THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 221 · PAIRING · Teams and firms

Leadership, hormones and sex

Reviews leadership through hormones, behaviour and culture. The dual-hormone hypothesis (Mehta and Josephs 2010) replicates only weakly (r = -0.061, 8,538 people, Dekkers et al. 2019). Eagly and Johnson (1990, 162 studies) find no sex difference in task or interpersonal style but a small female lean to democratic leadership (d = 0.22). Across 99 samples, male and female leaders are rated equally effective (d = -0.05), though men rate themselves higher (Paustian-Underdahl et al. 2014). Women are over-represented in crisis appointments, the glass cliff (Ryan and Haslam 2005).

Open the PDF 16 pages · 331 KB

Number
221
Letter code
OR-02
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Teams and firms
File
221 OR-02 Leadership, hormones and sex.pdf
Pages
16

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 15 open
  • 4 to check first
  • C10-34 open Check first Dual-hormone meta-analysis: 30 papers, 33 studies, 49 effect sizes, N = 8,538, testosterone × cortisol interaction r = −0.061, significant but negligible. OR-02 (PDF p. 2) …
  • C11-05 open Check first Dual-hormone meta-analysis: 30 papers, 33 studies, 49 effect sizes, N = 8,538, r = −0.061, attributed to Dekkers et al. 2019 Hormones and Behavior; PS-05 attributes the same …
  • C11-10 open Check first Eagly and Johnson 1990, Psychological Bulletin, 162 studies: task d = 0.00, interpersonal d = 0.04, democratic vs autocratic d = 0.22; PS-03 gives 161 studies
  • C11-13 open Check first Paustian-Underdahl, Walker and Woehr 2014, Journal of Applied Psychology, 99 samples, N = 101,676: overall d = −0.05; other-ratings d = −0.12 favouring women; self-ratings favour …
  • C11-04 open Mehta and Josephs 2010, Hormones and Behavior, dual-hormone hypothesis; executive study, testosterone predicted subordinates only when cortisol low
  • C11-06 open Grebe et al. 2019 p-curve: ~16 per cent power in published dual-hormone literature; seven unpublished datasets show no interaction
  • C11-07 open Immunoassays unreliable at female testosterone concentrations; oestradiol and power motivation in women rarely studied
  • C11-09 open OR-05 treats the dual-hormone hypothesis as valid while OR-02 and OR-03 report it failed (report-to-report discrepancy, carried not resolved)
  • C11-11 open Vecchio 2002 critique; 197 of 370 primary studies self-ratings (OR-02 gives 162 studies in the same paragraph)
  • C11-14 open Badura et al. 2018, Journal of Applied Psychology, 1,632 effect sizes, 120 samples, N = 32,579; men emerge more, gap shrinking; agency drives emergence, emotional ability drives …
  • C11-15 open Eagly and Karau 2002, Psychological Review, role congruity theory
  • C11-16 open Eagly, Makhijani and Klonsky 1992 meta-analysis: identical autocratic behaviour rated worse in women
  • C11-17 open Koenig et al. 2011: three paradigms, 40, 22 and 17 studies; leader stereotype masculine, weakening, weakest in education
  • C11-18 open Ryan and Haslam 2005, British Journal of Management, FTSE 100 glass cliff; Haslam and Ryan 2008 "think crisis, think female" and scapegoating
  • C16-38 open Eagly and Johnson 1990: leadership style task-oriented d = 0.00, interpersonal 0.04, 162 studies