THRIVING after the FALL
Book Two PAIRING after the FALL

The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter

Chapter 2: The Campfire Contract

80 claims, 35 to check first

C02-03 Check first open §Who ate what

Men's arm muscle 75 to 90 per cent greater than women's, Lassek and Gaulin 2009, Evolution and Human Behavior

To check against
DH-01 (Lassek & Gaulin 2009). Discrepancy: DH-11 gives 75 per cent upper body and 78 per cent upper arm, DH-03 gives 65 per cent muscle, DH-09 gives 78 per cent upper arm
The verdict
OPEN
C02-04 Check first open §Who ate what

Murdock and Provost 1973, 50 activities, 185 societies, cooking female in 183 of 185, smelting, metalworking and large-game hunting male in 90 to 100 per cent

To check against
DH-07 (Murdock & Provost 1973, Ethnology); DH-10 repeats 50 tasks, 185 societies
The verdict
OPEN
C02-08 Check first open §Who ate what

Anderson et al. 2023, PLOS ONE: women hunt in 50 of 63 foraging societies, large game in a third

To check against
DH-02 (Anderson et al. 2023); DH-11 cites the same paper
The verdict
OPEN
C02-10 Check first open §Who ate what

Wilamaya Patjxa, Peru: woman 17 to 19, about 9,000 years old, five projectile points and butchering kit; Haas 2020 Science Advances, 27 burials, 11 female, 16 male, 30 to 50 per cent

To check against
DH-04 (Haas et al. 2020). First name "Randall" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-11 Check first open §Who ate what

Pontzer, 30 Hadza adults, 17 women, 13 men, 2,649 vs 1,877 kcal/day

To check against
DH-02 (Pontzer et al. 2012, PLoS ONE). "Doubly labelled water" method is from general knowledge, not in DH-02
The verdict
OPEN
C02-14 Check first open §Who ate what, §Numbers

Dyble 2015, Science: 1,863 Mbendjele and 4,055 Agta co-resident pairs; 12 per cent unrelated adults when both sexes choose vs 0.6 per cent; observed Agta 11.2 per cent; Paranan 4.2 per cent

To check against
DH-02 (pairs), DH-03 (12.0 vs 0.6, 11.2, 4.2). DH-03 gives 191 Agta adults in 11 camps and 103 Mbendjele in 9 camps
The verdict
OPEN
C02-15 Check first open §Insulting the meat

Richard Lee, Canadian anthropologist, Dobe Ju/'hoansi (!Kung), Christmas ox, Natural History 1969, quotation "we cool his heart and make him gentle"

To check against
DH-03 (Lee 1969, Natural History). "Canadian" and "late 1960s" not in documents; exact wording of the quotation to be checked against the article
The verdict
OPEN
C02-19 Check first open §Insulting the meat, §In practice

Polly Wiessner 2014, PNAS: 174 conversations, 122 day, 52 night; day 31 per cent economic, 34 per cent complaint and conflict; night 81 per cent stories, myth, healing, conflict near zero

To check against
DH-03 (Wiessner 2014)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-22 Check first open §Insulting the meat

Borgerhoff Mulder 2009, Science, 21 societies, Gini about 0.17 foragers vs 0.35 and above agricultural; top-decile child 11 times likelier to stay

To check against
DH-03 (Gini), DH-05 and DH-12 (11 times)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-26 Check first open §Other hands, §In practice

Ivey 2000, Efe of the Ituri forest: 14.2 caregivers a day, range 5 to 24; 60 per cent of daylight with others at 18 weeks

To check against
DH-08 (Ivey 2000, AJPA). First name "Paula" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-27 Check first open §Other hands, §In practice

Hewlett, Aka, 15 families: fathers within arm's reach 47 per cent of the day, hold 57 minutes a day vs mothers 490

To check against
DH-08 (Hewlett 1991). DH-02 gives 22 per cent holding in camp, DH-01 gives 47 per cent
The verdict
OPEN
C02-30 Check first open §Other hands

Konner and Worthman 1980, Science: Ju/'hoansi birth interval about 44 months, 4.7 births, nursing close to three years

To check against
DH-08 (Konner & Worthman 1980; nursing interval figure stripped in extraction). Weaning 2.8 years is in DH-02 (Hawkes 1997/98 table) and DH-08 (Sellen & Smay 2001). First names not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-31 Check first open §Other hands

Kristen Hawkes, Hadza grandmothers 1980s and 1990s; grandmother hypothesis, PNAS 1998, with O'Connell, Blurton Jones, Alvarez, Charnov

To check against
DH-01 (Hawkes et al. 1998), DH-02 (Hadza time allocation 1980s and 1990s). Affiliation University of Utah not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-33 Check first open §Other hands, §In practice, §Numbers

