Men's arm muscle 75 to 90 per cent greater than women's, Lassek and Gaulin 2009, Evolution and Human Behavior
The Log · PAIRING · Read the chapter
Chapter 2: The Campfire Contract
80 claims, 35 to check first
- 80 open
- 35 to check first
Murdock and Provost 1973, 50 activities, 185 societies, cooking female in 183 of 185, smelting, metalworking and large-game hunting male in 90 to 100 per cent
Anderson et al. 2023, PLOS ONE: women hunt in 50 of 63 foraging societies, large game in a third
Wilamaya Patjxa, Peru: woman 17 to 19, about 9,000 years old, five projectile points and butchering kit; Haas 2020 Science Advances, 27 burials, 11 female, 16 male, 30 to 50 per cent
- To check against
- DH-04 (Haas et al. 2020). First name "Randall" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pontzer, 30 Hadza adults, 17 women, 13 men, 2,649 vs 1,877 kcal/day
Dyble 2015, Science: 1,863 Mbendjele and 4,055 Agta co-resident pairs; 12 per cent unrelated adults when both sexes choose vs 0.6 per cent; observed Agta 11.2 per cent; Paranan 4.2 per cent
Richard Lee, Canadian anthropologist, Dobe Ju/'hoansi (!Kung), Christmas ox, Natural History 1969, quotation "we cool his heart and make him gentle"
- To check against
- DH-03 (Lee 1969, Natural History). "Canadian" and "late 1960s" not in documents; exact wording of the quotation to be checked against the article
- The verdict
- OPEN
Polly Wiessner 2014, PNAS: 174 conversations, 122 day, 52 night; day 31 per cent economic, 34 per cent complaint and conflict; night 81 per cent stories, myth, healing, conflict near zero
- To check against
- DH-03 (Wiessner 2014)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Borgerhoff Mulder 2009, Science, 21 societies, Gini about 0.17 foragers vs 0.35 and above agricultural; top-decile child 11 times likelier to stay
Ivey 2000, Efe of the Ituri forest: 14.2 caregivers a day, range 5 to 24; 60 per cent of daylight with others at 18 weeks
- To check against
- DH-08 (Ivey 2000, AJPA). First name "Paula" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hewlett, Aka, 15 families: fathers within arm's reach 47 per cent of the day, hold 57 minutes a day vs mothers 490
Konner and Worthman 1980, Science: Ju/'hoansi birth interval about 44 months, 4.7 births, nursing close to three years
Kristen Hawkes, Hadza grandmothers 1980s and 1990s; grandmother hypothesis, PNAS 1998, with O'Connell, Blurton Jones, Alvarez, Charnov
Sear and Mace 2008, 45 populations: maternal grandmother improves survival in nearly every population measured; father in about a third; paternal grandmother variable, sometimes negative
- To check against
- DH-08 (Sear & Mace 2008, Evolution and Human Behavior). concept note §8 gives 69 per cent and 32 per cent, not used here. Sear "in London" is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
Reynolds, Mattison 2020, PNAS, Mosuo inflammation: patrilineal women 8.4 per cent vs men 3.2 per cent; matrilineal women 3.6 per cent vs men 6.5 per cent
- To check against
- DH-06 (Reynolds et al. 2020 PNAS). First names not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Gneezy, Leonard, List 2009, Econometrica: Maasai 50 per cent men vs 26 per cent women compete; Khasi 54 per cent women vs 39 per cent men
- To check against
- DH-06 (Gneezy et al. 2009). N per society stripped in extraction
- The verdict
- OPEN
Whyte 1978, 93 societies, ten independent dimensions of status; 88 per cent bar women from formal political leadership
Strassmann, Dogon, Mali: 736 consecutive days of hut visits, hormone assays on 93 women, hut attended for 86 per cent of true menses, never in pregnancy
- To check against
- DH-10 (Strassmann 1996 Behavioral Ecology, 1997 Current Anthropology)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Skov 2022, Nature: 11 Neanderthals Chagyrskaya, 2 Okladnikov, Altai, about 54,000 years, father and teenage daughter, groups of 10 to 20, more mtDNA than Y diversity
- To check against
- DH-12 (Skov et al. 2022). First name "Laurits" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Gurgy, France, Rivollat 2023, Nature: 94 individuals sequenced, 4850 to 4500 BCE, pedigree of 63 across seven generations, patrilineal, daughters absent, wives non-local by strontium
Lech valley, southern Germany, Mittnik 2019, Science: 9 of 10 parent-offspring pairs male, mothers from up to 350 km, unrelated individuals buried without goods
- To check against
- DH-12 (Mittnik et al. 2019). First name "Alissa" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Karmin 2015, Genome Research, 456 Y chromosomes, 110 populations, about 17 women per surviving male line, millennia around 5000 to 3000 BCE
Borgerhoff Mulder wealth-transmission coefficient 0.13 to 0.18 foragers, 0.61 agropastoral; another report 0.37 to 0.45
Olalde 2019, Science: Bell Beaker into Iberia about 2500 BCE, about 40 per cent autosomal shift, 90 to 100 per cent Y replacement, same in Britain
