THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 3: The Endocrine Accent

79 claims, 16 to check first

C03-08 Check first open Six weeks of nobody

Phoenix, Goy, Gerall & Young 1959, Endocrinology 65:369–382, guinea pigs; laboratory at University of Kansas

To check against
AN-08, BI-01 name no place; marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-12 Check first open Six weeks of nobody

Imperato-McGinley 1974, Science, Dominican Republic: 18 raised as girls, 17 adopted male identity at puberty

To check against
BI-01; Imperato-McGinley et al. 1974, Science 186:1213–1215 (note: the 18/17 figures may be from the 1979 NEJM follow-up)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-15 Check first open Two clocks; Numbers to carry

Testosterone reference ranges: men 10.4–34.7 nmol/L, women 0.5–2.4, no overlap

To check against
BI-02 names no laboratory source; check Endocrine Society or Mayo reference intervals
The verdict
OPEN
C03-20 Check first open Two clocks; Numbers to carry

Bull et al. 2019, npj Digital Medicine: 124,648 users, >600,000 cycles, 13 per cent exactly 28 days, mean 29.3, luteal 12.4 days; first name Jonathan

To check against
BI-04; Bull et al. 2019, npj Digit Med 2:83 (Natural Cycles app data)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-25 Check first open Cebu; Numbers to carry

Gettler et al. 2011, PNAS 108:16194–16199: Cebu, Philippines, saliva collected 2005 and 4.5 years later; new fathers' median testosterone down 26 per cent waking, 34 per cent evening (BI-02, DH-01, FA-03) or 20.5 per cent (CO-02); N given as 394 (SY-04), 465 (BI-02), 624 (DH-01, DH-08), 683 (BI-06)

To check against
Ranges carried in text, (to be checked) on N. Cross-reference Preface row P-24
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-32 Check first open Cebu; Strongest case; Numbers to carry

Geniole et al. 2020, Hormones and Behavior 123:104644: 45 studies, N 9,760; baseline r = 0.054 [0.028, 0.080]; men 0.071, women 0.002; manipulated 0.046 n.s. BI-02 gives r = 0.14

To check against
BI-03, AN-08 (point estimates stripped in AN-08 and BI-05 PDFs), BI-02. Cross-reference Preface P-22
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-33 Check first open Cebu; Strongest case

1,000-man intranasal testosterone (11 mg) RCT with no effect on economic preferences: Nadler, Zava, Camerer et al. 2024, PNAS (BI-03) or Nave et al. 2018 (BI-05)

To check against
Two reports name different authors and years; confirm citation
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-37 Check first open Thirteen per cent

Strassmann 1997, Current Anthropology: Sangui, Mali, 1986–88, 736-night census of menstrual hut; about 110 lifetime menses vs 400–450 modern (BI-04); BI-10 gives 100–160 ancestral, citing Eaton et al. 1994; first name Beverly

To check against
BI-04, BI-10; Curr Anthropol 38:123–129
The verdict
OPEN
C03-47 Check first open Thirteen per cent

Schmidt & Rubinow 1998, NEJM 338:209–216: NIMH Bethesda, leuprolide, 22 women, add-back reproduces symptoms only in PMDD; 2017 AJP follow-up: symptoms return in month one, gone by month three

To check against
BI-03, BI-04 (BI-03 says ages 30–50; not used)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-49 Check first open One in two hundred; In practice; Numbers to carry

Skovlund et al. 2016, JAMA Psychiatry 73:1154–1162: 1,061,997 Danish women 15–34; RR 1.23 COC, 1.34 POP, 1.40 LNG-IUS, 1.60 ring; adolescents higher; absolute 1.7→2.2 per 100 woman-years; risk peaks about six months after start; Copenhagen; first name Charlotte Wessel

To check against
BI-08, BI-10
The verdict
OPEN
C03-50 Check first open One in two hundred

Skovlund et al. 2018, Am J Psychiatry: 475,802 women, 6,999 suicide attempts, 71 suicides, RR 1.97 attempts, 3.08 suicide, peak at two months

To check against
BI-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-56 Check first open Thermostat

Duffy et al. 2011, PNAS: 157 (52 women, 105 men); intrinsic period 24.09 vs 24.19 h; 35 vs 14 per cent under 24 h; Boston; first name Jeanne

To check against
BI-09; PNAS 108 Suppl 3:15602–15608
The verdict
OPEN
C03-58 Check first open Thermostat; In practice

