: 211 studies, N = 621,463, g = 0.69 [0.58, 0.81], adjusted 0.54

To check against
PS-06 PDF, Frankenbach, Weber, Loschelder, Kilger and Friese 2022 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-56 Check first open §The mosaic, §Numbers to carry

Loomes, Hull and Mandy 2017: 54 studies, 13,784,284 participants, male-to-female odds ratio 3.25 [2.93, 3.62]; historical 4 or 5 to 1

To check against
PS-08, Loomes et al. 2017 (JAACAP)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-62 Check first open §The mosaic

Wigdor et al. 2022: iPSYCH, siblings of 1,707 autistic girls vs 6,270 autistic boys, higher recurrence for female probands

To check against
PS-08, Wigdor et al. 2022 (Cell Genomics)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-64 Check first open §The mosaic

Ritchie et al. 2018: UK Biobank, N = 5,216 (2,750 women, 2,466 men), ages 44 to 77, total brain volume d = −1.41, variance ratio 0.82

To check against
BI-07, Ritchie et al. 2018 (Cerebral Cortex); BI-11 gives mean age 61.7
The verdict
OPEN
C04-70 Check first open §The mosaic, §Strongest case, §Numbers to carry

Joel et al. 2015: >1,400 scans, 1 to 6 per cent internally consistent (BI-11); PS-08 gives 0 to 8, BI-07 gives under 8. Discrepancy

To check against
BI-11, BI-07, PS-08, Joel et al. 2015 (PNAS)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-73 Check first open §The mosaic, §Numbers to carry

Chekroud et al. 2016: 93 per cent classification of 1,166 people; one of three PNAS replies

To check against
PS-08 and BI-07, Chekroud et al. 2016 (PNAS). BI-11 gives classifier range 69 to 93 per cent
The verdict
OPEN
C04-79 Check first open §Strongest case (to be checked)

Breda et al. 2020 (PNAS): about 300,000 pupils, science gap tracks stereotype strength

To check against
BI-07, Breda et al. 2020; already in Preface rows
The verdict
OPEN
C04-01 open §Opening

Trier Social Stress Test: 10 minutes preparation, speech to a panel trained to show nothing, mental arithmetic in steps of 17, salivary cortisol

To check against
PS-04, Kirschbaum, Pirke and Hellhammer 1993 (Neuropsychobiology)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-04 open §Opening (to be checked)

Kudielka and Kirschbaum: first names and institution not in documents

To check against
PS-04 gives surnames only
The verdict
OPEN
C04-05 open §Opening, §Cortisol

Luteal-phase women match men's cortisol response; follicular and pill blunted

To check against
PS-04, Kirschbaum et al. 1999 (Psychosomatic Medicine)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-07 open §The shape, §Numbers to carry

Height d ≈ 2.6, 19 per cent overlap, 96 per cent probability of superiority

To check against
PS-05 (Nelson 2012), BI-11 table row for d = 2.61
The verdict
OPEN
C04-08 open §The shape (to be checked)

Janet Shibley Hyde, University of Wisconsin

To check against
Not in documents; own knowledge marked
The verdict
OPEN
C04-09 open §The shape

Costa, Terracciano and McCrae 2001: 26 cultures, N = 23,031, neuroticism d = −0.51 (US), agreeableness −0.59

To check against
PS-01 PDF, Costa et al. 2001 (JPSP)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-10 open §The shape

Schmitt, Realo, Voracek and Allik 2008: 55 nations, N = 17,637, neuroticism d = −0.40, agreeableness −0.15

To check against
PS-01 PDF, Schmitt et al. 2008 (JPSP)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-11 open §The shape

Kajonius and Johnson 2018: N = 320,128, neuroticism −0.40, agreeableness −0.58

To check against
PS-01 PDF, Kajonius and Johnson 2018
The verdict
OPEN
C04-12 open §The shape

Facet cancellation within extraversion: warmth and gregariousness (women) versus assertiveness and excitement-seeking (men)

To check against
PS-01, Costa et al. 2001
The verdict
OPEN
C04-14 open §The shape

Su, Rounds and Armstrong 2009: 47 inventories, N = 503,188; realistic d = 0.84, social −0.68, enterprising 0.04