Sear and Mace 2008, 45 populations: maternal grandmother improves survival in nearly every population measured; father in about a third; paternal grandmother variable, sometimes negative

To check against
DH-08 (Sear & Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior). concept note §8 gives 69 per cent and 32 per cent, not used here. Sear "in London" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-40 Check first open §Two halves, §In practice

Reynolds, Mattison 2020, PNAS, Mosuo inflammation: patrilineal women 8.4 per cent vs men 3.2 per cent; matrilineal women 3.6 per cent vs men 6.5 per cent

To check against
DH-06 (Reynolds et al. 2020 PNAS). First names not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-41 Check first open §Two halves, §In practice

Gneezy, Leonard, List 2009, Econometrica: Maasai 50 per cent men vs 26 per cent women compete; Khasi 54 per cent women vs 39 per cent men

To check against
DH-06 (Gneezy et al. 2009). N per society stripped in extraction
The verdict
OPEN
C02-43 Check first open §Two halves, §In practice

Whyte 1978, 93 societies, ten independent dimensions of status; 88 per cent bar women from formal political leadership

To check against
DH-07 (93 societies, 10 dimensions), DH-10 (52 variables, 88 per cent)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-46 Check first open §Two halves

Strassmann, Dogon, Mali: 736 consecutive days of hut visits, hormone assays on 93 women, hut attended for 86 per cent of true menses, never in pregnancy

To check against
DH-10 (Strassmann 1996 Behavioral Ecology, 1997 Current Anthropology)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-49 Check first open §Who moved

Skov 2022, Nature: 11 Neanderthals Chagyrskaya, 2 Okladnikov, Altai, about 54,000 years, father and teenage daughter, groups of 10 to 20, more mtDNA than Y diversity

To check against
DH-12 (Skov et al. 2022). First name "Laurits" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-50 Check first open §Who moved

Gurgy, France, Rivollat 2023, Nature: 94 individuals sequenced, 4850 to 4500 BCE, pedigree of 63 across seven generations, patrilineal, daughters absent, wives non-local by strontium

To check against
DH-12 (94 of 128, 63 individuals), DH-05 (94 of 110, 64 individuals). Discrepancy logged; body names both denominators. First name "Maïté" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-51 Check first open §Who moved, §In practice

Lech valley, southern Germany, Mittnik 2019, Science: 9 of 10 parent-offspring pairs male, mothers from up to 350 km, unrelated individuals buried without goods

To check against
DH-12 (Mittnik et al. 2019). First name "Alissa" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-53 Check first open §Who moved, §Numbers

Karmin 2015, Genome Research, 456 Y chromosomes, 110 populations, about 17 women per surviving male line, millennia around 5000 to 3000 BCE

To check against
DH-12 (5000 to 3000 BCE, 110 populations), DH-05 (8,000 to 4,000 years ago, 456 Y chromosomes). Dating discrepancy logged. First name "Monika" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-57 Check first open §Who moved, §In practice

Borgerhoff Mulder wealth-transmission coefficient 0.13 to 0.18 foragers, 0.61 agropastoral; another report 0.37 to 0.45

To check against
DH-05 and DH-12 (0.13 to 0.18, 0.61) vs DH-03 (0.37 to 0.45). Discrepancy logged in body
The verdict
OPEN
C02-58 Check first open §Who moved

Olalde 2019, Science: Bell Beaker into Iberia about 2500 BCE, about 40 per cent autosomal shift, 90 to 100 per cent Y replacement, same in Britain

To check against
DH-12 (Olalde et al. 2019). First name "Íñigo" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-59 Check first open §Who moved

Macintosh 2017, Science Advances: 89 tibiae, 78 humeri, 5300 BCE to 850 CE; Neolithic women's humeri stiffer than living elite rowers; up to five hours a day at the quern; legs about 12 per cent weaker by the Bronze Age

To check against
DH-05 (89 tibiae, 78 humeri, five hours), DH-04 (11 to 16 per cent over rowers, legs about 12 per cent weaker). Preface already carries the 11 to 16 per cent. First name "Alison" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-63 Check first open §Who moved

Murdock Ethnographic Atlas 1,231 societies: 186 strictly monogamous (about 15 per cent), 453 occasional polygyny, 588 frequent; polygyny permitted in about 85 per cent

To check against
DH-09. DH-01 gives about 85 per cent, DH-07 gives more than 80 per cent
The verdict
OPEN
C02-67 Check first open §Case against, §Numbers

Lee 1979: 25 homicides among about 1,500 Ju/'hoansi, 1920 to 1970, 33 to 40 per 100,000 a year, 23 per cent over sexual jealousy, higher than violent US cities of the 1970s

To check against
DH-02 (25 homicides, 1,500 people, 33.3 to 40, 23 per cent), DH-11 (about 40, 1970s inner cities comparison)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-70 Check first open §Case against