Kingma & van Marken Lichtenbelt 2015, Nature Climate Change: ASHRAE 55 calibrated to 70 kg male, overestimates female heat production by up to 35 per cent; 16 women; Maastricht; critic Bjarne Olesen (BI-09 gives surname only) on clothing insulation

To check against
BI-09; Nat Clim Change 5:1054–1056
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-62 Check first open Modern environment

Lokeshwar et al., European Urology Focus, NHANES 4,207 men 15–39: 605.39→451.22 ng/dL 1999–2016; normal-weight 664.79→529.24; year 2021 (BI-05) or 2020 (BI-10); first name Soum

To check against
BI-05, BI-10
The verdict
OPEN
C03-63 Check first open Modern environment; In practice

Levine et al. 2022, Human Reproduction Update: −51.6 per cent 1973–2018, 223 studies, 53 countries, −2.64 per cent a year after 2000; critics Boulicault et al. 2021 (Harvard GenderSci Lab), Allan Pacey (Sheffield); first names Hagai, Marion

To check against
BI-10
The verdict
OPEN
C03-66 Check first open People who reported back; Strongest case

Defreyne et al. 2018, ENIGI: 898 (440 trans men, 468 trans women), 36 months, no correlation serum testosterone–state anger at 3, 12, 36 months; transient rise at three months back to baseline by one year; anger tied to baseline psychopathology; Ghent as place (BI-12 does not name city); first name Justine

To check against
BI-12; Endocrine Abstracts 57 and PubMed 30822410
The verdict
OPEN
C03-01 open Opening

Mini-puberty: testosterone peak 100–400 ng/dL at 1–3 months (BI-06); BI-01 gives a window of 1–6 months

To check against
BI-01, BI-06 disagree on window; check Kuiri-Hänninen et al. 2014, Hormone Research in Paediatrics 82:73–80
The verdict
OPEN
C03-02 open Opening

Male infant testosterone near zero by first birthday, stays low until puberty

To check against
BI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C03-03 open Opening

Female infants: FSH elevated until age 3–4

To check against
BI-06; Kuiri-Hänninen 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C03-05 open Six weeks of nobody

Ovaries require WNT4 and RSPO1; "female default" is wrong

To check against
BI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C03-06 open Six weeks of nobody

Fetal testosterone surge weeks 8–24; DHT shapes external genitalia

To check against
BI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C03-07 open Six weeks of nobody

McCarthy 2015, Nature Neuroscience: puberty as second organisational window; first name Margaret

To check against
BI-01 gives surname only; check Schulz & Sisk or McCarthy & Nugent 2015 Nat Neurosci 18:1–8
The verdict
OPEN
C03-09 open Six weeks of nobody

CAH girls' toy play about 60 per cent toward male mean; cohorts of 40–125

To check against
BI-01; Hines, Berenbaum
The verdict
OPEN
C03-10 open Six weeks of nobody

Pasterski et al. 2005: 81 CAH children, 72 siblings; parents encouraged female-typical play in CAH girls more; first name Vickie

To check against
the AN digest; Pasterski et al. 2005, Child Development 76:264–278
The verdict
OPEN
C03-11 open Six weeks of nobody

CAIS cohorts of 10–30, female-typical in every measure

To check against
BI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C03-13 open Six weeks of nobody

Grunt & Young 1953, J Comp Physiol Psychol 46:138–144: castrated guinea pigs return to own rank on identical dose

To check against
AN-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-14 open Six weeks of nobody

Damassa et al. 1977, Endocrinology: 10 per cent of normal testosterone restores copulation in castrated rats

To check against
AN-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-17 open Two clocks

Oestradiol men 36.7–146.8 pmol/L; women 55–1,468 across cycle

To check against
BI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C03-21 open Two clocks

TSST meta-analysis 2017 (Liu et al.): 34 studies, 640 women, 710 men, men higher cortisol peak

To check against
BI-02; Liu et al. 2017, Psychoneuroendocrinology 82:26–37
The verdict
OPEN
C03-22 open Two clocks

Kudielka & Kirschbaum 2005, Biological Psychology: women report more distress, men higher cortisol

To check against
BI-06; Biol Psychol 69:113–132
The verdict
OPEN
C03-23 open Two clocks

Leproult & Van Cauter 2011, JAMA: 10 men, five-hour nights for one week, testosterone down 10–15 per cent; first names Rachel, Eve

To check against
BI-02 (calls it robust), BI-05 (calls it fallen); JAMA 305:2173–2174
The verdict
OPEN
C03-24 open Two clocks

