THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 187 · PAIRING · Deep history

Cross-cultural databases: what correlates with women's status

Reviews what cross-cultural databases show about women's status. Cooking falls mainly to women in 183 of 185 societies (Murdock and Provost 1973), and women's tasks are those compatible with childcare. Women's status splits into 10 independent dimensions across 93 societies (Whyte 1978). Three predictors of lower status recur: the plough (Alesina 2013), cattle, which turn matrilineal Bantu societies patrilineal (Holden and Mace 2003), and pastoralism, which brings controls on female sexuality (Becker 2019). Whether male dominance is universal remains contested.

Open the PDF 16 pages · 356 KB

Number
187
Letter code
DH-07
Book
PAIRING after the FALL
Shelf
Deep history
File
187 DH-07 Cross-cultural databases, what correlates with women's status.pdf
Pages
16

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 13 open
  • 3 to check first
  • C02-04 open Check first Murdock and Provost 1973, 50 activities, 185 societies, cooking female in 183 of 185, smelting, metalworking and large-game hunting male in 90 to 100 per cent
  • C02-43 open Check first Whyte 1978, 93 societies, ten independent dimensions of status; 88 per cent bar women from formal political leadership
  • C02-63 open Check first Murdock Ethnographic Atlas 1,231 societies: 186 strictly monogamous (about 15 per cent), 453 occasional polygyny, 588 frequent; polygyny permitted in about 85 per cent
  • C02-05 open Zero of 185 societies assign large-game hunting to women alone
  • C02-06 open Judith Brown 1970, American Anthropologist, compatibility with childcare (interruptibility)
  • C02-61 open Boserup 1970, plough and women's work
  • C14-23 open Standard Cross-Cultural Sample assembled by Murdock and White 1969. DH-07 gives 186 societies in one place and 185 in another. No society in the sample has women holding military …
  • C14-24 open Sanday 1981, Female Power and Male Dominance: 156 societies scaled on women's economic control, political voice and symbolic standing. Inner versus outer orientation. Outer …
  • C14-25 open Divale and Harris 1976, "male supremacy complex": warfare rewards young men with patrilocal residence, polygyny, political monopoly and subordination of women
  • C14-26 open Low: pathogen stress and male war mortality are the two best predictors of non-sororal polygyny, with controls for shared ancestry. Year and venue not in DH-07, carried with (to …
  • C14-27 open Henrich, Boyd and Richerson 2012: about 85 per cent of societies in the ethnographic record permit polygyny (DH-07 says "over 80 per cent" of Ethnographic Atlas societies). …
  • C14-29 open Whyte 1978, The Status of Women in Preindustrial Societies: 93 societies, factor analysis finds about ten dimensions of women's standing that barely correlate
  • C15-24 open Martin Whyte 1978: ten independent dimensions of women's status (as chapter 2 reported)