- To check against
- DH-12 (Olalde et al. 2019). First name "Íñigo" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Macintosh 2017, Science Advances: 89 tibiae, 78 humeri, 5300 BCE to 850 CE; Neolithic women's humeri stiffer than living elite rowers; up to five hours a day at the quern; legs about 12 per cent weaker by the Bronze Age
Murdock Ethnographic Atlas 1,231 societies: 186 strictly monogamous (about 15 per cent), 453 occasional polygyny, 588 frequent; polygyny permitted in about 85 per cent
Lee 1979: 25 homicides among about 1,500 Ju/'hoansi, 1920 to 1970, 33 to 40 per 100,000 a year, 23 per cent over sexual jealousy, higher than violent US cities of the 1970s
Page and Dyble 2019 juvenile sex ratios: Agta 1.29, Aché 1.53, Batek 1.72
- To check against
- DH-02 (Page/Dyble 2019). Reading as neglect or infanticide is the chapter's, not the document's
- The verdict
- OPEN
Fry and Söderberg 2013, Science: 21 mobile forager band societies, 148 lethal events, 55 per cent single killer and victim, 85 per cent within own society, 10 of 21 with no multi-attacker killings
Bowles 2009, Science: used Keeley and Pinker aggregate of about 15 per cent of deaths violent in non-state societies to model parochial altruism; 14 per cent from his own sample
- To check against
- DH-11 (Bowles 2009, 15 per cent aggregate). The 14 per cent is NOT in any DH document, marked marked in the text for checking
- The verdict
- OPEN
Nataruk, west of Lake Turkana, Kenya: Lahr et al. 2016, Nature, 27 individuals, about 10,000 years, at least 10 with lethal trauma, pregnant woman with bound hands
- To check against
- NOT in any DH document or PDF; carried from memory at the parent's instruction, marked marked in the text for checking
- The verdict
- OPEN
Fibiger 2013, 378 crania, Neolithic Denmark and Sweden, healed trauma 16.9 per cent men, 9.4 per cent women, perimortem equal by sex
- To check against
- DH-04 (Fibiger et al. 2013, AJPA, 3900 to 1700 BCE). First name "Linda" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Asparn-Schletz 67 dead, young women absent; Schöneck-Kilianstädten 26 dead, legs broken, young females absent
- To check against
- DH-05
- The verdict
- OPEN
Waynforth 2020, UK Millennium Cohort: odds ratio 0.61 for developmental delay with kin alloparenting
- To check against
- DH-03 (Waynforth 2020, OR 0.61, CI 0.46 to 0.82). First name "David" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Ghana Intestate Succession Law 1985 (PNDC Law 111), Akan: gap in hours worked between men and women widened by 41 per cent
- To check against
- DH-06
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hadza country lies north of Lake Eyasi, northern Tanzania (opening scene setting)
"something like two hundred thousand years" of foraging bands
- To check against
- DH-03 (Cieri et al. 2014, 200,000 years); concept note §6
- The verdict
- OPEN
Zero of 185 societies assign large-game hunting to women alone
- To check against
- DH-07 (Murdock & Provost 1973)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Judith Brown 1970, American Anthropologist, compatibility with childcare (interruptibility)
- To check against
- DH-07 (Brown 1970)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Martu women, Western Desert, Australia, hunting sand monitors provide the majority of calories in camp
- To check against
- DH-02 (Bliege Bird, Bird, Codding)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Venkataraman and colleagues 2024 rebuttal, about 35 per cent of Anderson's societies not locatable in D-PLACE
- To check against
- DH-02 (Venkataraman, Hames, Hagen, Kramer 2024, Evolution and Human Behavior)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Deb and colleagues 2024, Evolution and Human Behavior, equality of leisure within forager households
- To check against
- DH-02 (Deb 2024)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Women in wealthy countries do 70 to 90 per cent of household chores
- To check against
- DH-02, no primary source named
- The verdict
- OPEN
Christopher Boehm 1993, Current Anthropology, 53 communities, reverse dominance hierarchy, sanctions gossip, ridicule, ostracism, execution
- To check against
- DH-03 (Boehm 1993). Affiliation University of Southern California not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Richard Wrangham 2019 self-domestication by execution of reactively aggressive men
Robert Cieri 2014, Current Anthropology, more than 1,400 crania, craniofacial feminisation over 200,000 years
- To check against
- DH-03 (Cieri et al. 2014). First name not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
hxaro gift partnerships as exit option
- To check against
- DH-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
James Woodburn 1982, Man, immediate-return vs delayed-return
- To check against
