PAIRING · Part I · Overlapping Bells
Chapter 4
Overlapping Bells
4,271 words · 6 movements
The Opening
She is standing in a room without a window, a few minutes into a speech she was given almost no time to prepare, and the people at the table in front of her have not nodded once. A camera light is on behind them. She has been told to apply for a job she does not want, to a panel trained to show nothing, and in a moment they are going to ask her to count backwards in awkward steps and to start again whenever she slips. Under her tongue a roll of cotton is soaking up the only thing in the room that anyone is really interested in.
This is the Trier Social Stress Test, and the cotton is for cortisol, the hormone the adrenal glands release when the body decides that something matters. In most people the cortisol in that roll climbs to several times its resting level. That is the body, and it is measurable to the nanomole. What the cotton cannot tell you is whether the person holding it is a man or a woman. On average a man's cortisol climbs higher in that room than a woman's does, by a clear margin. Yet the woman at the table may be in the second half of her cycle, when her curve matches the men's, or on the pill, when it is flattened. She may simply be one of the many women whose adrenal glands answer a panel of blank faces harder than most men's do.
Draw it. Put cortisol along the bottom of a sheet of paper and stack every man's peak into one hump and every woman's into another. You get two bells on one axis, one set a little to the right of the other, and most of their area shared. The bulk of each bell sits on top of the other. Every honest claim about the sexes has that shape, and the whole argument comes down to two questions you can ask of any pair of bells: how far apart are the tips, and how much of the area is shared.
The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.
The Story
- The shape of a small difference
- Where the gap goes when you stop asking
- Cortisol and the hand on the shoulder
- The mosaic and the classifier
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.