PAIRING · Part I · Overlapping Bells
Chapter 5
Two Shelves and a Trap
3,534 words · 6 movements
The Opening
Stand in the aisle of a bookshop with a paperback in each hand and let your arms hang. In the left hand, Testosterone Rex, Cordelia Fine's book from 2017, which says the idea of one molecule running the male half of the species is a myth. In the right, T, Carole Hooven's from 2021, which says the molecule runs a great deal. They weigh about the same. Each was written by a scientist who has read the other's book and was not persuaded. Behind your left shoulder is the shelf that produced the first, with the mosaic brain, the toy aisle and the plough. Behind your right is the shelf that produced the second, with the Pleistocene, the hunters and the grandmothers. The aisle between them is about a metre wide, and this chapter would like you to stay in it for an hour.
Try it in a shop that stocks both. Notice which hand feels heavier. That is not the paper. That is the shelf you already belong to.
I belong to one. I said so in the Preface, because the confession is cheaper than pretending the man holding the books has no thumb on the scale. My mother's generation belonged to the other, with better reasons than mine, since the arguments on my shelf had been used against them in living memory. So this chapter is not going to tell you which shelf is right. It is going to show how each goes wrong, and then take the one fight I most want my side to win and show you what a fight nobody has won looks like.
The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.
The Story
- The gap that Hume found
- The sentence that survives
- What held, what fell, what is still on the table
- The paradox, worked through
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.