Su et al. 2021, Sleep Medicine: 18 controlled studies, partial restriction SMD −0.22 n.s., total deprivation about 25 per cent drop; N stripped in report and PDF

To check against
BI-05
The verdict
OPEN
C03-26 open Cebu

Single men with higher baseline testosterone more likely to partner and become fathers

To check against
BI-02; Gettler 2011
The verdict
OPEN
C03-27 open Cebu; In practice

Fathers doing three or more hours of childcare a day have the lowest testosterone

To check against
BI-06; Gettler 2011
The verdict
OPEN
C03-28 open Cebu

Grebe et al. 2019, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews: 114 effects, 66 studies, partnered and fathers lower; effect sizes lost in extraction and absent from PDF; first name Nicholas

To check against
BI-05; Grebe et al. 2019, NBR 98:221–233
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-29 open Cebu; In practice

Geniole et al. 2017, Hormones and Behavior: winner-loser meta-analysis, 60 effects, >2,500 participants, stronger in real venues; d lost in extraction and absent from PDF

To check against
BI-05; Horm Behav 92:37–50
The verdict
OPEN, marked in the text for checking
C03-30 open Cebu

Wingfield et al. 1990, American Naturalist 136:829–846: challenge hypothesis

To check against
AN-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-31 open Cebu

Goymann, Moore & Oliveira 2019, BioScience: male–female interactions provoke larger testosterone pulses than male–male across vertebrates; first name Wolfgang

To check against
AN-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-34 open Cebu

Carré et al. 2017, Biological Psychiatry: N 121, testosterone raises aggression only in high-dominance, low-self-control men; first name Justin

To check against
BI-03; Biol Psychiatry 82:249–256
The verdict
OPEN
C03-35 open Cebu

Dreher et al. 2016, PNAS 113:11633–11638: 40 men, both punishment and generosity up; first name Jean-Claude

To check against
BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-36 open Cebu

Tsimane men about 33 per cent lower testosterone than age-matched Americans, no age decline; 63 men, 30 per cent surge after football, 15 per cent at one hour; Trumble & Gurven

To check against
BI-10; Trumble et al. 2012, Evolution and Human Behavior; Proc R Soc B
The verdict
OPEN
C03-38 open Thirteen per cent

Dogon men watched the hut as a paternity signal

To check against
BI-04; Strassmann 1992/1997
The verdict
OPEN
C03-39 open Thirteen per cent

Gildersleeve et al. 2014: 134 effects, 50 studies; Wood et al. 2014 re-analysis of 58 reports found no shift; first names Kelly, Wendy

To check against
BI-04; Psychological Bulletin 140:1205 and Emotion Review 6:229
The verdict
OPEN
C03-40 open Thirteen per cent

Jones et al. 2018, Psychological Science: N 584, >5,000 sessions, no hormone–face-preference link; first name Benedict

To check against
BI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-41 open Thirteen per cent

Stern et al. 2021: N 257, 1,028 sessions, no ovulatory shift; first name Julia

To check against
BI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-42 open Thirteen per cent

Roney & Simmons 2013: oestradiol predicts desire positively, progesterone negatively; first names James, Zachary

To check against
BI-04; Horm Behav 63:636–645
The verdict
OPEN
C03-43 open Thirteen per cent

Arslan et al. 2021: about 26,000 diary entries, mid-cycle desire peak; first name Ruben

To check against
BI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-44 open Thirteen per cent

Schleifenbaum et al. 2022: partners do not detect fertility; first name Lara

To check against
BI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-45 open Thirteen per cent; In practice

PMS pooled prevalence 47.8 per cent across 17 studies (Direkvand-Moghadam et al. 2014)

To check against
BI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-48 open Thirteen per cent

Schoep et al. 2019, BMJ Open: 32,748 Dutch women, 8.9 days lost productivity a year, 80.7 per cent presenteeism, 20 per cent disclosed

To check against
BI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-51 open One in two hundred

Johansson et al. 2023, UK Biobank: 264,557 women, 7,354 sibling pairs, HR 1.71 in first two years

To check against
BI-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-52 open One in two hundred

Zethraeus et al. 2017: RCT, N 340, lower general well-being (PGWBI), no difference on depression scale; first name Niklas

To check against
BI-08; Fertil Steril 107:1238
The verdict
OPEN
C03-53 open One in two hundred

Allopregnanolone from progesterone acts on GABA-A; synthetic progestins are not metabolised to it

To check against
BI-10
The verdict
OPEN
C03-54 open One in two hundred

Pill raises SHBG 80–300 per cent; Pastor et al. 2013: about 15 per cent lower desire, >80 per cent no change