- DH-03 (Woodburn 1982)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Sarah Blaffer Hrdy: about 13 million calories per child to independence
- To check against
- DH-03 (Hrdy 2009). Affiliation UC Davis not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Humans among the roughly 3 per cent of mammal species that breed cooperatively
- To check against
- DH-01 (Hrdy 2005, 2009)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Mothers and Others, 2009
- To check against
- DH-08 source list (Hrdy 2009, Harvard University Press)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Kramer, Maya and Pumé: 10 per cent allocare reduces maternal care 25 per cent, saves about 165 kcal/day
- To check against
- DH-08 (Kramer 2018)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Meehan: grandmothers save a mother up to 216 kcal over nine hours
- To check against
- DH-08 (Meehan 2013). First name "Courtney" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Owen Lovejoy 1981, Science, male provisioning model
- To check against
- DH-01 (Lovejoy 1981)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Minangkabau, West Sumatra, more than 4 million, largest matrilineal group
- To check against
- DH-06 (Sanday 2002)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Khasi, Meghalaya: youngest daughter (khatduh) inherits; women historically excluded from village councils
- To check against
- DH-06
- The verdict
- OPEN
Mosuo, Yunnan: tisese walking marriage; brothers help raise sisters' children
- To check against
- DH-06
- The verdict
- OPEN
Haudenosaunee clan mothers name and remove sachems, veto war
- To check against
- DH-06
- The verdict
- OPEN
Bachofen 1861; Gimbutas Goddess; Eller; Çatalhöyük "zero evidence of a matriarchy"
Bamberger 1974, myths of matriarchy as charters for male rule, Amazon and Melanesia
- To check against
- DH-06 (Bamberger 1974)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Chakravarty, Dimasa: no gap; Gong and Yang 2012, Mosuo vs Yi: risk gap smaller but persists
- To check against
- DH-06
- The verdict
- OPEN
Sande and Poro societies, Sierra Leone and Liberia
- To check against
- DH-10
- The verdict
- OPEN
Gê of central Brazil: men's plaza at centre, women's houses at periphery, moieties bury each other's dead
- To check against
- DH-10 (Maybury-Lewis 1979)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Chris Knight, menstrual ritual as female coalition
- To check against
- DH-10 (Knight 1991)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Lippold 2014, 623 men, 51 populations, mtDNA TMRCA about twice Y
- To check against
- DH-12 (Lippold et al. 2014, Investigative Genetics). First name "Sebastian" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hazleton North, Britain, 5,700 years, one man with four women, six sons
- To check against
- DH-12 (Fowler et al. 2021, Nature, 35 individuals)
- The verdict
- OPEN
"The average man alive in 4000 BCE has no living descendant in the male line"
- To check against
- DH-12 (report's own phrasing), no primary source named
- The verdict
- OPEN
Zeng, Aw, Feldman 2018, Nature Communications, clan warfare model
Guyon, Marchi, Heyer, Chaix 2024, Nature Communications, peaceful fission model
Varna, 4560 to 4450 BCE, sex-differentiated diet, Grave 43 man 40 to 50 with more than 1 kg gold
- To check against
- DH-04 (Higham 2007, Gaydarska 2022)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Boserup 1970, plough and women's work
Middle Assyrian Laws about 1076 BCE, Law 40, veiling
- To check against
- DH-05
- The verdict
- OPEN
Chaco Canyon, New Mexico, nine individuals, 800 to 1130 CE, one mitochondrial genome, 330 years
- To check against
- DH-12 (Kennett et al. 2017, Nature Communications)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Çatalhöyük: co-buried individuals often not close kin
- To check against
- DH-12 (Yaka et al. 2021, Current Biology)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Narrator's mother kept a household book before 1975
- To check against
- Narrative device, passing reference; to be confirmed by the author or struck
- The verdict
- OPEN
Knauft, Gebusi, New Guinea: 200 to 326 homicides per 100,000
- To check against
- DH-11 (Knauft 1987). First name "Bruce" not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hill and Hurtado, Aché life expectancy at birth 30 to 35
- To check against
- DH-02 (Hill & Hurtado 1996). First names not in documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Beckerman, Barí, Venezuela, 822 pregnancies, survival to 15 of 80 vs 64 per cent (20 to 36 per cent dead)
- To check against
- DH-08 (Beckerman 1998). Percentages of deaths derived by subtraction
- The verdict
- OPEN
Crow Creek, South Dakota, about 60 per cent, dated 1325 CE, Ferguson critique
- To check against
- DH-11 (Keeley, Pinker, Ferguson 2013/2015)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Talheim, 34 killed struck from behind