To check against
PS-01 PDF, Su et al. 2009 (Psychological Bulletin). Headline 0.93 already in Preface rows
The verdict
OPEN
C04-15 open §The shape

Interests gap same direction in every country surveyed

To check against
PS-01 (Lippa 2010 cross-cultural, named in document)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-16 open §The shape

Else-Quest, Hyde, Goldsmith and Van Hulle 2006: 35 dimensions, 3 months to 13 years; inhibitory control d = −0.41, activity 0.33, negligible negative affectivity

To check against
PS-01 PDF, Else-Quest et al. 2006 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-17 open §The shape

Cross, Copping and Campbell 2011: 741 effect sizes; reward sensitivity d = 0.01, punishment sensitivity −0.33

To check against
PS-01 PDF, Cross et al. 2011 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-19 open §The shape

At d = 0.73: probability of superiority about 70 per cent, about 23 per cent of women above the median man

To check against
BI-11 worked example
The verdict
OPEN
C04-20 open §Where the gap goes

Chaplin and Aldao 2013: 555 effect sizes, 166 studies, N = 21,709; positive g = −0.08, internalising −0.10, externalising 0.09; differences vanish alone or with parents, grow with unfamiliar adults and peers

To check against
PS-02 PDF, Chaplin and Aldao 2013 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-21 open §Where the gap goes, §Strongest case

Eisenberg and Lennon 1983: self-report empathy gap vanishes under skin conductance and facial EMG

To check against
PS-02, Eisenberg and Lennon 1983 (Psychological Bulletin). Also a style-sheet anti-example
The verdict
OPEN
C04-22 open §Where the gap goes, §Strongest case

Klein and Hodges 2001: payment erases empathic-accuracy gap

To check against
PS-02, Klein and Hodges 2001 (PSPB)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-24 open §Where the gap goes

2022 PNAS RMET study: N = 312,739, 57 countries, female advantage in all

To check against
PS-02, Greenberg et al. 2022 (PNAS) per document
The verdict
OPEN
C04-25 open §Where the gap goes

2023 alexithymia meta-analysis: 120 studies, N = 88,721, d = 0.22 overall, 0.49 externally oriented thinking

To check against
PS-02 PDF, primary authors not named in text
The verdict
OPEN
C04-26 open §Where the gap goes

20,000 versus 7,000 words a day myth

To check against
PS-03 (Brizendine 2006 as origin, per document)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-28 open §Where the gap goes (to be checked)

Mehl authors' first names and institution

To check against
Not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-29 open §Where the gap goes

Leaper and Ayres 2007: 73 studies, men slightly more talkative d = −0.14

To check against
PS-03, Leaper and Ayres 2007 (PSPB)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-30 open §Where the gap goes

Anderson and Leaper 1998: 43 studies, intrusive interruptions d = 0.33

To check against
PS-03, Anderson and Leaper 1998 (Sex Roles)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-31 open §Where the gap goes

Zimmerman and West 1975: 96 per cent of interruptions by men, small sample

To check against
PS-03, Zimmerman and West 1975
The verdict
OPEN
C04-32 open §Where the gap goes, §Strongest case

LaFrance, Hecht and Paluck 2003: 448 effects, 162 reports, smiling d = 0.41, vanishes in same social role

To check against
PS-03, LaFrance et al. 2003 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-33 open §Where the gap goes, §Strongest case

Sommer, Aleman, Bouma and Kahn 2004: 14 studies, 377 men and 442 women, lateralisation d = 0.21, CI −0.05 to 0.48

To check against
PS-03, Sommer et al. 2004 (Brain)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-34 open §Where the gap goes, §In practice

Gottman: flooding above about 100 bpm, recovery 20 to 30 minutes

To check against
PS-02 and PS-03, Gottman 1994
The verdict
OPEN
C04-36 open §Where the gap goes

Schrodt, Witt and Shimkowski 2014: 74 studies, N = 14,255, demand-withdraw reverses when husband seeks change

To check against
PS-03, Schrodt et al. 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C04-37 open §Cortisol

Stroud, Salovey and Epel 2002: N = 50, men's cortisol to achievement, women's to rejection

To check against
PS-04, Stroud et al. 2002 (Biological Psychiatry)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-39 open §Cortisol (to be checked)