Page and Dyble 2019 juvenile sex ratios: Agta 1.29, Aché 1.53, Batek 1.72

To check against
DH-02 (Page/Dyble 2019). Reading as neglect or infanticide is the chapter's, not the document's
The verdict
OPEN
C02-72 Check first open §Case against

Fry and Söderberg 2013, Science: 21 mobile forager band societies, 148 lethal events, 55 per cent single killer and victim, 85 per cent within own society, 10 of 21 with no multi-attacker killings

To check against
DH-03 (148 events, over half lone, 10 of 21), DH-11 (55 per cent, 85 per cent). Affiliation Åbo Akademi University not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-73 Check first open §Case against

Bowles 2009, Science: used Keeley and Pinker aggregate of about 15 per cent of deaths violent in non-state societies to model parochial altruism; 14 per cent from his own sample

To check against
DH-11 (Bowles 2009, 15 per cent aggregate). The 14 per cent is NOT in any DH document, marked marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C02-75 Check first open §Case against

Nataruk, west of Lake Turkana, Kenya: Lahr et al. 2016, Nature, 27 individuals, about 10,000 years, at least 10 with lethal trauma, pregnant woman with bound hands

To check against
NOT in any DH document or PDF; carried from memory at the parent's instruction, marked marked in the text for checking
The verdict
OPEN
C02-76 Check first open §Case against

Fibiger 2013, 378 crania, Neolithic Denmark and Sweden, healed trauma 16.9 per cent men, 9.4 per cent women, perimortem equal by sex

To check against
DH-04 (Fibiger et al. 2013, AJPA, 3900 to 1700 BCE). First name "Linda" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-78 Check first open §Case against

Asparn-Schletz 67 dead, young women absent; Schöneck-Kilianstädten 26 dead, legs broken, young females absent

To check against
DH-05
The verdict
OPEN
C02-79 Check first open §In practice

Waynforth 2020, UK Millennium Cohort: odds ratio 0.61 for developmental delay with kin alloparenting

To check against
DH-03 (Waynforth 2020, OR 0.61, CI 0.46 to 0.82). First name "David" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-80 Check first open §In practice

Ghana Intestate Succession Law 1985 (PNDC Law 111), Akan: gap in hours worked between men and women widened by 41 per cent

To check against
DH-06
The verdict
OPEN
C02-01 open §Opening

Hadza country lies north of Lake Eyasi, northern Tanzania (opening scene setting)

To check against
Not in DH documents; general knowledge. DH-01/DH-02 name the Hadza of Tanzania only
The verdict
OPEN
C02-02 open §Opening

"something like two hundred thousand years" of foraging bands

To check against
DH-03 (Cieri et al. 2014, 200,000 years); concept note §6
The verdict
OPEN
C02-05 open §Who ate what

Zero of 185 societies assign large-game hunting to women alone

To check against
DH-07 (Murdock & Provost 1973)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-06 open §Who ate what

Judith Brown 1970, American Anthropologist, compatibility with childcare (interruptibility)

To check against
DH-07 (Brown 1970)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-07 open §Who ate what

Martu women, Western Desert, Australia, hunting sand monitors provide the majority of calories in camp

To check against
DH-02 (Bliege Bird, Bird, Codding)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-09 open §Who ate what

Venkataraman and colleagues 2024 rebuttal, about 35 per cent of Anderson's societies not locatable in D-PLACE

To check against
DH-02 (Venkataraman, Hames, Hagen, Kramer 2024, Evolution and Human Behavior)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-12 open §Who ate what

Deb and colleagues 2024, Evolution and Human Behavior, equality of leisure within forager households

To check against
DH-02 (Deb 2024)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-13 open §Who ate what

Women in wealthy countries do 70 to 90 per cent of household chores

To check against
DH-02, no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C02-16 open §Insulting the meat

Christopher Boehm 1993, Current Anthropology, 53 communities, reverse dominance hierarchy, sanctions gossip, ridicule, ostracism, execution

To check against
DH-03 (Boehm 1993). Affiliation University of Southern California not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-17 open §Insulting the meat

Richard Wrangham 2019 self-domestication by execution of reactively aggressive men

To check against
DH-03 (Wrangham 2019); DH-11 (Wrangham 2018 PNAS)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-18 open §Insulting the meat

Robert Cieri 2014, Current Anthropology, more than 1,400 crania, craniofacial feminisation over 200,000 years

To check against
DH-03 (Cieri et al. 2014). First name not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-21 open §Insulting the meat

James Woodburn 1982, Man, immediate-return vs delayed-return

To check against
DH-03 (Woodburn 1982)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-23 open §Other hands

Sarah Blaffer Hrdy: about 13 million calories per child to independence

To check against
DH-03 (Hrdy 2009). Affiliation UC Davis not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-24 open §Other hands

