THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 234 · PAIRING · The argument tested

Steelman the opposite thesis

Builds the strongest biological case for sex differences, then answers it from the constructivist side. Eliot et al. (2021) find sex explains about 1% of brain structure once size is controlled, Jordan-Young (2010) faults brain organisation theory, and Eagly and Wood (2023) find 71% of sex differences mirror power effects. It concedes the multivariate personality gap (Del Giudice et al. 2012, D = 2.71), the mental rotation gap and failed stereotype-threat replications. At d = 0.21, a random woman outscores a random man about 42% of the time.

Open the PDF 14 pages · 325 KB

Number
234
Letter code
SY-01
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
The argument tested
File
234 SY-01 Steelman the opposite thesis.pdf
Pages
14

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 50 open
  • 16 to check first
  • P-27 open Check first Hyde 2005: 46 meta-analyses, 78 per cent of differences small or near zero
  • P-28 open Check first Zell, Krizan & Teeter 2015: 106 meta-analyses, more than 12 million people, mean d = 0.21
  • P-34 open Check first Del Giudice, Booth & Irwing 2012: 16PF, N = 10,261, Mahalanobis D = 2.71, overlap about 10 per cent
  • P-47 open Check first Breda et al. 2020, PNAS: about 300,000 pupils; controlling for the "maths is not for girls" stereotype removes the paradox
  • P-52 open Check first Hudson et al. 2012, Sex and World Peace, WomanStats: 175 countries; violence against women the best predictor of state peacefulness
  • C05-30 open Check first Spencer, Steele and Quinn 1999, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology: able women underperform on a hard maths test when told it shows sex differences, and match men when told …
  • C05-31 open Check first Stoet and Geary 2012: 55 per cent of replication designs reproduced stereotype threat; half of those adjusted for prior maths scores in a way that manufactures the result; 30 per …
  • C05-40 open Check first Richardson and colleagues 2020, same journal: the STEM result rested on an undisclosed "propensity" measure; with the plain graduate share the correlation shrinks or vanishes; a …
  • C05-41 open Check first Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault, PNAS, 2020: 300,000 pupils in 64 countries; the "maths is not for girls" stereotype is stronger in richer, more equal countries and explains away …
  • C05-47 open Check first Eliot and colleagues 2021: after allowing for the roughly 10 per cent larger male brain, sex explains about 1 per cent of variance in brain structure
  • C05-50 open Check first Zell, Krizan and Teeter 2015: more than twelve million people; mean d = 0.21; about 85 per cent overlap; a random woman outscores a random man on a "male" trait about 42 per cent …
  • C05-53 open Check first Eagly and Wood 2023: 71 per cent of meta-analytic sex differences mirror the effects of experimental manipulations of power
  • C10-55 open Check first Mazei et al. meta-analysis, 10,888 participants: male negotiation advantage vanishes when negotiating on behalf of others
  • C16-34 open Check first Eagly and Wood 2023: 71 per cent of meta-analytic sex differences mirror the effects of experimental power manipulations
  • C16-69 open Check first d = 0.21 gives about 85 per cent overlap and a 42 in 100 chance the random woman outscores the random man
  • C16-70 open Check first Del Giudice, Booth and Irwing 2012: Mahalanobis D = 2.71 on 10,261 adults, about 10 per cent overlap
  • P-17 open Men about 60 per cent more muscle mass, most of the extra in the upper body (Lassek & Gaulin 2009)
  • P-20 open Women about 1.6 times men's body fat; gluteofemoral fat as a DHA store for infant brains
  • P-23 open Testosterone rises with competition and winning in both sexes
  • P-25 open Fatherhood raises prolactin and oxytocin
  • P-30 open Maths d = 0.05 across 1.29 million people (Lindberg et al. 2010)
  • P-31 open Verbal ability tilts slightly to women (Hyde & Linn 1988, d = -0.11)
  • P-35 open Kaiser et al. 2019 replication: D = 2.06, overlap about 30 per cent
  • P-36 open Male brains about 10 per cent larger; sex explains about 1 per cent of structural variance after size (Eliot et al. 2021, "Dump the dimorphism")
  • P-37 open Joel et al. 2015, PNAS: more than 1,400 brains, only a few per cent internally consistent
  • P-38 open Chekroud et al. 2016, PNAS: classifier predicts sex from structural MRI at 93 per cent
  • P-46 open Gender-equality paradox: Schmitt et al. 2008 (17,637 people, 55 cultures); Falk & Hermle 2018 (80,000 people, 76 countries); Stoet & Geary 2018
  • P-48 open Gottman's predictors: out-of-sample positive predictive value about 29 per cent (Heyman & Slep 2001)
  • P-50 open Team collective intelligence linked to share of women (Woolley et al. 2010, Science); questioned by Credé et al. 2019
  • C03-61 open Men about 60 per cent more muscle, mostly upper body (Lassek & Gaulin 2009); women about 1.6 times body fat
  • C05-01 open Testosterone Rex, Cordelia Fine, 2017, argues that one molecule running the male half of the species is a myth
  • C05-27 open Hyde 2005: 78 per cent of psychological sex differences small (d < 0.35); Del Giudice: multivariate D = 2.71 with about 10 per cent overlap; both reproduce; the replication report …
  • C05-32 open Mazei and colleagues, Psychological Bulletin, 2015: 10,888 participants; men obtain better economic outcomes in negotiation; gap disappears or reverses when women negotiate for …
  • C05-34 open Schmitt, Realo, Voracek and Allik 2008: 17,637 people in 55 nations; personality gap predicted by wealth, health and education
  • C05-45 open SY-01 was briefed to steelman the biological thesis and instead argued the constructivist case
  • C05-46 open Library discrepancy: Hyde 78 per cent (SY-01, SY-02, SY-04) against Zell 85.5 per cent (SY distilled sheet)
  • C05-48 open Jordan-Young 2010: more than 300 studies reviewed; dose-response rule fails; CAH girls confounded by surgery and medical stress
  • C05-49 open van Anders 2011, Psychoneuroendocrinology: testosterone as dependent variable; infant care lowers it in men, competition and authority raise it in both sexes
  • C05-51 open Lindberg and colleagues 2010: mathematics d = 0.05 across 1,286,350 people
  • C05-52 open Hyde and Linn 1988: verbal ability d = 0.11 favouring women
  • C05-54 open Fausto-Sterling: caregivers embed sex roles in the first fifteen months of life
  • C05-55 open Hyde 2005 warned that inflated claims of difference carry a social cost
  • C05-56 open Byrnes 1999: men take more risk in 14 of 16 domains
  • C05-57 open A d of 0.2 means two distributions sharing about 85 per cent of their area
  • C16-09 open Sex gaps in interest, risk and personality widened, not closed, in the richest and most equal countries
  • C16-61 open Breda, Jouini, Napp and Thebault 2020, PNAS: 300,000 15-year-olds, 64 countries; "maths is not for girls" stereotype stronger in richer countries; paradox vanishes once controlled
  • C16-65 open Eliot et al. 2021: male brains about 10 per cent larger; sex explains about 1 per cent of structural variance after volume correction
  • C16-66 open van Anders et al. 2011, Psychoneuroendocrinology: testosterone as a dependent variable; infant care lowers it, competition and authority raise it in both sexes
  • C16-67 open Mazei et al. 2015, Psychological Bulletin: 10,888 participants; male negotiation advantage disappears or reverses with advocacy for others, transparency or experience
  • C16-68 open Fausto-Sterling 2012: caregivers embed gender in infants from birth to 15 months