Kirschbaum 1995 conducted in Trier

To check against
Inferred from the test's name and OR-PS scene note, not stated in PS-04
The verdict
OPEN
C04-40 open §Cortisol, §In practice

Ditzen et al. 2007: 67 women, 10-minute neck and shoulder massage lowers cortisol and heart rate, verbal support does not

To check against
PS-04, Ditzen et al. 2007 (Psychoneuroendocrinology)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-41 open §Cortisol

Ditzen et al. 2009: 47 couples, N = 94, intranasal oxytocin increases positive communication and lowers cortisol

To check against
PS-02 PDF and PS-04, Ditzen et al. 2009 (Biological Psychiatry)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-42 open §Cortisol

Ditzen et al. 2013: oxytocin lowers salivary alpha-amylase in women, raises it in men

To check against
PS-02, Ditzen et al. 2013 (Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-43 open §Cortisol

Salk, Hyde and Abramson 2017: >3.5 million, 90 nations, OR 1.95, d = 0.27, age 12 OR 2.37, ages 13 to 15 OR 3.02, larger in more gender-equal nations

To check against
PS-04, Salk et al. 2017 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-46 open §Cortisol

Byrnes, Miller and Schafer 1999: 150 studies, men riskier in 14 of 16 categories, financial d ≈ 0.43, social −0.02, gap shrinking over time

To check against
PS-05 PDF, Byrnes et al. 1999 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-47 open §Cortisol

Niederle and Vesterlund 2007: 80 participants, equal performance, 73 per cent of men vs 35 per cent of women choose tournament, men overconfident

To check against
PS-01 and PS-05, Niederle and Vesterlund 2007 (QJE); Gillen et al. 2019 critique in OR-PS
The verdict
OPEN
C04-49 open §Cortisol, §In practice

Saccardo, Pietrasz and Gneezy 2022: N = 97,678; non-STEM women −25.5 per cent under competition; gap absent in STEM

To check against
PS-05 PDF, Saccardo et al. 2022
The verdict
OPEN
C04-52 open §Cortisol, §Strongest case, §In practice

Conley and Yang 2024: orgasm >90 per cent men vs 35 to 65 per cent women in partnered sex; pain and threat; Frankenbach reply 2024

To check against
PS-06, Conley and Yang 2024 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-53 open §Cortisol, §In practice

Klusmann 2002: N = 1,865, female desire declines with relationship duration, male stable

To check against
PS-06, Klusmann 2002 (Archives of Sexual Behavior)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-54 open §In practice

Muise, Schimmack and Impett 2016: satisfaction rises with frequency to about once a week

To check against
PS-06, Muise et al. 2016
The verdict
OPEN
C04-55 open §Cortisol

Del Giudice 2011: 113 samples, N = 66,132, men more avoidant and less anxious, D = 0.28 community (about 78 per cent overlap), 0.12 college

To check against
PS-07, Del Giudice 2011 (Psychological Bulletin)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-57 open §The mosaic

Autism ratio about 2:1 with intellectual disability, 6:1 to 10:1 without

To check against
PS-08, no single primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C04-58 open §The mosaic (to be checked)

2024 Swedish register study: cumulative ratio about 1.2:1 by age 20

To check against
PS-08 (BMJ time-trends study, authors not named)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-59 open §The mosaic, §In practice

Kentrou et al.: 1,211 autistic adults, 31.7 per cent of women vs 16.7 per cent of men misdiagnosed first

To check against
PS-08, Kentrou et al. 2019 or 2021 (year given inconsistently in document)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-60 open §The mosaic

Hirvikoski et al. 2016: 27,122 autistic Swedes, suicide leading cause of premature death without ID, about 9 times population rate

To check against
PS-08, Hirvikoski et al. 2016 (Lancet Psychiatry); the 2.56 overall mortality figure not used in text
The verdict
OPEN
C04-61 open §In practice

Raymaker et al. 2020: autistic burnout

To check against
PS-08, Raymaker et al. 2020 (Autism in Adulthood)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-63 open §The mosaic

Jacquemont et al. 2014: CNVs in autistic girls median 10 to 15 genes vs 2 to 3 in boys

To check against
PS-08, Jacquemont et al. 2014 (AJHG)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-65 open §The mosaic