Humans among the roughly 3 per cent of mammal species that breed cooperatively

To check against
DH-01 (Hrdy 2005, 2009)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-25 open §Other hands

Mothers and Others, 2009

To check against
DH-08 source list (Hrdy 2009, Harvard University Press)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-28 open §Other hands

Kramer, Maya and Pumé: 10 per cent allocare reduces maternal care 25 per cent, saves about 165 kcal/day

To check against
DH-08 (Kramer 2018)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-29 open §Other hands

Meehan: grandmothers save a mother up to 216 kcal over nine hours

To check against
DH-08 (Meehan 2013). First name "Courtney" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-32 open §Other hands

Owen Lovejoy 1981, Science, male provisioning model

To check against
DH-01 (Lovejoy 1981)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-34 open §Two halves

Minangkabau, West Sumatra, more than 4 million, largest matrilineal group

To check against
DH-06 (Sanday 2002)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-35 open §Two halves

Khasi, Meghalaya: youngest daughter (khatduh) inherits; women historically excluded from village councils

To check against
DH-06
The verdict
OPEN
C02-36 open §Two halves

Mosuo, Yunnan: tisese walking marriage; brothers help raise sisters' children

To check against
DH-06
The verdict
OPEN
C02-37 open §Two halves

Haudenosaunee clan mothers name and remove sachems, veto war

To check against
DH-06
The verdict
OPEN
C02-38 open §Two halves

Bachofen 1861; Gimbutas Goddess; Eller; Çatalhöyük "zero evidence of a matriarchy"

To check against
DH-06 (Bachofen, Eller 2000), DH-05 (Meskell & Nakamura on Çatalhöyük)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-39 open §Two halves

Bamberger 1974, myths of matriarchy as charters for male rule, Amazon and Melanesia

To check against
DH-06 (Bamberger 1974)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-42 open §Two halves

Chakravarty, Dimasa: no gap; Gong and Yang 2012, Mosuo vs Yi: risk gap smaller but persists

To check against
DH-06
The verdict
OPEN
C02-45 open §Two halves

Gê of central Brazil: men's plaza at centre, women's houses at periphery, moieties bury each other's dead

To check against
DH-10 (Maybury-Lewis 1979)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-47 open §Two halves

Chris Knight, menstrual ritual as female coalition

To check against
DH-10 (Knight 1991)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-48 open §Who moved

Lippold 2014, 623 men, 51 populations, mtDNA TMRCA about twice Y

To check against
DH-12 (Lippold et al. 2014, Investigative Genetics). First name "Sebastian" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-52 open §Who moved

Hazleton North, Britain, 5,700 years, one man with four women, six sons

To check against
DH-12 (Fowler et al. 2021, Nature, 35 individuals)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-54 open §Who moved

"The average man alive in 4000 BCE has no living descendant in the male line"

To check against
DH-12 (report's own phrasing), no primary source named
The verdict
OPEN
C02-55 open §Who moved

Zeng, Aw, Feldman 2018, Nature Communications, clan warfare model

To check against
DH-05, DH-12. First names Tian Chen, Alan, Marcus not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-56 open §Who moved

Guyon, Marchi, Heyer, Chaix 2024, Nature Communications, peaceful fission model

To check against
DH-05, DH-12. First names not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-60 open §Who moved

Varna, 4560 to 4450 BCE, sex-differentiated diet, Grave 43 man 40 to 50 with more than 1 kg gold

To check against
DH-04 (Higham 2007, Gaydarska 2022)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-64 open §Who moved

Chaco Canyon, New Mexico, nine individuals, 800 to 1130 CE, one mitochondrial genome, 330 years

To check against
DH-12 (Kennett et al. 2017, Nature Communications)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-65 open §Who moved

Çatalhöyük: co-buried individuals often not close kin

To check against
DH-12 (Yaka et al. 2021, Current Biology)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-66 open §Who moved (close)

Narrator's mother kept a household book before 1975

To check against
Narrative device, passing reference; to be confirmed by the author or struck
The verdict
OPEN
C02-68 open §Case against

Knauft, Gebusi, New Guinea: 200 to 326 homicides per 100,000

To check against
DH-11 (Knauft 1987). First name "Bruce" not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-69 open §Case against

Hill and Hurtado, Aché life expectancy at birth 30 to 35

To check against
DH-02 (Hill & Hurtado 1996). First names not in documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-71 open §Case against

Beckerman, Barí, Venezuela, 822 pregnancies, survival to 15 of 80 vs 64 per cent (20 to 36 per cent dead)

To check against
DH-08 (Beckerman 1998). Percentages of deaths derived by subtraction
The verdict
OPEN
C02-74 open §Case against

Crow Creek, South Dakota, about 60 per cent, dated 1325 CE, Ferguson critique

To check against
DH-11 (Keeley, Pinker, Ferguson 2013/2015)
The verdict
OPEN