To check against
BI-08
The verdict
OPEN
C03-55 open One in two hundred

Congruency hypothesis: Roberts et al. 2014, Psychological Science, 365 couples; BI-10 says replicated, BI-08 says Stern 2019/2021 failed to replicate; first name Craig (S. Craig)

To check against
BI-08, BI-10 disagree; carried as contested
The verdict
OPEN
C03-57 open Thermostat; In practice

Boulos et al. 2019, Sleep: 169 studies, women more slow-wave sleep, better objective sleep; insomnia RR 1.41 (Zhang & Wing 2006); men more apnoea

To check against
BI-09
The verdict
OPEN
C03-59 open Thermostat; In practice

Preferred temperature women 24–25 °C, men 21–22; Karjalainen 2011 dissatisfaction ratio 1.74; luteal set-point +0.3–0.5 °C

To check against
BI-09
The verdict
OPEN
C03-60 open Thermostat

Pain threshold d = 0.66, tolerance d = 0.79 (Riley 1998, Racine 2012); men's threshold lower with female examiner. "Three-quarters overlap" is my computation from d

To check against
BI-09
The verdict
OPEN
C03-61 open Thermostat

Men about 60 per cent more muscle, mostly upper body (Lassek & Gaulin 2009); women about 1.6 times body fat

To check against
Preface rows P-17, P-20; SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C03-64 open Modern environment

Eckert-Lind et al. 2020, JAMA Pediatrics: thelarche 0.24 years earlier per decade, 30 studies; first name Camilla

To check against
BI-10
The verdict
OPEN
C03-65 open Modern environment

Prenatal phthalates shorten male anogenital distance

To check against
BI-10; van den Driesche reviews
The verdict
OPEN
C03-67 open People who reported back

O'Connor, Archer & Wu 2004, JCEM 89:2837–2845: 28 men, 1,000 mg testosterone undecanoate, POMS anger 7.48→10.71, no behavioural aggression change; first names Daryl, John, Frederick

To check against
BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-68 open People who reported back; In practice

van de Grift et al., Journal of Sexual Medicine: 26 interviews (12 feminising, 14 masculinising); crying threshold lower on oestrogen, higher on testosterone; report dates it 2026 and also 2017; first name Tim

To check against
BI-12 (year inconsistent in report)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-69 open People who reported back

Men on androgen deprivation therapy report emotional lability and weepiness

To check against
BI-12 (source is a ProQuest thesis; find a primary)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-70 open People who reported back

ENIGI (Wierckx et al.): 73.9 per cent of trans men report increased sexual desire after testosterone; solitary not dyadic desire

To check against
BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-71 open People who reported back; Strongest case

Hulshoff Pol et al. 2006, Eur J Endocrinol 155:S107–S114: testosterone raised trans men's total brain volume by 31 mL in four months; Utrecht; first name Hilleke

To check against
BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-72 open People who reported back

van Goozen et al. 1995: spatial up, verbal fluency down on testosterone; Slabbekoorn et al. 1999 replicated spatial only; first name Stephanie

To check against
BI-12; Psychoneuroendocrinology 20:343 and 24:423
The verdict
OPEN
C03-73 open People who reported back

Burke et al. 2016: treatment-naive trans people perform like lived gender on mental rotation; first name Sarah

To check against
BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-74 open People who reported back; In practice

Walther et al. 2019, JAMA Psychiatry: 27 RCTs, 1,890 men, testosterone reduces depressive symptoms; Hudson et al. 2023 IPD meta-analysis, 5,601 men <12 nmol/L, no BDI improvement

To check against
BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-75 open Strongest case

Fine, Delusions of Gender; Jordan-Young, Brain Storm; Wallen 1999, Hormones and Behavior 36:236–250, emancipation from hormonal control

To check against
AN-08, BI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C03-76 open Strongest case

Plasma oxytocin 1.53 vs 4.53 pg/mL, assay-dependent ("threefold")

To check against
BI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C03-77 open In practice

Male testosterone declines about 1 per cent a year after 30

To check against
BI-06; Harman 2001 (Baltimore)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-78 open In practice; Cebu

"99.7 per cent of the variance" and "a third of one per cent" are my computations from r = 0.054 (r² = 0.0029); "2 per cent" from r = 0.14

To check against
Arithmetic, not a source
The verdict
OPEN
C03-79 open Working notes

Narrator born 1975, so 51 at writing (working notes only)

To check against
concept note biography
The verdict
OPEN