Cognitive variance ratio 1.08 to 1.20

To check against
BI-11, no single primary named
The verdict
OPEN
C04-66 open §The mosaic

Harrison et al. 2022: 220 species, no greater male variability in animal personality

To check against
BI-11, Harrison et al. 2022 (Biological Reviews); Del Giudice and Gangestad 2023 reply not used
The verdict
OPEN
C04-67 open §The mosaic, §Strongest case

Eliot 2021: sex explains under 1 per cent of brain structural variance after size

To check against
BI-07 and PS-08, Eliot et al. 2021 (Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-68 open §The mosaic (to be checked)

Lise Eliot, Chicago

To check against
Not in documents; own knowledge marked
The verdict
OPEN
C04-69 open §The mosaic

DeCasien et al. 2022: regional differences survive size correction, small to moderate, limbic

To check against
BI-07, DeCasien et al. 2022 (Human Brain Mapping)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-71 open §The mosaic (to be checked)

Daphna Joel, Tel Aviv

To check against
Not in documents; own knowledge marked
The verdict
OPEN
C04-72 open §The mosaic

Joel quotation: brains do not belong to one of two distinct categories

To check against
BI-11 quotes it
The verdict
OPEN
C04-74 open §The mosaic

Del Giudice 2016 monkey-face simulation shows Joel's method calls non-overlapping species mosaics

To check against
BI-07 and BI-11, Del Giudice et al. 2016 (PNAS)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-75 open §The mosaic

Del Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012: N = 10,261, warmth d = −0.50, dominance 0.27, emotional stability 0.32, D = 2.71 (10 per cent overlap), D = 1.71 without sensitivity (24 per cent)

To check against
BI-11 PDF, Del Giudice et al. 2012 (PLOS One). Headline D already in Preface rows
The verdict
OPEN
C04-77 open §Strongest case, §Contested

Classifier accuracy 60 to 70 per cent after total-volume correction, 87 to 92 per cent in volume-matched deep-learning studies

To check against
BI-07, primary authors not named
The verdict
OPEN
C04-78 open §Strongest case (to be checked)

Eagly and Wood 1999 social role theory

To check against
PS-01 and PS-05 name the theory; first names not given
The verdict
OPEN
C04-80 open §Strongest case, §Contested

Breda 2024 (PNAS): gender-equality paradox as Simpson's paradox by region

To check against
BI-11, Breda et al. 2024
The verdict
OPEN
C04-81 open §Contested

Stoet and Geary 2018 gender-equality paradox

To check against
BI-07 and BI-11, Stoet and Geary 2018 (Psychological Science)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-82 open §Strongest case

Same direction of personality differences in 55 nations

To check against
PS-01, Schmitt et al. 2008
The verdict
OPEN
C04-83 open §In practice

Buser 2016: losing a competition reduces women's subsequent effort more than men's

To check against
PS-05, Buser 2016
The verdict
OPEN
C04-84 open §In practice

Opt-out framing erases the competition gap

To check against
OR-PS sheet (OR-03), Flory et al. 2015
The verdict
OPEN
C04-85 open §In practice

Female autism and attention conditions diagnosed later than male, often first misread as anxiety or personality disorder

To check against
PS-08 (Kentrou 2019/2021 and late-diagnosis material)
The verdict
OPEN
C04-86 open §Contested

Hyde's critique of Del Giudice's multivariate D (latent-factor correction)

To check against
BI-07 and BI-11, Hyde 2014 reply per documents
The verdict
OPEN
C04-87 open §The shape

Sensitivity to punishment −0.33 and reward 0.01 signs (women more punishment-sensitive)

To check against
PS-01 PDF; sign convention checked against text
The verdict
OPEN
C04-88 open §The mosaic, §In practice

Narrator's arithmetic: d = 0.93 gives "seven-in-ten bet"

To check against
Interpolated from BI-11 table (0.80 → 71 per cent, 1.00 → 76 per cent); check
The verdict
OPEN
C04-89 open §Where the gap goes, §Cortisol

Narrator's arithmetic: 0.69 gives "roughly three quarters" shared area; 0.27 "more than 85 per cent"; 0.177 "more than 90 per cent"; 0.28 "about 78 per cent"

To check against
BI-11 table interpolation; 78 per cent for attachment D = 0.28 comes from PS-07
The verdict
OPEN